How did Facebook fool the Commission that easily during the WhatsApp acquisition?

margrethe-vestager

Press conference by Margrethe Vestager, Member of the EC, on a cartel case Date: 07/12/2016. Location: Brussels – EC/Berlaymont. © European Union, 2016. Source: EC – Audiovisual Service. Photo: Mauro Bottaro

The European Commission announced yesterday that a Statement of Objections was sent to Facebook accusing the company of providing incorrect or misleading information during the investigation under Facebook’s acquisition of WhatsApp. The aforementioned information was that Facebook had initially reassured the EC that it was not possible to match the user accounts of Facebook and WhatsApp.

However, it was last August when WhatsApp changed its privacy policy giving permission to share its users’ phone numbers and device information with Facebook; thus showing that the user accounts between the two companies can be easily matched after all. Was the tech giant acting deliberately or not? Did Facebook know this possibility and concealed it in fear of the EC cancelling the proposed acquisition? One thing is for sure, that tech giants like Facebook do not make so many naive mistakes every day.

EU Commission against Facebook

Facebook becomes the latest Silicon Valley target of the EU competition chief Margrethe Vestager, who has already demanded Apple to pay back billions in taxes to Ireland and severely hit Google with two market abuse investigations.

The Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, mentioned that it is mandatory for companies to provide accurate information to the European Commission when investigated over a proposed acquisition. In the case of Facebook, the company had misled the Commission with incorrect data, stating during the merger investigation in 2014 that it is unable to provide reliable automatic matching between Facebook and WhatsApp user accounts.

More specifically, Margrethe Vestager said: “Companies are obliged to give the Commission accurate information during merger investigations. They must take this obligation seriously. Our timely and effective review of mergers depends on the accuracy of the information provided by the companies involved. The Commission’s preliminary view is that Facebook gave us incorrect or misleading information during the investigation into its acquisition of WhatsApp. Facebook now has the opportunity to respond.”

Will Facebook respond effectively?

Facebook has now until the end of January to respond in written to the Commission but the initial response by a spokesperson of Facebook was that the company acted in “good faith” respecting the investigation procedure.

More in detail, the spokesperson said in an e-mail statement yesterday: “We have consistently provided accurate information about our technical capabilities and plans, including in submissions about the WhatsApp acquisition and in voluntary briefings before WhatsApp privacy policy update. We’re pleased that the Commission stands by its clearance decision, and we will continue to cooperate and share information officials need to resolve their questions.”

The firm, in case the Commission’s concerns are verified, faces now a fine of up to 1% of its 2014 turnover. This means that the tech giant will have to pay almost 180 million dollars.

The outcome though remains the same

The Commission’s investigation in order to approve the acquisition of WhatsApp Inc. by Facebook Inc. focused on three areas: consumer communications services, social networking services, and online advertising services. The conclusion was that Facebook and WhatsApp were not close competitors in the messaging market, but they were rather distant competitors in the social networking market. Moreover, in the online advertising market there were sufficient alternative providers of advertising and sources of Internet user information.

Taking the investigation further, the EC examined whether the acquisition could strengthen Facebook’s position in the online advertising market and hamper competition even if WhatsApp was not active in that market. Particularly, the Commission probed about the possibility that Facebook could introduce advertising on WhatsApp or use WhatsApp as a potential source of user data for improving the targeting of Facebook’s advertisements.

The outcome was that regardless whether Facebook would introduce advertising on WhatsApp or start collecting WhatsApp user data, the acquisition would not raise competition concerns. This is because after the merger, it will still be a sufficient number of alternative providers to Facebook for the supply of targeted advertising. A large amount of Internet user data which are valuable for advertising purposes are not within Facebook’s exclusive control.

The next step

It is now at the hands of Facebook to examine the documents that the Commission has in its possession and reply in written to the European institution requesting an oral hearing to state its arguments.

However, the charges will not affect the approval of the acquisition of WhatsApp by Facebook and are unrelated to neighbouring privacy, data protection or consumer protection issues according to the EC. The point though is whether Facebook did mislead the Commission after all, either intentionally or negligently, in an attempt to make sure that the acquisition will be accepted.

It is quite hard to believe that Facebook, even for the most naive analyst, that one of the greatest U.S. tech giants, hadn’t tested the matching of the user accounts between the two companies before proceeding to the merger process.

