From glass ceiling to glass cliff: women are not a leadership quick-fix

Theresa May 2019.jpg

Ms Theresa MAY, UK Secretary of State for the Home Department. Copyright: ‘The European Union’ Event: Extraordinary Justice and Home Affairs Council – 22 September 2015

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Beth A. Brooke-Marciniak, Global Vice-Chair, Public Policy, EY

What do you need to innovate in the Transformative Age? You need diversity. You need men. And you need women. Gender equality is not only a fundamental human right, but it is also linked to a country’s overall economic performance. Organizations where women hold 30% of leadership positions could add up to 6% to their net margins, according to recent research.

Therefore it makes no business sense to overlook diversity as a part of a business strategy. In fact, doing so only diminishes opportunities for sustained economic growth, innovation and social progress.

So if women are critical for innovation and long-term growth, why are we still an estimated 202 years away from achieving gender parity in the workplace?

The uphill battle

Despite the gender gap narrowing slightly this past year, according to the World Economic Forum’s Global Gender Gap Report 2018, women still face an uphill battle in leadership positions. And, it turns out, the higher women climb, the more biases, challenges and stereotypes they face.

Interestingly, though, when women are appointed to the top job, it’s often at a time of a crisis – when an organization is grappling with a financial crisis or other challenges and may even be on the verge of collapse. This phenomenon was coined the “glass cliff” by British academics Michelle Ryan and Alex Haslam, who in 2004 published findings from an extensive study of FTSE 100 companies and found a tendency for women to be appointed leaders of failing organizations.

Take a few notable examples:

• Jóhanna Sigurðardóttir became Iceland’s first female prime minister and the world’s first openly gay head of government amid economic and political fallout from the global financial crisis. She stabilized Iceland’s economy in a relatively short period of time.

• Former Xerox CEO Anne Mulcahy is often deemed a “glass cliff” success story. She took over as CEO in 2001 as Xerox was on the verge of a Chapter 11 bankruptcy and a year later, following an aggressive restructure, the company reported an operating profit.

It’s encouraging to see women being called upon to lead in times of crises – and succeeding at the highest levels. But by accepting roles in troubled companies or challenging times in government, they risk being held responsible for outcomes that were set in motion ahead of their appointments.

Some are still fired even after they’ve fixed the problem. Female CEOs are about 45% more likely than male CEOs to be dismissed from their own companies, according to a study by the University of Alabama. And, strangely, while improved organizational performance may protect a male CEO from being fired, the same does not hold true for women. In other words, women face greater challenges when appointed to leadership positions and, as per research by academics Alison Cook and Christy Glass, are provided fewer opportunities to establish their leadership capabilities.

CEO turnover

When a female CEO gets fired, research has found that she is usually replaced by a man. It’s what some academics refer to as “the saviour effect”. We’ve seen this story in news headlines again and again.

• Former Reddit CEO, Ellen Pao, is one example. According to several sources, Pao was only in the role for eight months before being replaced by Steve Huffman. Reddit’s chief engineer Bethanye Blount, who stepped down after just two months, said she believed Pao was in an unwinnable situation.

A Guardian article believes Patricia Russo was in a similar predicament. Russo led Lucent Technologies (later Alcatel-Lucent) through three consecutive years of negative shareholder returns before the board hired Dutchman Ben Verwaayen.

• An article titled “Theresa May is the latest woman leader appointed in a crisis and set up for failure” highlights yet another purported glass cliff scenario, with all-male candidates touted to replace May.

Despite greater attention being paid to gender inequality, women continue to face an uphill battle. While they are more likely to be hired when all is lost, they’re still more likely to be fired than men.

As CEOs and world leaders gather in Davos next month, let this serve as a reminder. Until we address the underlying biases that hold women back, gender gaps will remain. And as a result, deep-seated inequalities and a lack of diversity will continue to hinder sustained economic growth, innovation and social progress.

