COVID-19 shows why we must build trust in digital financial services

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Leora Klapper, Lead Economist, Development Research Group, World Bank

  • The pandemic has proved that digital financial inclusion is crucial – and that it cannot depend on cash-out services.
  • Weak financial infrastructure makes digital transactions difficult – and people often mistrust digital financial services.
  • Governments and financial institutions can earn that trust by building a resilient and inclusive financial system.

Last summer I met a woman in Mumbai as I was piloting the questionnaire for the World Bank’s Global Findex database. Even though she had a bank account for receiving government safety net payments, she didn’t use it for routine transactions. She still preferred to pay for a bus into the city centre to pay her utility bills in cash, because she didn’t know how to use the app on her phone and she didn’t trust that the money would go through.

In response to COVID-19, governments are rolling out relief payments, more salaries are being paid into accounts, and we’re seeing a surge in digital remittances sent home by migrant workers. If past research is any indication, most recipients will prefer to withdraw the entire sum in cash, just like the woman I met in Mumbai.

But the pandemic has shown that digital financial inclusion cannot rely on cash-out services. Business correspondents can close, ATMs can run out of money. A resilient digital financial system requires both expansive account ownership and a wider digital ecosystem so recipients can use the money in their account to pay their bills, purchase food, and send money to family members in need.

There are many roadblocks to digital financial services adoption. Among the most important is trust – trust that money in the account is safe, that people are being offered appropriate products, and that agents aren’t adding on extra fees. About half of all unbanked adults in Latin America report not having an account because they don’t trust financial institutions. Digital COVID-19 relief payments offer big opportunities to build up that trust.

During the pandemic, cash has carried a big administrative burden – it’s unsanitary, and waiting in line to be paid violates physical distancing. But digitalization could also expose customers, especially women, to financial services they might be unprepared to use.

People have good reasons to mistrust financial institutions. Mystery shopper audits in Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa found that loan officers failed to provide consistent information on costs, that inexperienced borrowers got less information than experienced borrowers, and that printed materials on borrowing costs were missing or failed to meet guidelines. A similar mystery shopper study in Chennai, India, found that bank staff almost always refused to offer basic accounts.

The adoption of digital financial services is on the rise in Africa
The adoption of digital financial services is on the rise in Africa Image: Global Findex Database

The onus for good financial behaviour should not rest exclusively on customers. Consumer safeguards are critical for building public trust in the financial system, so that people use their accounts to build financial security. For example, requiring clear and easy-to-understand product terms may be especially important for low-income women, given their relatively limited financial experience and capability. There’s evidence to support this: experiments in Mexico and Peru found that bank customers presented with simplified statements about credit and savings products made better financial choices. Regardless of how literate they are, people cannot make good financial decisions if they are given inaccurate or incomplete information.

There’s also a role for the government in financial education. The evidence for traditional classroom-based financial education is underwhelming. What’s working are interventions to improve financial capability that leverage teachable moments, such as when adults are applying for credit or when women are receiving government payments. Also, technology such as text messages can provide information cheaply and improve financial behaviour. Governments and financial service providers can partner and leverage technology to make it easier for government transfer recipients to know the amount of money they should be receiving, the closest operating cash-out point, and expected fees.

Image: Global Findex Database

The rapid digitalization of payments during the COVID-19 crisis will also create new electronic data points that can be used to compute alternative credit scores. But this new payment data needs to be collected responsibly. Take-up of digital financial services requires consumers to trust that their data and personal information will be kept safe, and governments should ensure that fintechs and financial institutions have cybersecurity systems in place.

It’s also important to remember that financial capability comes through experience. There’s growing evidence of ‘learning by doing’. For example, in Mexico, government beneficiaries who received a debit card accumulated sizeable savings, since using a debit card makes it easier and cheaper to withdraw money and because account holders use their debit card to check their account balances more frequently and build trust with the bank.

Our new paper shows that factory workers in Bangladesh who are paid into a payroll account learn to use more account features and use their accounts more efficiently and without assistance, as compared to workers paid in cash. Workers who get auto-deposit wage payments become savvier financial customers, and the benefits spill into the entire community; agents operating around factories that pay digital wages are less likely to add on extra fees because the workers in the area know their rights.

