Is decentralization a panacea for development?

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Vivin R Nair, Global Shaper, Trivandrum Hub,

  • Decentralization has been presented as a system to improve economic outcomes.
  • The outcome of decentralization varies according to different contexts.
  • Policymakers should focus on capacity-building as a cornerstone of decentralization.

There has been a revolution in governance since the second half of the 20th century – sweeping the world in diverse forms – which goes by the label of “decentralization” or “devolution”. The impact of COVID-19 has exacerbated an inclination towards a decentralized world, invariably without a conversation around building the preconditions necessary for a successful decentralized system.

The essence of decentralization has been succinctly put forth by Mahatma Gandhi: “A true democracy cannot be worked by twenty men sitting at the centre; it has to be worked from below by the people of every village.”

Traditionally, decentralization is defined as the transfer of powers and resources from central to sub-national government. Decentralization has been presented as a bearer of increased efficiency and a better economic outcome. However, empirical research reveals a burgeoning divergence between the theoretical and practical outcome of decentralization. Reverberating assertions of decentralization as merely operating, yet dysfunctional, has been buried under the enormous challenges posed by the pandemic-induced crisis.

What do the proponents and detractors of decentralization postulate?

One of the major arguments put forth by the proponents of decentralization has been its ability to match local needs through tailor-made policies and services. For example, following devolution, Wales created the Ministry for Education and Lifelong Learning to develop human capital, which was otherwise not provided special attention. Furthermore, decentralization can also increase competition among regions, leading to enhanced production and simulating innovations in policymaking.

Several academics have argued that decentralization brings with it greater accountability, proximity and higher participation among individuals. Proximity allows for a reduction in the cost of collecting and using that information; while participation and accountability paves the way for better surveillance and scrutiny of elected representatives’ actions.

The detractors of decentralization have argued that competition between regions could lead to a deadweight loss (the cost to the society due to an inefficient allocation of resources) on the nation’s overall growth. Numerous bureaucratic layers in decentralized governance could add to red-tape, corruption and an increased cost due to duplication of work. The lack of hard-budget constraints in the context of separate financing and decision-making units could lead to overspending by regional governments, resulting in fiscal deficits without proper responsibility. Professors Pranab Bardhan and Dilip Mookherjee show us that the chance of corruption as a result of increased proximity may result in lobbying over policymaking. The differences within policy agendas of various tiers of government can also lead to uncertainty.

Index of Decentralization
Index of Decentralization. Colour of a country corresponds to its percentile in the world’s distribution: red – 0-25th, yellow – 25-50th, blue – 50-75th, green – 75-100th. Image: Ivanyna and Shah, 2012

The real-world implications of a text-perfect theory

Over the past three decades, there has been a significant proclivity towards decentralization as a solution for developmental barriers, and a gateway for an efficient society. However, the outcome of decentralization varies according to different contexts, including the regional and institutional settings of a country and the process of implementation. An empirical study by Andrés Rodríguez-Pose and Adala Bwire shows that there is no direct relation between positive economic growth and devolution.

While the arguments favouring decentralization provide an excellent theoretical basis, the practical aspects of the same require greater attention. Conversations around de-globalization are indicative of not only vulnerabilities associated with increased inter-dependency but also weak local systems. The uniform application of decentralization across a country with diverse regional history, institutional quality and path dependency (a tendency for institutions to grow in a particular manner as a result of their historical, and deeply-ingrained structural characteristics) can, in fact, increase inequality emanating from systemic and structural blindness.

The ramification of a spatially blind application of decentralization measures can have a cascading effect on the well-being of a country. For instance, in a country with multiple provinces or states – with their own distinct histories, path-dependencies, and differentiated institutional qualities – the application of uniform decentralization policy can turn a blind eye towards the differences that exist within them. Once unaccounted for, those provinces that lag behind could potentially be trapped into a vicious cycle of increased corruption and red-tape.

COVID-19 has denuded the positive image associated with decentralization. The impact of nationwide lockdown directives has exposed weak links and the inability of governments to coordinate even within those countries that are theoretically decentralized. In a decentralized country like India, one could witness two kinds of approaches in dealing with the pandemic.

