Is the EU’s enlargement over-stretched?

Visit of Egemen Bağış, Turkish Minister for EU Affairs and Chief Negotiator for Turkey’s accession negotiations with the EU to the European Commission (on the left, seen from the back), László Andor, Member of the EC in charge of Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion (on the right) and Štefan Füle, Member of the EC in charge of Enlargement and European Neighbourhood Policy (in the centre), (EC Audio-visual Services, 10/04/2013).

Visit of Egemen Bağış, Turkish Minister for EU Affairs and Chief Negotiator for Turkey’s accession negotiations with the EU to the European Commission (on the left, seen from the back), László Andor, Member of the EC in charge of Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion (on the right) and Štefan Füle, Member of the EC in charge of Enlargement and European Neighbourhood Policy (in the centre), (EC Audio-visual Services, 10/04/2013).

The myth that the European Union is a seamless economic volume is belied not only after the latest developments, with Berlin and Paris working hard to institutionalise the fragmentation of EU’s financial markets. The dysfunction is also depicted by hard-core macroeconomic and labour market statistics. Again it’s not only the huge differences in the relative numbers of the unemployed in various EU member states, but more so the extreme differences prevailing in wages and salaries, which appear usuay when comparing first and third world economies. Differences of the order of the multiple of 12 are not only quantitative. They reveal also quality differences in the organisations of everyday life in different member states.

Qualitative differences

It’s like developing and developed countries trying to live under the same roof, follow the same economic policies and rules and sell their products in the same market. Those differences are less striking in the Eurozone of the 17 countries, where all of them belong more or less to the category of developed economies. Still the last four years of economic crisis and deep recession in many Eurozone member states have greatly increased the differences in key variables like, unemployment, hourly and yearly earnings even within the euro area. The unemployment explosion in Greece, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Ireland and elsewhere stand as an infallible witness of diverging futures within the EU.                         

                        

              Median gross hourly earnings, all employees (in euro)

earnings hourly median

It is however even more discouraging to watch and hear the Brussels dignitaries to talk all the time about interdependence and the need for common economic governance rules in the EU. It is as if the Bulgarian and the Danish working people have anything in common regarding their families’ lodging, nourishment, schooling, health care, environment and quality of life in general. Of course such comparisons are only possible if the Bulgarian or the Greek worker has an employment, God knows how he survives if he hasn’t.

Despite all that, Brussels insist that all those poor EU countries in order to remain in the Union or in Eurozone need to apply centrally planned restrictive fiscal policies and severe austerity measures, in reality depriving thus their real economy of any growth potential. Also not to forget that consumers and small businesses in poor countries like Romania and Portugal do not enjoy the same financial market conditions as their counterparts in Belgium and the Netherlands, concerning borrowing opportunities and interest rate costs. In many EU countries new consumer and business loans have disappeared.

At the same time all the EU 27 countries belong to the single internal market, where every restriction on movement of goods or market rules differences have been abolished. As if the Bulgarian and Greek firms could compete with the German industrial giants on a level play field market, which is today the EU. Experience has proved by now that the fact all the 27 countries operate under exactly the same market conditions, has invariably led to the impoverishment of the poor and enrichment of the rich countries. The ongoing crisis has only aggravated this tendency. On top of that the imposition of the same macro and micro economic policies seem to have seriously and irrevocably undermine the future of the developing countries within the EU.

Rich and poor workers

No, the Swedish and the Romanian workers do not have the same problems. To be convinced about that it suffices to read what follows here bellow. According to Eurostat, the EU statistical service, the average hourly labour costs and the structure of labour costs varied widely across the EU Member States in 2012. Hourly labour costs ( arithmetic mean) in the business economy (industry, constructions and services) ranged from €38.44 in Denmark, €37.70 in Belgium and €41.9 in Sweden, to €3.7 in Bulgaria. Eurostat notes that these figures cover not only wages and salaries (gross earnings) as well as social contributions paid by the employer but also vocational training costs, taxes and other expenditure paid by the employer less the subsidies received by the employer.

Understandably the same huge differences prevail in the annual wages. Always according to Eurostat, “Among EU Member States, in 2010 the mean (average) gross annual earnings of full-time employees in enterprises employing ten employees or more were highest in Denmark (€58,840), followed by Luxembourg (€49,316), the Netherlands (€45,215), Ireland (€45,207, in 2009), Belgium (€43,423) and Germany (€42, 400). On the other hand, the lowest mean gross annual earnings were registered in Romania (€5,891) and Bulgaria (€4,396)”.

Conflicting interests

Such differences in wages may hide directly conflicting interests, between Bulgarian and Greek workers on the one side and German and Swedish ones on the other. For one thing the German and the Swedish businesses for example, in order to be able to pay such high wages to their personnel, they obviously needed the freedom to sell their products completely unobstructed in Bulgaria and Greece, as it is the case today. From one point of view this is exactly “la raison d’être” of the European Union. The EU offers a level play field for the more competitive ones to exploit the others. In reality it seems that this huge single internal market is gradually becoming an insurmountable impediment for the growth of the less competitive.

