Can the EU really make Google and Facebook pay publishers and media?

Google logo__According to a number of media outlets of the Old Continent, the closing weeks of this summer will try to bring a major reform in the European publishing industry. As revealed last week by the Guardian and the Financial Times, the European Commission is working on a plan to give news publishers the right to demand payment from services like Google and Facebook for using their content. Despite the fact that an actual proposal will only be unveiled by Brussels in September, the plan itself sounds already like a radical change for the news industry.

A bigger plan

The measures are currently under development and there’s still a lot to find out around them, but what is already certain is that the proposals are part of a wider plan by the European Commission to weaken the dominance of internet giants in Europe, whose market share has ultimately slashed the revenues of newspapers and other traditional publishers.

A recent report published by the Guardian showed that online platforms such as Facebook will suck £450 million out of the UK news industry over the next decade. The report by strategy consultants OC&C says that, based on the impact of platforms on other mature media markets such as music, about 30% of annual digital revenue could go to platforms. That would mean the likes of Facebook and Apple taking between £200m and £250m a year this year, rising to between £400m and £450m from 2026.

Increasing pressure from publishers

Such figures suggest that the Guardian is probably more than right in saying that the Commission must have come under increasing pressure from publishers to level the playing field, after years of losses. The Financial Times indeed reports that the Commission sees the “dwindling revenues” at traditional news organisations as the core of the issue. A failure to push on with such a policy, according to the Commission’s draft document, would be “prejudicial for […] media pluralism”.

In its draft proposals, the words that the Commission reportedly uses actually leave no space for misunderstandings. “The sustainability of publishing industries in the EU may be at stake, with the risk of further negative consequences on media pluralism, democratic debate and quality of information”, as quoted by the Guardian. Therefore, the Commission will rule to let news publishers receive “exclusive rights” to make their content available online to the public, in a move that would “force services such as Google News to agree terms with news organisations” for showing extracts of articles, as revealed by the Financial Times.

Video and music content under the lens

The working document by the European Commission has also space for platforms like YouTube, Vimeo and Dailymotion, as circulated on many newspapers recently. The music industry has long complained that services such as YouTube do not pay artists adequate amounts for their music and has openly asked regulators to close the gap. Now the Commission is looking at imposing an obligation on platforms hosting user-uploaded content to seek agreements with rights holders “reflecting the economic value of the use made of the protected content”, as described in the draft documents.

YouTube uses Content ID, which automatically identifies an artist’s content, to give rights holders the choice of whether to leave it as it is, block it or monetize it through a revenue-sharing deal, and Google says that the music industry chooses to monetize 95% of its Content ID claims, generating more than $ 2 billion for rights holders. But rights holders say they do not have enough contractual power and that there’s never a fair discussion with online platforms since they have obligation to negotiate with them.

A jeopardized approach

The non-compulsory nature of the resolution and many of the aspects that online platforms have claimed as a defense of their conduct may carry the risk of creating a lot of uncertainty when the plan will be unveiled, and there could be more to come. It is true that the draft proposal already shows that the plan has been designed to be quite protective for the so called “traditional” publishing industry, but on the other hand there would be also the risk of creating a more fragmented market rather than a unified one. As an example, it is important to keep in mind that there would be no obligation on publishers to make Google pay for using their content. Many indeed may also choose to continue making their journalism available at zero cost in the hope of attracting more readers and having a broader range.

EU-US clash

What sounds almost sure, despite the huge uncertainty, is that the move will represent a new challenge for the already strained relationship between Silicon Valley and Brussels, which has been through hard times lately over issues concerning free competition, tax and privacy. The EU-Google file is more-than-ever hot and there’s a recent case of the US Treasury department attacking the Commission’s moves to obtain billions of euros from Apple for an alleged tax evasion case in the Old Continent.

The Commission seems anyway more than convinced to present the plan despite the risk of opening a real quarrel with US firms, in the name of the creation of a digital single market that stretches its borders up to this matter too. The mission has the aim of reducing the differences between national copyright schemes and now the Commission must have realized that a jeopardized approach on this topic didn’t produce good effects in the past.

