Forced Vaccination in COVID-19 Pandemic: Ethically Justified Intervention or Draconian Measure?

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article was exclusively written for The European Sting by Dr. Muhammad Rizky Nur Karim is a medical doctor from Padjadjaran University, Indonesia. He is affiliated to the International Federation of Medical Students Associations (IFMSA), cordial partner of The Sting. The opinions expressed in this piece belong strictly to the writer and do not necessarily reflect IFMSA’s view on the topic, nor The European Sting’s one.


The COVID-19 pandemic is still not over. However, a new hope arises with the discovery of vaccines. The vaccination program itself is not without challenges. Many people believe and choose not to be vaccinated, for various reasons. To counter this problem, there are countries that implement restrictive measures. Indonesia, for example, has a law that will give criminal sanctions such as fine or imprisonment to those rejecting vaccination in times of pandemic. This policy raised a major question: is it ethically acceptable to implement such restrictive measures?

An important perspective that should be considered is the human rights perspective. While people have the right to reject vaccination, it can be argued that the right can be overridden in respect of others’ right to life. The Siracusa Principles mentioned that the right to life is a non-derogable right. If someone rejects vaccination during a pandemic situation, it could possibly endanger the life of others, thus disturbing others’ right to life. From this perspective, forced vaccination policy might seem like a good choice to protect the people and their right to life. Thus, it is ethically acceptable to do it.

However, it does not mean that forced vaccination should be done as a first choice. In a theory proposed by Ross Upshur, there are four aspects that should be considered in deciding a public health intervention. One of the aspects to consider is “least restrictive or coercive means.” It is undoubtable that giving criminal sanction is a coercive measure. Criminal sanctions will force deterrence, but it does not guarantee the public’s trust in the public health system, including the vaccination. To make people trust the vaccination, methods such as proper health promotion and educating the public is a better first choice.

The implementation of forced vaccination, whatever the disease is, might seem like a drastic measure for some people. Of course, level of restriction is not the only aspect to consider in deciding a public health intervention. But one thing we can agree on is that the implementation of forced vaccination reflects the failure of other public health measures. As long as other less restrictive measures can be done, there is no need to implement forced vaccination. Right now, we should focus on promoting the benefits of vaccination and educating the public. As it stands, forced vaccination is the last resort in this pandemic. While it is an ethically justified intervention, it is also a draconian measure.

References:

UNESCO. (2005). Universal Declaration on Bioethics and Human Rights. Retrieved from: https://en.unesco.org/themes/ethics-science-and-technology/bioethics-and-human-rights

United Nations. (1948). Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Retrieved from: https://www.un.org/en/universal-declaration-human-rights/   

American Association for the International Commission of Jurists. (1985). Siracusa Principles on the Limitation and Derogation Provisions in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. Retrieved from: https://www.icj.org/siracusa-principles-on-the-limitation-and-derogation-provisions-in-the-international-covenant-on-civil-and-political-rights/

Upshur, R. E. (2002). Principles for the justification of public health intervention. Canadian journal of public health, 93(2), 101-103.

About the author

Dr. Muhammad Rizky Nur Karim is a medical doctor from Padjadjaran University, Indonesia. Dr. Karim is the former IFMSA’s Capacity Building Regional Assistant for Asia-Pacific for term 2017-2018. Right now, dr. Karim is pursuing a master’s degree in Health and Medical Law at the University of Melbourne, Australia. Dr. Karim is also working as a health law researcher at the Center of Health Law and Policy Indonesia.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Beating cancer: MEPs react to the EU Plan for joint action

4 ways to build resilience to digital risks in the COVID-19 era

Colombia’s former president says COVID-19 shows the importance of listening to indigenous peoples on how we treat the planet

Internet milestone reached, as more than 50 per cent go online: UN telecoms agency

The EU Parliament slams Commission on economic governance

Ramp up nuclear power to beat climate change, says UN nuclear chief

The role of the cyber leader in building secure and resilient digital ecosystems

3 ways to keep ourselves cool more sustainably

Mirrored classroom display highlights scale of massive education crisis

Four lessons from Africa on building effective business ecosystems

Climate change will never be combatted by EU alone while some G20 countries keep procrastinating

Ocean life faces ‘onslaught of threats’ from human activity, but tools exist to save it

EU economy: Between recession and indiscernible growth

General Elections in Spain: Twitter organises the first digital debate to empower young people.

COVID-19 has laid bare the cracks in long-term care. Here’s how to fix them

From Policy to Reality: Discrepancies in Universal Health Care Systems across the European Union

As rural communities age, their public transport is shrinking. It’s time to fix this

Return of Kuwaiti property by Iraq, signals hope of ‘full normalization’ between nations: UN Chief

Busting the myths about coronavirus

This Indian school accepts plastic waste instead of fees

UNICEF backpacks used as a haunting symbol to call for greater protection of children living in conflict

How tiny countries top social and economic league tables (and win at football, too)

Banking Union: Non-performing loans in the EU continue to decline

Robots and chatbots can help alleviate the mental health epidemic

How we can embrace the electrical vehicle transition by adopting smart charging

Is mental health really ‘health’?

The ethics of the Medical Technology Civilisation era

The US + Britain trivialize mainland Europe, NATO and the EU

3 ways to nurture collaboration between universities and industry

The EU wants to create 10 million smart lampposts

Switzerland to introduce strict restrictions on executive pay

Far more needed to ‘confront the world’s climate emergency’, UN chief tells ASEAN Summit

Europe’s far-right launches attacks on neighboring nations

Syria: Urgent, concrete actions needed, to protect children too young to ‘make sense of this senseless war’

COVID-19 increased the use of AI. Here’s why it’s here to stay

The European Union and Central Asia: New opportunities for a stronger partnership

IMF launches a new offensive against Germany

Integrating migrants and refugees into the labour market: Commission and social and economic partners relaunch cooperation

Europe united in not supporting a US attack on Syria

What is the biggest benefit technology will have on ageing and longevity?

Economic recovery won’t tackle youth unemployment problem

How curiosity and globalization are driving a new approach to travel

At G20 Summit OECD’s Gurría says collective action vital to tackle global challenges

MWC 2016 Live: Industrial world prepares to reap digital benefits

Mergers: Commission opens in-depth investigation into proposed acquisition of Metallo by Aurubis

Why small farms are key to the future of food – and how we can support them

Nicaragua ‘crisis’ still cause for concern amid murder, torture allegations: Bachelet

One life for another

Access and hesitancy as major challenges surrounding covid-19 vaccination campaigns

Zero carbon by 2050 is possible. Here is what we need to do

The mother of all fights about inflation, growth and banks

Three UN workers killed following Benghazi car bomb attack, as Security Council meets in emergency session, honours their ‘ultimate sacrifice’

Coronavirus: Commission proposes to provide €81.4 billion in financial support for 15 Member States under SURE

EU humanitarian budget for 2020 to help people in over 80 countries

UN launches drive to highlight environmental cost of staying fashionable

“We need to accelerate our negotiation on the China-EU Investment Treaty”, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang highlights from the 21st EU-China summit in Brussels

COVID-19: How multilateral development banks can lead through a crisis

New UN book club helps children deal with global issues

Here’s how to find a job you really love

WHO launches COVID-19 health alert service with Facebook and WhatsApp – Updates from Friday’s WHO briefing

More Stings?

Comments

  1. Liza Slinavcic says:

    what is this fscist article here?

Trackbacks

  1. […] the European Sting says this about mandatory vaccinations; “If someone rejects vaccination during a pandemic […]

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s