COVID-19: lessons from Italy on public-private healthcare procurement

masks 2020

(De an Sun, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Veronica Vecchi, Associate Professor of Practice, SDA Bocconi School of Management & Niccolò Cusumano, Associate Professor of Practice, SDA Bocconi School of Management

  • The pandemic has thrown into sharp focus the shortcomings of public-private healthcare procurement systems.
  • This crisis presents an opportunity to learn and to reshape these systems in time for the next emergency.
  • Here are 3 lessons drawn from Italy’s experiences – and recommendations around how to move forward.

The COVID-19 crisis has highlighted the case for improving the governance of procurement of critical supplies such as ventilators and personal protective equipment (PPE). Over the course of this emergency, in which global supply chains have been disrupted – initially by the Chinese lockdown and subsequently by a surge in demand from all affected countries – authorities at all institutional levels and private healthcare providers have competed with each other to maintain their supplies of healthcare services.

In many nations, even long before the pandemic, public healthcare budgets were under stress – and this has pushed public and private healthcare providers to find ways to balance growing demand against existing resources. The procurement of medical devices, technology and pharmaceutical products, the prices of which have been increasing above the level of general inflation for years, has been a principle focus of such policies, together with the general shift from hospital acute care towards outpatient services that are better able to address non-transmittable and chronic diseases.

COVID-19’s challenges to Italian public health procurement

On the basis of discussions with the main public health buyers involved in the procurement of critical devices, we have identified three main issues that have placed stress on public healthcare procurement in Italy.

1. Lack of preparation. Despite the existence of pandemic plans at the national and regional levels, the system was not prepared to face the surge in demand. Commoditized products such as PPE, that are widely available in normal times, proved to be bottlenecks. Common procurement management practice would recommend stockpiling in this case, which was almost nonexistent in Italy. However, as the US example shows, even strategic reserves are not an answer because of the problems of allocating materials between competing demands and the sheer cost of maintaining such a system over time. Contractual remedies also proved to be illusory, as many multinational firms found it impossible to fulfil their obligations in the presence of an international supply shock. In Italy, it took almost two months to begin domestic manufacturing of PPE.

2. Lack of coordination. Like almost all national healthcare systems, the Italian National Health Service has multilevel governance. During the COVID-19 emergency, regional authorities have had to coordinate the procurement of supplies together with Italy’s Civil Protection agency. The lack of coordination between national and regional levels has placed stress on procurement, production and delivery systems. Government authorities, private companies, donors and local hospitals were all trying to place orders at the same time. In this context, the actual level of need for medical supplies was not clear.

3. Procurement centralization was structured as a top-down cost-cutting initiative, thus hampering public-private collaboration. In the context of a high perceived risk of fraud and bribery in public procurement, legality and transparency have frequently been prioritized over value for money, innovation or effectiveness. Procurement rules and the fragmented control system have encouraged a climate of bureaucratic conformity and mistrust within the public sector, and between authorities and suppliers. Italian governments have, therefore, lost the chance to establish appropriate institutional and organizational approaches to encourage business-government cooperation and facilitate strategic public procurement. In this emergency context, as an example, integrated solutions, and not just single pieces of equipment, could have been bought to ensure the continuity of treatment in hospitals. However, the lack of experience and the urgency of filling warehouses have not allowed health-procuring authorities to move towards solutions. Further, the absence of public-private innovative solutions in place, such as telemedicine systems, would have proven to be more effective for domiciled care, which is still weak in some of the most affected areas of the country.

Hastily-generated public-private collaborations

In the search for the lowest price, procuring authorities are more dependent on suppliers based in specific geographical areas such as China and India. After the Chinese manufacturing shutdown, some procurement authorities returned to Europe-based manufacturers, which had previously been deemed too costly. Many stakeholders in the private and public sectors have argued that the search for price minimization, especially for commoditized items such as masks and sanitizers, has harmed the national market. The lack of a domestic biomedical industry in these sectors has also slowed down the reconversion of some production lines, for example for PPE, which require proper validation and verification from authorized laboratories that are missing both in Italy and across Europe. During the emergency, “hastily-generated” partnerships have bloomed. They are not only fundamental to ensure resilience in outbreaks; they can also pave the way for the creation of collaboration and trust to move public procurement towards a more strategic approach and to develop partnerships on a larger scale.

Recommendations for policy-makers

The narrative around public procurement should shift from compliance and preventing “waste” to trusting and empowering public managers. Public buyers have demonstrated their ability to find and experiment with new solutions to overcome severe market conditions, by showing willingness to take risks and responsibilities.

Despite the global impact of COVID-19, we are witnessing a surge in local emergencies; in this context, government authorities should be able (and willing) to encourage companies to increase their disaster-management capabilities and to select those providers who can better guarantee continuity. The aftermath of this pandemic could be an opportunity to design resilience-oriented procurement strategies based on the selection of reliable providers; the creation of a portfolio of providers to be activated in case of emergency; and the use of contracts to allow flexibility and outcome-assurance.