Prior efforts to force internet firms to pay up in European countries such as Germany and Spain, where Google reacted to a mandatory charge by shutting down Google News, indeed show how difficult the whole endeavour will eventually be. Hence, the Commission needs to be prepared now for a powerful reaction by the US Internet giants against its desperate plans to save the lives of media moguls of this continent.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Preparing medical students being digitally as well as socially responsible

Leveraging digital for high quality internships

Heard about deepfakes? Don’t panic. Prepare

New UN bullying report calls for ‘safe, inclusive’ schools for all children

2nd Global Consultation on Migrant Health 21-23 February 2017 in Sri Lanka

New Disability Inclusion Strategy is ‘transformative change we need’, says Guterres

Using CO2 as an industrial feedstock could change the world. Here’s how

This is the world’s greenest football club – and you’ve probably never even heard of it

Amazon, a pair of shoes and my Data Privacy walks away

Finland has a new eco-fashion line – clothes made from trees

UN News Daily #UNGA Guide: Mandela Peace Summit, Global Goals, Youth and Yemen

South Sudan ‘revitalized’ peace deal must be inclusive, Security Council hears

Agreement on EU funding for cross-border projects

Solidarity needed to overcome ‘isolated’ attacks on Venezuela refugees, migrants

Fair Taxation: EU updates list of non-cooperative tax jurisdictions

Will COVID-19 usher in a new culture of outdoor living and dining?

This Central Asian lake is a stark reminder of the impact we have on the planet

The EU has to prove it can remain one piece

“An open China brings opportunities to Europe”, a Sting Exclusive by China’s Ambassador to EU

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: Guterres calls for restraint in Venezuela, Jazz Day, the importance of breastfeeding, and updates from Libya, Iran and Mozambique

Big data is coming to agriculture. Farmers must set its course

This is how to achieve a clean economic recovery that combats organized crime

How climate change can be addressed through executive compensation

Colombia: ‘Significant strides’ towards integrated peace, UN envoy tells Security Council

The reverberation of permanent multiprofessional education in combating antimicrobial resistance: future generation prognostic change

Cross-roads

Trailing the US-EU economic confrontation

South Africa’s SMEs should be first in line for a digital upgrade

African continent ‘an example of solidarity’ towards migrants and refugees: UN chief

Carbon neutrality and funds for EU programmes are EP priorities for EU summit

Here’s what happened when a charity gave $1,000 each to poor households in Kenya

EU mobilises €21 million to support Palestine refugees via the UN Relief and Works Agency

Service and Sacrifice: For Ghana, UN peacekeeping is a ‘noble opportunity to serve humanity’

NATO summit, Brussels, 11-12/07/2018

Trump to run America to the tune of his business affairs

Colombia: Rights experts condemn killing of reintegrated former rebel fighter, call for respect of peace process

The Italian ‘no’ and France’s Fillon to reshape Europe; Paris moves closer to Berlin

Syria’s groundbreaking constitutional talks: ‘a clear success of mediation’ says Guterres in Turkey

Strong multilateral institutions key to tackling world’s dramatic challenges, UN chief says In Moscow

How the digital economy is shaping a new Bangladesh

Will technology connect or divide us? The challenge for leaders in Globalization 4.0

COP25 climate talks: What just happened, and what lies ahead?

In Yemen, Special Envoy sees UN role in preserving ‘essential’ aid pipeline at country’s major port

Colombia is a Latin American success story, but must pursue new reforms to achieve stronger and more inclusive growth

UN chief ‘following very closely’ reports of chemical weapons use in Syria’s Aleppo

France is bringing back national service

4 ways to keep the momentum rolling on mental health

We must treat cybersecurity as a public good. Here’s why

Statement on the Code of Practice against disinformation: Commission asks online platforms to provide more details on progress made

As Libya talks resume in Geneva, UN negotiator seeks to overcome sticking points

AI can help us unlock the world’s most complex operating system – the human body

How to make later life happy, healthy and meaningful

One more country to test the EU project: Kaczynski’s Poland

China is among the 20 most innovative economies for the first time

To save biodiversity, MEPs call for binding targets at global and EU level

Tributes for ‘role model’ former UN refugee agency chief, Sadako Ogata

Mergers: Commission approves acquisition of Raytheon by UTC, subject to conditions

Financing economic recovery, written by United Nations Under-Secretary-General

French full-body veil ban, violated women’s freedom of religion: UN Human Rights Committee

The costs of corruption: values, economic development under assault, trillions lost, says Guterres

More Stings?

Advertising

Comments

  1. Thanks for this post. I definitely agree with what you’re saying. I’ve been talking about this topic a whole lot lately with my brother so hopefully this will get him to see my point of view. Fingers crossed!

  2. I believe one of your advertisings triggered my internet browser to resize, you might well want to put that on your blacklist.

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s