What do scientists think about different climate policy? And why should we care?

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Ivan Savin, Professor of Quantitative Analytics, ESCP Business School (Madrid campus) , Research Fellow, Institute of Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA – UAB)


  • The debate around the most appropriate climate-policy instruments to reduce emissions is buoyant.
  • Studies have discerned public opinion about various climate policy instruments but there is little systematic evidence on what scientists across disciplines see as most adequate and viable.
  • Ivan Savin and co-authors conducted a global expert survey, demonstrating consensus on and controversy on different instruments and a need for more communication about climate policy.

Understanding scientists’ opinions about climate policy is important for at least two reasons.

Firstly, scientists advise policymakers through expert commissions such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Secondly, scientists from different fields partly shape public opinion about climate policy. In fact, a recent study shows that citizens in the United States and Germany expect scientists to be outspoken on climate policies and communicate their findings to policymakers and journalists.

To advance the debate on climate policy, Stefan Drews and Jeroen van der Bergh and I conducted a global survey of almost 800 scientists who recently published on climate policy in peer-reviewed journals. The aim was to elicit their views on climate policy criteria and instruments.

Researchers in our sample work in more than 70 developed and developing countries and a broad set of disciplines, including formal, social and natural sciences. We asked a large set of questions related to six types of climate policy instruments: direct regulation, e.g. quotas, standards, carbon taxation, cap-and-trade, e.g. the European Union’s emissions trading system, adoption subsidies; innovation support – such as research and development subsidies and information provision (ranging from education to eco-labels).

This survey produced a lot of results that have been recently published in Ecological Economics and Environmental Research Letters. Here, I want to highlight a few that I find most remarkable.

Consensus on some instruments, controversy on others

On average, all six instruments were rated by researchers as important (“value 3” on our Likert scale); however, the degree of consensus among disciplines on how important these instruments are in a policy mix varied widely, as per the figure below. In particular, direct regulation enjoys the greatest consensus, with only environmental and other economists being relatively more sceptical. These researchers predictably rated cap-and-trade and carbon tax high but researchers from other fields, notably political science and ecological economics, mostly disagreed.

To better elicit similarities and differences among disciplines on how important they consider the instruments, we clustered the 15 fields in our sample into five distinct groups. The result is demonstrated in the figure below, with the distance on the horizontal axis indicating the difference between fields in their views. As one can see, ecological economists and mathematicians or computer scientists are the most dissimilar groups from other discipline clusters. The remaining three groups are sociologists and psychologists; environmental and other economists plus law researchers; and a heterogeneous group consisting of various social and natural scientists.

Zooming in on the role of carbon pricing

Since carbon pricing instruments – carbon tax and cap-and-trade – have received contradictory appraisals on their capability to reduce carbon emissions in the recent literature, we examined researchers’ agreement with 10 statements about their functioning. The responses are displayed below. Among statements with the largest agreement are that consumers are more influenced by prices than environmental concerns – 80%, while there is more of a mixed response to whether carbon pricing can achieve zero carbon emissions.

We then statistically linked the importance of instruments in a climate policy mix with answers to these 10 statements. We found that two statements are positively and significantly associated with giving importance to both types of carbon pricing:

  • Rebound: agreement with carbon pricing effectively limiting energy/carbon rebound.
  • Policy harmonization: the belief in the potential of global upscaling of carbon pricing.

According to our results, one way to increase support for carbon pricing is to communicate the policy instrument’s advantages effectively.

Perceived strengths, weaknesses and knowledge gaps

Finally, we asked our expert scientists to indicate what they felt were the main strengths, weaknesses and knowledge gaps of carbon pricing compared with other policy instruments. Among the main strengths, the interviewed researchers named a clear price signal to both the producer and consumer, the financial sources the instrument provides to subsidize transformations towards zero-carbon economies and its flexibility in implementation. The perceived strengths of carbon pricing summarized above align with what economists have advocated for decades.

What appears less trivial is the perceived weaknesses of the instrument. In particular, researchers find it can increase inequalities by placing an unfair burden on the lower-income population, resulting in low political and public feasibility. Furthermore, the instrument appears to researchers as being vulnerable to manipulation and fraud.

