Building an inclusive economic recovery in the Caribbean

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Phil Crehan, Principal Investigator, Independent Consultant

  • A new study, The Economic Case for LGBT+ Inclusion in the Caribbean, shows the impact of exclusion and violence on LGBT+ people in the region, and how their livelihoods have been affected by COVID-19.
  • The legal and social exclusion of LGBT+ people has a negative economic impact of between 2.1-5.7% regional GDP.
  • Governments, economic development institutions and businesses must work together to include LGBT+ people in post-COVID recovery plans.

Generating data on socially excluded groups is critical for inclusive development and stronger societies. Such data is needed more than ever during the pandemic, to guide public health and economic recovery strategies. But governments and economic development institutions have done relatively little to support its collection, relying instead on studies generated by civil society, the private sector and academics.

My recent research with the organization Open For Business, with support from Virgin Atlantic, is called The Economic Case for LGBT+ Inclusion in the Caribbean, and it aims to fill part of that knowledge gap. Starting in April 2020, and through dozens of partnerships with organizations and academics, we collected and analyzed data on LGBT+ exclusion throughout 12 countries in the English-speaking Caribbean.

Our analysis shows the significant impacts of exclusion and violence, as well as COVID’s impact on livelihoods. Looking forward, we must understand the extent of these challenges in order to develop effective solutions.

The economic impact of exclusion

The legal and social exclusion of LGBT+ people is not only a serious challenge to human rights, but also a major constraint on economic growth. The loss is stark in the Caribbean: we estimate that between 2.1 – 5.7% of regional GDP is lost due to LGBT+ exclusion.

Using the economic model created by the World Bank, we looked at the most quantifiable economic losses, including diminished human capital and labor output, health disparities, and more. Two large-scale surveys and numerous in-depth interviews allowed us to capture the many challenges LGBT+ people face, while measuring corresponding aggregate economic impacts.

Other powerful findings emerge from our survey of the LGBT+ community in the Caribbean. First, one in two experienced exclusion within their own family (the chart below includes the straight and cisgender sample for comparison). Second, labor market discrimination is so systemic that it acts as occupational segregation, keeping the community out of higher paying jobs in the formal economy and often confined to the informal economy. Impacts include an 11% wage gap in comparison to the general population.

Chart showing the challenges and impact of exclusion
For LGBT+ people in the Caribbean, exclusion often starts in the family Image: Open for Business

Third, anti-LGBT+ laws and stigma create “push” factors for migration, especially for skilled workers, which contributes to ‘brain drain’ in the region. Finally, the social and economic impact of decriminalizing same-sex intimate acts seems to be powerful, with better outcomes in education, labor markets, and accessing justice.

A second survey of potential tourists to the Caribbean (LGBT+ and otherwise) allowed us to capture the strong relationship between anti-LGBT+ laws and a reduced likelihood to visit. From our sample, close to one in five would not visit due to their perception of LGBT+ treatment in the region, which impacts their own perception of personal safety upon a visit. On the other hand, 60% of the entire sample said they would be likely to visit a Caribbean country after it adopted same-sex civil unions (see Chart 2, below).

A chart showing the impact on tourism of LGBT+ exclusion
60% of tourists said they would be likely to visit a Caribbean country after it adopted same-sex civil unions Image: Open for Business

LGBT+ livelihoods

As the pandemic exacerbates historical inequalities, some of the hardest hit are marginalized communities. Our research in the Caribbean confirms that LGBT+ people are no exception. From our sample, more than one in four had an annual income of 5,000 (local currency), which is often below the average income at a country level. COVID’s economic toll exacted harsh impacts, as more than one in five overall reported a loss in income between 40-100%. One further devastating impact of COVID was food insecurity, as around one third were forced to skip some meals during the height of the pandemic.

LGBT+ livelihoods are impacted by exclusion from governments and economic development institutions. Often governments did little to provide PPE to the community, which led to a lack of crucial services with some LGBT+ organizations having to secure international funds to fill those gaps. Similarly, economic development institutions like the World Bank and other development banks overlooked the challenge of LGBT+ exclusion from COVID programming, and made little effort to consult the LGBT+ community in multi-million dollar public health loans or even general programming.

The private sector, on the other hand, is starting to address LGBT+ inclusion, as a matter of recruitment and talent. In fact, as we launched our research in partnership with CAISO: Sex and Gender Justice in Trinidad and Tobago, this group unveiled the country’s first LGBT+ Workplace Policy that was endorsed by many businesses. This sets a positive standard for the improvement of livelihoods through employment.

