Why Italy will not follow the Greek road; Eurozone to change or unravel

Italian President, Sergio Mattarella (on the left) receives the European Commission President, Jean-Claude Juncker in Rome. Mattarella’s recent decisions lead to new elections soon. Date: 26/02/2016. Location: Rome – Quirinal, Roma – Residence of the President of the Republic. (© European Union, 2016 / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service / Photo: Marco Zeppetella).

the next Italian election is, very probably, to take place within the next few months or even weeks. Then, Berlin, the rest of Eurozone capitals and probably the entire western financial world will learn, if it’s still politically possible to ask just one country’s taxpayers to save an obviously faltering global financial system. The test was performed in Greece during the past eight years. The political and social structures of the country finally stomached the persisting bitter pills and today the government budget produces unbelievable prime surpluses above 3% of a slashed by 25% GDP.

Of course, Greece was forced by Berlin, Brussels and the International Monetary Fund into the inferno. However, Italy is a different story both in size and availability of alternative routes, outside the single euro money highway. Most certainly, the Italian voters will turn the next election into an in, out referendum for the euro, as it happened in Greece in July 2015. In the latter country 63% of the vote was against the acceptance of the humiliating terms attached to remaining in Eurozone. The governing SYRIZA party however and personally the Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras overruled the result and conceded to the terms of creditors. But let’s take the story from the beginning.

The Greek catastrophe

Greece has lost by now one quarter of her annual national income and product, compared to the 2010 levels. Nevertheless, the country carries on rather soundly, despite unemployment rates around 20% overall and 40% for the youths. The impossible salvage, a quasi miracle, has to be attributed to the full policy reverse, if not ideological U-turn, of the leftists governing SYRIZA party and Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras himself. In the summer of 2015, Greece, Europe and the financial world lived horrifying days.

Finally, on 15 July, SYRIZA and Tsipras proposed and the Parliament conceded Greece to remain in the Eurozone and pay the dear price. It was barbaric spending cuts, hideous tax increases and unseen before reductions in wages and pensions. Is Italy ready to do the same? Many people doubt it; let’s see why. But first return to Athens to see what happened.

Unbearable Germany

All along the difficult years after 2010, Berlin led the Eurozone hawks callously demanding time after time Athens to capitulate. Finally, the Germans got what they wanted; profiteering ruthlessly on the Greek debt, while they should have shared the cost. After all, it was the German banks which the Greek taxpayers undertook to repay in full for imprudent credits. To be noted, that sharing sovereign bankruptcy costs between creditors and debtors has become a tradition, after the Latin American debt arrangement of the 1980s. On that occasion, the New York banks accepted to get partially paid off with the famous Brady Bonds. But no, Berlin wanted it its own way.

The reasons why Greece accepted this humiliating and financially catastrophic arrangement – capital controls are still there – is not difficult to explain. The country is small and geographically located in a very unstable cross continental region of the Balkans and the Eastern Mediterranean, where South East Europe meets Asia and Africa. At that time, Greece suffered of excessive foreign trade and fiscal deficits, guaranteeing an inferno if outside the Eurozone. So, it had to be the euro or no real money at all, let alone the external risks. This extended reference to Greece’s problems serves as a comparison base.

Italy is different

Italy suffers from nothing of the sort. Her neighbors pose no outside threats whatsoever and the country has a solid productive machine (industry, agriculture, services), also very competent on world markets. So, it’s the only south Eurozone country which can avoid a catastrophe in a possible transition period while leaving the euro area.

On top of that, it must be stressed that the really excessive Italian state debt at 130% of GDP is mainly financed and held at home by a super rich north, comparing excellently or even surpassing Germany in every respect (industry, services, agriculture and more). The European Central Bank also holds a good part, of the Italian state debt of round €250 billion, from a €1.3 trillion in total. Is Germany ready to negotiate a salvation of Italy? It might be so. So, Rome has the arsenal to resist the German attacks.

Fratzscher’s foundings

Speaking of Germany, Marcel Fratzscher the second most prominent economist of the country (according to an evaluation of Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung) estimated recently that his country has gained €294 billion in interest savings, since 2007 from the policies of Eurozone’s central bank, the ECB.

Apart from that, Germany is the largest beneficiary from the existence of the single currency and the single internal EU market. It has a yearly trade surplus of more around €60bn with her Eurozone partners, not because it manufactures better Mercedes, but because the others do not protect their own markets from the German dumping.

Dumping people

Yes, one may argue that Germany dumps a good part of her own people. Again Fratzscher in some ways unwillingly supports the dumping allegation. He says that part time work has doubled in a few years and adds that the average household “has almost 3 percent less income today than it did in 2000”.

All that must be attributed to the infamous and peculiar employer-trade unions ‘understanding’ sponsored ‘energetically’ by the government in even more peculiar ways. In this way, the country secures an almost uninterrupted labor peace. Isn’t it a democratic discrepancy, when a European country works underground with its ‘deep state’, in order to pacify its labor market? Why do we only denounce second and third world countries for suppressing their labor movements, and do not discuss how Germany secures an almost fully pacified labor market?

Seasick marines

As for the legendary German effectiveness and competitiveness there are important sectors of total German failure, proving the opposite. Banking and mercantile marine are two famous cases. The ‘great’ Deutsche Bank when exposed to the New York banking market competition, almost went bankrupt and returned shamed to Germany. It was saved by the grey workings of an underground ‘patriotic collaboration’ between the German economic elites and the state. Openly the German business leaders vowed to support the bank with what it needed. They didn’t give a damn if the EU fair completion legislation permitted such a salvation. Still, the Deutsche Bank has to fire more than ten percent of its personnel in order to survive.

