EU Commission: Once in every 20 beef meals you eat…horse probably with drugs in it

Tonio Borg, Member of the EC in charge of Health and Consumer Policy and Paola Testori Coggi Director General, in the Directorate-General for Health and Consumers of the European Commission, in a happy exchange at the Health Policy Forum. (EC Audiovisual Services, 09/04/2013).

Tonio Borg, Member of the EC in charge of Health and Consumer Policy and Paola Testori Coggi Director General, in the Directorate-General for Health and Consumers of the European Commission, in a happy exchange at the Health Policy Forum. (EC Audiovisual Services, 09/04/2013).

This week the European Commission, and in order to be fair and precise, the European Commissioner Tonio Borg, tried once more to convince 500.7 million European consumers that the horsemeat and the Phenylbutazone scandal didn’t reveal any loopholes, in the EU food quality control systems. In a European Commission Press release issued at the beginning of this week, Borg insisted once more that according to the “test results on horse DNA and Phenylbutazone (showed) no food safety issues but tougher penalties to apply in the future to fraudulent labelling”.

Playing with our health

At this point the European Sting has to remind to Borg that within 24 hours from 14 to 15 February he changed altogether his assessment of the horsemeat scandal gravity. Sting writer Suzan A. Kane wrote on 16 February: {It was only the day before yesterday that the 27 EU ministers of Agriculture heard Tonio saying, “regarding the unlabeled presence of horsemeat found in certain processed food products, including burgers and beef lasagne…it is important to underline that the evidence to date in relation to this episode does not suggest a health crisis. Horsemeat, according to EU legislation, can be used for the production of minced meat and meat preparations”…As it turned out this horsemeat is suspected of containing phenylbutazone. This is a veterinary medicine the use of which in food-producing animals is illegal. In less than 24 hours Tonio was obliged by facts to retreat in his words and yesterday asked the 27 member states to test samples also for this dangerous for human health substance}.

This time the Commissioner responsible or probably irresponsible for Health and Consumer Policy tries once more to convince us that nothing happened, by using some statistical methods he obviously cannot understand. He maintains that there was no danger at all from the phenylbutazone found in our food. According to the Press release “the probability of a consumer being both susceptible to developing aplastic anaemia and being exposed to phenylbutazone was estimated to range approximately from 2 in a trillion to 1 in 100 million”.

As all first year students of Statistics know well that when it comes to probabilities it’s very easy to arrive to millions. The more complex a possible outcome is, the more probabilities are being multiplied to calculate the overall probability, for this complex possible outcome to happen. For example if the probability of a person being susceptible of developing aplastic anaemia is 1/1 000 000 and the probability to eat a meatball with phenylbutazone is 1%, then the probability this person susceptible of developing aplastic anaemia to eat a contaminated meatball is 1/1,000,000 * 1/100=1/100,000,000. For one thing one meticulous researcher could question those two probabilities. Usually when politicians want to hide the truth from people by using statistics, they underestimate the bad probability and overestimate the good one.

The play with statistics is very dangerous and very easily steerable to the preferred direction. Bankers for example, by underestimating the statistical risks built-in the ‘products’ they sold to investors, drove the whole world to the present financial and real economy crisis. In the case of human health however it’s not ‘profit & loss’ but health and illness, if not life and death. On top of that even if one accepts Borg’s logic that the probability for somebody to become very ill is 1 to 100 000 000, in the case of the 500 000 000 European million citizens, it is certain that 5 people will suffer. No Mr Borg?
In any case the whole text of the Press release issue by Borg is an obvious attempt to minimise the dangers, from a food industry quality control system completely inadequate and prone to produce alerts. For years the British cows, were fed with animal proteins before getting crazy, and nobody stopped it. Or what about this present case? The horsemeat stuffed with phenylbutazone, which was sold as beef before being detected in Britain, had galloped for weeks freely all over the European Union.

More probabilities

There is a lot more however in this Commission Press release. According to the text published, “the coordinated EU-wide testing for horsemeat DNA and phenylbutazone requested, and co-financed, by the European Commission in the wake of the horsemeat scandal has revealed that less than 5 % of the tested products had horse DNA and that about 0.5 % of the equine carcasses tested were found to be contaminated with bute”. If we use the laws of statistics and basic arithmetic, the probability to eat a beef product containing horsemeat with bute is 5/100* 5/1000= 25/100000=1/4000.

Not very little, because it means that one, in every 4000 beef preparations in the EU, contains horsemeat with bute. When Borg was telling the truth? Was it at the time when he reassured us that we are safe, because our chance to be ill from this reason is 2 in a trillion or now that out chances to swallow bute is one in 4000? Is it possible for a healthy person to eat bute and not be affected in some way? And for God’s sake, if we run such a danger every time we open our refrigerator, then what good is there in paying with our taxes all those fancy services, which supposedly control the quality of our food? The consumer organisations could do much better with all that money.