The views reflected in this article are the views of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the global EY organization or its member firms.


the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

How blockchain is addressing key problem patterns in the financial services sector

UN report on Syria conflict highlights inhumane detention of women and children

Is the English language too powerful?

AI-powered automation will have an ethnic bias

Opening Remarks by H.E. Ambassador Yang Yanyi, Head of the Chinese Mission to the EU at the Chinese Fashion Night

India’s Largest Entrepreneurship Event is Back! (23-24th August 2016)

The world is getting angrier, according to a new poll

WHO and UNICEF in campaign to protect 1.6 million in Sudan from cholera

The latest technology isn’t enough – you need the business model to go with it

Review on ethics and technological development

EU finally agreed to cut roaming charges in 2017 but criticism is always there

Repression, use of force risk worsening Bolivia crisis: UN human rights chief

The scheming of Boris: win an election after a no-deal Brexit

OECD welcomes French plans to increase and better target foreign aid

Three-quarters of South Sudanese children have known nothing but war, says UNICEF

COVID-19: National authorities should do more to raise awareness of EU action

Climate action must stay top of the global agenda as we emerge from COVID-19

Confidence-building measures continue in new Yemen prisoner-swap talks

Questions and answers: Commission proposes SURE, a new temporary instrument worth up to €100 billion to help protect jobs and people in work

Cédric in India

Better sanitation for India is in the pipeline

Apple® logo (copyright: Apple)

Apple takes further step into music: EU Regulators formally approve its planned Shazam acquisition


Deutsche Bank: the next financial crisis is here and the lenders need €150 billion from taxpayers

Kids who live in the countryside have better motor skills, a study in Finland has found

Venezuela’s needs ‘significant and growing’ UN humanitarian chief warns Security Council, as ‘unparalleled’ exodus continues

State aid: Commission approves German scheme for very high capacity broadband networks in Bavaria

Is the European Banking Union an impossible task?

Cholera surges, children in urgent need one month after Cyclone Idai slammed southern Africa – UNICEF

Taxes on polluting fuels are too low to encourage a shift to low-carbon alternatives

These are the world’s best cities to be a cyclist

ECB’s new money bonanza handed out to help the real economy or create new bubbles?

Coronavirus makes inequality a public health issue

Northern Ireland: Parliament wants to secure post-Brexit regional funding

‘Vaccines are safe’ and save lives, UNICEF declares, launching new #VaccinesWork campaign

Companies ‘failing’ to address offline harm incited by online hate: UN expert

Here’s how the EU is doing on gender equality

Earthquake: Monte Dei Paschi Di Siena

UK Labour Party leader Corbyn readies to change Brexit political backdrop

What the future holds for the EU – China relations?

How do we go about improving mental health in the community and reducing suicide rates in the 15-29 age group?

‘Collective amnesia’ over causes of global financial crash – human rights expert

Cape Town’s crisis shows us the real cost of water

Eurozone: Statistics don’t tell the whole story

Charges against Baha’i in Yemen must be dropped: UN experts urge release of detainees

5 lessons for social entrepreneurs on how to change the system

At UN, France’s Macron says more ‘political courage’ is needed to face global challenges

Nowhere is safe to hide in war-torn Yemen, say UN-appointed rights experts

Foreign Affairs Council (Trade) of 22/05/2018: EU relations with key trading partners

Privatization of the health sector and the right to receive treatment

More international support needed to curb deadly measles outbreak in DR Congo

‘Path to peace’ on Korean Peninsula only possible through diplomacy and full denuclearization: US tells Security Council

Ebola Outbreak in Democratic Republic Congo is ‘largely contained’: WHO


A shortened EU Summit admits failures, makes risky promises

The Red Cross’s health chief explains how business must respond to coronavirus

Trade surplus up production down in Eurozone

Germany is turning its old mines into tourist hotspots

10 ways COVID-19 could reshape offices

The world needs carbon-neutral flying. Here’s how to bring it one step closer

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s