Another famous case of German impotency to compete in the high seas, is the full failure of the country’s shipping sector. During the past ten years, mainly Greek ship-owners have cheaply bought and dearly re-sold after some time tens of merchant ships of German ownership. So, the ‘bitter pill’ that the previous heartless minister of Finance, Wolfgang Shäuble tried to shamelessly insert into the obligations of the Athens government a super-tax for the Greek ship-owners turned around to hit him on the head.

Teuton thinking

He was so ‘Teuton’ as not to understand that ocean going ships have propellers and can go wherever they like and raise whichever flag they chose. At the same time, the German state offers a multiple and largely illegal subsidies to her merchant marine companies. The merchant marine is an infallible proof that the German effectiveness is of a special character, needs special support to flourish, while Berlin unscrupulously and deceitfully tries to undermine fair competition.

All in all, during the next few months, the Italian political developments will bring everybody before their responsibilities. How long yet will Jens Weidmann, the President of Bundesbank (German central bank) will be able to denounce ECB’s monetary policy as favoring the South and still Germany gaining hundreds of billions from it? How long more will Berlin be able to block any discussion about the recycling of the German surpluses, through investments and more consumption? For how long more will Germany be able to pretend it fulfills her EU obligations and still refuse to honor her obligations to Athens?

Hopefully, the Italian deviation may awaken the sound German thinkers and convince the country’s leaderships not to continue on the catastrophic way until we come to a horrible repetition of history.

 

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

New poll shows what people think coronavirus will do to their economies

EU Parliament says ‘no’ to austerity budget

Will Qualcomm avoid Broadcom’s hostile takeover post the 1 bn euro EU antitrust fine?

Pakistan-India crossing is a ‘Corridor of Hope’, UN chief says, wraps up visit with call for interfaith dialogue

Informal meeting of heads of state or government, Sibiu, 09/05/2019

These islands are using tourists to help offset the effects of tourism

Is Haiti better prepared for disasters, nine years on from the 2010 earthquake?

Brexit talks stalled at launch; issues with European Court’s authority in Britain

New chapters in EU-China trade disputes

Health equity and accessibility for migrants is a peremptory demand

As fighting in Libya escalates, so does number of children ‘at imminent risk of injury or death’

How has policy affected employment in small businesses in the US?

This city in India swaps plastic for free meals

A backbencher Tory MP threatens both EU and UK with a no-deal Brexit

Federalist EU ‘naively’ believes Washington shares her TTIP high fever

Plastic waste from Western countries is poisoning Indonesia

How to keep our cities cool as temperatures rise

Migration crisis update: The “Habsburg Empire” comes back to life while EU loses control

Autonomous weapons that kill must be banned, insists UN chief

Entrepreneurial leadership: what does it take to become a leader?

Financing fossil fuels risks a repeat of the 2008 crash. Here’s why

A quarter of Pacific islanders live below ‘basic needs poverty lines’, top UN development forum hears

Government internet ban leaves parts of Myanmar ‘in a blackout’, UN expert calls for immediate lifting

How can impact investors balance the green energy equation?

Why Trump’s tariffs are good news for US garlic farmers

Do not take the EP’s consent on MFF for granted, says Budget Committee Chair

Ebola cases rising in DR Congo, but UN health agency cites progress in community trust-building

External action: more funds for human rights, development and climate change

Your chocolate can help save the planet. Here’s how

rescEU assets mobilised to help Greece fight devastating forest fires

3 reasons why responsibly-deployed technology is key to the COVID recovery

Guinea-Bissau: Upcoming elections vital to prevent ‘relapse’ into instability, says UN envoy

Assembly of European Regions @ European Business Summit 2014: Made in Europe – Made of Regions

Urgently address ‘defining challenges of our time’, to empower youth worldwide, top UN official tells forum

Brazilian health: right or privilege?

Hardened creditors drive Greece to dire straits; Tsipras desperate for an agreement

State aid: Commission approves German scheme for very high capacity broadband networks in Bavaria

ECB offers cheaper money despite reactions from Germany

Pumping more money into banks but leaving them unregulated doesn’t help

These researchers want to use your computer in the search for a COVID-19 vaccine

5 myths about face masks under the microscope

Mine action is at ‘the nexus’ of peace, security and development: UN official

Greece may offer to China a European gateway

5 ways the world is rallying around Australia as bushfires rage

Lithuania finds the ways to maintain its energy security

The hidden risks nature loss poses for businesses

How do we design an inclusive energy transition?

What if nature became a legal person?

DR Congo: Restore internet services as ‘a matter of urgency’, urges UN expert

Commission: Raising the social issues that can make or break the monetary union

UN experts urge Turkey to repatriate Irish woman associated with terror group

World’s 1.8 billion youth must ‘have a say in the future of the planet’

November infringements package: key decisions

Genocide threat for Myanmar’s Rohingya greater than ever, investigators warn Human Rights Council

Peacekeeping: A ‘great opportunity’ to develop professionally and personally

Code of Practice on Disinformation one year on: online platforms submit self-assessment reports

How can we prepare students for the Fourth Industrial Revolution? 5 lessons from innovative schools around the world

G20 LIVE: G20 Antalya Summit in Numbers, 15-16 November 2015

The cuts on 2014 Budget will divide deeply the EU

‘All atrocity crimes are preventable’ and can never be justified – UN chief

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s