COVID-19 shows why we must build trust in digital financial services

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Leora Klapper, Lead Economist, Development Research Group, World Bank

  • The pandemic has proved that digital financial inclusion is crucial – and that it cannot depend on cash-out services.
  • Weak financial infrastructure makes digital transactions difficult – and people often mistrust digital financial services.
  • Governments and financial institutions can earn that trust by building a resilient and inclusive financial system.

Last summer I met a woman in Mumbai as I was piloting the questionnaire for the World Bank’s Global Findex database. Even though she had a bank account for receiving government safety net payments, she didn’t use it for routine transactions. She still preferred to pay for a bus into the city centre to pay her utility bills in cash, because she didn’t know how to use the app on her phone and she didn’t trust that the money would go through.

In response to COVID-19, governments are rolling out relief payments, more salaries are being paid into accounts, and we’re seeing a surge in digital remittances sent home by migrant workers. If past research is any indication, most recipients will prefer to withdraw the entire sum in cash, just like the woman I met in Mumbai.

But the pandemic has shown that digital financial inclusion cannot rely on cash-out services. Business correspondents can close, ATMs can run out of money. A resilient digital financial system requires both expansive account ownership and a wider digital ecosystem so recipients can use the money in their account to pay their bills, purchase food, and send money to family members in need.

There are many roadblocks to digital financial services adoption. Among the most important is trust – trust that money in the account is safe, that people are being offered appropriate products, and that agents aren’t adding on extra fees. About half of all unbanked adults in Latin America report not having an account because they don’t trust financial institutions. Digital COVID-19 relief payments offer big opportunities to build up that trust.

During the pandemic, cash has carried a big administrative burden – it’s unsanitary, and waiting in line to be paid violates physical distancing. But digitalization could also expose customers, especially women, to financial services they might be unprepared to use.

People have good reasons to mistrust financial institutions. Mystery shopper audits in Latin America and Sub-Saharan Africa found that loan officers failed to provide consistent information on costs, that inexperienced borrowers got less information than experienced borrowers, and that printed materials on borrowing costs were missing or failed to meet guidelines. A similar mystery shopper study in Chennai, India, found that bank staff almost always refused to offer basic accounts.

The adoption of digital financial services is on the rise in Africa
The adoption of digital financial services is on the rise in Africa Image: Global Findex Database

The onus for good financial behaviour should not rest exclusively on customers. Consumer safeguards are critical for building public trust in the financial system, so that people use their accounts to build financial security. For example, requiring clear and easy-to-understand product terms may be especially important for low-income women, given their relatively limited financial experience and capability. There’s evidence to support this: experiments in Mexico and Peru found that bank customers presented with simplified statements about credit and savings products made better financial choices. Regardless of how literate they are, people cannot make good financial decisions if they are given inaccurate or incomplete information.

There’s also a role for the government in financial education. The evidence for traditional classroom-based financial education is underwhelming. What’s working are interventions to improve financial capability that leverage teachable moments, such as when adults are applying for credit or when women are receiving government payments. Also, technology such as text messages can provide information cheaply and improve financial behaviour. Governments and financial service providers can partner and leverage technology to make it easier for government transfer recipients to know the amount of money they should be receiving, the closest operating cash-out point, and expected fees.

Image: Global Findex Database

The rapid digitalization of payments during the COVID-19 crisis will also create new electronic data points that can be used to compute alternative credit scores. But this new payment data needs to be collected responsibly. Take-up of digital financial services requires consumers to trust that their data and personal information will be kept safe, and governments should ensure that fintechs and financial institutions have cybersecurity systems in place.

It’s also important to remember that financial capability comes through experience. There’s growing evidence of ‘learning by doing’. For example, in Mexico, government beneficiaries who received a debit card accumulated sizeable savings, since using a debit card makes it easier and cheaper to withdraw money and because account holders use their debit card to check their account balances more frequently and build trust with the bank.

Our new paper shows that factory workers in Bangladesh who are paid into a payroll account learn to use more account features and use their accounts more efficiently and without assistance, as compared to workers paid in cash. Workers who get auto-deposit wage payments become savvier financial customers, and the benefits spill into the entire community; agents operating around factories that pay digital wages are less likely to add on extra fees because the workers in the area know their rights.

