Forced Vaccination in COVID-19 Pandemic: Ethically Justified Intervention or Draconian Measure?

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article was exclusively written for The European Sting by Dr. Muhammad Rizky Nur Karim is a medical doctor from Padjadjaran University, Indonesia. He is affiliated to the International Federation of Medical Students Associations (IFMSA), cordial partner of The Sting. The opinions expressed in this piece belong strictly to the writer and do not necessarily reflect IFMSA’s view on the topic, nor The European Sting’s one.


The COVID-19 pandemic is still not over. However, a new hope arises with the discovery of vaccines. The vaccination program itself is not without challenges. Many people believe and choose not to be vaccinated, for various reasons. To counter this problem, there are countries that implement restrictive measures. Indonesia, for example, has a law that will give criminal sanctions such as fine or imprisonment to those rejecting vaccination in times of pandemic. This policy raised a major question: is it ethically acceptable to implement such restrictive measures?

An important perspective that should be considered is the human rights perspective. While people have the right to reject vaccination, it can be argued that the right can be overridden in respect of others’ right to life. The Siracusa Principles mentioned that the right to life is a non-derogable right. If someone rejects vaccination during a pandemic situation, it could possibly endanger the life of others, thus disturbing others’ right to life. From this perspective, forced vaccination policy might seem like a good choice to protect the people and their right to life. Thus, it is ethically acceptable to do it.

However, it does not mean that forced vaccination should be done as a first choice. In a theory proposed by Ross Upshur, there are four aspects that should be considered in deciding a public health intervention. One of the aspects to consider is “least restrictive or coercive means.” It is undoubtable that giving criminal sanction is a coercive measure. Criminal sanctions will force deterrence, but it does not guarantee the public’s trust in the public health system, including the vaccination. To make people trust the vaccination, methods such as proper health promotion and educating the public is a better first choice.

The implementation of forced vaccination, whatever the disease is, might seem like a drastic measure for some people. Of course, level of restriction is not the only aspect to consider in deciding a public health intervention. But one thing we can agree on is that the implementation of forced vaccination reflects the failure of other public health measures. As long as other less restrictive measures can be done, there is no need to implement forced vaccination. Right now, we should focus on promoting the benefits of vaccination and educating the public. As it stands, forced vaccination is the last resort in this pandemic. While it is an ethically justified intervention, it is also a draconian measure.

References:

UNESCO. (2005). Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights. Retrieved from: https://en.unesco.org/themes/ethics-science-and-technology/bioethics-and-human-rights

United Nations. (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Retrieved from: https://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/   

American Association for the International Commission of Jurists. (1985). Siracusa Principles on the Limitation and Derogation Provisions in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Retrieved from: https://www.icj.org/siracusa-principles-on-the-limitation-and-derogation-provisions-in-the-international-covenant-on-civil-and-political-rights/

Upshur, R. E. (2002). Principles for the justification of public health intervention. Canadian journal of public health, 93(2), 101-103.

About the author

Dr. Muhammad Rizky Nur Karim is a medical doctor from Padjadjaran University, Indonesia. Dr. Karim is the former IFMSA’s Capacity Building Regional Assistant for Asia-Pacific for term 2017-2018. Right now, dr. Karim is pursuing a master’s degree in Health and Medical Law at the University of Melbourne, Australia. Dr. Karim is also working as a health law researcher at the Center of Health Law and Policy Indonesia.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

There’s a global learning crisis and it’s leaving millions without basic skills

Commission introduces surveillance of imports of bioethanol, and remains open to examining requests from other sectors

UN condemns ‘unspeakable’ attack that leaves scores dead in central Mali

Online government services could change your life. But only if you have access to the internet

Yesterday’s “jokes” and sarcasm by Digital Single Market’s Vice President Ansip on EU member states’ right to protect their telco markets

Prevent future crises and empower youth – now!

