Philanthropy must face a reckoning on race in 2021

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Abdullahi Alim, Specialist, Africa and Middle East, Global Shapers Community, World Economic Forum

2020 has marked an important turning point for conversations on race.

The police killing of George Floyd in the US in May, following too many other similar deaths and injustices, sparked protests and renewed a discussion around civil rights and police reform. The devastating effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on lives and livelihoods have disproportionately affected people of color around the world, shining a spotlight on structural economic and social inequalities.

Civil society leaders have stepped up to address these gaps. Yet they continue to face hurdles from philanthropic donors and a funding system that too often creates a power imbalance rather than resolving one. Few frontline workers dare to speak openly about the funding challenges they experience so as not to offend donors, further exacerbating these issues.

As a result, important conversations around equity and inclusion are forced into oblivion, leaving charitable donors to unwittingly perpetuate inequity in the social sector, even as they seek to end it in the wider world.

Image: World Economic Forum

Fighting for people of color

For Carolyn Pitt, CEO of Film Connx, the pandemic focused her attention on the outsized impact on people of color. Drawing on her activist experience, Pitt addressed a bipartisan U.S. Congressional committee to advocate for stimulus dollars to support the battered film industry, which serves as an employment base for a number of African Americans in Georgia.

Cheryl Gordon is a 43-year-old African-American activist who leads a movement to help inspire criminal justice reform. “I’m clocking 60 hour weeks. If I’m lucky, I can spend every second weekend with my kids.”

The cost of her activism is all too familiar for the millions of black women at the frontlines of social justice. In the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd, her work received increased attention but nowhere near as much funding.

“My team could not compete with the big nonprofits,” she said. “They don’t live or work here but still get the funds. I received about one-tenth relative to them, and [the donors] dictated how we spent every dollar. I found it insulting but we needed the money.”

This example raises important questions for the future of charitable donations: By overriding the judgement of those with lived experience, do donors risk perpetuating the very structures they are compelled to address? More specifically, does the power imbalance between Cheryl and the given funder mirror the racial power imbalance experienced by Black people around the world every day?

Obstacles to impact

Lack of funding is one of the largest sources of stress for social entrepreneurs. According to a recent study from the Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship, 47% of social entrepreneurs said that the lack of consistent access to capital is the top barrier to scaling their organization.

Organizations led by people of color or serving the interests of people of color often face additional hurdles.

For example, donors tend to opt to support large and mostly white-led organizations over those led by practitioners with lived experience. This pattern becomes even more concerning when large organizations then subcontract black and brown organizations to do the work for a fraction of their funding.

Another obstacle is called movement capture, where white donors’ compromise social movements by pressuring them to readjust their work to reflect the donors’ own preferences. As a result, communities bear the cost of lacklustre programs while practitioners suffer credibility strains.

Social entrepreneurs also face pressure to cut costs while increasing outputs. Donors treat them like startups and pressure them to be lean, agile and ruthlessly efficient. This can lead to excessive workloads, high staff turnover and low earnings.

“Our donors pressured us to cut back on staff and budget even less pay for the remaining team,” said one nonprofit leader (who asked to be anonymous so as not to impede funding opportunities). “You would be surprised how little we earn and how much we do. It’s a recipe for a toxic work culture.”

By focusing the conversation around organizational efficiency, donors are less likely to think through how decades-long austerity measures that have effectively wiped out the government programmes for the working class in many developing countries, leaving them to rely on an increasingly stretched nonprofit sector. Emphasizing mindfulness is important, but it’s not enough.

The normalizing of low earnings in the social sector poses the question of whether donors can create truly equitable societies when those tasked with such work are ultimately forced to join the working poor as well. This phenomenon cuts across the developed world, too, with practitioners often finding themselves with little savings and pension upon retirement.

Serving vulnerable communities

COVID-19 is prompting the long-overdue reckoning for a social sector marked by burnout, inequity and seemingly endless pressure to be lean.

To reverse this culture, a decent allocation of grant funding should cover salary and overheads, with the understanding that this can lead to better outcomes and less burnout among staff. Donors should also take stock of just how stretched the social sector is and whether their demands for organizational change might hinder the ability of nonprofits to reach the most vulnerable.

