Amazon, Luxembourg and Ireland hit by EU’s latest turn of the screw over competition

Margrethe Vestager, European Commissioner for Competition, in Brussels - Berlaymont, last week. (Copyright European Union, 2017 / Source: EC - Audiovisual Service / Photo: Lukasz Kobus)

Margrethe Vestager, European Commissioner for Competition, in Brussels – Berlaymont, last week. (Copyright European Union, 2017 / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service / Photo: Lukasz Kobus)


Last week, the European Commission has ordered Amazon to pay a 250 million euros ($293 million) bill in back taxes to Luxembourg, as a consequence of “undue tax benefits”. The Commission also announced that it is planning to take the Irish government to European court over its failure to recover €13bn in unpaid taxes from Apple Inc., related to a 2016 ruling. The latest moves represent a turn of the screw by Brussels to make US tech giants pay more taxes in Europe, as well as the latest chapter of a discussion on taxes and competition in the bloc.

Background

Launched almost three years ago, in 2014, the European Commission’s investigation concluded that a tax ruling issued by Luxembourg in 2003, and prolonged in 2011, lowered the tax paid by Amazon in Luxembourg “without any valid justification”. The European watchdog indeed alleges that the Seattle, Washington-based company benefited from a so-called sweetheart tax deal for almost a decade, that granted it illegal state support from Luxembourg, the hub for its European operations.

In an official statement, the European Commission explained that Amazon to shifted the vast majority of its profits from an Amazon Group company, that is subject to tax in Luxembourg (Amazon EU the “operating company”), to a company which is not subject to tax (Amazon Europe Holding Technologies). “In particular”, the official EU statement says, “the tax ruling endorsed the payment of a royalty from Amazon EU to Amazon Europe Holding Technologies, which significantly reduced Amazon EU’s taxable profits”.

The ruling

So last Wednesday the European Commission announced it has concluded that Luxembourg granted undue tax benefits to Amazon of around €250 million, and that the EU member State must now recover the illegal aid provided to Amazon. Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: “Luxembourg gave illegal tax benefits to Amazon. As a result, almost three quarters of Amazon’s profits were not taxed”. “In other words, Amazon was allowed to pay four times less tax than other local companies subject to the same national tax rules. This is illegal under EU State aid rules. Member States cannot give selective tax benefits to multinational groups that are not available to others”, she also added.

The European Commission also explained in its official press release that its investigation showed that the level of the royalty payments, endorsed by the tax ruling, was “inflated and did not reflect economic reality”, and that the tax ruling granted a “selective economic advantage to Amazon by allowing the group to pay less tax than other companies subject to the same national tax rules”. In particular, the Commission believes that, thanks to the fact that under Luxembourg’s general tax laws, only the operating company is subject to corporate taxation in Luxembourg, the holding company (Amazon Europe Holding Technologies), received a substantial, unfair advantage.

The reaction

The Financial Times last week quoted Amazon as saying: “We believe that Amazon did not receive any special treatment from Luxembourg and that we paid tax in full accordance with both Luxembourg and international tax law. We will study the commission’s ruling and consider our legal options, including an appeal”. Tech magazine Engadgenet also reported that Amazon said : “Our 50,000 employees across Europe remain heads-down focused on serving our customers and the hundreds of thousands of small businesses who work with us.”

Luxembourg’s government, for its part, said: “As Amazon has been taxed in accordance with the tax rules applicable at the relevant time, Luxembourg considers that the company has not been granted incompatible state aid”.

Boiling Apple

In a separate announcement, the Commission has also announced it is taking further steps against Apple Inc. and, as an actor of the same complex play, against Ireland. On 30 August 2016, a Commission decision concluded that Ireland’s tax benefits to Apple were illegal under EU State aid rules, because it “allowed Apple to pay substantially less tax than other businesses”. Now the European competition watchdog as decided to refer Ireland to the European Court of Justice “for failing to recover from Apple illegal State aid worth up to €13 billion”, as required by a Commission decision.

With an official European Commission statement on October 4, Commissioner Margrethe Vestager said: “Ireland has to recover up to 13 billion euros in illegal State aid from Apple. However, more than one year after the Commission adopted this decision, Ireland has still not recovered the money, also not in part”. “We of course understand that recovery in certain cases may be more complex than in others, and we are always ready to assist. But Member States need to make sufficient progress to restore competition. That is why we have today decided to refer Ireland to the EU Court for failing to implement our decision”, she added.

The deadline for Ireland to implement the Commission’s decision on Apple’s tax treatment was 3 January 2017. “The Commission has therefore decided to refer Ireland to the Court of Justice for failure to implement the Commission decision, in accordance with Article 108(2) of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU)”, the official EC press release therefore stated.