Therefore, it is imperative that the European Commission keeps a rigid stance on the matter, exhausting all possible means to prevent other companies from following similar policies.

Let’s not forget the obvious, that similar company policies could have a crucial impact on the data privacy rights of the European citizen.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

To my Chinese friend

Human rights chief calls for international probe on Venezuela, following ‘shocking accounts of extrajudicial killings’

An open letter from business to world leaders: “Be ambitious, and together we can address climate change”

THE COMMITTEES: From the colonies to the space race – past, present, future converge in Fourth Committee

Inegalitarian taxation on labour haunts Europe’s social model

Postal workers in France are helping elderly people fight loneliness

Eurozone banks to separate risky activities: Can they stay afloat?

Joint advocacy letter template to sign and ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons

Nuclear test ban treaty critical to global collective security – UN chief

Water supply a human right but Greeks to lose their functioning utilities

Lack of involvement, or lack of opportunities?

UN condemns deadly attack against G5 Sahel force headquarters in Mali

FROM THE FIELD: A UN peacekeepers-eye view of DR Congo

Libya: ‘Substantial civilian casualties’ in Derna, UN humanitarian chief ‘deeply concerned’

EU-Russia relations: the beginning of a warmer winter?

What can stop the ‘too big to fail’ bankers from terrorising the world?

The European Parliament double-checks the EU 2014-2020 budget

Job automation risks vary widely across different regions within countries

Want a more inclusive society? Start with mobility

New chapters in EU-China trade disputes

UN urges ‘restraint’ in Bangladesh’s post-presidential election violence

Why are the Balkans’ political leaders meeting in Geneva this week?

A Sting Exclusive: “China-Africa Cooperation Sets a Fine Example of South-South Cooperation”, by China’s Ambassador to EU

Why do medical students have to emigrate to become doctors in 2017?

Young people meet in Malta to shape the future of Europe

UN agency chief calls Ethiopia’s revised refugee law ‘one of most progressive’ in Africa

Draghi tells the Parliament the ECB to use all its weaponry; euro slides to parity with the dollar

Canada and EU officially sign the trade agreement that could open-up the road to TTIP

UN chief condemns deadly attacks in Afghanistan

These charts show where the world’s refugees came from in 2017 – and where they’re heading

Imported and EU fisheries products should be treated equally

Why we need both science and humanities for a Fourth Industrial Revolution education

Better care, stronger laws needed to save 30 million babies on the brink of death

Eating less beef and more beans would cut deaths by 5-7%

Commission goes less than mid-way on expensive euro

Is ECB helping Germany to buy cheaply the rest of Europe?

TTIP is not dead as of yet, the 15th round of negotiations in New York shouts

Can Greece’s devastating economy deal with the migration crisis?

Three ways the world must tackle mental health

EU lawmakers vote to reintroduce visas for Americans over “reciprocity principle”

“Access denied”: the Greek health system under pressure

UN chief condemns killing of ‘blue helmets’ in DR Congo, as violence erupts prior to elections

MWC 2016 LIVE: EC adds Brazil to partner tally

Some Prevailing Arguments and Perceptions over the South China Sea Issue Are Simply Wrong

The representatives of the regions and the cities know better what the EU needs on migration, trade, poverty and taxation

Climate Change: a challenge yet to be tackled in medical schools

A Sting Exclusive: “Seize the opportunity offered by Africa’s continental free trade area”, written by the Director General of UNIDO

Climate change will never be combatted by EU alone while some G20 countries keep procrastinating

Guinea-Bissau: Upcoming elections vital to prevent ‘relapse’ into instability, says UN envoy

This is the world’s greenest football club – and you’ve probably never even heard of it

EU to increase spending and improve delivery of education in emergencies and protracted crises

Deal on protecting workers from exposure to harmful substances

From diamonds to recycling: how blockchain can drive responsible and ethical businesses

“Health and environment first of all”, EU says with forced optimism after 7th round of TTIP talks

‘12 million’ stateless people globally, warns UNHCR chief in call to States for decisive action

Bid to raise $5.5 billion for millions of Syrians and their host communities

EU members commit to build an integrated gas market and finally cut dependency on Russia

The ECB still protects the banks at the expense of the EU taxpayers

The way to entrepreneurship in the developing world

A Europe that delivers: EU citizens expect more EU level action in future

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s