EU Commission: Once in every 20 beef meals you eat…horse probably with drugs in it

Tonio Borg, Member of the EC in charge of Health and Consumer Policy and Paola Testori Coggi Director General, in the Directorate-General for Health and Consumers of the European Commission, in a happy exchange at the Health Policy Forum. (EC Audiovisual Services, 09/04/2013).

Tonio Borg, Member of the EC in charge of Health and Consumer Policy and Paola Testori Coggi Director General, in the Directorate-General for Health and Consumers of the European Commission, in a happy exchange at the Health Policy Forum. (EC Audiovisual Services, 09/04/2013).

This week the European Commission, and in order to be fair and precise, the European Commissioner Tonio Borg, tried once more to convince 500.7 million European consumers that the horsemeat and the Phenylbutazone scandal didn’t reveal any loopholes, in the EU food quality control systems. In a European Commission Press release issued at the beginning of this week, Borg insisted once more that according to the “test results on horse DNA and Phenylbutazone (showed) no food safety issues but tougher penalties to apply in the future to fraudulent labelling”.

Playing with our health

At this point the European Sting has to remind to Borg that within 24 hours from 14 to 15 February he changed altogether his assessment of the horsemeat scandal gravity. Sting writer Suzan A. Kane wrote on 16 February: {It was only the day before yesterday that the 27 EU ministers of Agriculture heard Tonio saying, “regarding the unlabeled presence of horsemeat found in certain processed food products, including burgers and beef lasagne…it is important to underline that the evidence to date in relation to this episode does not suggest a health crisis. Horsemeat, according to EU legislation, can be used for the production of minced meat and meat preparations”…As it turned out this horsemeat is suspected of containing phenylbutazone. This is a veterinary medicine the use of which in food-producing animals is illegal. In less than 24 hours Tonio was obliged by facts to retreat in his words and yesterday asked the 27 member states to test samples also for this dangerous for human health substance}.

This time the Commissioner responsible or probably irresponsible for Health and Consumer Policy tries once more to convince us that nothing happened, by using some statistical methods he obviously cannot understand. He maintains that there was no danger at all from the phenylbutazone found in our food. According to the Press release “the probability of a consumer being both susceptible to developing aplastic anaemia and being exposed to phenylbutazone was estimated to range approximately from 2 in a trillion to 1 in 100 million”.

As all first year students of Statistics know well that when it comes to probabilities it’s very easy to arrive to millions. The more complex a possible outcome is, the more probabilities are being multiplied to calculate the overall probability, for this complex possible outcome to happen. For example if the probability of a person being susceptible of developing aplastic anaemia is 1/1 000 000 and the probability to eat a meatball with phenylbutazone is 1%, then the probability this person susceptible of developing aplastic anaemia to eat a contaminated meatball is 1/1,000,000 * 1/100=1/100,000,000. For one thing one meticulous researcher could question those two probabilities. Usually when politicians want to hide the truth from people by using statistics, they underestimate the bad probability and overestimate the good one.

The play with statistics is very dangerous and very easily steerable to the preferred direction. Bankers for example, by underestimating the statistical risks built-in the ‘products’ they sold to investors, drove the whole world to the present financial and real economy crisis. In the case of human health however it’s not ‘profit & loss’ but health and illness, if not life and death. On top of that even if one accepts Borg’s logic that the probability for somebody to become very ill is 1 to 100 000 000, in the case of the 500 000 000 European million citizens, it is certain that 5 people will suffer. No Mr Borg?
In any case the whole text of the Press release issue by Borg is an obvious attempt to minimise the dangers, from a food industry quality control system completely inadequate and prone to produce alerts. For years the British cows, were fed with animal proteins before getting crazy, and nobody stopped it. Or what about this present case? The horsemeat stuffed with phenylbutazone, which was sold as beef before being detected in Britain, had galloped for weeks freely all over the European Union.

More probabilities

There is a lot more however in this Commission Press release. According to the text published, “the coordinated EU-wide testing for horsemeat DNA and phenylbutazone requested, and co-financed, by the European Commission in the wake of the horsemeat scandal has revealed that less than 5 % of the tested products had horse DNA and that about 0.5 % of the equine carcasses tested were found to be contaminated with bute”. If we use the laws of statistics and basic arithmetic, the probability to eat a beef product containing horsemeat with bute is 5/100* 5/1000= 25/100000=1/4000.

Not very little, because it means that one, in every 4000 beef preparations in the EU, contains horsemeat with bute. When Borg was telling the truth? Was it at the time when he reassured us that we are safe, because our chance to be ill from this reason is 2 in a trillion or now that out chances to swallow bute is one in 4000? Is it possible for a healthy person to eat bute and not be affected in some way? And for God’s sake, if we run such a danger every time we open our refrigerator, then what good is there in paying with our taxes all those fancy services, which supposedly control the quality of our food? The consumer organisations could do much better with all that money.

Last but not least the Commission didn’t comment at all about the huge probability we might be fed with low quality horsemeat, when we pay for beef. This probability is an unbelievable 5%, meaning that once in every twenty times we eat a beef preparation, it contains horsemeat. There is obviously something rotten in the kingdom of our food quality control services.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

How technology is driving a fourth wave of environmentalism

Syria: Why did the US now take the Russian offer for a truce? What next?

The influence of the multilateral agreement on migrant health

The opportunity of studying Medicine abroad

Want more climate action? Let’s show how good a planet-friendly life can be

Wide-ranging reforms needed to ensure Italy’s economic recovery

Milk, fruits and vegetables distributed to schoolchildren thanks to EU programme

Human Rights Council election: 5 things you need to know about it

Humanitarian visas to avoid refugees’ deaths

Corruption thwarts attempts to build a better world and ‘must be fought by all, for all’

Medical Devices Regulation: Commission welcomes Council support to prioritise the fight against coronavirus

Development aid drops in 2018, especially to neediest countries

ECB to buy corporate bonds: Will government financing be the next step?

Innovation for a smarter world: ITU Telecom World 2018

What data dominance really means, and how countries can compete

Would you want to live to 150? Top quotes on what it means to grow old

‘Dire consequences’ for a million children in the Middle East, North Africa, as funding dwindles

Food finally features in the climate debate. Now what?

Commission presents EU-Vietnam trade and investment agreements for signature and conclusion

The movement of anti-vaccers: taking humanity back 200 years

The digital revolution will transform the steel industry

Inaction on obesity stands in the way of sustainable development

EU-US ties to break over Iran; Democrats’ electoral win may not change it

We need to talk about failure in the social sector

ECB asks for more subsidies to banks

Girls still being treated as aliens in medicine in the 21st century

Oxford Dictionaries’ word of the year for 2019 is ‘climate emergency’

How the gig economy can transform farms in the developing world

‘Once lost, hearing doesn’t come back,’ World Health Organization warns on World Hearing Day

US-North Korea summit in Singapore ‘a promising development’ says Guterres

How AI is shaping financial services

Don’t compare data to oil – digitization needs a new mindset

Antarctica: the final coronavirus-free frontier. But will it stay that way?

Health Education, is it a necessity?

Parliament’s interparliamentary delegations established

14 ways to protect your mental health in the pandemic, according to Public Health England

Skills, not job titles, are the new metric for the labour market

Building social good – lessons from an Asian giant

The Fourth Industrial Revolution needs a social revolution, too. Here’s how we can make this happen

We are ‘burning up our future’, UN’s Bachelet tells Human Rights Council

Burnout is a pandemic. Why don’t we talk more about it?

What the US and the world can expect from the 8 November election?

Canada needs to increase foreign aid flows in line with its renewed engagement

A Sting Exclusive: “Delivering on the Environmental Dimension of the new Sustainable Development Agenda”, Ulf Björnholm underscores from UNEP Brussels

Could the EU’s ban on palm oil in biofuels do more harm than good?

Eurozone: Avoiding a new Greek accident

The business case for investing in sustainable plastics

ACP-EU Parliamentary Assembly: strengthening the partnership

Mental health and suicide: from the 19th century to present

Shenzhen just made all its buses electric, and taxis are next

Commission makes it easier for citizens to access health data securely across borders

The West and Russia took what they wanted from Ukraine

FROM THE FIELD: South Sudan’s green shoots, highlight environmental recovery from war

Poor quality is healthcare’s silent killer. Here’s what we can do about it

The US bugged Europe: Is this news?

As the Universal Declaration of Human Rights turns 70 – is it time for a new approach?

How drones can help rural Africa take flight

France and Germany can’t reach consensus regarding EU’s top jobs

These companies can recycle nearly anything, from cigarette butts to fax machines

8 steps towards a sustainable economic recovery

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s