Going forward – a strong case for inclusion

By using participatory research methods, and in collaboration with numerous partners, we built a strong case for inclusion based on livelihoods and economic growth. The next phase of our project is to help cultivate the region’s LGBT+ business voice. Yet governments, economic development institutions and businesses can do much more to help. This should include:

  • Governments must work with LGBT+ organizations to ensure that post-COVID economic recovery plans are inclusive – both for human rights and economic reasons.
  • Economic development institutions must address legal discrimination and the impacts of LGBT+ exclusion in the countries where they operate, and promote LGBT+ inclusion in programs in response to their own non-discrimination mandates.
  • Many corporations are advancing pro-LGBT+ policies, and this should be cultivated and expanded to address significant gaps due to governmental inaction.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Australia urged to evacuate offshore detainees amid widespread, acute mental distress

Any doubt?

From funders to partners: elevating community expertise to help communities thrive

German opposition win in Lower Saxony felt all over Europe

London is becoming the world’s first National Park City

Yemen consultations have started, insists top UN negotiator

Commission approves emergency measures to protect eastern Baltic cod

How data can help mining companies tackle their trust deficit

From drought to floods in Somalia; displacement and hunger worsen, says UN

From raised fists at the 1968 Olympics to taking the knee: A history of racial justice protests in sport

Will the European Court of Justice change data privacy laws to tackle terrorism?

This is how travel hotspots are fighting back against overtourism

Do all you can to resolve climate change ‘sticking points’ UN chief urges South-East Asian leaders, in Bali

Four lessons from Africa on building effective business ecosystems

Australian homes are turning to solar power in record numbers

European research priorities for 2021-2027 agreed with member states

Meeting the basic needs of our healthcare workers

Mental health: a medical school’s demand

Embracing the diversity in a multicultural city of Romania

The EU Commission lets money market funds continue the unholy game of banks

How the power of sport can bring us together and drive social justice

EU Blue Card: Commission welcomes political agreement on new rules for highly skilled migrant workers

Why building consumer trust is the key to unlocking AI’s true potential

Ukraine’s new political order not accepted in Crimea

Protecting European consumers: toys and cars on top of the list of dangerous products

This is how New York plans to end its car culture

Progress against torture in Afghan detention centres, but Government needs to do more, says UN report

European Citizens’ Initiative: Commission registers ‘Mandatory food labelling Non-Vegetarian / Vegetarian / Vegan’ initiative’

Is South Korea set to lose from its FTA with the EU?

Anti-vaccers: does the empty can rattle the most?

The role of public affairs in student NGOs

Future Forces Forum: Prague will be hosting the most important project in the field of Defence and Security

Latin America’s cities are ready to take off. But their infrastructure is failing them

Political power of women suffering ‘serious regression’, General Assembly President warns

7 top things to know about coronavirus today

How global trade can save lives and livelihoods – and help protect the planet

EU job-search aid worth €9.9 million for 1,858 former Air France workers

European Semester 2018 Spring Package: Commission issues recommendations for Member States to achieve sustainable, inclusive and long-term growth

COVID-19: Save European culture and values, MEPs tell Commission

Children suffering ‘atrocities’ as number of countries in conflict hits new peak: UNICEF

We need to rethink ESG to ensure access to water and sanitation for all

International Court of Justice orders Pakistan to review death penalty for Indian accused of spying

Rise in violent conflict shows prevention ‘more necessary than ever’: UN chief

Top UN political official updates Security Council on Iran nuclear deal

It’s not summer holidays what lead to the bad August of the German economy

How can the world end viral hepatitis by 2030? 5 experts explain

How to talk about climate change: 5 tips from the front lines

Failure to open accession talks with Albania and North Macedonia is a mistake

Myanmar doing too little to ensure displaced Rohingya return: UN refugee agency chief

Further reforms in Sweden can drive growth, competitiveness and social cohesion

EU-UK relations: solutions found to help implementation of the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland

Statistics show the ugly face of youth training schemes

Croatian Presidency outlines priorities to EP committees

Media and entertainment in flux: it’s time for the close-up

5 droughts that changed human history

Are the G20 leaders ready to curb corporate tax-avoidance?

European Youth, quo vadis?

China is the first non-EU country to invest in Europe’s €315 billion Plan

EU institutions agree on priorities for coming years: A common agenda for our recovery and renewed vitality

Coronavirus Global Response: EIB and Commission pledge additional €4.9 billion

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s