Predatory labour taxation not an issue for the Commission

Algirdas Šemeta, Member of the European Commission in charge of Taxation and Customs Union (EC Audiovisual Services).

Algirdas Šemeta, Member of the European Commission in charge of Taxation and Customs Union (EC Audiovisual Services).

It’s really unbelievable how easily some European Union Commissioners sidestep the hot issues and make speeches about trivial themes or focus on aspects of secondary interest. Take for example Algirdas Šemeta, the EU Commissioner responsible for Taxation and Customs Union, Audit and Anti-fraud. In a speech entitled, “Making progress on European Tax Policy: Towards more fairness and grater competitiveness”, delivered in Dublin on 11 January, he choose to put the emphasis on the wrong subjects and spoke about the “European Semester”, leaving aside the burning issues of the equitable distribution of tax burdens. He even forgot to say that all taxes in order to be equitable have to be progressive, with the richer paying larger percentages of their income.

He actually sidestepped the ostentatiously high tax burden on labour and talked about the positive effects of the “European Semester”. As everybody knows the European Semester is the new fiscal instrument of the European Union to control government budget deficits in the 27 member states and has nothing to do with the tax burden on citizens, let alone its equitable distribution.

Member states are completely free to tax incomes from labour and capital the way they like, or even choose whom to tax and whom to let go. Šemeta says nothing about all that or the  inequitable methods that some countries use while taxing their subjects. As a result the term “fairness” in the title of his speech serves just decorative and public relations purposes. It’s not at all analysed nor conclusions are drown about how fairly is the tax burden distributed in member states.

Nor the term “competitiveness” is dully analysed by Šemeta, because he says nothing about the hugely counterproductive character of heavy taxation on incomes from labour. As a matter of fact in most EU member states tax factors on income from labour are much higher than on profits. He said nothing about it. No tables of inequality were revealed.

In more than one EU country incomes from capital profits are taxed with a flat rate of 10%, while in those same countries labour incomes are taxed with progressive factor scales, reaching and actually exceeding 50%. On top of that working people pay their social security contributions, which vary between 10% and 20%. In reality, above a not very high level of income from labour, the tax burden on it plus social security payments claim even more that 70% of it.
This reality completely destroys any incentive for a salary earner to gain more from his work. It also kills his willingness to ask for a rise.

The good Commissioner instead of focusing and analysing with numbers the inequitable and unproductive distribution of the tax burden between labour income and capital profits, he chooses to state the obvious by citing some general purpose truths.

Stating the obvious

It goes without saying that the Commission cannot touch the issues quoted below because the EU has no say on member states tax policies. Probably that is why he states all those obvious truths. According to Šemeta: “there has been a general trend observed in the Member States towards fundamental tax reforms. However, there is still scope to shift the overall tax burden towards tax bases that are less detrimental to growth and job creation.
Such a shift requires a package approach which ensures equitable redistribution and is adapted to the circumstances of the individual Member State”. Then he continues,

“This is why the Commission recommends that:

*First, the tax burden on labour should be substantially reduced in countries where it is comparatively high and hampers job creation. To ensure that reforms are revenue neutral, taxes such as consumption tax, recurrent property tax and environmental taxes should be favoured.

*Second, revenue should preferably be raised by broadening tax bases rather than by increasing tax rates or creating new taxes;

*Third, tax compliance should be improved by reducing the shadow economy, combatting tax evasion and ensuring greater efficiency in the tax administration.

*Finally, the corporate tax bias towards debt-financing should be reduced and tax schemes which increase the debt bias of households should be reviewed to avoid financial risks”.

Mind you when the Commissioner dared utter a word about reducing the tax burden on labour, he rushed to add that this has to be “income neutral” and actually proposes a counterbalancing increase of taxation on consumption. All first year students of economics are taught that consumption taxes increase the inequality of the overall tax burden. In practice he proposed an even more inequitable way to make it up to the government’s coffers for losses after a possible cut of taxes on labour.