Governments and employers are playing a formative role pushing the pace of digitalization by making COVID-19 relief payments into people’s bank accounts. But people will not use their accounts unless they trust the financial system. Let’s use this unprecedented moment to introduce policies that help people develop that trust – and then keep them in the system to build their financial capability once the immediate crisis has passed.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

6 ways countries can prepare for the next infectious disease pandemic

Moves to create a Kosovo army have ‘deteriorated relations’ with Serbia: UN peacekeeping chief

Smart city experts should be looking to emerging markets. Here’s why

3 unexpected consequences of the US-China trade war

China and China-EU Relations in the New Era

Beyond ‘business as usual’. Addressing the climate change crisis

Eurozone at risk of home-made deflation and recession

We need to give voice to ‘We the Peoples’, says UN chief

With Libyans now ‘fighting the wars of others’ inside their own country, UN envoy urges Security Council action to end violence

German stock market is not affected by the Greek debt revolution while Athens is running out of time

Coronavirus: EU guidance for a safe return to the workplace

5 things COVID-19 has taught us about inequality

Pharmaceuticals: Commission refines intellectual property rules

All States have ‘primary responsibility’ to protect against hate attacks

How the ‘California effect’ could shape a global approach to ethical AI

South Korea: A cherished partner for the EU

Where is heading Putin’s Russia?

New Mozambique storm rips off roofs, brings lashing rain as aid response kicks in

UN refugee agency presses States to aid 49 refugees stranded on Mediterranean

Young translators at EU schools – Commission opens registration for 2020 translation contest

Negotiated two-State solution still ‘the only option’ for Palestine: Guterres

UN political chief calls for dialogue to ease tensions in Venezuela; Security Council divided over path to end crisis

State aid: Commission approves €1.2 billion French “Fonds de solidarité” scheme for small enterprises in temporary financial difficulties due to coronavirus outbreak

These are the top 10 global causes of death – but two diseases are in decline

Brazilian health: right or privilege?

Why the minutes and the months matter most to young people during the COVID-19 crisis

Stop cooperation with and funding to the Libyan coastguard, MEPs ask

Statement by the European Commission following the extraordinary meeting of the EU-UK Joint Committee

Why Eurozone urgently needs the ECB to print and distribute at least €500 billion

The remote doctor in the 21st century

Over 820 million people suffering from hunger; new UN report reveals stubborn realities of ‘immense’ global challenge

“France will be there, it will always be there!”, French President Hollande says in a rather disorganised speech; the Sting reports live from World Economic Forum 2015 in Davos

What just happened? 5 themes from the COP24 climate talks in Poland

More bank bailouts at taxpayers’ expenses

EP wants data protection guaranteed before allowing fingerprint exchange with UK

Business growth is key to post-pandemic recovery

A new paradigm for collaboration: mission-based ecosystems

Africa is ‘on the rise’, says UN chief Guterres, urging collaboration for better future

MEPs urge UK to break current deadlock

Gender equality and medicine in the 21st century: an equity unachieved

Commission supports Member States in tackling coronavirus hotspots with offer of four million additional doses of BioNTech-Pfizer vaccine to be delivered this month

These 4 companies are turning food waste into cosmetics, clothing and more

Ahead of State of the Union the European Youth Forum highlights lack of action on youth employment

More international support needed to curb deadly measles outbreak in DR Congo

White Coat, Stained red

Gas pipeline in the European Union. (Copyright: EU, 2012 / Source: EC - Audiovisual Service / Photo: Ferenc Isza)

EU Investment Bank approves € 1.5bn loan for Trans Adriatic Pipeline (TAP)

COVID-19 has accelerated India’s digital reset

Commission celebrates the 30th anniversary of the Jean Monnet Activities promoting European studies worldwide

Meet the Seed Warrior: the man on a mission to rescue India’s rice diversity

UN rights chief ‘extremely concerned’ over deadly crackdown on protesters in Iran

Amid COVID-19 constraints, UN women’s commission meets to push gender equality forward

COVID-19, higher education and the impact on society: what we know so far and what could happen

As rural communities age, their public transport is shrinking. It’s time to fix this

Why the future of food must be blue as well as green

The digital revolution will transform the steel industry

ILO: Unemployment to increase by 8.1 million in 2013-2014

Central Mali: Top UN genocide prevention official sounds alarm over recent ethnically-targeted killings

Eco-anxiety during the Pandemic

GSMA Mobile 360 – Africa on 16-18 July 2019, in association with The European Sting

Destroying nuclear waste to create clean energy? It can be done

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s