Can we crack the hydrogen puzzle this time around?

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Tony Pan, Chief Executive Officer, Modern Electron

  • Hydrogen is back on the agenda as a potential decarbonization solution – but several fundamental challenges remain to be solved.
  • These are the same barriers that stymied the last hydrogen hype cycle, 20 years ago.
  • Here’s a detailed look at those challenges – and why things might be different this time around.

Hydrogen is enjoying a massive resurgence in 2020 as a zero-emission wonder fuel. There is real hope that hydrogen might be able to decarbonize many parts of the economy that electrification cannot reach. Both Europe’s Covid Green Recovery stimulus and Joe Biden’s Clean Energy Plan include a focus on producing hydrogen with renewable energy. But critical challenges remain.

We do not yet know how to affordably transport, distribute, and store hydrogen. As such, hydrogen cannot realize its full potential.

Hydrogen has gone through hype and disappointment cycles before. Right now, the EU is leading the charge. Turn the clock back 20 years, however, and the USA and Japan were its biggest proponents.

Why did hydrogen not achieve its promise the last time around?

Lessons from the last hype cycle

The physical properties of hydrogen make it challenging to transport and store. Even once we get hydrogen to cryogenic temperatures, liquid hydrogen has a measly 25% of the volumetric energy density of gasoline. Gaseous hydrogen is even worse, with only 10% of the volumetric energy density of gasoline at reasonable pressure. Hence if we were to ship hydrogen in containers, we face the following challenges:

1. Compressed hydrogen

We could store compressed hydrogen in a container and then transport it.

But due to hydrogen’s low density, we would need very large containers. And when storing any compressed gas, there is no economy of scale: the mass of the container is proportional to the amount of gas stored. Therefore, to store a lot of hydrogen, we need a voluminous and heavy container.

The numbers are abysmal. Even using pricey super-strong materials for the container, such as composites with carbon fibre, only a measly 5% of the total container weight is the hydrogen fuel. That is neither cheap, small, nor lightweight. This is a disadvantage for compressed hydrogen in ground vehicles, and is challenging for aviation, since planes have to be both light and small to reduce drag for fuel economy.

Even in oceanic shipping, which is less sensitive to weight, the increased volume of compressed hydrogen fuel would be crippling. In a normal diesel ship today, roughly 4% of its storage volume is taken up by fuel. But with compressed hydrogen, the fuel size would take up 40% of the storage volume of the ship, hurting the ship’s ability to transport goods in bulk.

2. Cryogenic liquid hydrogen

We could store liquefied hydrogen in a container and then transport it. This would remove the need for expensive, heavy containers that can withstand pressurization. But hydrogen only becomes a liquid at -250˚C. Temperatures that low are both expensive and difficult to maintain, since we have to boil off some hydrogen continually to keep the rest cool.

Both compressed and liquefied hydrogen storage also incur extra losses in energy to either compress or cool the gas. Furthermore, both require specialized equipment, whose upfront cost deters adoption. Indeed, the cost of a hydrogen refuelling station – up to 10 times that of a fast-charging electric vehicle station – has hampered the wide deployment of hydrogen-powered cars

3. Hydrogen pipelines

We could skip containers and distribute hydrogen via pipelines. This is the cheapest method in the long term. But the cost of a mature hydrogen pipeline system has to be shared by many users, and that will be expensive given that there are few hydrogen users to begin with.

It could take trillions of dollars to build a dedicated hydrogen distribution pipeline system. For example, a group of German pipeline operators recently unveiled a plan to build a 1,200km hydrogen grid by 2030 at a cost of €660 million, based on converted natural-gas pipelines. This is consistent with the rule of thumb that it takes $1 million per mile to put in suburban gas pipelines. But 1,200 km is humbling when we consider that in Germany alone, the natural gas network is 530,000 km long. The USA has a total of about 3 million miles of transmission and distribution gas pipes, delivering gas all the way to people’s homes.