After reading all the 2,016 words of his speech he made no concrete reference to the destructive inequality between taxes on labour and profits. And this while speaking in a country like Ireland, where this difference has attracted wide criticism from many sources. Even if he didn’t want to annoy his hosts, he could at least say one word in support of the wage earners. And by God the Irish are hard-working people.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Taxes on polluting fuels are too low to encourage a shift to low-carbon alternatives

All for equality – 2020 is a pivotal year for Gender Equality

Humanitarian Aid: €64 million for most vulnerable in Southern Africa

EU unfolds strategy on the Egypt question

Can privatisation be the panacea for the lack of growth in Europe?

‘Hateful attacks’ pushing Sri Lanka backwards, UN advisers warn, urging an end to ‘discriminatory practices’ that feed intolerance

Brexit uncertainty keeps shaking the world’s financial markets

EU Facility for Refugees in Turkey: third annual report shows continued vital and tangible support for refugees and their host communities

Europe turns out more jobs this summer

Migrants, asylum seekers detained in Hungary ‘deliberately deprived of food’: UN human rights office

UN announces roadmap to Climate Summit in 2019, a ‘critical year’ for climate action

Donald Tusk presents EU summit conclusions for last time

Macron plans for Europe, Brexit and banks but vague on France

A Sting Exclusive: Disaster risk resilience, key to protecting vulnerable communities

MEPs want to ensure sufficient funding for Connecting Europe’s future

Why exchange programs are essential for the medical students of the 21st century

These social entrepreneurs are lighting up Africa

Let Nagasaki remain ‘the last city’ to suffer nuclear devastation says museum director, as UN chief arrives

3 ways to rebuild trust in how we regulate technology

Contribution of healthcare professionals towards the 2030 Global Health Agenda

Rude work emails are bad for your health and on the rise – here’s what you need to know

Youth leaders share positive visions of the future, as Guterres launches UN75 in New York

Stateless Rohingya refugee children living in ‘untenable situation’, UNICEF chief

European Youth cries out: Sustainable Development Goals ambitious, but lack focus on youth

Here’s how business needs to change for a new decade

How sustainable infrastructure can help us fight climate change

The Commission neglects the services sector and favours industry

EU to gain the most from the agreement with Iran

New rules for temporary border controls within the Schengen area

Landmark EU Parliament – ECB agreement on bank supervision

Reducing disaster risk is a good investment, and ‘the right thing to do’, says Guterres

The world’s most vulnerable must be protected: WHO briefing

COVID-19 shows we need a broader definition of safe mobility

Tackle ‘unacceptable inequalities’ in cancer care, saving up to seven million lives, WHO urges

South Sudan: UN official welcomes release of women and children abducted by armed group

Any doubt?

ECB: A revolutionary idea to revitalize the European economy with cheap loans to SMEs

The COVID-19 Wave III and the lessons we should have learned

These charts show where the world’s refugees came from in 2017 – and where they’re heading

Disintegrating Tories will void May’s pledge for Brexit deal in seven weeks

UN ‘determined to lead by example’ on disability rights: Guterres

COP21 Breaking News: China has promised to cut emissions from its coal power plants by 60% by 2020

4 charts that show how technology is enabling the energy transition

How our Europe will regain its strength: op-ed by Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission

Australian homes are turning to solar power in record numbers

UN rights chief slams ‘unconscionable’ US border policy of separating migrant children from parents

‘Essential step’ towards universal health care made at pivotal UN conference

Libyan national conference postponed, nearly 500,000 children at ‘direct risk’ from fighting around Tripoli

Did Draghi ask the Germans to accept a drastic change of austerity policies?

Migrant children at US border have right to protection and ‘be with their families’: UNICEF chief

The Junior Enterprise concept, one of the best ways to develop practical skills

Work is on the brink of a revolution – we need office buildings to match

“A Junior Enterprise is run only by students.. there are no professors or managers that can help you solve your problems”

5 steps businesses can take to protect air quality after COVID-19

Here’s how we can make innovation more inclusive

Trump blocks US warmongers from bombing Iran

Why trust and technology go hand-in-hand

10 tonnes of trash was taken off Everest – and repurposed

What the mighty mangrove tells us about our broken relationship with nature

Climate Change Revolution: by-laws for the world

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s