How the institutional response to COVID-19 can prepare us for climate change

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Giulio Boccaletti, Chief Strategy Officer, The Nature Conservancy

  • Political institutions’ response to the pandemic could be a crucial dress-rehearsal for a transition to a different economic model in the face of climate change;
  • How national institutions work with the individual to build enough trust to guide the transition will be crucial;
  • Efforts towards a climate-secure world need to graduate from technical discussions to the conception of the right institutional architecture to support this change.

When Hannah Arendt, the German-American philosopher, reflected on the dawn of the nuclear age, she observed that a world that relegates existential questions to technical and scientific language alone is a world in which people have lost the ability to author their own life.

Arendt’s concern with the technocratic state was extreme, the product of her life experience and the times in which she lived. Nonetheless, she was pointing to a fundamental challenge: if there is no trusted language that can subject choices to political debate, political institutions are unlikely to create spaces in which all individuals participate and which produce politically legitimate solutions to real-life problems.

How do we confront problems that are defined scientifically, yet solve them through political systems that are designed to offer a space in which everyone can author their life and contribute to collective action? The COVID-19 pandemic has laid bare the complexity of such scientifically driven policy responses and raised profound political issues.

An effective track-and-trace system or localized draconian lockdowns, for example, enable a surgical containment of the epidemic but require a significant breach of individual privacy and freedom – rights that have deep roots in the political history of many countries.

Despite these complexities, and with some notable outliers, the response of most countries has been impressive in both scale and scope. At a minimum, it is remarkable that, even without any previous experience, many countries have chosen to shut down their economies at unprecedented cost in order to protect the most vulnerable in society.

Some have observed that such a response to the pandemic has provided a crucial dress-rehearsal for how political institutions might fare in sustaining a transition guided by science to a different economic model in the face of climate change. Countless reports describe technologies that might help avoid the worst effects of climate change, from solar power, sea walls and wind farms to drought-resistant crops and forest restoration. These all form part of a growing list of ingredients in the most substantial technical transition plan ever conceived.

But as with the pandemic, the transition, while science-informed, will result in a distribution of impacts and costs that will be uneven at best and very significant political challenges if poorly governed. Individuals will experience these events in very different ways and with different material consequences. Those material consequences may or may not be economically significant, but they will be politically salient.

To ensure politics is fully mobilized towards implementation, individuals will need trustworthy national institutions to help them understand it, especially if they are to bear some of these costs. This is where the pandemic holds an important lesson. In countries that have successfully implemented lockdowns, public health institutions have earned sufficient trust to guide those decisions and that trust did not arise simply from being scientific institutions.

The privileged role of medical science in contemporary politics is the result of decades of frontline work. Health is the largest expenditure in most country’s national accounts amounting to close to 10% of GDP in OECD countries. In many of these countries, much of that expenditure is public, part of the post-World-War welfare promises that have led the state to become the biggest economic actor in the modern economy. It coordinates and delivers myriad services that individuals experience in the course of their lifetime. It also motivates an enormous private sector which shares the same basic scientific framework.

Health is also highly bureaucratized: all countries have a ministry of health, which coordinates the expenditures of the state; scientific advisory structures, institutions staffed by medical and health experts; and, crucially, vast delivery organizations – hospitals, clinics – with capillary territorial reach. These elements are all united by a common body of knowledge and epistemological framework.

The fact that the family doctor belongs to the same institutional architecture as government advisors and pharmaceutical research ensures medical language is not entirely lost to the public and that individual health can be part of the story of individual political agency. It is that complex architecture that has built the trust health officials enjoy to legitimately influence policy.

As a dress rehearsal for disruptive change, the response to the COVID-19 crisis is, therefore, instructive. Sufficiently radical changes to the nature of our built and natural environment and to our economy will pose a fundamental challenge to how we govern the landscape and to who does what, where and for whose benefit. For those challenges to be resolved in service of a commonwealth, politics and political principles matter even more than detailed technical recipes. The quality of the national institutions that are supposed to both advise the state and give voice to the experience of the individual will matter a great deal.

Trust in OECD governments has been going down in recent years
Trust in OECD governments has been going down in recent years Image: Our World in Data

While there is ample international architecture for dealing with climate change, a common theory for national institutions is missing. What is the equivalent of the 20th-century public health institution that will help societies and individuals cope with the challenges posed by the largest economic and landscape transition in human history?

It is unlikely that the answer will depend on creating entirely new institutions; there is not enough time for that. Existing institutions offer building blocks that may need to be rearranged to face what is to come. Educational institutions, for example, are important delivery vehicles for general literacy and may have to play a far more consistent role in helping individuals understand their experience in a changing world. Universities are the training grounds for the generation of professionals who will guide the transition and who must share a basic language and epistemology.

Public institutions that deal with the landscape (agricultural ministries, environment ministries, energy ministries, water ministries) are currently organized to reflect economic categories but will need to coordinate across their domains to deliver a national landscape that is resilient to a different planetary environment. Consistent advice on the state of the environment and the effectiveness of policy interventions will need a disciplinary approach akin to what epidemiology does for public health.

What’s the World Economic Forum doing about climate change?

Climate change poses an urgent threat demanding decisive action. Communities around the world are already experiencing increased climate impacts, from droughts to floods to rising seas. The World Economic Forum’s Global Risks Report continues to rank these environmental threats at the top of the list.

To limit global temperature rise to well below 2°C and as close as possible to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, it is essential that businesses, policy-makers, and civil society advance comprehensive near- and long-term climate actions in line with the goals of the Paris Agreement on climate change.Global warming can be beaten thanks to this simple plan

The World Economic Forum’s Climate Initiative supports the scaling and acceleration of global climate action through public and private-sector collaboration. The Initiative works across several workstreams to develop and implement inclusive and ambitious solutions.

This includes the Alliance of CEO Climate Leaders, a global network of business leaders from various industries developing cost-effective solutions to transitioning to a low-carbon, climate-resilient economy. CEOs use their position and influence with policy-makers and corporate partners to accelerate the transition and realize the economic benefits of delivering a safer climate.

Contact us to get involved.

The political institutions that mediate individual experience into collective agency are crucial to our social life. But in order to build trust, a robust, capillary and reputable institutional architecture, which can both advise political processes and reassure individual citizens of the legitimacy of their knowledge, is also needed.

In the end, a crucial lesson from the pandemic is this: efforts to bring about the transition to a climate-secure world need to graduate from technical discussions about what ought to happen to the conception of the institutional architecture that will place the individual citizen and their political agency at the heart of a science-based transition.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

If the Current Situation in Hong Kong Arose in the West

Yemen talks: Truce agreed over key port city of Hudaydah

These countries are pioneering hydrogen power

Who gains when the US and China fight over trade?

This Japanese TV show about work-life balance is a big hit – here’s why

These countries have the most doctors and nurses

European Commission successfully places first EU SURE bond in 2021

Recovery effort will fizzle out quickly if there is no long-term perspective

European Youth Forum @ European Business Summit 2015: Why interns should matter to business

‘We need to do more’ to transform the world, deputy UN chief tells African audiences

This is where teachers are most (and least) respected

4 eco-friendly products put sustainable spins on classic practices, from teacups to hankies

It’s EU vs. Google for real: the time is now, the case is open

EU-Vietnam free trade deal gets green light in trade committee

Social justice, inclusion and sustainable development need a ‘Great Reset’. Here are 3 key steps we can take

Mali just took a huge step towards universal healthcare

EU budget: Stepping up the EU’s role as a security and defence provider

World Retail Congress announces Dubai 2016 Hall of Fame Inductees

The business of media in 2021

From Kenya to China, here’s why countries should start working together on AI

EU to give more power to national antitrust authorities in a bid to secure regulatory fines

European Union policy for improving drought preparedness and mitigation

Repression, use of force risk worsening Bolivia crisis: UN human rights chief

Can the EU last long if it cuts Cyprus out?

State aid: Commission approves €2 billion Italian guarantee scheme to support trade credit insurance market in the context of the coronavirus outbreak

Marking Sir Brian Urquhart’s 100th birthday, UN honours life-long servant of ‘we the peoples’

‘Health is a right, not a privilege’ says WHO chief on World Health Day

ILO: Unemployment to increase by 8.1 million in 2013-2014

3 actions for business to prepare for a post-pandemic future

EU Leaders’ meeting in Sofia: Completing a trusted Digital Single Market for the benefit of all

The power of trust and values in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

UN urges ‘restraint’ in Bangladesh’s post-presidential election violence

Detecting online child sexual abuse requires strong safeguards

How China raised the stakes for electric vehicles

Why Nordic nations are the best places to have children

Draghi joined Macron in telling Germany how Eurozone must be reformed

The challenges of the vaccination campaign in Brazil, including the state of Amazonas

Senior UN adviser sees ‘rare’ victory for humanitarian diplomacy as aid convoy reaches desert camp in Syria

MWC 2016 LIVE: GTI shifts to phase two – 5G – after hitting milestones

What does a good digital ID look like?

Lockdown is the world’s biggest psychological experiment – and we will pay the price

EU legislation protecting home buyers approved in Parliament

African economies sustain progress in domestic resource mobilisation

COVID-19: MEPs call for measures to close the digital gap in education

Zeid calls for ICC probe into Myanmar Rohingya crisis

Nagorno Karabakh: EU allocates additional €3 million in emergency aid for civilians affected by the hostilities

Restoring prospect of peace in Middle East is ‘our shared responsibility’ UN envoy tells Security Council

One small flight for a drone, one ‘big leap’ for global health

Amazon sinks while our breath sinks

The Collapse of the Brazilian Health Care System

We spend half our time at work in meetings – and that’s not necessarily a bad thing

Mental health of health professionals: the alter ego

‘Violence, atrocities and impunity’ reign throughout Libya, ICC prosecutor tells UN Security Council

We can’t rid Asia of natural disasters. But we can prepare for them

Medical Devices Regulation: Commission welcomes Council support to prioritise the fight against coronavirus

Resettlement: EU Member States’ pledges exceed 30,000 places for 2020

4 steps to developing responsible AI

The European Commission and EU consumer authorities publish final assessment of dialogue with Volkswagen

Genocide threat for Myanmar’s Rohingya greater than ever, investigators warn Human Rights Council

Chart of the day: These are the cities where the World Cup threatens productivity the most

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s