‘Habitual residence’ rules deprive EU workers from social benefits

Press conference by László Andor, Member of the EC, Member of the EC, on the guide on application of ‘Habitual Residence Test’ for social security. (EC Audio-visual Services, 13/1/2014).

Press conference by László Andor, Member of the EC, Member of the EC, on the guide on application of ‘Habitual Residence Test’ for social security. (EC Audio-visual Services, 13/1/2014).

With a timely move the European Commission published yesterday a guide on the application of the ‘Habitual Residence Test’, in this way permanently blocking what has been termed as social ‘benefit tourism’. By the same token, the Commission also erased the rightful expectation of people who are employed as ‘posted workers’ in another EU member state, to claim the social benefits of the host country. In most cases they have already been deprived of the right to claim equal wages as their colleagues of the host member state.

This ‘habitual residence’ guide came only a few weeks after the Commission facilitated the ‘posting of workers’ last December, by securing that this arrangement can be used even by a temporary employment firm or a placement agency. Those labour ‘merchants’ can now hire workers in one member state to be employed by one or more “user” businesses established in another Member State. Of course the remuneration will be of the low labour cost country.

In principle, the above arrangements are not new. Even since 1996 the Directive 96/71/EC provided that in the case of ‘posted workers’ “The obligation to respect the minimum rates of pay does not oblige Member States to set or introduce minimum wages, if they do not exist in the Member State in question”. In Britain and Germany there is no legally binding minimum wage. As a result, the remuneration of posted workers from Poland or Bulgaria working for two years in Germany or Britain tend to be nearer to the levels of his or hers country of origin rather than the much higher levels of the host country.

Balkan wages in north Europe

But it’s not only the level of remuneration for Bulgarian workers posted say to Germany that resembles Balkan standards. Also the social security conditions applying in their case are the ones provided by the regime of their country of origin rather than the host member state. Regulation No 883/2004 of 29 April 2004 ruling on the coordination of social security systems, foresees the following in the Article 12, “A person who pursues an activity as an employed person in a Member State on behalf of an employer which normally carries out its activities there and who is posted by that employer to another Member State to perform work on that employer’s behalf shall continue to be subject to the legislation of the first Member State, provided that the anticipated duration of such work does not exceed twenty-four months and that he is not sent to replace another person”. Last December the EU extended this arrangement to posted workers who ‘belong’ to an agency of their home country and work on behalf of more than one employer in the host country, under Balkan conditions for at least two years.

In short, ‘posted workers’ get Balkan wages and social protection, while working for up to two years in another member state. Now the Commission wants to make sure that even ‘posted workers’ who live and work for up to two years in another member state cannot claim social benefits in this host country. And this despite the fact that their residence is there for at least two years. Yesterday László Andor, Commissioner for Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion, said: “There are clear safeguards in EU law to prevent people from abusing social welfare systems of other EU countries. This guide will make it easier for Member States authorities to apply the ‘Habitual Residence’ safeguards in practice. The handbook is part of the Commission’s ongoing actions to facilitate the free movement of people throughout the EU.”

Habitually lost

A few lines below this statement the Press release issued by the Commission makes sure that ‘posted workers’ cannot be considered as ‘habitual residents’ in the country in which they work for two years. For example a Bulgarian working legally in Germany or a Polish working in Britain for two years is not entitled to German or British social security benefits. The Commission stresses that the “The guide, drafted in cooperation with Member States, clarifies the separate concepts of ‘habitual residence’ and ‘temporary residence’ or ‘stay’”. These definitions are laid down in EU law (Regulation EC/883/2004). Even a British citizen who has settled in Portugal and still owns a home in Britain is not any more a ‘habitual resident’ of Britain and is not entitled of the social benefits of his country of origin.

This new Commission guide on application of ‘Habitual Residence Test’ for social security gives a lot of complicated examples in order to help the national authorities answer questionable claims of benefits. The common denominator in all those cases is that the foreign citizen or the national who lives abroad is not entitled of social benefits. Even students in another country who return to their parents’ home only during holidays are not considered as ‘habitual residents’ of the country where they study and spend 90% of their days for say five years.

Who sets the rules

It’s more than evident that the Commission has succumbed to the demands of the big core member states like Germany, France and Britain. Obviously, the central and wealthy EU member states are trying to curtail the demands for social benefits and restrict the right to such claims to the absolute minimum of people. The exoneration from the right to claim social benefits in their own country of nationals who live most of the year in another member state must be a total novelty.

