Towards Responsible #AIforAll in India

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Anna Roy Senior, Advisor, NITI Aayog, Government of India & Arunima Sarkar, Project Lead, Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning, World Economic Forum


  • NITI Aayog is developing an approach towards ensuring responsible usage of AI in India with the support of Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution, World Economic Forum.
  • The approach defines broad principles that AI solutions should adhere to, while also exploring implementation and enforcement mechanisms.
  • A draft document has been released for public consultation. NITI Aayog is currently exploring a roadmap for enforcement of principles across the public sector, private sector and academic research.

Building further on the National Strategy on AI (NSAI) released in 2018, NITI Aayog is now working on outlining an approach towards realising the economic benefits of AI in a manner that is “responsible” to its users and broader society. The approach attempts to establish broad principles for design, development and deployment of AI in India – drawing on similar global initiatives but grounded in the Indian legal and regulatory context. The paper also explores means of operationalization of principles across the public sector, private sector, research and academia.

NITI Aayog, the think tank of the Government of India, is developing the approach to “Responsible #AIforAll” based on a large-scale stakeholder consultation facilitated by The Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution (C4IR) India. A Responsible AI working document (developed on the basis of a consultation workshop held in December 2019, organised by the C4IR India, World Economic Forum) was presented during a global consultation with AI ethics experts around the world on 21 July 2020 and subsequently released by NITI Aayog for wider public consultations.

India strives to balance regulation and innovation in the domain of AI technology.

What should AI ethics principles look like?

A number of Ethical AI principles have been developed globally on the underlying theme of protection of basic human rights. For an approach more tailored to the Indian context, principles in the working document have been developed on the basis of the “fundamental rights” afforded to Indian citizens as per its Constitution. These principles have been designed to be “long lasting” in pre-empting risks of AI regardless of the use case in question.

At the same time, however, nimbleness is required for these principles to not stifle innovation and to benefit from the latest developments in this rapidly developing field. The principles will need to evolve and an institutional mechanism to update them periodically is likewise necessary.

It is also important to evaluate the kind of regulatory framework that might work for India, bearing in mind that for a number of sectors (health, finance) there already exist regulators who may be positioned as the natural choice for discharging this function by extending their regulatory ambit. Thus the question of leaving it to sectoral regulators and legislation or having a new statutory authority confronts the policy-makers. Another consideration that arises is the “degree” of enforcement required for adherence to the defined principles. Do we just need high-level principles, or should we be regulating specific applications and use cases?

How do you put these principles into practice?

Enforcement mechanisms are evolving at various levels, viz. standards, guidelines, legislation. Drawing the line between self-certification and regulation is one of the key questions being discussed by NITI Aayog in various expert consultations. While self-certification is useful and should be explored with basic elements notified by the Government for adherence by enterprises, the same cannot be a substitute for a more direct approach.

In various expert consultations, a risk-based stratification of AI use cases suggestive of different degrees of enforcement of principles has emerged as the most favoured line of action.

Towards enforcement of principles, AI ethics standards are necessary but not sufficient, and need to be supplemented by guidelines and legislation. Further notifying standards alone would be a very passive approach and more initiative needs to be directed towards ensuring these get adequately integrated in an organization’s culture and workflow. Guidelines and legislation though more powerful tools for enforcement of principles, are also less agile and flexible to innovation.

AI ethics in the private sector

Internal ethics boards, self-assessment guides and external audits have been recommended by several experts as key mechanisms for private sector enforcement. Under certain scenarios, one could consider requiring providers to allow independent audit(s) of their solutions. This can help prevent or mitigate unanticipated outcomes.

The other major issue is to distinguish between sector-agnostic and sector-specific guidelines. Evaluation of AI-based use cases at the industry level can help identify sector-specific variations. Depending on the impact, benefits and risks attached to the portfolio of use cases, governance frameworks can then be operationalized accordingly. This will also allow for testing the responsible AI policy framework in real-world applications.

AI ethics in research

To ensure that research in the field of AI adheres to the principles, experts have recommended drawing from practices in the field of healthcare. Specific practices include the creation of “Internal Review Boards (IRBs)” or specific ethics review committees.

Incentivizing ethical AI research is another key focus area. NITI Aayog, while expounding the concepts of “India as the AI Garage” and “Global AI Alliance” in the NSAI, has been advocating inter alia international collaboration on ethical AI and government funding directed to similar projects. The NITI Aayog paper would aim to identify broad sectors in which research can be considered.

AI ethics in public sector deployment

As the public sector deployment of AI systems is expected to impact population at large, it’s important to ensure responsible public procurement of AI. To do so, mechanisms will need to be put into place to ensure that choices of public sector procurement professionals are guided by multidisciplinary group of experts in the field, which may take the form of “ethics review committees” to review procurement documents and the evaluation of proposals.

Other operationalization recommendations

A number of other techniques are being considered, including:

  • Creating environments conducive to innovation, such as regulatory sandboxes for facilitating innovation, development and adoption of AI.
  • “Ethics by design” approach whereby ethical principles are implemented from the beginning of the design process.
  • Continuous post-deployment monitoring of AI systems (similar to post-market surveillance for drugs and medical devices).
  • Ensuring accessible and affordable grievance redressal mechanisms for decisions made by the AI system.
  • In case of AI-based decision making, contestability (ability to appeal) also becomes important. If an algorithm will be making decisions that affect people’s rights and public benefits, it is important to describe how the administrative process would preserve due process by enabling the contestability of automated decision-making.

What is the World Economic Forum doing about the Fourth Industrial Revolution?

