We’re costing our energy system wrongly. Here’s how to get it right

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Laura Sandys, Non Executive Director at SGN, and Energy Systems Catapult

  • A decarbonized energy system works very differently to a fossil-fuel based one – which is why it demands a new approach to costs.
  • A new model must include the value to the system of demand-side assets, such as solar PV and heat pumps.
  • Here are three recommendations for policy-makers that can help to drive this necessary change.

We are missing a big trick when it comes to how we decarbonize our energy system. We are trying to squeeze a capital-intensive set of renewable technologies into market and value arrangements, all of which are designed around a commodity-based fossil fuel past.

Until we recognise that the decarbonized system has very different characteristics, a different cost base and new and varied value streams, we will end up paying for an inefficient, under-optimised, much slower and less fair transformation.

At the heart of the problem is that we are obsessed with the price of the commodity; many investment decisions and analysis are still calibrated using the levelized cost of electricity. In the new world this is far too simplistic, and is becoming less and less representative of the cost and value of our new system.

The new system cost base is moving from the cost of the electron to system management, network costs and the amount of storage required. In addition, the very new component that needs to be better understood is the potential and significant value of decarbonization assets that we will need in our homes and for motoring.

The key component that has sat on the sidelines for too long is the true value of flexibility, demand shifting and optimization, and self supply. While owners of EVs, heat pumps or self-generation can receive some limited benefits from operating them flexibly, this does not reflect the full value of these actions to the wider system. Let us also consider that consumers will need millions and millions of these types of assets across the system to decarbonize – but we are not rewarding them appropriately.

This ‘mis-costing’ of the energy system is why ReCosting Energy, inspired by the World Economic Forum’s work on whole system costs, has developed new metrics that aim to appropriately cost our energy system – looking way beyond the value of the electricity itself. Working with the UK Government’s modelling team, and great teams from Frontier Economics and LCP, we have developed a new set of metrics that use whole system costs, but importantly do what we think is a first: comparing and competing demand-side assets with generation assets.

The components of whole electricity system costs
The components of whole electricity system costs Image: Frontier Economics

The model above firstly looks at whole system costs. These criteria were first developed in 2016 by Frontier Economics for DECC (UK Department for Energy and Climate Change) but seem to have not been as widely used by government in making investment decisions as they should.

We then broadened the “normal” analysis – simply comparing different generation assets – by adding demand-side assets and comparing them equally with generation assets. Our ambition here was to show that demand-side assets need to be equally valued to those of generation in our new system.

Why the levelised cost of electricity approach is no longer fit for purpose
Why the levelised cost of electricity approach is no longer fit for purpose Image: Challenging Ideas

This revealed several important issues:

1. Levelised cost of electricity is no longer fit as an evaluation tool for the new system

2. It is possible to compare demand-side and generation technologies alongside one another.

3. Most importantly that non-generation, demand-side assets from energy efficiency, EVs and heating actually deliver overall system savings

This model used a simple “the cost per additional MW added to the system” by the various interventions. However, our work aims to stimulate others to take on this modelling framework to start to value all assets – whether demand or generation – equally, providing policy-makers and investors with a much wider range of options.

Our ambition is that these metrics must start to drive change within a policy area that is still dominated by generation considerations, and does not regard demand-side assets as equal. Here are three recommendations for making that happen:

1. Demand must be seen as equal to generation in terms of policy and regulatory development.

2. This means that investors in assets which reduce or shift demand (including households deciding how to operate technologies such as heat pumps and EVs) should receive the same benefits from these actions that generation would – because buying these ‘valuable’ assets is as big a financial ask for a family, as developing an offshore wind farm is for an investor.

3. Fundamentally the market changes from ‘supplying’ as much as it can of the commodity to creating a new market in which optimised demand and optimised supply ‘compete’ with one another.

This last point truly unlocks benefits to whole system costs, requires new services for consumers, and drives costs down across both the supply and demand side of the system. It is a new market paradigm fit for the future.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

5 challenges for government adoption of AI

A Sting Exclusive: “Sustainable development goals: what role for business?” Commissioner Mimica asks live from European Business Summit 2015

Christmas spending: Who can afford not to cut?