Unfortunately the unemployed of the less productive countries don’t even have the possibility to emigrate and seek a better life in the rich countries of the EU, despite all the rhetoric about the freedom of movement of labour. Remember what happened to the Romanian Roma in France last year? In the USA probably exist similar differences in wages and salaries between the different states and regions, but people are completely free to travel and work where ever they want. In the EU it is out of question for Romanian, Bulgarian, Greek, Spanish and Portuguese unemployed to hang around in the parks and the squares of German and the Swedish cities and towns waiting to find work. They got to have a job within two months, otherwise they can be expelled to their country of origin.
All in all the European Union has rather over-stretched its enlargement abilities and this seems today to be in the heart of all its problems.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

EU will not deliver on promises without democratic accountability

Energy of African youth ‘propelling’ new development era as UN ties bear fruit

3 reasons we should all care about biodiversity

This app lets you order leftovers to help fight food waste

Statement by Commissioner for Crisis Management Janez Lenarčič on the explosion in Beirut, Lebanon

Multilateralism’s ‘proven record of service’ is focus of first-ever International Day

How banking with blockchain can stamp out corruption and increase financial inclusion

Technology and public healthcare: the basis to fight COVID-19

I have a rare disease. This is my hope for the future of medicine

IMF: Sorry Greece, Ireland, Portugal we were wrong!

COVID-19 not yet a pandemic, says UN health agency chief

5 lessons for the future of universities

EU-China: Commission and China hold first High-level Digital Dialogue

Indexation of family benefits, child tax credit and family tax credits: Commission takes Austria to Court for discrimination

Why Sweden’s cashless society is no longer a utopia

In Gaza, UN envoy urges Israel, Palestinian factions to step back from brink of a war that ‘everybody will lose’

China’s impact as a global investor; the Sting reports live from World Economic Forum 2015 in Davos

Dangers of poor quality health care revealed ‘in all countries’: WHO report

The Fourth Industrial Revolution is about to hit the construction industry. Here’s how it can thrive

5 lessons for the future success of virtual and augmented reality

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: Libya civil war, African displacement, global trade tensions, terrorists’ children ‘secretly detained’, and more

12 ways the tech sector can help save the climate in 12 years

World Food Programme accesses Yemeni frontline district for first time since conflict began

There is no recipe for a healthy mental state

How supporting climate action on a local level can transform the world

At last Britain considers a super-soft Brexit

Afghanistan: UN mission welcomes new polling dates following election delays

Why people with disabilities are your company’s untapped resource

Falling inflation urges ECB to introduce growth measures today

‘Summon the spirit of San Francisco’, says General Assembly President on UN Charter anniversary

Despite progress towards peace, Afghanistan facing ‘daunting challenges’ ahead of presidential vote

Can cybersecurity offer value for money?

Love Affair with Some(one)/(thing)

Commission to decide definitely on genetically modified Maize 1507 seed

Longer hours, more emails and shorter meetings – working from home in the time of COVID

ECB to people: Not responsible if you lose money on Bitcoin, your governments are

Italian banks: It’s Rome’s turn to confront Berlin’s aggressiveness

Young people are not a nameless, faceless mass. So why do we treat them as such?

Emerging technologies are reshaping financial services. Here’s how

A Brussels antithesis reveals where the EU is heading

4 ways family businesses can lead the pandemic recovery

EU to fail 2050 Green targets due to lack of European citizens’ engagement

Lorenzo Natali Media Prize 2019: winners of EU’s development journalism award unveiled

How to prevent a suicide?

DR Congo: Electoral process advancing despite threat of armed groups, UN envoy tells Security Council

Conditions deteriorating alarmingly in Yemen, warns senior UN official

Why do medical students need to go abroad to become a doctor in 2017?

OECD sees global growth slowing, as Europe weakens and risks persist

South Korea once recycled 2% of its food waste. Now it recycles 95%

A record number of College members travel to Addis Ababa for the 10th European Union-African Union Commission-to-Commission meeting

E-energy declaration: will energy digitalization be beneficial to the climate?

11 lessons the history of business can teach us about its future

Wednesday’s Daily Brief: Sudan, Libya, Yemen updates, solutions for e-waste, flood response in Iran, online security for children

Traditional knowledge at ‘core’ of indigenous heritage, and ‘must be protected’, says UN Forum

Stakeholder capitalism is urgently needed – and the COVID-19 crisis shows us why

Cheap sea transport with low cost seafarers

South Korea: A cherished partner for the EU

Milk, fruits and vegetables distributed to schoolchildren thanks to EU programme

Trump asked Merkel to pay NATO arrears and cut down exports ignoring the EU

Yemen conflict: ‘Fragile’ hopes rise, as violence decreases and life-saving humanitarian funding surges

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s