GSMA Mobile 360 – Digital Societies in Kuala Lumpur, in association with The European Sting

These 4 start-ups are using seaweed to help save the planet

The European Parliament wants to stay in one place

Building a Climate-Resilient Future – A new EU Strategy on Adaptation to Climate Change

Climate change is threatening Switzerland’s stunning scenery

Promoting gender equality a ‘crucial contribution’ in effort to restore, protect our planet’s oceans

On Google antitrust case: “Let’s face it, some companies want to hurt Google and it goes as simple as that”

In Pakistan, Guterres urges world to step up climate action, praises support to Afghan refugees

Modernising EU justice systems: New package to speed up digitalisation of justice systems and boost training of justice professionals

China’s impact as a global investor; the Sting reports live from World Economic Forum 2015 in Davos

The quantum computer revolution: here tomorrow, so we must prepare today

UN allocates $20 million in emergency funding, as Cyclone Idai disaster unfolds

Commission welcomes entry into force of EU4Health programme

Gaza blockade causes ‘near ten-fold increase’ in food dependency, says UN agency

Marco Polo’s Dream

What the Corn Laws tell us about Brexit Britain

3 reasons why embracing the circular economy can be powerful for middle income countries

This is what the gender pay gap looks like in eight countries

A Sting Exclusive: why the environment is important to your health, by UNEP’s Head for Europe

Why women have an essential role in biodiversity conservation

Heat-resistant crops, ‘green’ infrastructure, can prepare Near East and North Africa to better tackle droughts – UN agency

Huawei answers allegations about its selling prices

Fear casts again a cold, ugly shadow over Europe; Turkey sides with Russia

Italian banks: It’s Rome’s turn to confront Berlin’s aggressiveness

These six intelligences will drive smart leadership in disrupted times

Maduro ‘brings the truth’ about Venezuela to UN Assembly; says he is ready to meet US President Trump

Brexit: MEPs concerned over reported UK registration plans for EU27 citizens

‘Transformational benefits’ of ending outdoor defecation: Why toilets matter

How much time has the ‘European Union of last chance’ left?

Does research make sense any more? The dire need for new ways to measure success

Universal basic income is the answer to the inequalities exposed by COVID-19

11 innovations protecting life below water – and above it

Health is nothing but the main consequence of climate change

Mali’s ‘self-defence’ groups must face justice, after deadly intercommunal attacks

Just transition in EU regions: support to people, economy and environment

Commission: Gifts of €6 billion and free trainees to ‘help’ poor employers

Commission reinforces tools to ensure Europe’s interests in international trade

It is me

To end deforestation, we must protect community land rights

UN rights expert ‘strongly recommends’ probe by International Criminal Court into ‘decades of crimes’ in Myanmar

Why green bonds are beating all expectations in the post-pandemic recovery

From glass ceiling to glass cliff: women are not a leadership quick-fix

If we don’t protect the ocean, humanitarian disaster awaits

Women’s rights in Asia – how far have we come?

EU-Ukraine Free Trade Agreement sees the light as Moscow’s reaction once more looms

‘Unique opportunity’ to resolve border dispute between Sudan, South Sudan

How India is harnessing technology to lead the Fourth Industrial Revolution

FROM THE FIELD: Faces and Voices of Conflict

Why press freedom should be at the top of everyone’s agenda

It’s EU vs. Google for real: the time is now, the case is open

Amsterdam is developing a fleet of autonomous boats to reduce city traffic

INTERVIEW: ‘Defend the people, not the States’, says outgoing UN human rights chief

MEPs question whether the new Migration Pact will bring about real change

More Stings?

Comments

  1. Liza Slinavcic says:

    what is this fscist article here?

  2. APERSONWITHMORETHANONEBRAINCELL says:

    The world has gone mad and especially the likes of you. Eugenicists created the Georgia Guide Stones to show those that comprehend it, what the real agenda is. Lower the Carbon Footprint they say, but who creates the carbon when they breathe the Oxygen in??? Is anyone too stupid to understand that they mean YOU??? The real agenda here is the depopulation of this planet, simply because those in power are so highly outnumbered by intelligent beings on this planet that they now fear for their own safety and therefore they have to guilt-trip people into thinking that they are the cause that the earth is getting warmer, instead of seeing that it is a natural climate cycle. The whole agenda is to get people alienated and divided from one another, because they are afraid of the old American wisdom: United We Stand, Divided We Fall. They want to assure that the human race falls and bows down to them as their slaves. The whole masking is only to prove their power over us, it does nothing to protect against any viruses. It is like brandishing cattle for the slaughter, because the less oxygen people inhale, the more likely they are to die, because cells that do not get enough oxygen will turn anaerobic and cancerous.

Trackbacks

  1. […] the European Sting says this about mandatory vaccinations; “If someone rejects vaccination during a pandemic […]

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: