COVID-19: How the pandemic has made football’s structural problems worse

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Franck Bancel, Professor of Finance, ESCP Business School & Henri Philippe, Partner, Accuracy

  • During the decade that preceded the COVID-19 crisis, football in Europe enjoyed a continuous increase in revenues.
  • The crisis has put stress on football governance by raising the question of how to share the wealth created in a sector that is no longer growing.
  • Significant disparities between clubs have also worsened during the ongoing outbreak of coronavirus.

The consequences of COVID-19 have led to a considerable crisis for football, with matches suspended or cancelled and major events like the UEFA Euro 2020 postponed. For more than a year, the revenues of European clubs have been significantly affected by the absence of fans in stadiums and by smaller TV audiences. In France, the withdrawal of Mediapro, which held the broadcasting rights for Ligue 1 and Ligue 2, deprived the clubs of a significant share of their revenue.

The ‘big five’ leagues had to face rights payment deferrals and grant rebates to broadcasters, with England’s Premier League recently agreeing to roll over its existing television deal after seeing its revenue fall – for the first time ever – to cause the largest pre-tax loss in its history. To cope with this, European clubs took on a massive amount of debt and their ability to repay this debt remains uncertain. More fundamentally, the value of football and its attractiveness are now the subject of debate in a context where stadiums have been empty for 15 months.

During the decade that preceded the crisis, football in Europe enjoyed a very substantial increase in its revenues (average annual revenue growth of 8.2% over the last 20 years). In the five major European championships, the value of broadcasting rights increased with every call for tenders; they now represent the largest part of the clubs’ revenues. Other revenues such as sponsoring or ticket sales have also increased, but not as much and have mainly benefitted the big European clubs. The first paradox is that this growth in revenues has not resulted in a significant improvement in the clubs’ financial performance. The main reason for this is that the clubs’ first priority is to manage the sport-related risk. In order to enjoy future growth in revenue, a club must remain competitive and ensure that it is not demoted to a lower division.

This means recruiting the best players (who are by definition rare assets) and paying the costs of transfers and higher salaries. At least in the short term, the new revenues will not offset these costs. In the “arms race” that the clubs have engaged in over the past two decades, it is the players and agents who have captured the lion’s share of the industry’s income. In these circumstances, some clubs have done very well and made significant capital gains. But these gains depend on the club’s performance in the sport and are also linked to the capacity of the richest clubs to buy players. Now, because of the COVID crisis, these clubs may no longer be interested in buying or may focus on the most talented young players.

Decades of continuous growth in football - and then COVID-19
Image: UEFA

Structurally, football clubs generate little or no cash flows and their equity is limited. At best, as was the case before the COVID crisis, the best-managed clubs made no (or few) losses. This does not exclude the possibility of creating value for investors, but that is predicated on industry revenues growing. If the clubs’ revenues are growing, investors may assume that, in the long term, they will get a share of this growth and that they will be in a position to benefit from greater media coverage of football, even though most of the value is captured by the players.

From this point of view, the COVID crisis has put a spanner in the works and it will take several years to return to pre-crisis levels (not forgetting the question of whether all clubs will benefit from this recovery). Meanwhile, investors who had bet on continued growth have lost their bet in the short term and probably in the medium term too. At the moment, little information has come through on how the investment funds that own the clubs will behave. Will they take the clubs into bankruptcy because their initial investment has been lost? The answer will probably depend on the conditions that governments set up to manage the repayment and/or conversion of the COVID debt into a ‘bearable’ financial liability.

The COVID crisis also raises the question of football governance, which currently operates at several different levels. Football is structured in a pyramid with FIFA at the summit, then the continental confederations like UEFA, and then national associations and leagues. The paradox of this governance structure is that all of its actors cooperate but also compete with each other to organise competitions. For example, UEFA’s development of the Champions League may be done to the detriment of national championships. Moreover, first division championships contribute to financing amateur clubs. The football economy is thus intricately linked to the attractiveness of the professional clubs.

The COVID crisis has put stress on this organisation and governance by raising the question of how to share the wealth created in a sector that is no longer growing. The recent attempt to create a closed league (the European Super League) reflects the desire of a few European clubs to redefine the conditions for sharing this wealth. This challenge to the system would have had consequences for the entire industry and that is why national governments, UEFA and most of the football ecosystem opposed it. But does that mean the governance of football is unchangeable? Because football is globalised, its governance operates at the supranational and national levels.

Changing its governance would therefore require a common political will, at least at the European level. But the globalisation of football has allowed the entrance of shareholders whose interests do not converge. For example, while financial investors seek a return on equity, state shareholders are motivated by the soft power of football and maximum media coverage. In this context, it is very difficult to transform the governance of football.

The COVID crisis has exacerbated the tensions and structural problems of football, that is, its low profitability and significant disparities between clubs. In the short term, the crisis has disrupted the strategies of investors who had bet on continued growth in the sector and capital gains (player transfers, etc.). The crisis may also cause some clubs to restructure or even to disappear altogether.

In Créer de la valeur dans le football – Comment évaluer les clubs et leurs actifs (Revue Banque Editeur, 2019), we sketch out several scenarios for the future of football: ‘status quo’ (there is no major change in the football industry), ‘bankruptcy’ (many clubs go bankrupt and the attractivity of football declines), or ‘rupture’ (the structure of the industry is called into question: new regulations, new competitions, etc.). In a sense, these three scenarios are still completely relevant, because the consequences of the COVID crisis are still uncertain. In a few months, it is likely, however, that one of these three scenarios will prevail.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

The EU Parliament slams Commission on economic governance

Antitrust: Commission sends Statement of Objections to O2 CZ, CETIN and T-Mobile CZ for their network sharing agreement

Take Care of In Order to Be Taken Care of

3 reasons why embracing the circular economy can be powerful for middle income countries

6 innovative technologies about to transform our infrastructure

Why growth is now a one way road for Eurozone

Female leaders warn about the erosion of women’s rights

Statement by Frans Timmermans, Executive Vice-President for the European Green Deal, on the announcement to postpone the COP26

Halt death sentences on children, UN rights expert urge Saudi authorities

This is how Britain saved some of its most precious wildlife from the threat of extinction

How to put people at the heart of your company’s COVID-19 response

‘Whole spectrum of Afghan society’ must get behind peace talks, UN envoy tells Security Council

EU regions get additional 47.5 billion EUR to tackle local effects of COVID-19

These artists created a huge open library – and their idea’s gone global

Commission refers Denmark to the Court for failing to fulfil its obligations in relation to the name “Feta”

Mine action is at ‘the nexus’ of peace, security and development: UN official

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: The health of capitalism won’t be the only worry for those who head for Davos

China’s stock markets show recovery signs while EU is closely watching in anticipation of the €10bn investment

Does the Commission subsidise a forced labour scheme in Britain?

One for all? Are physicians prepared to deliver care to the LGBTQIA+ community?

UN chief lauds Fijians as ‘natural global leaders’ on climate, environment, hails ‘symbiotic relationship’ with land and sea

How start-ups will lead India through the Fourth Industrial Revolution

This one small change could transform education for millions

Why rich countries are seeing more poverty

World Wildlife Day: UN chief urges ‘more caring’ relationship with nature

EU approves close to €240 million to strengthen resilience in neighbouring countries hosting Syrian refugees in light of the coronavirus pandemic

Third Facebook-Cambridge Analytica hearing: data breach prevention and cures

De-escalate now, to steer Yemen off ‘precarious path’, UN Security Council hears

Brexit: Six more months of political paralysis or a May-Corbyn compromise?

Golden Pen of Freedom Awarded to Murdered Saudi Journalist Jamal Khashoggi during World News Media Congress 2019

Questions and Answers on the EU Digital Covid Certificate

The fires in the Brazilian amazon rainforest may be related to the increase in the number of hospitalizations for respiratory complications in the state of PARÁ

Why does the whole world want Britain to stay in the EU?

EU citizens disenchanted with Economic and Monetary Union over rising poverty and high unemployment

Your next pair of sneakers could be made from coffee

Mental health in times of a pandemic: what can each individual do to lessen the burden?

Migration crisis: how big a security threat it is?

Reducing deforestation means getting serious about environmental crime

Security Council should ‘nurture’ Colombian consensus against return to violence, top UN official urges

This is the most sustainable way to use fashion – and it’s not renting clothes

Collaboration: the key to success in the digital economy

Lessons in disaster relief from the world’s most cyclone-battered state

Happy workers are more productive, research shows

Women to save Europe’s own labour resources

Food system failures in our age of abundance

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: Libya civil war, African displacement, global trade tensions, terrorists’ children ‘secretly detained’, and more

Trade, taxes and other takeaways from Li Keqiang’s speech to the World Economic Forum

The European Sting @ European Business Summit 2014 – the preview

UNICEF urges ‘transformative shift’ in family-friendly work policies to reap ‘huge’ benefits

Ecofin: ‘The Friday battle’ for the banking union

Boosting the EU’s green recovery: Commission invests €1 billion in innovative clean technology projects

Guarantee of mental health’s stability in times of pandemic

Mobile technology: health in your hands

Digital Finance Package: Commission sets out new, ambitious approach to encourage responsible innovation to benefit consumers and businesses

Parliament demands ban on neo-fascist and neo-Nazi groups in the EU

The new era of Matriarchy?

The role companies play in boosting growth in emerging markets

A Sting Exclusive: “Our ambition is by 2020 Indonesia to become an emerging power of World’s Maritime Access”, reveals the Chargé d’Affaires at the Embassy of Indonesia in Brussels, treating WEF, ASEAN and EU-Indonesia relations on the eve of the World Economic Forum East Asia 2015 in Jakarta

Want a sustainable business? Hire in talent

Sustainable development demands a broader vision, says new OECD Development Centre report

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s