Last but not least the Commission didn’t comment at all about the huge probability we might be fed with low quality horsemeat, when we pay for beef. This probability is an unbelievable 5%, meaning that once in every twenty times we eat a beef preparation, it contains horsemeat. There is obviously something rotten in the kingdom of our food quality control services.


the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

With 10 million Yemenis ‘one step away from famine’, donors pledge $2.6 billion

Understanding of LGBT realities ‘non-existent’ in most countries, says UN expert

Illegal fishing plagues the Pacific Ocean. Here’s how to end it

GSMA Announces New Speakers for Mobile 360 Series – MENA, in association with The European Sting

Some truths about the coronavirus, according to the World Health Organization

Help African farmers cope with climate change threats, UN food agency urges

6 things to know about the General Assembly as UN heads into high level week

UN relief official in Yemen condemns ‘horrific’ attack on passenger buses

Harnessing the power of nature in the fight against climate change

We can solve climate change – if we involve women

There is no greater sorrow on earth than the loss of one’s native land

The UK remains in the EU until a new Brexit date is set

UN food aid to Yemen will fully resume after two-month break, as Houthis ‘guarantee’ delivery

UN human rights chief regrets closure of Burundi office following Government pressure

Will the three major parties retain control of the new EU Parliament?

This is where people work the longest – and shortest – hours

Nauru President warns of possible climate change ‘economic Armageddon’

Half of all violent deaths involve small arms and light weapons

A Sting Exclusive live from Brussels: Solheim’s consequential visit leading the world and the UN

Is there a de facto impossibility for the Brexit to kick-start?

Road to Brexit: the UK seeks early agreement on Data Privacy with the EU

Austrian Presidency priorities discussed in committees

Does upgrading our minds mean losing the spark of genius?

The world’s most expensive places to own a home

Draghi: ECB to flood Eurozone and the world with more zero cost money; risk of drowning in cash

MEPs agree on new rules to tax digital companies’ revenues

The world has made spectacular progress in every measure of well-being. So why does almost no one know about it?

10 predictions for the global economy in 2019

Dignified health for all who live here

Celebrating Gaston Ramon – the vet who discovered vaccinology’s secret weapon

UN Chief ‘strongly rejects’ Guatemala decision to expel anti-corruption body

How many more financial crises in the West can the world stand?

Guterres censures terrorist attacks in Nigeria, pledges UN ‘solidarity’

5 ways blockchain can transform the world of impact investing

ECB tied in the anti-monetary German ideology

Right2Water initiative: Is the Commission ready to listen to citizens?

Now is the time to seize ‘unprecedented opportunity’ of the Sustainable Development Forum, says ECOSOC President

The Junior Enterprise concept: Business & Education

G20 LIVE: “ISIL is the face of evil; our goal is to degrade and ultimately destroy this barbaric terrorist organisation”, US President Barack Obama cries out from Antalya Turkey

The punishment gap: how workplace mistakes hurt women and minorities most

The issues of practicing medicine in Pakistan

Making Europe’s businesses future-ready: A new Industrial Strategy for a globally competitive, green and digital Europe

How drones can manage the food supply chain and tell you if what you eat is sustainable

We need greater protection for our oceans. We can’t let politics stand in the way

MWC 2016 LIVE: Telenor CEO calls on operators to embrace Mobile Connect initiative

The EU Consumer Policy on the Digital Market: A Behavioral Economics View

COP21 Breaking News_09 December: List of Recent Climate Funding Announcements

Here are three ways blockchain can change refugees’ lives

UN chief welcomes South Sudan’s Unity government, lauds parties for ‘significant achievement’

Commission launches debate on more efficient decision-making in EU social policy

UN Envoy ‘confident’ deal can be reached to avert further violence around key Yemeni port city

Taxation: Commission refers Hungary to the Court for failing to apply the minimum EU excise duty on cigarettes

From rescue animals to electric buses, California is introducing bold new rules

Brexit: EP Group leaders support a flexible extension until 31/1/20

Coronavirus: the Commission mobilises all of its resources to protect lives and livelihoods

Parliament makes it easier to organise a European Citizens’ Initiative

Statement by the Brexit Steering Group on UK paper on EU citizens in the UK

MWC 2016 LIVE: Intel focuses on 5G “beyond the Powerpoint”

Medical students of today, technological doctors of tomorrow

These 4 Nordic countries hold the secret to gender equality

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s