Governments and employers are playing a formative role pushing the pace of digitalization by making COVID-19 relief payments into people’s bank accounts. But people will not use their accounts unless they trust the financial system. Let’s use this unprecedented moment to introduce policies that help people develop that trust – and then keep them in the system to build their financial capability once the immediate crisis has passed.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Can India reduce deaths on one hazardous road to zero? This group is trying

COVID-19 tracing apps: MEPs stress the need to preserve citizens’ privacy

Politics still matter in the US but not in Europe

MEPs list conditions for new EU-Azerbaijan deal

South Korea once recycled 2% of its food waste. Now it recycles 95%

The unique role of business in building social good

Will the French let Macron destroy their party political system?

Yemen: ‘Living hell’ for all children, says UNICEF; Angelia Jolie calls for ‘lasting ceasefire’

Brexit: UK business fear of a no-deal scenario preparing for the worst

How to build long-term resilience in vulnerable communities

EU-UK relations: solutions found to help implementation of the Protocol on Ireland and Northern Ireland

This woman changed the world of work – and you’ve probably never heard of her

The Eurogroup offered a cold reception to IMF’s director for Europe

Trump stumbles badly on his Russian openings; Europeans wary of Putin

COVID-19: EU helps to deliver vaccines to Moldova and medical items to Montenegro and North Macedonia

Boosting the EU’s Green Recovery: EU invests over €2 billion in 140 key transport projects to jump-start the economy

4 ways to improve the lives of older people

Antitrust: Commission imposes binding obligations on Gazprom to enable free flow of gas at competitive prices in Central and Eastern European gas markets

EU4Health: 9.4 billion EUR budget needed for new EU health programme

A Sting Exclusive: “One year on from the VW scandal and EU consumers are still in the dark”, BEUC’s Head highlights from Brussels

European Semester 2018 Spring Package: Commission issues recommendations for Member States to achieve sustainable, inclusive and long-term growth

The French army is enlisting sci-fi writers to predict the future

What meat consumption has brought to the environment and how herbal diets can help human health

Here’s the secret to financing a greener future

Anti-vaccination: a private choice leading to collective outcomes

Consumer product quality: MEPs take aim at dual standards

This is how we can save millions of people from extreme poverty after COVID-19

Yemen: Security Council backs new mission in support of key port city truce

Scientists have created the world’s ‘first psychopath AI’

UN refugee agency presses States to aid 49 refugees stranded on Mediterranean

Take medical use of cannabis seriously, say MEPs

First-ever EU defence industry fund to finance joint development of capabilities

Parliament toughens its position on banking union

West Darfur tensions could see 30,000 flee across Sudanese border to Chad: UN refugee agency

China dazzles the world with her Silk Road plan to connect, Asia, Europe and Africa

Budgetary Control Committee asks for stronger measures to protect EU spending

Europe plans to send satellites into space to monitor CO2 emissions

Euro-Mediterranean Assembly fixes its permanent seat in Rome

EU to lead one more fight against climate change at G7 summit

New EU visa rules – Questions and Answers

4 ways leaders are driving innovation in the public sector and revolutionising governance

Electronic Cigarettes: A booster or alternative to Smoking?

Fostering intergenerational solidarity and cooperation through age-friendly environments: the right answer to Europe’s demographic challenge

‘Virtual Biopsy’ device detects skin tumours in 15 minutes

Where EU air pollution is deadliest

Eurogroup: IMF proposes Germany disposes

Where do Americans stand on immigration? They’re not as divided as you might think

“Scalpel, please”. For how long hearing this from a woman will be a surprise?

These are the skills young people will need for the green jobs of the future

Mergers: Commission clears acquisition of joint control over INWIT by Telecom Italia and Vodafone, subject to conditions

Why infrastructure is the only way to fight a COVID-19 recession in the US

MEPs want ambitious funding for cross-border projects to connect people

A Europe that Protects: Commission calls for more efforts to ensure adoption of security proposals

Nigeria floods: Guterres ‘deeply saddened’ by loss of life and rising need

EU young translators’ contest kicks off!

How trade wars pose a threat to the global economy

Why precision medicine won’t transform healthcare – but governance could

Fairer, simpler, more flexible EU farm policy: MEPs vote on post-2020 reform

#WorldBicycleDay: 5 benefits of cycling

Investing in rural women and girls, ‘essential’ for everyone’s future: UN chief

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: