EU’s guidelines on net neutrality see the light although grey areas do remain

Günther Oettinger___2016

Participation of Günther Oettinger, Member of the EC, in the round table on ‘5G manifesto for timely deployment of 5G in Europe’. © European Union , 2016 / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service / Photo: Lieven Creemers.

Last week will not only be remembered for the world-record fine imposed to Apple by the European Union and the Hutchison-VimpelCom merger in Italy. There was also space for some important news on net neutrality.

The Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications (BEREC), which is the regulating agency of the telecommunication market in the EU, published last week guidelines on how the EU will implement net neutrality rules that were adopted last year. The document, which clarifies how internet service providers should treat the data they handle in the EU, represents the final stage in the three-year process of adopting net neutrality legislation in the bloc.

Net Neutrality principle

Net neutrality is the principle that all data should be treated equally, and that Internet service providers (ISPs) should enable access to all content without blocking or slowing down specific websites on purpose, regardless of the source. In a few words, net neutrality’s mission should be preventing broadband operators from favoring specific sources of content such as commercial partners.

BEREC only admitted a small range of exceptions, which refer to “specialised services” that are optimised for specific content, such as high-quality voice calling on mobile networks, real-time health services (such as video feeds for use in remote surgery) and live broadcasts over internet TV services. “Regulators would have to check that giving preference to such services would not degrade others”, BEREC specified in its statement.

Background

The new net neutrality rules were adopted in the EU last year and took effect in April this year, and after then BEREC launched a six-week public consultation on the draft Guidelines, closing on 18 July. “The number of 481,547 contributions received before the deadline was unprecedented for a BEREC consultation, and coming from diverse categories of respondents: civil society, public institutions and independent experts, ISPs, content and application providers and other industry stakeholders”, as it was declared by BEREC in its official statement. The Guidelines finally saw the light last week, and were published together with an accompanying consultation report, summarising stakeholders’ views submitted and how BEREC took them into account.

The net welcomes the news

The publication has been welcomed by digital rights experts, and digital rights groups are describing the document as a victory for the free and open internet. “Europe is now a global standard-setter in the defence of the open, competitive and neutral internet. We congratulate BEREC on its diligent work, its expertise and its refusal to bend to the unreasonable pressure placed on it by the big telecoms lobby,” said Joe McNamee, executive director of the European Digital Rights (EDRi) in a statement, as reported by the BBC and other prominent news outlets last week.

Commissioner Günther Oettinger, in charge of Digital Economy and Society, called BEREC’s Guidelines as “a reference for every national regulator having to decide whether a company or a public service provider violates the net neutrality rules and whether to start proceedings against them”. “Ensuring an open Internet is a fundamental principle to promote and protect the Internet that we want”, he said. “Today, we made a further step in the right direction”, he added.

Loopholes risk

Something many experts were afraid of was that the regulations that were first adopted last year contained several holes, or “loopholes”, including a provision that would have allowed providers to offer an internet fast lane to paying sites. Some campaigners and groups indeed claimed that the 2015 document also contained allowances for ISPs to predict “periods of peak demand” and so introduced some traffic management measures that would have eventually led to lowering the effects of net neutrality. The European consumer organisation BEUC too warned that the exceptions would have undermined the overall achievement at those times.

Grey areas

It seems that now, under the Guidelines, telecom firms will only be allowed to slow down internet traffic to fix bad quality, and not towards any kind of commercial return. However, the new regulations received also several critics and there are many people that are convinced that the Guidelines still leaves many questions untouched. Many have indeed raised the point that Internet service providers that restrict online access to pornography or adult content could be breaking the new EU guidelines on net neutrality. The issue is particularly serious in the UK, as described by the Guardian, where companies such as ISPs Sky, BT and TalkTalk already block access to adult sites following pressure from the government, as do mobile operators such as O2.

Ad blocking at risk

And if blocking porn falls into a grey area ad blocking may be at risk too, as the clause contained in BEREC’s “net neutrality” guidelines indeed states that telecoms companies “should not block, slow down, alter, restrict, interfere with, degrade or discriminate advertising when providing an IAS (internet access service)”. This way all software that blocks adverts from appearing on smartphones may find themselves breaking the law.

No regulation at network level

The Guidelines by BEREC actually state that while consumers should be allowed to install “ad blocking” apps on their phones, network-level blocking should be prohibited. A guidance document, contained in a report issued alongside last week’s updated guidelines reads: “BEREC notes that the regulation does not consider that end-user consent enables ISPs to engage in such practices at the network level”. “End-users may independently choose to apply equivalent features, for example via their terminal equipment or more generally on the applications running at the terminal equipment, but BEREC considers that management of such features at the network level would not be consistent with the regulation”, the guidance adds.

The Guardian last week reported that Frode Sorensen, co-chair of the BEREC Expert Working Group on net neutrality refused to comment on specific cases or countries, but said the updated guidance made it clear that it had found no legal basis for using customer choice to “justify blocking any content without national legislation” or for reasons of “traffic management or security”.

End-user blocking

And if there were any doubts on how popular end-user ad blocking already is in the world, a report published earlier this year by PageFair will help get the bigger picture. The report shows that a least 419 million people (22% of the world’s 1.9bn smartphone users) are blocking ads on the mobile web. In Europe and North America, as of March 2016, there were 14 million monthly active users of mobile adblocking browsers.

The report also shows that, as of March 2016 an estimated 408 million people are actively using mobile adblocking browsers, like for instance a mobile browser that blocks ads by default. These figures are the clear indicators of how adblocking will likely become the most hotly discussed topic in the digital media industry, and surely the new Guidelines on net neutrality rules in the EU will inescapably be the hottest point of discussion.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Internet of Things: a Force for Good or Evil?

Mind the (gender) gap: why we should stand together on inclusion

How can we build a workforce for our digital future?

GSMA Announces New Speakers for Mobile 360 Series – Middle East and North Africa

From glass ceiling to glass cliff: women are not a leadership quick-fix

Europe bewildered by radicalisation and terrorism

Why this is the year we must take action on mental health

IPCC reports devastating climate consequences; US in denial while EU does not fully support the 2050 net zero emissions target

Europe’s richest regions actively seek investment from China’s biggest banks

UN chief condemns killing of ‘blue helmets’ in DR Congo, as violence erupts prior to elections

Can medical students be prepared for Global Health ethical issues?

Afghanistan: UN ‘unequivocally condemns’ attack in Kabul

The space internet race is dawning. Here’s what to expect

COP21 Breaking News_09 December: The Draft Agreement Updated

Stricter rules to stop terrorists from using homemade explosives

What washing your hands can teach you about global change

How to make PHC a favourable career choice for medical students: Strategies and reflections

European Court of Justice to Google: It is #righttobeforgotten but not #righttoberemembered

For the future of Europe youth remains a priority

How a trade war would impact global growth

Humanitarian Aid: additional €50 million to tackle drought in the Horn of Africa

A day in the life of a refugee: the role of nations and citizens of the world

What does global health translate into?

Opposite cultures: Should it be a problem?

An entrepreneurial point-of view on tackling the migration crisis and the risks of abolishing Schengen

How migrants who send money home have become a global economic force

UN working with both sides, after hidden tunnels confirmed along Lebanon-Israel ‘Blue Line’

Main results of Asia-Europe Meeting (ASEM) – 18-19/10/2018

HPV vaccine: the silver bullet that saves women

Top envoy to Yemen praises ‘flexibility’ of chief negotiators as new UN mission chief is named

Erasmus+ 2021-2027: more people to experience learning exchanges in Europe

Failing to agree climate action would ‘not only be immoral’ but ‘suicidal’, UN chief tells COP24

ECB is about to lend trillions to banks

vSudan: UN chief calls for ‘positive momentum’ as civilian rule talks stall between military and opposition

Act now to end violence, Zeid urges Nicaraguan authorities

Data exchanges: Strengthening Europol cooperation with non-EU countries

Could a Digital Silk Road solve the Belt and Road’s sustainability problem?

Thursday’s Daily Brief: Ebola in DR Congo, malnutrition in Laos, baby health, support for Sahel force, #ClimateAction

Measles cases nearly doubled in a year, UN health agency projects

Three ways the Fourth Industrial Revolution is shaping geopolitics

The EU Commission is lying to the “Right2Water” campaign

80,000 youngsters at risk in DRC after forcible expulsion from Angola: UNICEF

To feed 10 billion people, we must preserve biodiversity. Here’s how

Hundreds of thousands migrants ready to cross the Mediterranean. Only a local matter?

A health approach to climate change

G20 LIVE: G20 leaders reaffirm OECD’s role in ensuring strong, sustainable and inclusive growth

7 of the world’s 10 most polluted cities are in India

A reflection of health inequity in recent epidemics

A Europe that Protects: Commission calls for continued action to eradicate trafficking in human beings

UN chief ‘deeply alarmed’ over military offensive in south-west Syria

Young and unemployed the perfect victims of ‘vultures’

‘Do everything in your power to tackle climate change’ UN chief urges on Mother Earth Day

Colombia: Rights experts condemn killing of reintegrated former rebel fighter, call for respect of peace process

There is no greater sorrow on earth than the loss of one’s native land

Night owls, rest easy

What happens when you toss your water bottle in the trash?

COP21 Breaking News_12 December: Another sleepless night for the negotiators before Indaba meeting

Emergency meeting called as Ebola spreads to Congolese city – UN health agency

“Health and environment first of all”, EU says with forced optimism after 7th round of TTIP talks

2014 budget: The EU may prove unable to agree on own resources

More Stings?

Comments

  1. Admiring the time and energy you put into your weblog and in depth info you offer. It’s excellent to come across a blog every once in a even though that isn’t the same old rehashed material. Fantastic read! I’ve bookmarked your website and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google account.

Trackbacks

  1. […] EDRi: The fight against hate speech undermines the fundamental rights of citizens (Krapuul) 12/09 EU’s guidelines on net neutrality see the light although grey areas do remain (The European Sting) 13/09 EU-Canada Airline Data Pact Violates Privacy:Adviser (Bloomberg BNA) […]

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s