Does the Commission subsidise a forced labour scheme in Britain?

The European Commission and Member States are meeting to discuss implementation of the Youth Guarantee at a seminar organised by the Commission in La Hulpe, Belgium on 17-18 October. All those people participating in this seminar found something to do to get paid for, but have failed to help even one young unemployed person to find a job. (EC Audiovisual Services)

The European Commission and Member States are meeting to discuss implementation of the Youth Guarantee at a seminar organised by the Commission in La Hulpe, Belgium on 17-18 October. All those people participating in this seminar found something to do to get paid for, but have failed to help even one young unemployed person to find a job. (EC Audiovisual Services)

The British Supreme Court in London upheld yesterday a Court of Appeal decision that the government’s heavily advertised ‘model’ programme, “back to work”, designed to ‘help’ the unemployed to find a job, or training or apprenticeship, is illegal and therefore has to be stopped or substantially changed. The scheme requires that the young unemployed should work without pay and cuts their jobseeker’s allowance (JSA) if they don’t comply with the rules. The programme had been heavily promoted by the British government as a model that should be used also by other countries. It has attracted heavy criticism, though, from many quarters, for imposing unpaid labour.

Understandably, before the Supreme Court, there was an Appeal Court to decide on the case. The European Sting closely followed this affair. As a matter of fact, at the end of last February, a British Appeal Court ruled that the “back to work” scheme was illegal for enforcing unpaid work. On 2 March the Sting writer Suzan A. Kane noted, “In reality, this British government programme was not designed to help the unemployed, but rather to cut their unemployment benefits. Under its rules, young people receiving unemployment benefits had to accept any job without payment (!), if they wanted to keep their allowances. Of course, the whole scheme implicated some ‘flexible’ private firms, which wanted to have in their workforce unpaid slaves, not regular workers. The whole ‘circus’ was called ‘on the job training’”.

Unpaid labour

Of course, the employers who used workers for free, didn’t pay any social security contributions, either. Workers were sweating for them for nothing, really. Given that, the selection process of the business to be supplied with free labour, must have been quite a parody. Who would say no to such a gift? This said, could the bureaucrats who make the decisions ask for kickbacks, while directing the unpaid labourers to a certain firm? Who knows?

In any case, the British government wasn’t happy at all with this Court of Appeal ruling and took the case to the Supreme Court. Unfortunately for David Cameron’s government, all the five Supreme Court judges agreed with the Court of Appeal decision. Their ruling says that the programme has legal flaws and it was not explained in detail to perspective participants.

According to the British Press it was a graduate, Cait Reilly, who brought the case to the courts. She claimed that the requirement to work without payment violated her human rights. As expected, the Supreme Court didn’t accept that the scheme led to exploitation and ‘forced labour’. In such an eventuality, the London government’s days could have been numbered.

Does the EU subsidise forced labour?

It’s a bad coincidence though for the Brussels bureaucracy that this scandal breaks out at a time when there is a lot of talk going on, about the Commission’s ‘Youth Guarantee’ scheme. It’s not the first time that the Brussels dignitaries advertise a pointless and ineffective employment scheme. It may also prove bad luck for the Commission, if this British government ‘forced labour’ programme turns out to have received EU funds.

Only last week, the European Economic and Social Committee revealed that four months after last June, when the Commission’s ‘Youth Guarantee’ initiative pompously got the green light from the 28 EU leaders Summit of 28 June, and not one jobless young person has been offered a job or a training or an apprenticeship. To be reminded, that this ‘Youth Guarantee’ scheme promises that within four months from graduation, all young unemployed under 25 (it’s 7.5 million of them) would be offered one or more of the above three options.

