The European Internet is not neutral and neither is the Commissioner

Participation of Neelie Kroes, Vice-President of the EC, at the seminar "Women on top", organised in Amsterdam

Participation of Neelie Kroes, Vice-President of the EC, at the seminar “Women on top”, organised in Amsterdam (EC Audiovisual Library)

How many times were you out with friends and wanted to show them a new cool video on Youtube through your smart phone but buffering was unbelievably slow? What about the time you had a cheap pay-as-you-go subscription and you wanted to save money using Viber to call your friends for free instead of giving more money to Vodafone? How painful was it that the Viber connection was insanely slow even though you had a full 3G signal? Is this due to the fact that 3G and 4G technology is rather poor? Should we be then looking forward to the 5G that will hopefully allow us to experience excellent Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) communication and free video streaming? Think again!

It was only ten days ago that the European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) and the European Digital Rights (EDRi) sent a letter to the European Commission demanding immediate action on net neutrality for the European Internet. Monique Goyens, Director General of BEUC, and Andreas Krisch, President of EDRi, representing more than 80 consumer and citizens organizations in the EU, sign the letter that condemns the inability of the Commissioner Neelie Kroes to defend neutrality in the European Internet. In fact, in this letter those organizations condemn the standard current practice of Telecom Giants to block, filter and throttle deliberately free Internet services like VoIP as they see them as competition.

The Internet like it should be: Neutral

Net neutrality is a fundamental design principle of the Internet. As professor Tim Wu from Columbia Law School puts it: “The idea is that a maximally useful public information network aspires to treat all content, sites and platforms equally”. In short, all information a user sends and receives through the Internet should have the same value and not be discriminated by the Internet Service Provider (ISP), the mobile network (e.g. Vodafone) or the government. This is exactly why the Internet came to revolutionize the society of the 21st century. The democratization of the flow of information makes it possible today for modern people to participate more actively in society, education and communication. Having said that, it is well understood that the Internet is inherently neutral. However, often telecom operators or ISPs do not respect the principle of neutrality that the creator of the web, Tim Berners-Lee, embraces.

The EC to treat cancer with aspirins

The stance of the European Commission on this crucial issue for the modern European society has never really tackled the problem. Instead, the issue has been regarded as a problem of the market. Thus, competition and transparency are the two tools that the EC has used to defend a neutral Internet. However, net neutrality is threatened by deliberate traffic management of the information accessible to the user and not by price or speed difference in the services provided to her. Transparency of the services provided to the Internet user or the ability to switch ISP or telecom operator has little to do with Internet neutrality. The primordial principle of net neutrality defines that it is the citizen who decides and controls every bit of information he sends or receives and not the Internet provider.

It is stimulating here to follow some statements by Neelie Kroes, the 72 year old Commissioner for Digital Agenda, in order to understand clearly the distinctly problematic approach of the EC on this issue. The Commissioner has supported that the European citizens should be able to choose their Internet subscription and activity but this “does not preclude consumers from subscribing to more differentiated, limited Internet offers, possibly for a lower price.” Moreover, here are some other past statements of the Commissioner: “Make no mistake: I am in favor of an open Internet and maximum choice. That must be protected. But you don’t need me or the E.U. telling you what sort of Internet services you must pay for.”… “On net neutrality, consumers need effective choice on the type of internet subscription they sign up to. Choice should also drive innovation and investment by internet providers, with benefits for all.” In addition to those statements that prove the misguided “market oriented” approach of Mrs Kroes on the issue, in an interview at the French newspaper Liberation she did not omit even to mention her opinion that the Telecom sector should not be over regulated and that they can have the right to limit and control the flow of the information on the Web.

Everybody against the Commissioner

Mrs Kroes’ wrong policy making on the issue has been undoubtedly the reason why many organizations and media have strongly criticized her work. It is clear that she considers the issue to be of minor importance and that she aims to put out a fire with a glass of water, the glass of water being competition and transparency mechanisms. Moreover, she openly supports the telecom industry’s antidemocratic strategy to throttle or limit the Internet bandwidth as they want.

Apart from the European Consumer Organization and the European Digital Rights, other organizations like the French La Quadrature du Net are explicitly against the Commissioner’s stance. Last January the organization argued that Mrs Kroes is significantly influenced by the lobbyists of the Telecom industry. What is more, the European Parliament, the democratic representator of the European citizen in the EU, has several times expressed its worries over the policies followed on the issue by DG Connect. The EP voted last December for the second time after November 2011 in favour of net neutrality in Europe, drawing the attention of the Commission and the Council on the issue and calling them to urgently change their “wait and see” approach.

The need to have an EU regulation to secure Internet neutrality in the Old Continent is unanimously embraced today. However, Mrs Kroes’ laissez-faire stance is an impediment for a truly democratic European Web. It is shocking to find out that some EU members like the Netherlands and Slovenia that see the clear inability of the Commission to protect the European citizen on this matter, have voted country legislations on their own to protect net neutrality. France also is currently discussing its own legislation too on the issue. What else do you need to see the immediate necessity for an EU legislation on the issue?

