What can the military teach us about keeping the lights on?

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Miranda A. Ballentine, CEO, Renewable Energy Buyers Alliance

  • Our planet’s increasingly severe weather is causing power systems to fail across the world.
  • We need to change the way we think about ‘grey rhinos’ – high impact, low-frequency events, like the storm that hit Texas in February
  • Infrastructure operators and planners can learn from the military’s approach. Here’s a guide.

Whether it’s Florida during hurricane season, California during fire season, or Texas during, erm… ice season, one thing is certain: Mother Nature’s threats are growing in impact. They’re no longer black swan events, either.

Electricity infrastructure planners around the globe can learn from the US military, whose mission requires planning for low-frequency, high-impact threats, and which has increasingly focused on energy resilience as foundational to their global peacekeeping and war-fighting missions.

After the catastrophic power outages in Texas in February, politicized finger-pointing started immediately. Some blamed frozen wind turbines, others faulted the state’s over-reliance on natural gas (which was stymied by frozen well-heads and pipelines), and yet others said the islanded transmission system and price-focused market structure used by the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), the independent operator of Texas’ grid, were most culpable.

Let’s face it, though: failure to plan for extreme weather affects every type of power generation and any type of market structure.

This is really a story about a widespread failure to take climate change-induced weather scenarios into account when planning for, recovering from, and rebuilding after extreme weather events.

In the US and around the world, every type of power system within every regulatory structure has faced catastrophic power failures due to increasingly severe weather.

There have been many assessments of what, precisely, froze or failed in Texas, and since the full postmortem will take months to untangle, I’ll spare you another recap. Suffice it to say that, end-to-end, there was a good-old-fashioned lack of infrastructure weatherization for the polar vortex freeze that pushed south into Texas in February, despite the strong recommendations of US electricity regulators following the 1989 and 2011 polar freezes.

So, what are we to do? In many ways, it’s simple. But it’s not at all easy. Nor is it cheap.

All of us – whether we are energy customers who depend on a reliable and resilient grid, or energy suppliers in charge of providing such – must change the way we think about (and what we’re willing to pay for) high-impact, low-frequency attacks on our power grid.

In the military, mission assurance requires energy assurance, which is why planners often use a four-step approach to building robust and resilient energy systems. It’s called D2R2: Deter. Defend. Recover. Rebuild.

In the private sector, reliable energy is equally important, and the same approach can be used by infrastructure planners. This is P2R2. Prevent. Plan. Recover. Rebuild. Here’s how it works:

1. Prevention. While we may have some ability to prevent human attacks on our power system (like cyber incursions or theft of substation components), preventing Mother Nature’s increasingly volatile weather attacks may be impossible. It bears repeating that, according to the US’ most recent Federal Government Climate Threat Assessment, released by the Trump Administration in 2019: “More frequent and intense extreme weather and climate-related events … are expected to continue to damage infrastructure, ecosystems, and social systems that provide essential benefits to communities.”

We need to reduce greenhouse gas pollution by accelerating the transition to zero-emission power sources to prevent further climate damage. At the same time, current and future extreme weather events need to be considered grey rhinos — a cousin to both the black swan and the elephant in the room — probable, low-frequency, high-impact (yet often neglected) threats.

2. Planning. Historical weather models are no longer accurate estimates of the future, yet most infrastructure planners still rely on them to determine the equipment necessary to provide vital services. Instead, planners need to use future-focused, climate-informed, predictive models to assess the “new normal” of uncommon, but extreme, weather events.

In addition to climate-informed models, planning requires assessing recovery capabilities through desktop exercises, system stress-testing, and real-world, pull-the-plug practices. NERC’s GridEx exercises and Electric Infrastructure Security (EIS) Council’s EarthEx exercises are great examples; however, those scenarios are not developed locally and may be seen by system operators as black swan events.

The US Military has considered electricity to be critical to mission success since the cold war, when they hardened key substations for the possibility of high-altitude nuclear detonation that could cause electromagnetic pulse outages. In the last decade, the Pentagon has had a renewed focus, as cyberattacks and Mother Nature’s weather have again threatened power infrastructure. The Department of Defense now requires a range of desktop simulations as well as physical pull-the-plug stress-testing of systems.

Civilian electricity systems need a similar approach. The combination of climate-informed models and stress-testing will help grid operators determine how and where to shore up infrastructure to withstand extreme weather (or other risks to the power system). Likewise, given the significant costs associated with infrastructure upgrades and enhancements, as a society, we will need to decide how to pay for these improvements. Cybersecurity

What is the World Economic Forum doing about making our electricity ecosystem cyber resilient?

Cyber resilience is a challenge for organizations globally, but particularly for the electricity industry. Power systems are among the most complex and critical of all infrastructures and act as the backbone of economic activity.

The unprecedented pace of technological change driven by the Fourth Industrial Revolution means that our systems of health, transport, communication, production and distribution will demand rapidly increasing energy resources to support global digitalization and advancement of interconnected devices.

Our Platforms for Shaping the Future of Cybersecurity and Digital Trust and Shaping the Future of Energy and Materials have pioneered a Systems of Cyber Resilience: Electricity Initiative, which brings together leaders from more than 50 businesses, governments, civil society and academia, each with their own perspective, to collaborate and develop a clear and coherent cybersecurity vision for the electricity industry.

Our Systems of Cyber Resilience: Electricity project is designed to enhance cyber resilience across the electricity ecosystem. To join our platforms and bring your cyber resilience expertise to drive this or similar initiatives, contact us or read more in our Impact Story.

3. Recovery. Planning also requires recognizing that all generation sources fail sometimes, whatever the cause. Thus, how a power system recovers from a widespread outage must also evolve. An interconnected grid enables regions with excess power to serve regions in need.

Micro-grids for critical facilities, rolling outage protocols that ensure sufficient warmth and water supply for everyone, and strong transmission will be necessary for 21st century recovery.

Here, again, the private sector can take a lesson from the military.

4. Rebuilding. As pipelines and turbines thaw out and resume normal operations (it seems Texas was spared significant sustained damage in this regard), it may be easy to resume a business-as-usual approach and not see the next preventable grey rhino charging our way. Examining how New York and Puerto Rico are rebuilding after widespread, weather-induced damage to their grids is enlightening. Cascading blackouts during Tropical Storm Sandy resulted in the New York Power Authority re-building with much greater segmentation in their transmission system, allowing them to shut power to fewer residents in future storms.

Building robust, resilient power systems for 21st century threats is the name of the game.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Social Committee slams the 28 EU leaders for false promises

The Commission calls for a climate neutral Europe by 2050*

Commission launches initiative for more sustainable cocoa production

Is the English language too powerful?

Refugee crisis update: EU seeks now close cooperation with Africa while Schulz is shocked to witness live one single wreck full of immigrants

A Sting Exclusive: “Our ambition is by 2020 Indonesia to become an emerging power of World’s Maritime Access”, reveals the Chargé d’Affaires at the Embassy of Indonesia in Brussels, treating WEF, ASEAN and EU-Indonesia relations on the eve of the World Economic Forum East Asia 2015 in Jakarta

COVID-19: Why we must take the widescreen view of workforce uncertainty

Congolese expelled from Angola returning to ‘desperate situation’: UN refugee agency

New seat projections for the next European Parliament

This Syrian national has been trapped at Kuala Lumpur airport for 3 months

Thought AIs could never replace human imagination? Think again

State aid: Commission approves €6 billion German measure to recapitalise Lufthansa

UN updates guidelines to ensure successful return to civilian life for former combatants

As fighting in Libya escalates, so does number of children ‘at imminent risk of injury or death’

Ebola in DR Congo: conflict zones could constitute ‘hiding places’ for the deadly virus – WHO chief

China is now heavily endorsing its big investment flow in the Central Eastern European (CEE) countries

5G will drive Industry 4.0 in the Middle East and Africa

EU consumers will soon be able to defend their rights collectively

Trump badly cornered at home by agribusiness and steel consumer lobbies: Trade

Migration surge leaves children stranded, begging on Djibouti’s streets

The EU Commission fails to draw the right conclusions about corruption

Madagascar: UN Secretary-General reaffirms support for electoral process

Art, mental health and suicide: different strategies for increasing access to health services

Statement by the European Parliament ahead of the 10 April Brexit Summit

EU elections update: Can the EU voters vote unaffected from fake news and online disinformation?

Germany openly seeks more advantages for its banks

Is climate change making allergy season worse? These scientists think so

The ECB again takes care of the bankers not the people

This new programme could hold the key to solving global health challenges

UN-led Yemen ceasefire monitoring team gets ready to begin operations

Here’s how community lending could help refugees find their feet

UK: Crawley group wins European Citizens’ Prize

This opera company is helping people in their recovery from COVID-19

Quality education an ‘essential pillar’ of a better future, says UN chief

EU budget: Making the EU fit for its role as strong global actor

Terrorism ‘spreading and destabilizing’ entire regions, Guterres warns States, at key Kenya conference

Climate change could be making forests shorter – this is how

This US city put an algorithm in charge of its school bus routes and saved $5 million

‘Forgotten crisis’ in Cameroon, with attacks on the rise, millions in need of ‘lifesaving assistance’

Amazon indigenous groups want to create a nature sanctuary the size of Mexico

Ebola situation worsening in DR Congo, amidst growing ‘funding gap’ UN health agency warns

Talent, not technology, is the key to success in a digital future

Here’s how the global financial crisis is still affecting your wages

The success story of a Chinese investment in the Greek port of Piraeus

Africa must ‘value youth’ in the drive towards lasting peace, young envoy tells Security Council

Climate negotiations on the road to a strong Paris agreement rulebook

Health inequalities: private healthcare providers versus state healthcare providers

GSMA Announces New Keynote Speakers, Event Updates for 2019 “MWC Los Angeles, in Partnership with CTIA”

Factories are no longer the sure route to prosperity. Here’s why

State aid: Commission approves €1.4 billion Swedish scheme to support uncovered fixed costs of companies affected by coronavirus outbreak

More countries are making progress on corruption – but there’s much to be done, says a new report

Vote at 16 in Malta: next stop Europe

The digital building blocks of better communities

State aid: Commission approves €300 million public support for the development of ultrafast broadband network in Greece

A Sting Exclusive: “Without climate, forget about peace!”, Swedish MEP Bodil Valero cautions from Brussels

Young people are Europe’s biggest value and hope

Weather reports could soon be telling us about the role of climate change

Use space technology to build a better world for all, urges UN chief

EU joint response to disasters: deal reached with Council

Africa is launching the world’s largest free trade area – but these are the stumbling blocks

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s