In any case, this new guide of ‘Habitual Residence Test’ is a clear indication that the internal dualism of the EU between high and low labour cost countries is to be safeguarded rather than to be erased. Presumably, the high labour cost member states want to have access to low cost labour but they do not facilitate the permanent emigration. The foreign national may be living and working for years in another EU member state but he is always considered as ‘habitual resident’ of his country of origin and has no rights on the social benefits and the level of labour remuneration of the host country.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

China Unlimited: an exclusive interview with the former Ambassador of Hungary to China

Healthcare workers’ safety: a forgotten necessity

Understanding the ‘second brain’ in your gut

5 things to know about the exploding world of pro gaming

First EU-wide protection for whistle-blowers agreed

The EU has to prove it can remain one piece

These 8 countries have perfect scores for women’s rights at work

International Women’s Day: Where does she belong?

Africa-Europe Alliance: European Commission committed to a sustainable African agri-food sector

4 things ISPs can do to reduce the impact of cybercrime

Trump ‘used’ G20 to side with Putin and split climate and trade packs

State aid: Commission opens in-depth investigation into arbitration award in favour of Antin to be paid by Spain

Vile act of torture prohibited ‘under all circumstances’, UN chief affirms on International Day to support victims

3 ways to ensure the internet’s future is creative, collaborative and fair

This lethal fungus is threatening to wipe out the world’s bananas

EU food watchdog: more transparency, better risk prevention

New rules on drivers’ working conditions and fair competition in road transport

Help African farmers cope with climate change threats, UN food agency urges

Why cybersecurity matters more than ever during the coronavirus pandemic

Europe eyes to replace US as China’s prime foreign partner

3 ways to make technologies more inclusive for people with disabilities

Confidence in the COVID-19 vaccine grows in UK and US, but global concerns about side effects are on the rise

Preventing and resolving conflicts must form ‘backbone’ of collective efforts – UN chief

UPDATED: Thousands flee fighting around Libyan capital as Guterres condemns escalation, urges ‘immediate halt’ to all military operations

How emerging markets will shape Africa in 2020

5 factors driving the Chinese lawtech boom

This tool shows you which cities will flood as ice sheets melt

High-tech or ‘high-touch’: UK survey gives clues to the jobs of the future

Security Council urges ‘maximum restraint’ around Gulf region as Iran and United States trade diplomatic blows in New York

EU Parliament says ‘no’ to austerity budget

ISIS fighters fleeing Mosul for Syria can topple Assad. Why did the US now decide to uproot them from Iraq?

China and China-EU Relations in the New Era

5 things you might not know about forests – but should

More hiring freedom can reduce teacher shortages in disadvantaged areas

When it comes to envirotech adoption, NGOs can lead us out of the woods

‘Extinction crisis’ pushes countries to agree stronger protection for global wildlife

Why we need both science and humanities for a Fourth Industrial Revolution education

The digital transformation is a skills and education opportunity for all. Companies must use it

European Commission increases support for the EU’s beekeeping sector

Building a Climate-Resilient Future – A new EU Strategy on Adaptation to Climate Change

The UK option: An overarching alternative for the whole Brexit options

‘The time for action is now’ senior UN peacekeeping official says, urging support for regional force combating Sahel terrorism

Mediterranean migrant drownings should spur greater action by European countries, urge UN agencies

Carbon levy on EU imports needed to raise global climate ambition

Iran: women hunger strikers entitled to medical care, UN rights experts urge

It is now the era to evolve mutually as the bacteria do

COVID-19: Revised rules to encourage banks to lend to companies and households

Fashion’s hot new trend: clothes you don’t need to wash (very often)

Stronger partnerships with post-conflict countries needed to ensure ‘path towards durable peace’: UN chief

Republic of Korea President proposes DMZ as future ‘peace and cooperation district’ on Peninsula

Women’s work faces the greatest risk of automation, says new research

May led Britain to chaos, now looks for way out with unpredictable DUP

We must rethink and repurpose cybersecurity for the COVID-19 era

EU-Turkey relations: EU considers imposing sanctions while Turkey keeps violating Cyprus’ sovereignty

National parks give a $6 trillion boost to mental health worldwide

Here’s how data can shine a light on financial crime

Will Eurozone be able to repay its debts? Is a bubble forming there?

Eight years in, Syria still embroiled in conflict ‘that no longer sparks outrage’, Security Council hears

Difficulties of vaccination against COVID-19

Services are the hidden side of the US-China trade war

More Stings?

Comments

  1. I couldn’t resist commenting. Very well written!

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s