Siemens-Alstom merger: Can Germany and France lobby to circumvent EC’s rejection, against EU consumers’ interests?

Press conference by Margrethe Vestager, Member of the EC
Date: 06/02/2019. Location: Brussels – EC/Berlaymont. © European Union , 2019 Source: EC – Audiovisual Service Photo: Lukasz Kobus

The European Commission (EC), after months of investigation and discussions, came to the independent conclusion to refuse the merger of the rail companies Siemens and Alstom despite the improvements provided by the two firms together with the continuous pressure by the French and German governments.

Nevertheless, France and Germany still believe that the EU has wrongly prohibited this gigantic merger and is considering of proposing new changes to the competition policies in order to avoid similar outcomes.

On the other hand, the EC decided with correct argumentation and away from EP election interests to protect the consumers’ rights against the enlargement of the EU companies which would create monopolies in the rail industry. Consequently, the argument that with this merger the EU would able to face the Chinese rival CRRC (China Railway Rolling Stock Corporation) and Canada’s Bombardier Transportation went to the trash bin. The Sting commends strongly any decision of the European Commission which is beyond any political interest and is solely made to protect the European Consumers.

EC puts a stop to the mother of all rail mergers

The European Commission decided last week that the proposed Siemens’ acquisition of Alstom should be prohibited under the EU Merger Regulation due to the fact that the actions taken by both firms were not enough as far as the EU competition rules are concerned. More specifically, European Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: “Millions of passengers across Europe rely every day on modern and safe trains. Siemens and Alstom are both champions in the rail industry. Without sufficient remedies, this merger would have resulted in higher prices for the signalling systems that keep passengers safe and for the next generations of very high-speed trains. The Commission prohibited the merger because the companies were not willing to address our serious competition concerns.”

Siemens & Alstom fight back

Siemens CEO Joe Kaeser mentioned last Monday that this ruling was not up-to-dated implying that it needs to be changed. Mr Kaeser told:  “If it had been decided in the UAE I assure you it would have been different. We must not confuse antitrust laws with industrial policies, we need to respect that. But if the future of the world’s mobility is being determined with law that is 30 years old, that may have to be revisited — for the future, not for the past.”

Similarly, Alstom expressed its disappointment about the EC’s judgment. The French company supported that has done all the necessary improvements in order for the competition concerns to be covered related to Signalling and Very High Speed trains but still the European executive body declined to proceed with this acquisition.

Franco-German alliance

During the period of EC’s investigation, France together with Germany supported this acquisition which would have led to a huge EU train maker conglomerate capable to by at large monopolize the EU market with a strategy compete with its Chinese competitor CRRC.

But EC’s decision was felt by the German and French government as a hit below the belt, in view of the upcoming EU elections. The French finance minister asked for an alteration of the EU competition rules expressing his disapproval for the outcome. More in detail, Bruno Le Maire told CNBC at the World Government Summit in Dubai last Sunday: “Let’s have a look at reality — we are facing a huge challenge with the rise of the Chinese industry. What do we do — shall we divide the European forces, or try to merge the European forces from the industrial point of view?”

What is more, Bruno Le Maire mentioned two days ago that: “It is necessary to reform the EU competition policy. It’s urgent. It’s part of the proposals I will make with my German counterpart Olaf Scholz in the coming weeks”.

The pre-election Mergers

Naturally, Bombardier is the winner from this Franco-German merger halt.  The Canadian firm avoided having a company of twice its size as a rival in the train industry. Furthermore, it is not unlikely to fire up the merger talks between Alstom and Bombardier in order to reduce the costs and take a larger part from the pie.

Another possible merger in the EU is the one between Thyssenkrupp and Tata Steel which is being also investigated by the European Commission in order to make sure that competition rules are complied in the steel industry. The EC is expected to come up with a decision by April 29. However, Thyssenkrupp is much concerned after the Siemens-Alstom prohibition because it is on the course to create EU’s largest steelmaker after ArcelorMittal. Guido Kerkhoff, Chairman of the Executive Board & CEO of Thyssenkrupp, said yesterday that: “You cannot put the same label on it at all”.

Will competition rules change to the detriment of EU consumers?

All in all, it is true that this time the EC independently managed to handle the situation and deny the Siemens-Alstom merger but what if the competition policies change? Many companies and governments are most probably going to support such an action ahead of the EU elections as the interests at stake are just too high.

However, it remains to be seen whether the bloc’s watchdog will continue tackling similar threats independently and thus protecting the EU consumers’ rights by prohibiting price increases and making sure that they are well served by markets where a fair competition exists and monopolies are halted.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Measles claims more than twice as many lives than Ebola in DR Congo

COP21 Breaking News: Conference of Youth Focuses on Hard Skills to Drive Greater Climate Action

Bolivia: UN underlines support for ‘credible, transparent and inclusive’ election

On Youth Education: “Just a normal day in the life of a medical student”

Investment Plan for Europe: European Investment Bank to provide BioNTech with up to €100 million in debt financing for COVID-19 vaccine development and manufacturing

Wars have rules: 5 things the UN humanitarian chief wants countries to tackle so human suffering in conflict can be minimized

Continue ‘their mission’ urges UN chief, as the victims of the Baghdad bombing are remembered, 15 years on

Global public-private collaboration tackles cybersecurity skills gap

Mobility package: Transport Committee backs deal with EU Ministers

Can the EU really make Google and Facebook pay publishers and media?

Eurozone guarantees all banks with…taxpayers’ money

Nauru President warns of possible climate change ‘economic Armageddon’

Trump aims trade offensive solely to China, renews truce with EU

UN underlines need for dialogue to resolve Israel-Palestine conflict

Security Council extends mandate of UN Interim Force in Lebanon for a year

5G and the growing need for national CTOs

FROM THE FIELD: Enslaved Guatemalan indigenous women wait for reparations

COVID-19 reminds us of the crucial role nurses play

Coronavirus: Member States agree on an interoperability solution for mobile tracing and warning apps

‘Transformational benefits’ of ending outdoor defecation: Why toilets matter

UN health agency to gauge global threat, as China confirms coronavirus transmission between humans

20 years on from landmark Mine Ban Treaty, dangers on the rise to life and limb

UN health agency launches week of action to ban lead paint

These countries have some of the highest voter turnout in the world

Property regimes for international couples in Europe: new rules apply in 18 Member States as of today

MEPs condemn attacks on civilians, including children, in Yemen

Germany may prove right rejecting Commission’s bank resolution scheme

Do we judge robots on their colour? This study says we do

The European Parliament rewrites the EU budget in a bright day for the Union

President David Sassoli to visit Skopje: “Remain on the European track”

Brexit negotiations: Can May’s Britain bounce back?

Eurozone: Despite anemic growth and shaky banks marks record trade surplus

UN investigates systematic sexual violence across South Sudan

Mobile 360 Africa 11-13 July 2017

This start-up is making a palm oil alternative from used coffee grounds

Deeper reforms in Germany will ensure more inclusive and sustainable growth

EU Facility for Refugees in Turkey: EUR 400 million Special Measure on education adopted

European Defence Fund: €205 million to boost the EU’s strategic autonomy and industrial competitiveness

State aid: Commission approves €3 billion Portuguese guarantee schemes for SMEs and midcaps affected by Coronavirus outbreak

How COVID-19 is making companies act for the long term

How can the EU hit net-zero emissions?

Here’s why the world’s recovery from COVID-19 could be doughnut shaped

Antitrust: Commission consults stakeholders on guidance for national courts when handling disclosure information

IMF: All you want to know about Argentina

The issues of practicing medicine in Pakistan

Resolving Israel-Palestinian conflict, ‘key to sustainable peace’ in the Middle East: Guterres

European Fund for Transition to support more workers made redundant

These are the most desirable cities for overseas workers

Syria: UN chief warns Idlib offensive may set off ‘humanitarian catastrophe’

Peace operations benefit from improved cooperation between the UN and troop-providing countries, says peacekeeping chief

At epicentre of Indonesia disaster, Guterres praises resilience of Sulawesi people

The ethical dilemmas of medicine

MWC 2016 LIVE: The top 5 themes of this year’s Mobile World Congress

Nuclear testing has ‘disastrous consequences’ for people and planet, General Assembly told

Security Council welcomes Yemen breakthrough, but lasting peace remains a ‘daunting task’

Jeroen Dijsselbloem new Eurogroup president

At last some rules on banks

Most leaders are missing this crucial character trait

Parliament backs measures to cut e-commerce VAT fraud

5 ways to break down the barriers for women to access leadership roles

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s