The World Economic Forum was the first to draw the world’s attention to the Fourth Industrial Revolution, the current period of unprecedented change driven by rapid technological advances. Policies, norms and regulations have not been able to keep up with the pace of innovation, creating a growing need to fill this gap.

The Forum established the Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution Network in 2017 to ensure that new and emerging technologies will help—not harm—humanity in the future. Headquartered in San Francisco, the network launched centres in China, India and Japan in 2018 and is rapidly establishing locally-run Affiliate Centres in many countries around the world.World Economic Forum | Centre for the Fourth Industrial R…

The global network is working closely with partners from government, business, academia and civil society to co-design and pilot agile frameworks for governing new and emerging technologies, including artificial intelligence (AI), autonomous vehicles, blockchain, data policy, digital trade, drones, internet of things (IoT), precision medicine and environmental innovations.

Learn more about the groundbreaking work that the Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution Network is doing to prepare us for the future.

Want to help us shape the Fourth Industrial Revolution? Contact us to find out how you can become a member or partner.

One of the key aspects of India’s ambition of #AIforAll includes responsible AI and balancing ethical considerations with need for innovation. When released, India’s Responsible AI for All paper will lay down recommendations for addressing some of the AI ethics challenges in India’s future roadmap for AI.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

How the world’s best teacher is changing lives in Africa

Member States and Commission to work together to boost artificial intelligence “made in Europe”

Nitrate pollution of water sources: new impulses for EU Water Policy?

Can indoor farming feed the world?

EU leaders agree on 2030 Climate and Energy Package: is “flexible” brave enough?

This German supermarket’s shelves are filled with food other stores won’t sell

This 3D-printed steak could help us reduce meat consumption

Biodiversity ‘fundamental’ for global food systems, at “heart’ of development – UN agriculture chief

LETTER FROM AFGHANISTAN: Elections serve up food for thought, for Afghan youth

This young scientist is tackling food insecurity for the world’s most vulnerable groups

Longer hours, more emails and shorter meetings – working from home in the time of COVID

‘Global care crisis’ set to affect 2.3 billion people warns UN labour agency

Civilians ‘continue to pay highest price’ in Ukraine conflict, with peace prospects losing ‘momentum’

3 things to know about our Sustainable Development Impact Summit

Trump’s Russophiles under investigation, Europe remains ‘en garde’

EU Parliament: The surplus countries must support growth

Eurozone at risk of home-made deflation and recession

‘Collective amnesia’ over causes of global financial crash – human rights expert

World ‘off track’ to meet most Sustainable Development Goals on hunger, food security and nutrition

Millions of Bangladeshi children at risk from climate crisis, warns UNICEF

Eurozone: The crisis hit countries are again subsidizing the German and French banks

Eurozone: Disinflation engulfs the industrial goods sector

A Sting Exclusive: “Leading by example! EU must push for UN deal to avoid dangerous climate change”, European Parliament Vice-President Ulrike Lunacek cries out from Brussels

Sweden is fighting loneliness by housing older and younger generations together

Keeping cool in the face of climate change

Mobile Technology in Nowadays Medical Practice: Is It a Safe Path?

“Working together to make a change at the COP 21 in Paris”, an article by Ambassador Yang of the Chinese Mission to EU

A jingoistic Spanish ‘war’ from the past

Security Union: political agreement on strengthened Schengen Information System

Leaders making these 5 key investments can shape an inclusive future

Over 330,000 Congolese migrants at risk after mass deportations from Angola – UN rights chief

An all-out fight for the EU budget

In Venezuela, Bachelet calls on Government to release prisoners, appeals for ‘bold steps towards compromise’

Colourism: How skin-tone bias affects racial equality at work

EU attempts to make new deal with Turkey as relations deteriorate

These countries create most of the world’s CO2 emissions

Will Europe be able to deal with the migration crisis alone if Turkey quits the pact?

Brexit: Six more months of political paralysis or a May-Corbyn compromise?

“The winner is who can accelerate the transition to a new digital era”. The Sting reports live from EBS 2015: a Digital Europe 4.0

UN global education envoy urges new funding for ‘lost generation’ of children forced out of classrooms by conflict

Where are the world’s nuclear weapons?

Will the EU ever tackle the migration crisis despite the lack of political will?

‘Dire consequences’ for a million children in the Middle East, North Africa, as funding dwindles

COP21 Breaking News_03 December: Unprecedented Global Alliance for Buildings and Construction to Combat Climate Change

Trade: First year of the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement shows growth in EU exports

Climate change: new rules agreed to determine which investments are green

Currency Union might not let an independent Scotland join the EU as the “Yes” front now leads

Data protection: Commission decides to refer Greece and Spain to the Court for not transposing EU law

The Cold War had an unintended side effect: It created a European wildlife paradise

Cholera surges, children in urgent need one month after Cyclone Idai slammed southern Africa – UNICEF

EU Emissions Trading System does not hurt firms’ profitability

How AI and satellite imaging can stamp out modern slavery

“A sustainable economy, low-carbon, resource-efficient, resilient and more competitive on the global stage”, EU Commissioner Vella in a Sting Exclusive

DR Congo: Ebola response resumes despite ‘risky environment’

Are Halloween pumpkins a problem for the planet?

Suicide Prevention: Using Graduation as a Transformative Tool

WHO reports ‘very strong progress’ in battling DR Congo Ebola outbreak

We need to give voice to ‘We the Peoples’, says UN chief

Medical deserts in the European Union: the practicalities of universal health coverage

Water scarcity is a growing problem across the Middle East. Is this how we solve it?

More Stings?

Advertising

Trackbacks

  1. […] Source: Towards Responsible #AIforAll in India – The European Sting – Critical News & Insights o… […]

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s