The real lack of Neutrality

The crucial question now is: Has the Commissioner always been against net neutrality in Europe? I am afraid not. It seems that Mrs Kroes had very good intentions right before she took over at the DG Connect. We see that back in early 2010 she had supported that ISPs “shouldn’t be allowed to limit the access to service or content out of commercial motivation, but only in cases of security issues and spamming”. We see that it takes only a couple of years time for a Commissioner to cancel all her promises and be unfaithful to the European citizen. Is it the case that at the age of 72 it is possible for a Commissioner not to be able to perfectly control her sayings?

To be perfectly honest, that was the first thing that occurred to me but then I ran into the proposal submitted by the official lobbying mechanism of Telecoms and ISPs (ETNO) during the ITU’s World Conference on International Telecommunications (WCIT) last year in Dubai. I would like to close this story by keeping one single sentence from ETNO’s proposal : “Nothing shall preclude commercial agreements with differentiated quality of service delivery to develop.” It is as if it was coming from Mrs Kroes’ mouth, isn’t it?

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Barriers to healthcare: are they real?

Greferendum: the biggest political gaffe in western modern history to tear Europe apart? #Grexit #Graccident

Germany is the world’s most innovative economy

New seat projections for the next European Parliament

Latin America is a mass-transit powerhouse. But it needs fine-tuning

UN health experts warn ‘dramatic resurgence’ of measles continues to threaten the European region

EU approves disbursement of €500 million in Macro-Financial Assistance to Ukraine

How cultural understanding can help in the cultural shock

Reflections on the the biggest refugee crisis since World War II

Libya stands at a ‘critical juncture’, UN mission head tells Security Council

China by numbers: 10 facts to help you understand the superpower today

Northern Ireland: Parliament wants to secure post-Brexit regional funding

A new generation of women leaders is making waves in the Arab world

Ongoing insecurity in Darfur, despite ‘remarkable developments’ in Sudan: UN peacekeeping chief

EU Directive makes haircut on uncovered deposits a standard in bank bail-ins

Let us keep ‘their spirit of service alive’: Guterres leads tributes to UN workers who died in Ethiopia crash

UN chief welcomes possibility of resumed talks between US and North Korea

New VAT rules in the EU: how a digital sea could have become an ocean

Work Together to Build a New Type of International Relations and a Community with a Shared Future for Humanity

Killing of aid worker in Syria part of ‘disturbing trend’

MWC 2016 LIVE: 5G to embrace unlicensed bands and Wi-Fi

‘Bicycle Kingdom’ makes a comeback, as China seeks solutions to tackle air pollution crisis

G20 starts to tackle inequality

Minority governments ‘à la mode’ in Europe but can they last long?

UN food agency appeals for access to key storage facility amid fight for Hudaydah

Eating less beef and more beans would cut deaths by 5-7%

Afghanistan extends ceasefire with Taliban; UN urges both sides to work towards lasting peace

Further reforms needed for a stronger and more inclusive Argentine economy

UN chief praises impact of Palestine refugee agency as ‘our common success’, at key pledging conference

The ‘abuse of food relief in Yemen’ must end now

Onagawa’s spirit of togetherness: lessons from the 2011 tsunami

China dazzles the world with her Silk Road plan to connect, Asia, Europe and Africa

Drone regulation is necessary to democratize the sky for humanity

European Commission and four online marketplaces sign a Product Safety Pledge to remove dangerous products

Who will secure Lithuania?

Parliament pushes for cleaner cars on EU roads by 2030

Is Data Privacy really safe seen through Commissioner’s PRISM?

3 ways to rebuild trust in how we regulate technology

Refugee crisis update: EU fails to relocate immigrants from Greece and Italy

GSMA Mobile 360 – MENA Dubai on 26-27 November 2019, in association with The European Sting

Sri Lankan authorities must work ‘vigorously’ to ease simmering ethno-religious tensions, urges UN rights expert

Cybersecurity: agreement reached on better protection for citizens and companies

Which EU countries have to correct their economic policies?

Despite falling attacks, ISIL terrorists remain ‘global threat’: UN report

4 radical shifts required to achieve universal health coverage worldwide

Senior UN adviser sees ‘rare’ victory for humanitarian diplomacy as aid convoy reaches desert camp in Syria

‘Much more’ can be done to raise awareness about the plight of persons with albinism: UN chief

EU Commission closer to imposing anti-dumping duties on Chinese solar panel imports?

This project in India helps people and tigers co-exist peacefully

Microplastics have been found in Rocky Mountain rainwater

Constitutional Committee breakthrough offers ‘sign of hope’ for long-suffering Syrians

The decline of our oceans is accelerating, but it’s not too late to stop it

US migrant children policy reversal, still ‘fails’ thousands of detained youngsters: UN rights experts

South Sudan: UN condemns ‘brutal’ sexual assaults on roads to Bentiu

Menu for change: why we have to go towards a Common Food Policy

EU-US trade war? EU calls for logic while Trump’s administration is a loose cannon in a dangerous lose-lose situation for global prosperity

Eurozone: New data show recession and debt closer to explosion

A Sting Exclusive: “Paris and beyond: EU action and what COP21 should deliver”, Green MEP Keith Taylor discusses from Brussels 

‘Health is a right, not a privilege’ says WHO chief on World Health Day

‘A trusted voice’ for social justice: Guterres celebrates 100 years of the International Labour Organization

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s