These important reflections might cause discomfort to donors and may even surface deep wounds that are at the core of why they choose to fund social change. Nevertheless, such a process can only lead to a healthier relationship between donors and nonprofit leaders and to the benefit of the communities they intend to serve.

By tackling such critical and pointed questions, donors are less likely to centre their funding around an existential desire to find meaning and praise. Moreover, such a shift would instead build on the rich knowledge of practitioners with lived experiences and provide better support to oppressed communities.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

We underestimate the power of data at our peril. This is why

EU to Turkey: No other ties than €3+3bn to upkeep refugees

Bank resolutions set to remain a national affair

Stop illegal trade in cats and dogs, say MEPs

Sustainable fishing staying afloat in developed world, sinking in poorer regions

5G networks: to slice or not to slice?

UN space-based tool opens new horizons to track land-use on Earth’s surface

UN agriculture agency digs in to help forests and farms build resilience to climate change

Stateless Rohingya refugee children living in ‘untenable situation’, UNICEF chief

Mental Health: In Times of COVID-19

Access to health and guarantee of sexual and reproductive rights as a way of eradicating HIV

How health privatization increases health inequities

4 bold new ways New York is going clean and green

Is there a de facto impossibility for the Brexit to kick-start?

Challenges facing the COVID-19 vaccination campaigns

Concorde is a reminder that the only way for innovation is up

Indoor air pollution is deadly. Here’s an unconventional solution

Rule of law in Slovenia: MEPs conclude their first mission to the country

Agriculture and Fisheries Council

Commission statement on the European Remembrance Day for Victims of Terrorism

Mergers: Commission opens in-depth investigation into proposed acquisition of GrandVision by EssilorLuxottica

2018 Sakharov laureate Oleg Sentsov receives his award

‘Amid stormy global seas, UN charter remains our moral anchor’, says Guterres on United Nations Day

3 ways to rebuild trust in how we regulate technology

Higher education becoming again a privilege of the wealthy?

Why do medical students need to go abroad to become a doctor in 2017?

Can India reduce deaths on one hazardous road to zero? This group is trying

It’s time for global businesses to accept local responsibility

Draghi rehabs ECB into a tool to support growth and employment; a departure from Teutonic orthodoxy

COVID-19: How the pandemic has made football’s structural problems worse

What’s a logarithmic graph and how does it help explain the spread of COVID-19?

European Commission issues first emission of EU SURE social bonds

Indonesia wants to reach net-zero plastic pollution by 2040. Do you have a big idea to help them do it?

Here’s how one social entrepreneur became a first responder to the Indian COVID crisis

The racial wealth gap in the US is affecting its citizens and its economy – this is how

The water where baby fish are outnumbered 7 to 1 by plastic

Medical students, climate change and health: an unorthodox combination

Celebrating Multilingualism Day at the EP – where 24 languages meet

Coronavirus: Commission approves contract with CureVac to ensure access to a potential vaccine

Female directors reached record highs in 2019 Hollywood

State aid: Commission approves €1.74 billion Danish scheme to support mink farmers and related businesses in context of coronavirus outbreak

Act now to end violence, Zeid urges Nicaraguan authorities

Fight against climate change and poverty will fail without overhaul of global financial system, says major UN report

As many as 330,000 displaced by heavy fighting in south-west Syria – UN agency

Virus Coronavirus: No time to die

What companies can do to build more inclusive AI

A Sting Exclusive: “Consumer expectations for the 2015 UN summit on climate change”, Director General of BEUC Monique Goyens outlines from Brussels

These EU countries have the most government debt

European Parliament approves more transparency and efficiency in its internal rules

What we take for granted: The EU is not perfect

This school-in-a-bag helps educate the most remote areas

Climate change is speeding up. Our response needs to be even faster

Situation in central Mali ‘deteriorating’ as violence, impunity rise, UN rights expert warns

MEPs debate Brexit and relations with China following EU spring summit

As COP25 goes into the night, Guterres calls for more climate ambition

EU’s judicial cooperation arm, Eurojust, to become more effective with new rules

Preparing Africa for ravages of climate change ‘cannot be an afterthought’ – COP24

Hungary: people born in the 2020s won’t have legal rights any more to buy tobacco

De-escalate now, to steer Yemen off ‘precarious path’, UN Security Council hears

Over 85% of European bathing sites rated as excellent for water quality

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: