Here’s how natural disasters impact middle-class incomes

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Regina Pleninger, Economist, World Bank


  • Direct damages are only a part of the economic burden that natural disasters impose, new US research has found.
  • Secondary effects on economic development in the post-disaster period can be more severe, as reconstruction takes valuable resources from other sectors.
  • Using CPS income data to examine the effects of natural disasters across the income distribution, the authors found that middle-class incomes suffer significantly.
  • Adaptation strategies that support financial hardship can help circumvent some of the effects, they say.

Natural disasters have short- and long-term effects on the economy as well as people’s lives. For example, weather shocks and the resulting macroeconomic fluctuations cost the economy 0.3% of permanent consumption in New Zealand (Gallic and Vermandel 2020). Direct damages are only a part of the economic burden that natural disasters impose (Noy 2009, 2012). Secondary effects on economic development in the post-disaster period are potentially more severe as reconstruction takes valuable resources from other sectors: a severe natural disaster reduces per capita incomes by 7.4% two decades later, thereby undoing 3.7 years of average development (Hsiang and Jina 2014). This has major implications for countries that are regularly exposed to severe natural disasters. This column documents the results of a study on the effects of natural disasters on income distribution in US counties (Pleninger 2022).

Why study the US?

The US experiences natural disasters frequently, with a variety of types and with a geographic variation. Furthermore, the Federal Emergency Management Agency provides data on disaster declarations at regional, state and county levels that score over geological measures. Declarations rule out inconsequential natural hazards occurring in remote areas and, thus, measure actual impacts.

The coasts and the Midwest have the highest numbers of disaster declarations (Figure 1, top panel). On the east and gulf coasts, coastal storms, such as hurricanes, are the most common declared disasters (Figure 2, bottom panel). The most frequent disaster in the Midwest is heavy storms. Droughts and wildfires are mainly reported in the West. Disasters are usually declared in multiple counties, and one county tends to have multiple disaster declarations per year and for different types.

Different types of income

In order to estimate the effect of natural disasters on income distribution, I use the Current Population Survey (CPS) from 1996¬ to 2017, which provides different income definitions. Total income consists of labour and capital income, whereas labour income can be further divided into earnings and transfer income.

Each type of income can be defined at the individual or the household level. Due to the wider availability, the literature usually relies on household-based measures of income inequality that neglect intra-household inequality between two spouses. In contrast, individual-based measures are likely to overestimate overall inequality, as household members tend to share at least part of their income within their family. Using both measures provide upper and lower bounds of the true effects.

Using CPS income data, I partition all incomes at the county level into three groups, namely bottom, middle and top, to estimate the effects on the entire income distribution. The bottom-income group encompasses the bottom 40% of income earners. In contrast, the top-income group includes individuals or households with the highest 10% incomes.

Middle-class incomes are affected

The results suggest significant negative effects of natural disasters on middle-class incomes. The effect is particularly strong for individual-based measures. Income smoothing within the household seems to absorb some of the effects. Observing the effects over time, Figure 2 suggests that the impact is short-term in nature. It is significantly negative in the year of the disaster but becomes insignificant years after. In addition, the effect is driven by earnings (top-right graph) and, in particular, by wages (bottom graph). There is no significant effect of natural disasters on the incomes of the bottom 40% or top 10%. However, there is a negative effect on the capital income of the top 10%. Since capital income constitutes only a small portion of total income, even for the top income group, the effects do not appear in the total income results.

Does migration matter?

Counties hit by severe disasters experienced larger out-migration, lower home prices and higher poverty rates (Boustan et al. 2020). Several studies report that natural disasters and climate change have implications for population size, families’ location choices, and business sector development (Hornbeck 2012; Coffman and Noy 2012; Kahn 2010). The CPS data shows that 4% of the sample population moved within the analysed time frame of this study. However, less than 1% report natural disasters as the primary reason for their move. Most movers report job, family, or housing as their primary reason. Since large and selective migration flows can have an effect on income distribution, there is reason to believe that migration rather than natural disasters are affecting incomes. Therefore, a sample that places movers back to their original locations is constructed to calculate income inequality measures based on these reassigned incomes. These synthetic measures represent income inequality in the absence of migration. After controlling for migration, the main results still hold, suggesting that the effects of natural disasters on incomes are not biased by migration.

Adaptation helps, but intensification does not

One important adaptation tool is unemployment insurance, which supports individuals in times of financial hardship. Natural disasters have no contemporaneous effect on unemployment benefits. However, benefits increase significantly one year after a disaster. This time lag in benefit payments is one explanation for the contemporaneous negative effect of natural disasters on earnings. Hence, adaptation is important to circumvent some of the effects. This can also be observed when studying the effects of disasters for counties that experienced zero to four disasters in the last five years. Figure 3 shows the effects of natural disasters on total income (top-left graph), middle-class earnings (top-right graph) and top 10% earnings (bottom graph) for a given number of recent disasters (x-axis). The effect is strongly negative in counties that experienced no disaster in the last five years. But there are no statistically significant effects on incomes in counties with one or two previous disasters. Lastly, the effect on middle-class earnings (top-right graph) becomes increasingly negative as the number of disasters accumulates.

Policy implications

The increase in the frequency and severity poses a challenge for local, state, and federal governments to deal with the aftermath of disasters. First, income inequality levels are already high in the US compared to other OECD countries: the Gini coefficient for the US is above 40, compared with the UK, Canada, and Germany, where it is in the lower 30s (World Development Indicators 2022). 1 Due to the initially higher inequality levels, additional stress on the income distribution is likely to trigger social discontent. Second, the strong effect on middle-class incomes suggests that this income group is not adequately protected by insurance and other benefits to cushion the effects. Lastly, counties that have no experience with natural disasters ex-ante tend to be more affected, suggesting that adaptation policies work and, thus, should be more widely implemented. For instance, increasing the speed of unemployment benefits payments might cushion some of the financial strains experienced in the year of the disaster.

References

Boustan, L P, M E Kahn, P W Rhode and M L Yanguas (2020), “The effect of natural disasters on economic activity in US counties: A century of data”, Journal of Urban Economics 118: 103257.

Coffman, M and I Noy (2012), “Hurricane Iniki: measuring the long-term economic impact of a natural disaster using synthetic control”, Environment and Development Economics 17(2): 187-205.

Gallic, E and G Vermandel (2020), “Weather shocks”, European Economic Review 124: 103409.

Hornbeck, R (2012), “The enduring impact of the American Dust Bowl: Short-and long-run adjustments to environmental catastrophe”, American Economic Review 102(4): 1477-1507.

Hsiang, S M and A S Jina (2014), “The Causal Effect of Environmental Catastrophe on Long-Run Economic Growth: Evidence from 6,700 Cyclones”, NBER Working Paper No. 20452.

Kahn, M (2010), “Climatopolis: How will climate change impact urbanites and their cities?”, VoxEU.org, 11 September.

Noy, I (2012), “The enduring economic aftermath of natural catastrophes”, VoxEU.org, 5 September.

Noy, I (2009), “The macroeconomic consequences of disasters”, Journal of Development Economics 88(2): 221-231.

Pleninger, R (2022), “Impact of Natural Disasters on the Income Distribution”, World Development 157: 105936.


Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Interesting reads

UN News A partially collapsed residential building in the city of Deir al-Balah, Gaza, after residents were evacuated amid heavy rain and strong winds.

Six killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital

This article is published in association with United Nations. An Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital on Wednesday night killed six people, injured 27 others and caused extensive damage. Ramiz Alakbarov, the UN Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process ad interim, on Thursday said he was deeply alarmed by the attack.” The strike […]
© UN News/Laura Quinones Sunrise over COP31 as participants arrived as early as 5am to avoid traffic closures.

‘Make or bake time’: Guterres urges climate justice pact as leaders gather at COP31

This article is published in association with United Nations. UN chief António Guterres called for a new global climate justice agreement at COP31 on Wednesday, urging governments to tax fossil fuel companies to help countries bearing the brunt of a crisis they did little to cause. His appeal came as world leaders gathered in Antalya […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Gaza winter aid: ‘No more delay’, Fletcher tells governments stalling on support

© UNRWA Children play outside tents in Gaza. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s Emergency Relief Coordinator, Tom Fletcher, expressed deep concern about the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza, as UN member states and partners have been repeatedly delaying sending their support to the Strip. “Foreign Ministers and partners have […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.l student with a strong interest in research and global health.

COP31: Energy transition takes centre stage as countries map path beyond fossil fuels

This article is published in association with United Nations. The global energy transition took centre stage on the second day of COP31, as countries explored how to move away from fossil fuels, accelerate clean energy and overcome financial and infrastructure barriers standing in the way. Today at COP31 Energy and Transport Day at COP31 got […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Children among the dead as heavy rains flood tents and shelters in Gaza

This article is published in association with United Nations. An infant reportedly drowned and five Gazans were killed – including three children – when a sand dune collapsed on their tents as the first heavy rains swept across the enclave at the weekend, according to the UN aid coordination office (OCHA). Thousands of families lost […]
© EducAid “Before [this], the difference was huge – I used to carry Anas, and he had to crawl on his hands,” said Anas’s mother.

‘For the first time I have my own chair’: Gaza siblings find new freedom

This article is published in association with United Nations. In Gaza, 10-year-old Anas is one of three siblings born without legs and with only two fingers on each of their hands. They struggle to move around and perform daily activities like eating and writing independently. With funding from the UN’s aid coordination office (OCHA), and […]
© UNICEF A child looks out from a makeshift shelter in Rafah, in the south of the Gaza Strip.

Gunfire damages tents at Rafah displacement site in Gaza, as aid teams prepare for winter storms

This article is published in association with United Nations. Gunfire hit and damaged multiple tents at a displacement site in Gaza’s northern Rafah region on Tuesday, reportedly causing injuries and forcing a humanitarian partner to leave the area, the UN aid coordination office (OCHA) has said. The NGO had been working on flood control ahead […]
© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon..

UN peacekeeping chief warns of ‘security vacuum’ as Blue Helmets leave Lebanon and Western Sahara

© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon.. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s peacekeeping chief warned on Wednesday that the withdrawal of “Blue Helmets” from Lebanon and Western Sahara risks leaving a dangerous security vacuum, while the Security Council remains divided over what, if anything, should […]
© IOM/Haithm Abdulbaqi Young people in Yemen play football on a sandy pitch.

15 years of ‘almost no progress’ in getting young people moving: WHO

This article is published in association with United Nations. One in four adolescents worldwide reported not getting at least 60 minutes of physical activity on any day in the previous week, according to new global estimates released by the World Health Organization (WHO) on Wednesday. That amounts to some 240 million young people aged 11 […]
© UNICEF/Sultan Mahmu A mother and daughter wade through floodwaters in Feni, southeastern Bangladesh.

COP31 explained: What’s at stake at this year’s UN climate summit?

This article is published in association with United Nations. The world has more tools than ever to tackle climate change, yet millions remain unable to benefit from them. As clean energy technologies advance faster than ever, the challenge facing countries at COP31 is no longer just finding solutions – but making sure everyone can afford […]
© UNICEF/Christina Pashkina A school in Chuhuiv, Ukraine, lies in ruins after being hit by a missile.

Air raid alerts and attacks on schools: the devastating face of education in Ukraine

This article is published in association with United Nations. Ukraine has sustained almost 2,000 attacks on education since the full-scale Russian invasion in 2022, with some 270 this year alone, the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) said on Tuesday, a day after a strike at a school being used to distribute aid. Tweet URL Since the […]
© UNICEF/Oleksii Filippov People walk past a war-damaged building in Ukraine.

Ukraine: WFP provides hot meals to Oleshky evacuees as UN pushes to restore power before winter

This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN World Food Programme (WFP) is providing emergency food assistance to more than 400 people who were able to leave the Russian-occupied city of Oleshky, in Ukraine’s Kherson region, during a brief local ceasefire. Many arrived in worrying condition at medical facilities in Kyiv on […]

COP17: Nations chart ‘Yerevan Pathway’ to speed up action for nature

This article is published in association with United Nations. At the halfway mark to 2030, countries meeting in Armenia have agreed a roadmap to accelerate action for nature, after a global review found the world off track to meet its biodiversity targets. Agreement was formalised through the Yerevan Pathway as the UN Biodiversity Conference (COP17) […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.

AI is changing the way we think. The question is whether we’ll notice in time

This article is published in association with United Nations. Artificial intelligence promises to make life easier. With a few keystrokes, it can write emails, summarize reports, generate ideas and answer complex questions in seconds. For many people, it feels like a technological leap on par with the arrival of the internet itself. But according to […]
© NYCDDC Flood defences are built on the east side of Manhattan Island by the East River in New York City.

Higher Ground: How New York is raising a park to hold back the sea

This article is published in association with United Nations. On 29 October 2012, Hurricane Sandy slammed into New York City, unleashing a devastating storm surge that flooded homes, subways and tunnels, knocked out power and sparked deadly fires. In just 48 hours, 44 people were killed, nearly two million New Yorkers lost power, and 6,500 […]
This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.

World News in Brief: ‘No safe place in Ukraine’, IAEA calls for Iran nuclear inspections, Kenya hosts thousands of Ethiopians fleeing clashes

This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) on Tuesday urged continued international support for Ukraine’s population as Russian airstrikes intensify and humanitarian needs grow in advance of another bitterly cold winter. The “relentless” attacks are targeting critical energy infrastructure, leaving millions without heat and electricity, and limited access to […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.

Four in five domestic workers lack formal job protections, UN finds

This article is published in association with United Nations. An estimated 66.5 million domestic workers – representing more than four out of five domestic workers worldwide – were informally employed in 2025, a new report by the UN’s labour organisation has found. This makes them more than twice as likely as other employees to lack […]
© WFP/Mohamed Hinnawi An elderly woman in Al Saraya, Gaza, looks after young children after losing three sons, her husband, and home during the war.

Gaza: Families brace for fourth winter in tents as aid operations remain stymied

This article is published in association with United Nations. Families in Gaza are bracing for a fourth winter in tents and makeshift shelters as UN aid operations face mounting obstacles, with transport suspended on Tuesday due to Israel’s closure of the key Kerem Shalom crossing for election day. The UN project services agency in the […]

West Bank: Hebron crackdown displaces thousands, Türk warns of ethnic cleansing

This article is published in association with United Nations. Israel’s “aggressive operation” in the West Bank city of Hebron raises serious concerns of ethnic cleansing, UN human rights chief Volker Türk warned on Monday, as the number of Palestinians forced from their homes passed 3,000 on the eve of Israeli elections. The UN aid coordination […]

Why don't you drop your comment here?

Go back up

Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

The European Sting – Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology – europeansting.com