The importance and relevance of public-private collaborations have certainly been exposed by COVID-19. Indeed, procurement as a partnership approach has been challenged by the operating framework and culture of the public sector, which have hindered the development of inter-organizational relationships and trust.

Policy-makers should reflect on which areas of procurement would be less affected during the outbreak if previous partnerships existed with market suppliers, by comparing flexibility, rapidity and business continuity offered by contractual agreements based on different levels of collaboration. To co-design and deploy collaborations will require not only new management competence to move procurement from a compliance-based perspective into a risk-management perspective, but also a new strategic approach to procurement – one in which the public sector behaves as a sophisticated buyer and where procurement is used to achieve policy goals such as business resilience, innovation and the creation of national production.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Brain drain 2017: why do medical students need to emigrate to become doctors in 2017?

‘Internal security’ or how to compromise citizens’ rights and also make huge profits

How can entrepreneurship tackle the migration crisis in the EU?

Vegetarianism is good for the economy too

Misinformation and growing distrust on vaccines, ‘dangerous as a disease’ says UNICEF chief

We have the tools to beat climate change. Now we need to legislate

Latest tragedy in the Mediterranean claims over 100 lives – UN refugee agency

European Youth Forum on Summit on Jobs and Growth

Why is Grexit again in the news? Who is to pay for Eurozone’s banking problems?

EU’s tougher privacy rules: WhatsApp and Facebook set to be soon aligned with telcos

To achieve the Great Reset, we will need more than just the actions of the powerful

Migration policy affects attractiveness of OECD countries to international talent

6 charts that show how Japan’s economy stacks up as it enters a new era

MEPs want to boost energy storage in the EU to help spur decarbonisation

DR Congo President and UN chief meet at a ‘historic moment’ for democracy in the country

EU budget: Commission proposes €1.26 billion to reinforce the European Solidarity Corps

Strengthen inclusion, participation of people with autism to ‘achieve their full potential’ says UN chief

Italian banks: It’s Rome’s turn to confront Berlin’s aggressiveness

Draghi strives to control the unruly exploitation of financial markets by banking leviathans

Eurozone: How safe are our deposits? Which banks will survive?

Europe enters uncharted waters with Kiev-Moscow standoff

Stakeholder capitalism is urgently needed – and the COVID-19 crisis shows us why

Growing up near green space is good for your mental health as an adult

Here’s how data could make our cities safer

New York and London mayors call on cities to divest from fossil fuels

‘Climate change is the battle of my life’, UN chief tells students living on the frontline in Fiji

UN chief ‘deeply saddened’ by Ethiopia plane crash which killed 157, including at least 21 UN workers

What little Cameron got in Brussels seems enough to keep Britain in the EU

Thailand gave healthcare to its entire population and the results were dramatic

Finland should do more to improve job prospects of low-skilled youth

Syria: Civilians caught in crossfire, UN refugee chief urges Jordan to open its border

5 steps businesses can take to protect air quality after COVID-19

One third of poorer countries face both undernutrition and obesity: WHO report

This is why retail is such a sore point in India-US trade relations

What matters most to young Europeans?

Only the Americans are unhappy with the ceasefire agreement in eastern Ukraine

Greece begins a new chapter following the conclusion of its stability support programme

ECB’s new money bonanza handed out to help the real economy or create new bubbles?

Digitalization is changing banking – These 3 trends will help shape its future

G20 LIVE: G20 Antalya Summit in Numbers, 15-16 November 2015

Amidst ‘high political tension’, UN chief appeals to G20 leaders for stronger commitment to climate action, economic cooperation

Air pollution, the ‘silent killer’ that claims seven million lives a year: rights council hears

How banking with blockchain can stamp out corruption and increase financial inclusion

Does the Erasmus program really contribute to the construction of a solid EU identity?

Why CEOs need to become activists in sustainability

The European Commission to stop Buffering

Tools of asset development: Renewable Energy Projects case

The blackened white coat of the doctors

UN says ‘many humanitarian achievements’, one year after ouster of ISIL from Mosul

Brexit must not put UK university research at risk

Volkswagen getting away with it in Europe

Energy: EU funding for priority projects should reflect 2050 climate objectives

Healthy habits to help you cope with health anxiety

‘End the ongoing atrocities’ against people with albinism in Malawi, say UN rights experts

How building renovations can speed up the electric vehicle revolution

The relation of deforestation and respiratory diseases

Deutsche Bank chased away from US, threatened with more fines

What does strategy have to do with a platform approach?

International Criminal Court acquits former president Gbagbo of war crimes in Côte d’Ivoire

How emerging markets will shape Africa in 2020

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s