How teaching ‘future resilient’ skills can help workers adapt to automation

High-Level Forum on providing protection to Afghans at risk

How India is harnessing technology to lead the Fourth Industrial Revolution

It’s time to end the stigma around mental health in the workplace

Yes, together we can make a change! YO!Fest and EYE 2016

More urgency needed to help increasing numbers ‘locked out’, before 2030, says UN’s Bachelet

Climate change is forcing 20 million people a year from their homes, Oxfam says

COVID-19 has been a setback for women. Gender-responsive policies can stem the losses

Gig workers among the hardest hit by coronavirus pandemic

This Brooklyn farm company is training a new generation of urban farmers

Empathic AI could be the next stage in human evolution – if we get it right

UN chief urges emergency fund support as one of the ‘most effective investments’ in humanitarian action

LGBTQ+: The social evolution of a minority

EU job-search aid worth €9.9 million for 1,858 former Air France workers

Armed groups threaten every child in Central African Republic, UNICEF warns

Inegalitarian taxation on labour haunts Europe’s social model

Here’s how one business leader is tackling injustice: It starts with personal commitment

To my Chinese friend

UN agency warns conditions around Yemen’s key port city of Hudaydah still ‘very bad’, as staff rush to deliver aid

Commission launches debate on responding to the impact of an ageing population

Honeybees are transforming the lives of mangrove farmers in Viet Nam – here’s how

Migration crisis update: mutual actions and solidarity needed as anti-migrant policies thrive

India vs Virus: voices from the COVID front line

Coronavirus: 70% of the EU adult population fully vaccinated

Azeri natural gas will keep the EU warm soon

Black Lives Matter – for Pakistan’s Sheedi community too

Go early, go hard and keep it simple: how Senegal is staying ahead of the COVID-19 pandemic

Busting the myths about coronavirus

4 key steps to decommissioning coal-fired power plants

Coronavirus response: Team Europe supports Somalia with three EU Humanitarian Air Bridge flights

‘Huge’ stakes, ‘daunting’ job to tackle gender-based violence, UNICEF chief tells ground-breaking conference

We need tech solutions that value human interaction more than ever

European Commission adopts new tools for safe exchanges of personal data

Health Systems and Society: ways to reinforce the human power during the pandemic

Eight years after Fukushima, nuclear power is making a comeback

World Wildlife Day: UN chief urges ‘more caring’ relationship with nature

US – Russia bargain on Syria, Ukraine but EU kept out

How COVID-19 is driving a long-overdue revolution in education

Portugal: €4.66 million in aid for 1,460 dismissed workers and jobless young

‘A new chapter’ dawns for democracy in Guinea-Bissau: top UN official

Statement by Executive Vice-President Margrethe Vestager on the Commission’s proposal for a new Regulation to address distortions caused by foreign subsidies in the Single Market

5 surprising ways major cities are going green

The right approach to addressing overcapacity problem from a Chinese perspective

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “Chinese economy has great potential, resilience and ample space for policy adjustment”, China’s Vice President Li Yuanchao reassures from Davos

New neighbours: Could Venus really be home to alien life?

Remarks by Commissioner Virginijus Sinkevičius on the Zero Pollution Action Plan

Chart of the day: When do young Europeans leave home?

UN chief condemns attack targeting international forces in northern Mali

Emotional stability and the COVID-19 pandemic: is it possible to reconcile them?

Volkswagen scandal update: “We want clarity fast, but it is equally important to have the complete picture”, Commission’s spokesperson underscores from Brussels

Nordic noir: The unhappiness epidemic affecting young people in the world’s happiest countries

Climate change: cutting the good by the root?

Why the global trade of chemicals is key to COVID-19 recovery

What does the future of energy look like, how do we get there, and who will benefit?

Brexit: PM May must hush Boris Johnson to unlock the negotiations

Eurozone needs more than some decimals of growth

GSMA Reveals Global Partners for MWC21 Barelona

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: