Is decentralization a panacea for development?

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Vivin R Nair, Global Shaper, Trivandrum Hub,

  • Decentralization has been presented as a system to improve economic outcomes.
  • The outcome of decentralization varies according to different contexts.
  • Policymakers should focus on capacity-building as a cornerstone of decentralization.

There has been a revolution in governance since the second half of the 20th century – sweeping the world in diverse forms – which goes by the label of “decentralization” or “devolution”. The impact of COVID-19 has exacerbated an inclination towards a decentralized world, invariably without a conversation around building the preconditions necessary for a successful decentralized system.

The essence of decentralization has been succinctly put forth by Mahatma Gandhi: “A true democracy cannot be worked by twenty men sitting at the centre; it has to be worked from below by the people of every village.”

Traditionally, decentralization is defined as the transfer of powers and resources from central to sub-national government. Decentralization has been presented as a bearer of increased efficiency and a better economic outcome. However, empirical research reveals a burgeoning divergence between the theoretical and practical outcome of decentralization. Reverberating assertions of decentralization as merely operating, yet dysfunctional, has been buried under the enormous challenges posed by the pandemic-induced crisis.

What do the proponents and detractors of decentralization postulate?

One of the major arguments put forth by the proponents of decentralization has been its ability to match local needs through tailor-made policies and services. For example, following devolution, Wales created the Ministry for Education and Lifelong Learning to develop human capital, which was otherwise not provided special attention. Furthermore, decentralization can also increase competition among regions, leading to enhanced production and simulating innovations in policymaking.

Several academics have argued that decentralization brings with it greater accountability, proximity and higher participation among individuals. Proximity allows for a reduction in the cost of collecting and using that information; while participation and accountability paves the way for better surveillance and scrutiny of elected representatives’ actions.

The detractors of decentralization have argued that competition between regions could lead to a deadweight loss (the cost to the society due to an inefficient allocation of resources) on the nation’s overall growth. Numerous bureaucratic layers in decentralized governance could add to red-tape, corruption and an increased cost due to duplication of work. The lack of hard-budget constraints in the context of separate financing and decision-making units could lead to overspending by regional governments, resulting in fiscal deficits without proper responsibility. Professors Pranab Bardhan and Dilip Mookherjee show us that the chance of corruption as a result of increased proximity may result in lobbying over policymaking. The differences within policy agendas of various tiers of government can also lead to uncertainty.

Index of Decentralization
Index of Decentralization. Colour of a country corresponds to its percentile in the world’s distribution: red – 0-25th, yellow – 25-50th, blue – 50-75th, green – 75-100th. Image: Ivanyna and Shah, 2012

The real-world implications of a text-perfect theory

Over the past three decades, there has been a significant proclivity towards decentralization as a solution for developmental barriers, and a gateway for an efficient society. However, the outcome of decentralization varies according to different contexts, including the regional and institutional settings of a country and the process of implementation. An empirical study by Andrés Rodríguez-Pose and Adala Bwire shows that there is no direct relation between positive economic growth and devolution.

While the arguments favouring decentralization provide an excellent theoretical basis, the practical aspects of the same require greater attention. Conversations around de-globalization are indicative of not only vulnerabilities associated with increased inter-dependency but also weak local systems. The uniform application of decentralization across a country with diverse regional history, institutional quality and path dependency (a tendency for institutions to grow in a particular manner as a result of their historical, and deeply-ingrained structural characteristics) can, in fact, increase inequality emanating from systemic and structural blindness.

The ramification of a spatially blind application of decentralization measures can have a cascading effect on the well-being of a country. For instance, in a country with multiple provinces or states – with their own distinct histories, path-dependencies, and differentiated institutional qualities – the application of uniform decentralization policy can turn a blind eye towards the differences that exist within them. Once unaccounted for, those provinces that lag behind could potentially be trapped into a vicious cycle of increased corruption and red-tape.

COVID-19 has denuded the positive image associated with decentralization. The impact of nationwide lockdown directives has exposed weak links and the inability of governments to coordinate even within those countries that are theoretically decentralized. In a decentralized country like India, one could witness two kinds of approaches in dealing with the pandemic.

On one hand, the State of Kerala has been efficiently using the decentralized system to test, trace, and isolate cases; on the other, several states under the same system have, invariably, failed to tackle the pandemic. Thus, decentralization should be redefined and reformulated to accommodate the regional imbalances and path-dependency trends. Policymakers ought to focus on capacity-building as a cornerstone of decentralization.

In summary, selling decentralization as an all-encompassing solution to the problems of economic development and governance should be viewed with caution, as it may have both positive effects as well as negative repercussions. In societies with deep inequalities, decentralization is the ideal way forward; but policymakers should be cautious about the formulation and implementation of the same.

The success of decentralization is contingent upon various other factors, such as institutional quality, national and local context, the way and form in which decentralization is implemented. An adequate conversation about the preconditions and bridging inter-regional inequalities and decentralization must go hand-in-hand. In the context of “The Great Reset”, it becomes imperative that the new social contract ought to focus on fundamentally revamping decentralization.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Coronavirus: the truth against the myths

The UK referendum has already damaged Europe: even a ‘remain’ result is not without cost to Britain and the EU

UN ‘determined to lead by example’ on disability rights: Guterres

Is there a cure for corruption in Greece?

More women in Latin America are working, but gender gap persists, new UN figures show

‘Negative forces’ at work in DR Congo threaten ‘largely peaceful’ relations across Great Lakes region, says outgoing UN envoy

These countries have the most powerful passports

Africa’s Sahel: Act now before the crisis ‘becomes unmanageable’, urges Grandi

Electronic or conventional cigarettes – which is safer?

Sacrifice of fallen ‘blue helmet’ to be honoured with UN’s highest peacekeeping award

EU mobilises further €15.2 million humanitarian support for food safety, epidemics preparedness and support to people in conflict areas in Latin America and Caribbean

Commission moves to ensure supply of personal protective equipment in the European Union

They won this year’s Nobel for economics. Here’s why their work matters

3 reasons why data is not the new oil – and why this matters to India

EU paves the way for a stronger, more ambitious partnership with Africa

The Novel Coronavirus: The Truth against the Myths

In China things are moving in the right direction

Costa Coffee products (Copyright: Costa Coffee; Source: Costa Coffee website, Press area)

The start of the “Caffeine rush”: Coca-Cola acquires Costa Coffee days after Nestlé-Starbucks deal

Greece lost a month that cannot be found neither in “mini Summits” nor in Berlin

This ‘hidden killer’ is responsible for one in five deaths, and you might never have heard of it

A new proposal breaks the stalemate over the Banking Union

Italian archaeological trafficking group dismantled

Human rights breaches in Nigeria and Burundi

Corruption thwarts attempts to build a better world and ‘must be fought by all, for all’

The European Commission, European Investment Bank and Breakthrough Energy Ventures establish a new €100 million fund to support clean energy investments

Marking Sir Brian Urquhart’s 100th birthday, UN honours life-long servant of ‘we the peoples’

FROM THE FIELD: Weather reports come to aid of Uganda’s farmers

European Development Days 2013

Clamp down on illegal trade in pets, urge Public Health Committee MEPs

Progress against torture in Afghan detention centres, but Government needs to do more, says UN report

FROM THE FIELD: Faces and Voices of Conflict

Sweden to reach its 2030 renewable energy target this year

Main results of Foreign Affairs EU Council, 16/07/2018

Does it pay for cities to be green?

Single Market Scoreboard 2020: Member States need to do more to ensure the good functioning of the EU Single Market*

How regenerative agroforestry could solve the climate crisis

The end of Spitzenkandidat: EU leaders concluded unexpectedly on EU top jobs

Violence in North and West Africa increasingly targeting civilian and border areas – OECD/SWAC

The impact of COVID-19 on the life of the elderly

EU Commission announces Safe Harbour 2.0 and a wider Data protection reform

Energy: EU funding for priority projects should reflect 2050 climate objectives

Why banks escape from competition rules but not pharmaceutical firms

The 28 EU leaders show contempt for the European Elections results

Taxation: Commission refers Germany to the Court for its failure to apply EU rules on VAT for farmers

Rule of Law: Commission launches infringement procedure to protect the independence of the Polish Supreme Court

Commission’s feeble response to financial benchmarks fraud

UN chief welcomes establishment of inclusive government in Central African Republic

Handwashing is not just for coronavirus – how good hygiene could help reduce antibiotic use

A day in the life of a Rohingya refugee

Yemen: ‘Living hell’ for all children, says UNICEF; Angelia Jolie calls for ‘lasting ceasefire’

New UN Syria envoy pledges to work ‘impartially and diligently’ towards peace

This is how countries compare on gun deaths

Transition between education and employment: how the internship culture is threatening the foundations of our education

Millennials (and Gen X) – Here are the steps you should take to secure your financial future

Eurogroup asked to reduce public debts of its member states

Public health through universal health coverage can help to attain many SDGs

Gender equality: an issue much talked about but less acted upon

This Indian school accepts plastic waste instead of fees

Global Cooperation for Local Action: Fighting antimicrobial resistance

Malta: investigation risks being compromised while Prime Minister is in office

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s