A Californian city gave people $500 a month – no strings attached. Here’s what happened

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Sean Fleming, Senior Writer, Formative Content


  • 125 people in the US city of Stockton received monthly payments of $500 for two years.
  • At the start of the project, 28% of the recipients were in full-time work; that rose to 40% a year later.
  • Mental health also improved.
  • But universal basic income still has its detractors who claim it provides ‘a false hope’.

Giving people money can encourage them to become more economically productive.

This seemingly counterintuitive conclusion is one of the findings of a real-life trial of the consequences of universal basic income (UBI) programmes – where people receive a regular payment, usually from the state.

Around 150 kilometres east of San Francisco lies the city of Stockton, population 300,000, which was declared bankrupt in 2012. In 2019, an organization called the Stockton Economic Empowerment Demonstration (SEED) was established to administer UBI to 125 low-income residents of the city.

Each of the people participating in the programme received a monthly payment of $500 for two years. The project’s findings indicate that the additional money has been beneficial in a number of ways.

a chart showing the qualifications needed to apply for the programme
This is how people can apply for the programme. Image: SEED

Something to feel good about

Mental and physical well-being improved, with reductions in depression and anxiety recorded. Households were able to avoid or limit their exposure to financial ups and downs often experienced by low-income families, especially in the event of unexpected costs.

SEED found that those in the UBI trial “experienced clinically and statistically significant improvements in their mental health … moving from likely having a mild mental health disorder to likely mental wellness over the year-long intervention”.

But one of the most potentially significant findings was that people in receipt of the $500 UBI payments were more likely to find full-time employment.

At the start of the project, in February 2019, 28% of the UBI recipients were in full-time work. That had risen to 40% a year later. The SEED trial included a control group, not in receipt of the payments. In that control group, full-time employment increased by 5% over the same period.

A ‘wrongheaded’ idea?

UBI is a contentious issue for some people. Milton Ezrati, who is described as a Wall Street veteran, dismissed the idea of UBI as “wrongheaded” in Forbes, in 2019. He refers to a “study of people on unemployment (that) discovered, for instance, that they spent more time in front of the television and sleeping than upgrading their working skills”.

Ezrati is far from being a lone voice when it comes to criticism of UBI. The UK’s Centre for Social Justice, a think tank set up by former government minister Iain Duncan Smith, calls UBI “a false hope”.

The former mayor of Stockton, California, Michael D Tubbs would most likely disagree. “Poverty is the biggest issue. Everything we deal with stems from that. There’s so many people working incredibly hard, and if life happens, there’s no bottom,” he states in the report on the first 12 months of the SEED trial.

SEED has been anonymously tracking participants’ spending. It found that the biggest target of spending was food. Non-food purchases at supermarkets, large stores and wholesale outlets was the next largest. Transportation costs and utility payments were another large part of the spending breakdown.

Alcohol and tobacco accounted for less than 1% of spending.

A chart showing what recipients spent their money on
articipants spent the majority of the $500 monthly UBI amount on essentials. Image: SEED

The pursuit of opportunities

As well as the increase in the number of people working, the SEED researchers found that recipients were able to make long-term choices about their lives and livelihoods. The report quotes a man in his mid-30s who had been “eligible for a real estate license for more than a year, but could not afford taking the time off work to complete it. With the $500, he says that his life was ‘converted 360 degrees… because I have more time and net worth to study… to achieve my goals’”.

What is the COVID Response Alliance for Social Entrepreneurship?

The COVID Response Alliance for Social Entrepreneurship is a coalition of 85 global leaders, hosted by the World Economic Forum. Its mission: Join hands in support of social entrepreneurs everywhere as vital first responders to the pandemic and as pioneers of a green, inclusive economic reality.

Its COVID Social Enterprise Action Agenda, outlines 25 concrete recommendations for key stakeholder groups, including funders and philanthropists, investors, government institutions, support organizations, and corporations. In January of 2021, its members launched its 2021 Roadmap through which its members will roll out an ambitious set of 21 action projects in 10 areas of work. Including corporate access and policy change in support of a social economy.

For more information see the Alliance website or its “impact story” here.

There are also examples of people being able to pursue training or internship opportunities, as the additional $500 income meant they were able to quit low-paying, dead-end jobs.

UBI schemes have been trialled in several places around the world. A scheme currently operating in South Korea makes lower monthly payments via a localized form of currency.

In Gyeonggi Province, which surrounds the capital Seoul, recipients of the $220 quarterly payment get their money via a special bank account that allows the income to be spent only in local businesses that have registered to support the scheme. The payments have a use-by expiration date, too, meaning they cannot be stockpiled or saved. Instead, the money circulates into the local economy. https://www.facebook.com/plugins/video.php?href=facebook.com%2Fworldeconomicforum%2Fvideos%2F3944065349043713%2F&width=640&show_text=false&appId=1085482764806408&height=360

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Social Committee slams the 28 EU leaders for false promises

The Commission calls for a climate neutral Europe by 2050*

Commission launches initiative for more sustainable cocoa production

Is the English language too powerful?

Refugee crisis update: EU seeks now close cooperation with Africa while Schulz is shocked to witness live one single wreck full of immigrants

A Sting Exclusive: “Our ambition is by 2020 Indonesia to become an emerging power of World’s Maritime Access”, reveals the Chargé d’Affaires at the Embassy of Indonesia in Brussels, treating WEF, ASEAN and EU-Indonesia relations on the eve of the World Economic Forum East Asia 2015 in Jakarta

COVID-19: Why we must take the widescreen view of workforce uncertainty

Congolese expelled from Angola returning to ‘desperate situation’: UN refugee agency

New seat projections for the next European Parliament

This Syrian national has been trapped at Kuala Lumpur airport for 3 months

Thought AIs could never replace human imagination? Think again

State aid: Commission approves €6 billion German measure to recapitalise Lufthansa

UN updates guidelines to ensure successful return to civilian life for former combatants

As fighting in Libya escalates, so does number of children ‘at imminent risk of injury or death’

Ebola in DR Congo: conflict zones could constitute ‘hiding places’ for the deadly virus – WHO chief

China is now heavily endorsing its big investment flow in the Central Eastern European (CEE) countries

5G will drive Industry 4.0 in the Middle East and Africa

EU consumers will soon be able to defend their rights collectively

Trump badly cornered at home by agribusiness and steel consumer lobbies: Trade

Migration surge leaves children stranded, begging on Djibouti’s streets

The EU Commission fails to draw the right conclusions about corruption

Madagascar: UN Secretary-General reaffirms support for electoral process

Art, mental health and suicide: different strategies for increasing access to health services

Statement by the European Parliament ahead of the 10 April Brexit Summit

EU elections update: Can the EU voters vote unaffected from fake news and online disinformation?

Germany openly seeks more advantages for its banks

Is climate change making allergy season worse? These scientists think so

The ECB again takes care of the bankers not the people

This new programme could hold the key to solving global health challenges

UN-led Yemen ceasefire monitoring team gets ready to begin operations

Here’s how community lending could help refugees find their feet

UK: Crawley group wins European Citizens’ Prize

This opera company is helping people in their recovery from COVID-19

Quality education an ‘essential pillar’ of a better future, says UN chief

EU budget: Making the EU fit for its role as strong global actor

Terrorism ‘spreading and destabilizing’ entire regions, Guterres warns States, at key Kenya conference

Climate change could be making forests shorter – this is how

This US city put an algorithm in charge of its school bus routes and saved $5 million

‘Forgotten crisis’ in Cameroon, with attacks on the rise, millions in need of ‘lifesaving assistance’

Amazon indigenous groups want to create a nature sanctuary the size of Mexico

Ebola situation worsening in DR Congo, amidst growing ‘funding gap’ UN health agency warns

Talent, not technology, is the key to success in a digital future

Here’s how the global financial crisis is still affecting your wages

The success story of a Chinese investment in the Greek port of Piraeus

Africa must ‘value youth’ in the drive towards lasting peace, young envoy tells Security Council

Climate negotiations on the road to a strong Paris agreement rulebook

Health inequalities: private healthcare providers versus state healthcare providers

GSMA Announces New Keynote Speakers, Event Updates for 2019 “MWC Los Angeles, in Partnership with CTIA”

Factories are no longer the sure route to prosperity. Here’s why

State aid: Commission approves €1.4 billion Swedish scheme to support uncovered fixed costs of companies affected by coronavirus outbreak

More countries are making progress on corruption – but there’s much to be done, says a new report

Vote at 16 in Malta: next stop Europe

The digital building blocks of better communities

State aid: Commission approves €300 million public support for the development of ultrafast broadband network in Greece

A Sting Exclusive: “Without climate, forget about peace!”, Swedish MEP Bodil Valero cautions from Brussels

Young people are Europe’s biggest value and hope

Weather reports could soon be telling us about the role of climate change

Use space technology to build a better world for all, urges UN chief

EU joint response to disasters: deal reached with Council

Africa is launching the world’s largest free trade area – but these are the stumbling blocks

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s