As for perceived knowledge gaps, researchers cited policy synergy with other instruments, global implementation of carbon pricing and better empirically grounded models.

What’s striking is that some of the assessed perceptions and opinions are not in line with insights from the theoretical and empirical literature on carbon pricing. In a nutshell, there must be more communication about climate policy, particularly carbon pricing, between academic experts from distinct disciplines to ascertain the better climate policy instruments at play.


Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Interesting reads

© UNOCHA/Viktoriia Andriievska A man enters a bombed building in Kyiv, Ukraine.

Ukraine: Civilian casualties in 2026 already far exceed previous years’ tolls

This article is published in association with United Nations. This year has seen dramatically higher civilian casualties in Ukraine than any other year since the full-scale invasion of the eastern European country by Russia in February 2022, the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) said on Tuesday. In October 2026, the number of […]
© UN Climate Change/Kubilay Citfci UN Climate Conference in Antalya, Türkiye.

COP31 enters decisive week as climate talks face political test and AI initiatives gather pace

This article is published in association with United Nations. New international initiatives on artificial intelligence and green industrialization showcased technology’s growing role in climate action, even as negotiators remained deadlocked on finance, fossil fuels and adaptation ahead of the final stretch of the UN talks. Today at COP31 As COP31 entered its second and final […]
UN Social Media/ María Fernández del Moral COP31 press conference to launch the Priorities for Action on AI for Climate Information Integrity.

COP31: New initiative targets AI and reliable climate change information

This article is published in association with United Nations. New guidance has been issued to ensure that people everywhere can obtain credible climate change information from artificial intelligence (AI) and understand how the technology impacts the environment. The Priorities for Action on AI and Climate Information Integrity were launched at the COP31 climate conference in […]
UN News A partially collapsed residential building in the city of Deir al-Balah, Gaza, after residents were evacuated amid heavy rain and strong winds.

Six killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital

This article is published in association with United Nations. An Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital on Wednesday night killed six people, injured 27 others and caused extensive damage. Ramiz Alakbarov, the UN Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process ad interim, on Thursday said he was deeply alarmed by the attack.” The strike […]
© UN News/Laura Quinones Sunrise over COP31 as participants arrived as early as 5am to avoid traffic closures.

‘Make or bake time’: Guterres urges climate justice pact as leaders gather at COP31

This article is published in association with United Nations. UN chief António Guterres called for a new global climate justice agreement at COP31 on Wednesday, urging governments to tax fossil fuel companies to help countries bearing the brunt of a crisis they did little to cause. His appeal came as world leaders gathered in Antalya […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Gaza winter aid: ‘No more delay’, Fletcher tells governments stalling on support

© UNRWA Children play outside tents in Gaza. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s Emergency Relief Coordinator, Tom Fletcher, expressed deep concern about the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza, as UN member states and partners have been repeatedly delaying sending their support to the Strip. “Foreign Ministers and partners have […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.l student with a strong interest in research and global health.

COP31: Energy transition takes centre stage as countries map path beyond fossil fuels

This article is published in association with United Nations. The global energy transition took centre stage on the second day of COP31, as countries explored how to move away from fossil fuels, accelerate clean energy and overcome financial and infrastructure barriers standing in the way. Today at COP31 Energy and Transport Day at COP31 got […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Children among the dead as heavy rains flood tents and shelters in Gaza

This article is published in association with United Nations. An infant reportedly drowned and five Gazans were killed – including three children – when a sand dune collapsed on their tents as the first heavy rains swept across the enclave at the weekend, according to the UN aid coordination office (OCHA). Thousands of families lost […]
© EducAid “Before [this], the difference was huge – I used to carry Anas, and he had to crawl on his hands,” said Anas’s mother.

‘For the first time I have my own chair’: Gaza siblings find new freedom

This article is published in association with United Nations. In Gaza, 10-year-old Anas is one of three siblings born without legs and with only two fingers on each of their hands. They struggle to move around and perform daily activities like eating and writing independently. With funding from the UN’s aid coordination office (OCHA), and […]
© UNICEF A child looks out from a makeshift shelter in Rafah, in the south of the Gaza Strip.

Gunfire damages tents at Rafah displacement site in Gaza, as aid teams prepare for winter storms

This article is published in association with United Nations. Gunfire hit and damaged multiple tents at a displacement site in Gaza’s northern Rafah region on Tuesday, reportedly causing injuries and forcing a humanitarian partner to leave the area, the UN aid coordination office (OCHA) has said. The NGO had been working on flood control ahead […]
© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon..

UN peacekeeping chief warns of ‘security vacuum’ as Blue Helmets leave Lebanon and Western Sahara

© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon.. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s peacekeeping chief warned on Wednesday that the withdrawal of “Blue Helmets” from Lebanon and Western Sahara risks leaving a dangerous security vacuum, while the Security Council remains divided over what, if anything, should […]
© IOM/Haithm Abdulbaqi Young people in Yemen play football on a sandy pitch.

15 years of ‘almost no progress’ in getting young people moving: WHO

This article is published in association with United Nations. One in four adolescents worldwide reported not getting at least 60 minutes of physical activity on any day in the previous week, according to new global estimates released by the World Health Organization (WHO) on Wednesday. That amounts to some 240 million young people aged 11 […]
© UNICEF/Sultan Mahmu A mother and daughter wade through floodwaters in Feni, southeastern Bangladesh.

COP31 explained: What’s at stake at this year’s UN climate summit?

This article is published in association with United Nations. The world has more tools than ever to tackle climate change, yet millions remain unable to benefit from them. As clean energy technologies advance faster than ever, the challenge facing countries at COP31 is no longer just finding solutions – but making sure everyone can afford […]
© UNICEF/Christina Pashkina A school in Chuhuiv, Ukraine, lies in ruins after being hit by a missile.

Air raid alerts and attacks on schools: the devastating face of education in Ukraine

This article is published in association with United Nations. Ukraine has sustained almost 2,000 attacks on education since the full-scale Russian invasion in 2022, with some 270 this year alone, the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) said on Tuesday, a day after a strike at a school being used to distribute aid. Tweet URL Since the […]
© UNICEF/Oleksii Filippov People walk past a war-damaged building in Ukraine.

Ukraine: WFP provides hot meals to Oleshky evacuees as UN pushes to restore power before winter

This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN World Food Programme (WFP) is providing emergency food assistance to more than 400 people who were able to leave the Russian-occupied city of Oleshky, in Ukraine’s Kherson region, during a brief local ceasefire. Many arrived in worrying condition at medical facilities in Kyiv on […]

COP17: Nations chart ‘Yerevan Pathway’ to speed up action for nature

This article is published in association with United Nations. At the halfway mark to 2030, countries meeting in Armenia have agreed a roadmap to accelerate action for nature, after a global review found the world off track to meet its biodiversity targets. Agreement was formalised through the Yerevan Pathway as the UN Biodiversity Conference (COP17) […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.

AI is changing the way we think. The question is whether we’ll notice in time

This article is published in association with United Nations. Artificial intelligence promises to make life easier. With a few keystrokes, it can write emails, summarize reports, generate ideas and answer complex questions in seconds. For many people, it feels like a technological leap on par with the arrival of the internet itself. But according to […]
© NYCDDC Flood defences are built on the east side of Manhattan Island by the East River in New York City.

Higher Ground: How New York is raising a park to hold back the sea

This article is published in association with United Nations. On 29 October 2012, Hurricane Sandy slammed into New York City, unleashing a devastating storm surge that flooded homes, subways and tunnels, knocked out power and sparked deadly fires. In just 48 hours, 44 people were killed, nearly two million New Yorkers lost power, and 6,500 […]
This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.

World News in Brief: ‘No safe place in Ukraine’, IAEA calls for Iran nuclear inspections, Kenya hosts thousands of Ethiopians fleeing clashes

This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) on Tuesday urged continued international support for Ukraine’s population as Russian airstrikes intensify and humanitarian needs grow in advance of another bitterly cold winter. The “relentless” attacks are targeting critical energy infrastructure, leaving millions without heat and electricity, and limited access to […]

Why don't you drop your comment here?

Go back up

Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

The European Sting – Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology – europeansting.com