“Intensive work”

Ireland on Wednesday immediately described as “extremely regrettable” an EU decision to take the country to the European Court of Justice, but promised to collect money owed as soon as possible. Dublin said the Commission’s August order for the U.S. tech giant to pay the unpaid taxes was “unjustified”, but it had agreed to collect the money and was seeking one or more investment managers to handle an escrow account, as reported by Reuters.

“It is extremely regrettable that the Commission has taken this action, especially in relation to a case with such a large-scale recovery amount,” Irish finance ministry said in a statement. “Irish officials and experts have been engaged in intensive work to ensure that the State complies with all its recovery obligations as soon as possible, and have been in constant contact with the European Commission and Apple on all aspects of this process for over a year”.

Open disputes

Amazon’s and Apple’s cases are two of the four among such tax probes launched by the European Commission since 2013, although there are more competition-related cases opened on the desk of EU regulators, including FIAT, McDonald’s and Google. The Commission has indeed promised it will scrutinize tax arrangements between large multinationals and the bloc’s member states, as part of a major reform of EU tax rules, including changes to cross-border VAT that is due to be discussed in the coming days and weeks.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Top global firms commit to tackling inequality by joining Business for Inclusive Growth coalition

Stronger European Border and Coast Guard to secure EU’s borders

The China-US trade deal will be signed on time; the path is set

5 things you need to know about creativity

Human trafficking cases hit a 13-year record high, new UN report shows

rescEU assets mobilised to help Greece fight devastating forest fires

Illegal fishing plagues the Pacific Ocean. Here’s how to end it

MEPs criticise “America first” policy

Texting is a daily source of stress for 1/3 of people – are you one of them?

Nigeria floods: Guterres ‘deeply saddened’ by loss of life and rising need

Special measures for Greece: 100% absorption rate

What next after more sanctions against Russia, will the Ukrainian civil war end?

Top UN rights official urges transparent probe into Khashoggi disappearance

UN highlights profound implication of population trends on sustainable development

World Refugee Day, 20 June 2020: Joint Statement by the European Commission and the High Representative

Three ways the world must tackle mental health

Business uncertainty rises as US grants only temporary exception to EU for steel and aluminium tariffs

Mergers: Commission clears acquisition of Refinitiv by London Stock Exchange Group, subject to conditions

‘Jerusalem is not for sale’ Palestinian President Abbas tells world leaders at UN Assembly

Trash bin at the top of the world: can we prevent Arctic plastic pollution?

New energy security framework will help meet growing needs in East Africa, sustainably – UN economic wing

What washing your hands can teach you about global change

Time to say goodbye to the plastic straw. But what’s the best alternative?

Nature is our strongest ally in ensuring global water security

These artists created a huge open library – and their idea’s gone global

Nearly four million North Koreans in urgent need, as food production slumps by almost 10 per cent

This is how you should be social distancing – depending on where you are and what you’re doing

Code of Practice against disinformation: Commission calls on signatories to intensify their efforts

6 ways the COVID-19 pandemic could change our approach to human capital

Student Tutor Ratio: at a glance

The crunch ‘COP 24’ UN climate change conference: what’s at stake and what you need to know

Quelling antimicrobial resistance: a clinico-pharmacological exigency

Capital markets selloff: The financial moguls send messages to monetary authorities

China-EU Special Report: Chinese Premier Li Keqiang endorses China’s big investment on Juncker’s plan at 10th China-EU Business Summit

Coronavirus response: Team Europe supports Somalia with three EU Humanitarian Air Bridge flights

The sun’s impact on Earth and weather celebrated, as planet marks World Meteorological Day

The EU Commission lets money market funds continue the unholy game of banks

European Business Summit 2014: Sting Report, Day I

Waste-free consumption: 3 reasons why cities will lead

Can we create an empathic alternative to the capitalist system?

Independent rights experts sound alarm at Iran protest crackdown, internet blackout

Climate crisis could see ‘collapse’ of some economies without diversification, warns UN trade chief

Job automation risks vary widely across different regions within countries

More hiring freedom can reduce teacher shortages in disadvantaged areas

The Eurogroup+ is born to govern the EU Banking Union

How Japan became the world leader in floating solar power

GSMA Mobile 360 – MENA Dubai on 26-27 November 2019, in association with The European Sting

Trade: First year of the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement shows growth in EU exports

Panic buying of face masks and other supplies puts healthcare workers at risk, says WHO

‘Building back better’ – here’s how we can navigate the risks we face after COVID-19

Mergers: Commission approves the merger of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N.V. and Peugeot S.A., subject to conditions

European Citizens’ Initiative: Commission decides to register ‘Right to Cure’ initiative

Here’s how we get businesses to harmonize on climate change

Study finds sharks are ‘functionally extinct’ in 20% of reefs observed

How the coronavirus market turmoil compares to 2008 – and what we can do

Can ECB’s €60 billion a month save Eurozone?

Community Manager – 1289

3 ways to fight short-termism and relaunch Europe

ITU Telecom World Awards launches 2018 edition

Banking package: Parliament and Council reach an agreement

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s