COVID-19 prisoner releases are not a matter of mercy, but of justice


(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Kieran Oberman, Senior Lecturer in Political Theory, University of Edinburgh

  • Governments have started to release some prisoners and immigrant detainees because of the coronavirus pandemic.
  • Protecting the incarcerated is not a matter of mercy, but of justice.
  • Large numbers must now be released, starting with those who pose the least threat to society or the most vulnerable to the disease.

A prison or an immigration detention centre is a terrible place to be during a pandemic. With so many people packed in together, the virus can easily spread. In light of this, some governments have started to release some prisoners and immigrant detainees.


However, the number of releases has varied considerably across countries. While Turkey and Iran are releasing tens of thousands of prisoners, many Western democracies have dragged their heels. Canada, Australia and the Netherlands were all slow to act. The UK had plans to release up to 4,000, 5% of the prison population, but actual releases were few and then halted altogether after an administrative botch freed the wrong people.

Around the world, the most common response has been to lock prisoners in their cells and deny them visits. This has not gone down well with prisoners. Riots have broken out in Italy and Colombia.

The picture regarding immigration detention centres is no less bleak. After COVID-19 outbreaks in New Jersey detention centres, the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) released several hundred people, but given that the US has the largest immigration detention regime in the world, those are not large numbers. John Sandweg, who headed ICE under Obama, has called for the release of all detainees spare those who pose a safety or flight risk. In the UK, detained immigrants have decried not only the lack of releases but also disease prevention measures within facilities. They report insufficient masks, hand gel and testing.

In the case of both prisons and detention centres, campaigners are urgently calling for releases to be stepped up, with priority awarded to the most vulnerable: the many incarcerated people who are elderly, in poor health or both. (If you think prison is just for youngsters, you are wrong. In the US, there are now more prisoners over 55 than between 18-24). But what exactly is the case for releases? Why should people who have committed crimes or immigration infractions be released?

The most obvious answer is humanitarian. On this view, cold justice would demand the incarcerated stay inside, but a decent society tempers justice with mercy. When people’s health is at risk, we are willing to overlook past discretions. The more practically minded will add that it is not just prisoners who are at risk. When prisoners get the virus, they spread it to staff, who spread it to the wider public.

Humanitarianism and public health might both then speak in favour of releases. But, I think we are in danger of understating the case. In an age of pandemic, protecting the incarcerated is best regarded not as matter of mercy, but of justice itself.

The Aging Population in State Prisons

To see this, we need to consider a concept that is central to justice, both in law and ethics: proportionality. Proportionality holds that people cannot be subject to undue costs even for the sake of valuable goals. Its importance is perhaps best illustrated by examples from times and places when it has been violated. In the Middle Ages, for instance, people were hung for theft and other petty crimes. Today, we recognize that as wrong. It is not that hanging petty criminals didn’t achieve legitimate goals, such as deterring further crime. No doubt it did. Rather, hanging was wrong because the cost imposed was so utterly beyond what the criminals were due, given the crimes committed.

Proportionality is important then in the punishment of criminals. It is also crucial when imposing immigration restrictions. Even if we agree that restrictions are sometimes justified, not everything can be done to enforce them. Such severe measures as separating children from parents, or, as the Danish People’s Party notoriously suggested, shooting at migrant boats, are simply unacceptable. This is true whether or not such measures help to deter unauthorized crossings. Effectiveness and proportionality are separate considerations.

Now, consider the pandemic. Before it started, judgements were made as to what would be proportionate treatment of criminals and unauthorized migrants. This is particularly obvious in the case of criminals. Criminals undergo sentencing, the whole point of which is to identify a proportionate punishment. In the case of immigrants, the length of detention tends to be indeterminate (a controversy in itself), but even so there is judicial review and an expectation that detention will be temporary. One further point is so obvious one could easily skip over it: immigrants, as well as almost all criminals (those not on death row) are only supposed to lose their liberty. Their bodies are meant to remain unscarred and intact.

But in the face of what is meant to be, the pandemic changes everything. People are now not subject only to a loss of liberty. Their lives are put at risk. It is as if people have had their old sentences ripped up and new ones handed down. In addition to whatever the courts and immigration tribunals decided they were due, they are now exposed to the virus as well.

What is the World Economic Forum doing about the coronavirus outbreak?

A new strain of Coronavirus, COVID 19, is spreading around the world, causing deaths and major disruption to the global economy.

Responding to this crisis requires global cooperation among governments, international organizations and the business community, which is at the centre of the World Economic Forum’s mission as the International Organization for Public-Private Cooperation.

The Forum has created the COVID Action Platform, a global platform to convene the business community for collective action, protect people’s livelihoods and facilitate business continuity, and mobilize support for the COVID-19 response. The platform is created with the support of the World Health Organization and is open to all businesses and industry groups, as well as other stakeholders, aiming to integrate and inform joint action.

As an organization, the Forum has a track record of supporting efforts to contain epidemics. In 2017, at our Annual Meeting, the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI) was launched – bringing together experts from government, business, health, academia and civil society to accelerate the development of vaccines. CEPI is currently supporting the race to develop a vaccine against this strand of the coronavirus.

Am I suggesting that everyone should be released? No. We still need to weigh the goals of incarceration against the costs. But how we make that calculation must change. Given the pandemic, large numbers must now be released, starting with those who pose the least threat to society or the most vulnerable to the disease.

Hanging petty criminals was wrong. Shooting migrant boats would be wrong. Refusing to release prisoners during a pandemic falls short of that but it is not altogether different. It too fails proportionality. Justice requires we do better.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

This entrepreneur is helping farmers get food to consumers during lockdown

Switzerland has the most highly skilled workers in the world. This is why

These are the countries best prepared for health emergencies

The essence of care is cosmopolitan

Call to revitalize ‘language of the ancestors’ for survival of future generations: Indigenous chief

Mental Health: Role of the individual for their well-being in the pandemic

‘Fire-fighting approach’ to humanitarian aid ‘not sustainable’: Deputy UN chief

Black babies more likely to survive when cared for by Black doctors, suggests new study

EU Commission spends billions without achieving targets

“The Arctic climate matters: to what degree?”, a Sting Exclusive co-authored by UN Environment’s Jan Dusik and Slava Fetisov

EU-Vietnam free trade deal gets green light in trade committee

Here are five things to know about the future of being human

UN health agency spotlights stalled effort to close health divide across Europe, in new report

IMF v Germany: Eurogroup keeps the fight under control

European Junior Enterprise Network – Ready to take the Step Into the Future?

Here’s what I learned at Davos 2020

Yesterday’s “jokes” and sarcasm by Digital Single Market’s Vice President Ansip on EU member states’ right to protect their telco markets

We need to talk about integration after migration. Here are four ways we can improve it

UN human rights chief fears world has grown numb to Syrian carnage

Health is nothing but the main consequence of climate change

Financial abuse of elderly ‘rampant, but invisible’, says UN expert

Europe should make voice ‘more heard’ in today’s ‘dangerous world,’ says UN chief

Reducing disaster risk is a good investment, and ‘the right thing to do’, says Guterres

5 priorities for leaders in the new reality of COVID-19

How the United States can win back its manufacturing mojo

From low-earth orbit, ‘envoys’ of humanity join UN space forum

iSting: Change Europe with your Writing

Council Presidency: Floundering with the EU 2014 budget

This wall of shoes is for the women killed by domestic violence

Workplace risks: Final vote on protection from carcinogens, including diesel fumes

Copyright: MEPs update rules for the digital age

UN chief calls for ‘united front’ against anti-Semitism after US synagogue mass-shooting

Eurogroup asked to reduce public debts of its member states

Top UN political official updates Security Council on Iran nuclear deal

I created a class to teach zero waste. It turned into so much more

Superbugs: MEPs advocate further measures to curb use of antimicrobials

‘Amid stormy global seas, UN charter remains our moral anchor’, says Guterres on United Nations Day

ECB’s €1.14 trillion again unifies Eurozone; Germany approves sovereign debt risks to be pooled

Grexit no longer a threat but how to manage a “tutti frutti” government if not with fear?

‘Our goal is to democratize the air.’ How aerial transportation will shape cities of the future

Service and Sacrifice: For Ghana, UN peacekeeping is a ‘noble opportunity to serve humanity’

Israeli security forces’ response to Gaza protests ‘a recipe for more bloodshed’, says UN expert

Environmental Implementation Review: Commission helps Member States to better apply EU environment rules to protect citizens and enhance their quality of life

Yemen ceasefire deal: ‘Potential’ now to restore humanitarian lifeline to millions

AI can wreak havoc if left unchecked by humans

Celebrating Gaston Ramon – the vet who discovered vaccinology’s secret weapon

2 trillion drinks containers are made every year – so where do they go?

E-cigarettes are killing us softly with their vapor

Business is a crucial partner in solving the mental health challenge

The Ultimate Career Choice: General Practice Specialist

State aid: Commission approves German scheme for very high capacity broadband networks in Bavaria

These airports are now opening their doors to non-fliers

AI looks set to disrupt the established world order. Here’s how

Why do thousands of migrants need to be drowned for Brussels to wake up?

EU-US resume trade negotiations under the spell of NSA surveillance

There are 3 barriers blocking good menstrual hygiene for all women. Here’s how we overcome them

Denmark’s last circus elephants are retiring – here’s what might take their place

Tax havens cost governments $200 billion a year. It’s time to change the way global tax works

This AI can predict your personality just by looking at your eyes

Here’s how we reboot digital trade for the 21st century

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s