Digging a bit deeper in these EU employment schemes, it comes out that it’s never about real jobs or training. If a business needs a worker, it comes out and finds one. In the case of those EU funded programmes, the real thing is that usually the businesses which participate do not really need workers, but rather eye the subsidies which go with them. The key in this game is ‘traineeship’. In most cases it’s badly paid petty jobs in retailing shops. University graduates are offered almost invariably cleaning jobs, without the right to deny them. In short, it’s always training with the broom. Then came the British government with its brave new ideas and took the scheme a bit further giving life to the dreams of any employer; unpaid workers!







the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

How the North Korea-U.S. detente is a leveling of the playing field

Free and secure access needed in DR Congo conflict zone to tackle Ebola – WHO

Humanitarian aid: EU mobilises over €18 million for the Central African Republic in 2019

Our Digital Future

How revealing the cost of coal makes us all better off

The ‘yellow vests’ undermined Macron in France and the EU

Take care of your borders and then expand them

Pakistan: UN strongly condemns terrorist attack that leaves scores dead and wounded at election rally

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “There is a communication issue (about China) which markets don’t like” Christine Lagarde, Managing Director of IMF stresses from Davos

Negotiated two-State solution still ‘the only option’ for Palestine: Guterres

Air quality: Commission takes action to protect citizens from air pollution

Spotlight Initiative – EU and UN fight against domestic violence in the Pacific region

Parliament approves key directive regulating professional qualifications

UN postal agency ‘regrets’ US withdrawal

UN mission in DR Congo appeals for calm as violent protests continue

Eurozone: There is a remedy for regional convergence

Banks can fight financial crime. But we can’t do it alone

Service and Sacrifice: Malaysian peacekeepers in Lebanon proud to serve their homeland and the United Nations

This is what a planet-wide network of ocean sanctuaries could look like

South Sudan: UN calls for end to inter-communal clashes, attacks against aid workers

Anti-vaxxers are hurting vaccination campaigns. We need to fight back

Apple’s tax avoidance scheme remains as creative as their new iPhone

IMF: The global economy keeps growing except Eurozone

The digital skills gap is widening fast. Here’s how to bridge it

This AI outperformed 20 corporate lawyers at legal work

State of Health in the EU: shift to prevention and primary care is the most important trend across countries

From Kenya to China, here’s why countries should start working together on AI

Peacekeeping chief highlights challenges facing UN Police

We need a global convention to end workplace sexual harassment

Millions of young lives at risk due to humanitarian funding shortfall: UNICEF

Look no hands: self-driving vehicles’ public trust problem

Polluted lungs: health in the center of environment discussion

South Asia can become an innovation hub. Here’s how

Why climate change matters for future health professionals

Nuclear test ban treaty critical to global collective security – UN chief

Space science now a ‘fundamental pillar’ of 21st century human development: top UN space official

“Only through energy policy we can trigger competitiveness”. The Sting live from #EBS2015: Energy Union – When will it happen?

Central Africa: Security Council concerned by ‘grave security situation’, calls for better agency cooperation

Impressions of China

Mining the deep seabed will harm biodiversity. We need to talk about it

South Sudanese refugees need $2.7 billion, as safe return remains elusive

10 Downing street: Another desperate attempt to unite Britain on Brexit

Horse meat runs faster than authorities…

Eurozone hasn’t escaped the deflation danger

This lethal fungus is threatening to wipe out the world’s bananas

Accelerating a more sustainable industrial revolution with digital manufacturing

New identity cards deliver recognition and protection for Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh

Why the world is not as globalized as you think

EU takes again positive action on migration crisis while Turkey asks for dear favors in exchange for cooperation

Apparently the EU Digital Single Market passes necessarily from China’s Digital Silk Road

Food safety critical to development and ending poverty: FAO deputy chief

EU Council: The US airlines may freely pollute the European air

Serious concerns over Sahel, require ‘urgent action’: Senior UN Africa official

General Data Protection Regulation shows results, but work needs to continue

This AI can predict your personality just by looking at your eyes

EU to manage external borders against the will of member states; Greece to be the first target

Commission reports on progress in risk reduction in the Banking Union and calls for faster progress on Capital Markets Union ahead of EU Leaders’ meetings

Is deflation a real danger for Eurozone?

Could a Digital Silk Road solve the Belt and Road’s sustainability problem?

What the Fifth Industrial Revolution is and why it matters

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s