One shortcut being explored is to retrofit natural gas pipelines for pure hydrogen distribution. But hydrogen reacts and embrittles many components of pipelines, such as iron, steel and welds. Furthermore, hydrogen is the smallest molecule, and so it leaks through normal pipes, resulting in loss and safety hazards. And we lack affordable machinery to compress hydrogen for pipeline transport. Efforts are underway to solve these fundamental issues.

Global public investment in hydrogen R&D is on the rise again
Global public investment in hydrogen R&D is on the rise again Image: IEA

4. Storing hydrogen across time

Would things be easier if we ignored transport for now, and just store hydrogen across time?

The good news is that there are low-cost options that work at large scale, such as salt and rock caverns. But these are geographically limited. In the words of Bloomberg New Energy Finance: “If hydrogen were to replace natural gas in the global economy today, three to four times more storage infrastructure would need to be built, at a cost of $637 billion by 2050 to provide the same level of energy security.” Storing large amounts of hydrogen is one of the grand challenges and a prerequisite for a robust hydrogen economy.

This time can be different

Despite these challenges, hydrogen is very much worth investing in. Electricity only contributes one-third of manmade carbon emissions, and hydrogen is still one of our best bets for decarbonizing the other sectors of our economy. Mitigating climate change is too important for us not to try all possible paths on the table.

The dramatic fall in costs of renewable electricity allows us to bet on producing hydrogen without CO2 emissions at a cost that can be competitive in the coming decade. Just solving the zero-CO2 production of hydrogen alone presents an incredible opportunity; hydrogen is already used as an industrial feedstock. For a single-use location such as a petrochemical plant, zero-CO2 hydrogen produced close by reduces the need for transportation, distribution or storage. Just replacing existing grey hydrogen in industry with green hydrogen would save 800 million tons of CO2 per year. As for wider distribution of hydrogen to achieve partial decarbonization in the near future, up to 20% of hydrogen by volume can be blended with natural gas and shipped through our current gas pipeline infrastructure without major modification. These are all good starts, but are obviously not home runs.

What’s the World Economic Forum doing about the transition to clean energy?

Moving to clean energy is key to combating climate change, yet in the past five years, the energy transition has stagnated.

Energy consumption and production contribute to two-thirds of global emissions, and 81% of the global energy system is still based on fossil fuels, the same percentage as 30 years ago. Plus, improvements in the energy intensity of the global economy (the amount of energy used per unit of economic activity) are slowing. In 2018 energy intensity improved by 1.2%, the slowest rate since 2010.

Effective policies, private-sector action and public-private cooperation are needed to create a more inclusive, sustainable, affordable and secure global energy system.

Benchmarking progress is essential to a successful transition. The World Economic Forum’s Energy Transition Index, which ranks 115 economies on how well they balance energy security and access with environmental sustainability and affordability, shows that the biggest challenge facing energy transition is the lack of readiness among the world’s largest emitters, including US, China, India and Russia. The 10 countries that score the highest in terms of readiness account for only 2.6% of global annual emissions.

To future-proof the global energy system, the Forum’s Shaping the Future of Energy and Materials Platform is working on initiatives including, Systemic Efficiency, Innovation and Clean Energy and the Global Battery Alliance to encourage and enable innovative energy investments, technologies and solutions.

Additionally, the Mission Possible Platform (MPP) is working to assemble public and private partners to further the industry transition to set heavy industry and mobility sectors on the pathway towards net-zero emissions. MPP is an initiative created by the World Economic Forum and the Energy Transitions Commission.

Is your organisation interested in working with the World Economic Forum? Find out more here.

Policy-makers and private industry should not neglect the challenges of hydrogen transmission, distribution and storage. Such efforts span a wide range of research and development; as, for example, work on a class of materials called metal hydrides that show lots of promise as a new hydrogen storage medium. There are also efforts to convert hydrogen into ammonia or methanol, which is easier to transport, and then either use the derivative molecule as fuel, or convert it back into hydrogen at the customer destination. Last of all, there are efforts to cut the Gordian knot, and circumvent the need to move hydrogen long distance entirely, via the distributed production of hydrogen.

Such innovations across the entire hydrogen supply and distribution chain will be imperative if hydrogen is to play a consequential role in decarbonizing our entire economy.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

European Parliament approves more transparency and efficiency in its internal rules

Team Europe contributes €500 million to COVAX initiative to provide one billion COVID-19 vaccine doses for low and middle income countries

A Sting Exclusive: Towards better business opportunities for the EU and its neighbours, Commissioner Hahn live from European Business Summit 2015

European Investment Bank to borrow €70 billion in 2013

Wednesday’s Daily Brief: updates from the Near East and Libya, Ebola in DR Congo, World War remembrance

5 curve-flattening technologies being developed by young people

Governments urged to put first ever UN global migration pact in motion, post-Marrakech

How COVID-19 shows the urgent need to address the cyber poverty gap

From UN Assembly podium, Central African Republic leader appeals for lifting arms embargo

A free press is ‘cornerstone’ for accountability and ‘speaking truth to power’: Guterres

JADE Generations Club 2015: Knowledge vs. competences – Do not wait for the change to happen, but make it happen

The Parliament sets the way for the European Banking Union

EuroLat: serious concern about migration and support to multilateral trade

Commission adopts Recommendation on EU coordinated approach to travel and transport in response to new variant of coronavirus in the UK

The response to the current COVID-19 crisis must make the EU more resilient

Pharmaceuticals in the environment: Commission defines actions to address risks and challenges

3 things to know about women in STEM

Why integrated planning is key to truly transformative electrification

The European reaction to the neo-fascist wind

Burning Amazon rainforests: Darting towards the doom of Human Race

It’s Trump’s anti-globalization and inward-looking rhetoric that perturbs GOP and US

Half the world’s population is still offline. Here’s why that matters

Factory workers are facing a mental health crisis. Here’s how to respond

“The winner is who can accelerate the transition to a new digital era”. The Sting reports live from EBS 2015: a Digital Europe 4.0

The EU Consumer Policy on the Digital Market: A Behavioral Economics View

SMEs and micro firms sinking together with south Eurozone

Do you dare to go to China?

Trump’s withdrawal from the Paris climate deal is bad for US business. Here’s why.

COVID-19: More new virus cases outside China than in, ‘no time for complacency’, says UN health agency

Joint advocacy letter template to sign and ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons

Why embracing human rights will ensure Artificial Intelligence works for all

Should trade continue to be global after the pandemic?

We can end TB right now. Here’s how

A new roadmap for corporate climate governance

GSMA Announces New Speakers for Mobile 360 Series – Middle East and North Africa

Deal on digitalisation of access to justice will benefit citizens

UN chief calls for Security Council to work with Myanmar to end ‘horrendous suffering’ of Rohingya refugees

The three sins the EU committed in 2015

Venezuela: Parliament recognises Guaidó, urges EU to follow suit

Normal reactions to the abnormality of the pandemic

These countries create most of the world’s CO2 emissions

Entrepreneurship in a newly shaped Europe: what is the survival kit for a young Catalan and British entrepreneur in 2018?

How young people can help respond to the coronavirus outbreak

Where labour costs the most (and least) in the European Union

Libyan national conference postponed, nearly 500,000 children at ‘direct risk’ from fighting around Tripoli

How banks can help companies restructure for growth

Could robot leaders do better than our current politicians?

Nearly three million more displaced year-on-year, warns refugee agency chief, but solutions are within reach

Implementation of EU Facility for Refugees in Turkey: EU mobilises €663 million in humanitarian assistance

US and Mexico child deportations drive extreme violence and trauma: UNICEF

UN condemns ‘heinous’ suicide attack on education centre in Afghanistan

Who holds the key to the future of biotechnology? You do

Only a few months away from the single European patent space

The US is building a bike trail that runs coast-to-coast across 12 states

European Parliament backs CO2 emissions cuts for trucks

Why 2020 is a turning point for cybersecurity

Wind farms now provide 14% of EU power – these countries are leading the way

Colombia: Santos thanks the EU for its support to the peace process

Quality of air in Bucharest-Romania: is it fog or is it smog?

Young people all over the world come together to demand paid good quality internships

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s