On one hand, the State of Kerala has been efficiently using the decentralized system to test, trace, and isolate cases; on the other, several states under the same system have, invariably, failed to tackle the pandemic. Thus, decentralization should be redefined and reformulated to accommodate the regional imbalances and path-dependency trends. Policymakers ought to focus on capacity-building as a cornerstone of decentralization.

In summary, selling decentralization as an all-encompassing solution to the problems of economic development and governance should be viewed with caution, as it may have both positive effects as well as negative repercussions. In societies with deep inequalities, decentralization is the ideal way forward; but policymakers should be cautious about the formulation and implementation of the same.

The success of decentralization is contingent upon various other factors, such as institutional quality, national and local context, the way and form in which decentralization is implemented. An adequate conversation about the preconditions and bridging inter-regional inequalities and decentralization must go hand-in-hand. In the context of “The Great Reset”, it becomes imperative that the new social contract ought to focus on fundamentally revamping decentralization.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Re-thinking citizenship education: bringing young people back to the ballot box

Where do Americans stand on immigration? They’re not as divided as you might think

From underestimation to valorization: how mobile technology is transforming global health

EU and U.S. castigate Facebook on Cambridge Analytica scandal as citizens’ data privacy goes down the drain again

The 27 EU leaders did nothing to help May unlock the Brexit talks

Yemen: Security Council backs new mission in support of key port city truce

South Sudan: €48.5 million in additional EU humanitarian aid

FROM THE FIELD: What do you want to be when you grow up? One day I will…

Denouncing attacks against Baghdad protesters, UN warns ‘violence risks placing Iraq on dangerous trajectory’

European Parliament marks EU accession prospects for Serbia and Kosovo

South Sudan: UN rights experts see little headway on peace deal amid spike in local-level violence

Nicaragua ‘crisis’ still cause for concern amid murder, torture allegations: Bachelet

Women lose most from the climate crisis. How can we empower them?

New Consumer Agenda: European Commission to empower consumers to become the driver of transition

These are the most desirable cities for overseas workers

Is Universal Health Coverage really available for all in the European Union?

Force used against protestors in Gaza ‘wholly disproportionate’ says UN human rights chief

The European reaction to the neo-fascist wind

Greece @ MWC14: Greek-born mobile champions at MWC 2014

UN rights chief denounces Burundi for ‘belligerent and defamatory’ attack on inquiry team

Coronavirus: a Disease that spreads as fastly as its fake news

European Youth Forum and youngest MEPs call on President Juncker to keep his promise to Europe’s youth

Haitian President at General Assembly calls for essential development aid as UN mission shifts away from peacekeeping

The European Green Deal sets out how to make Europe the first climate-neutral continent by 2050, boosting the economy, improving people’s health and quality of life, caring for nature, and leaving no one behind

There is huge talent in the world’s refugee camps. We must realize this overlooked potential

How do we really feel about women leaders?

Innovations for Content Professionals at the DCX exhibition 2018 in Berlin, in association with The European Sting

Coronavirus is creating retirement insecurity. These 10 steps can diffuse the timebomb of an ageing population

The EU wants to create 10 million smart lampposts

Circular Plastics Alliance: 100+ signatories commit to use 10 million tons of recycled plastic in new products by 2025

Green Deal: measures to step up the fight against global deforestation

How youth and technology can drive Africa’s COVID-19 response

The community and a decent working conditions for the young health workforce

Trailing the US-EU economic confrontation

FROM THE FIELD: Niger supporting the most vulnerable, as crises mount

These 5 charts show our shifting behaviour around coronavirus

What’s really driving corporate climate action?

Climate change hits the poor hardest. Mozambique’s cyclones prove it

From Israel’s ‘start-up nation’, 4 lessons in innovation

Monday’s Daily Brief: the cost of maternal healthcare, Sudan and Chad updates, sustainability in focus

OECD tells Eurozone to prepare its banks for a tsunami coming from developing countries

Here’s how to rebut the climate doom-mongers

Drones are saving lives in Tanzania’s remote communities

Trade: First year of the EU-Japan Economic Partnership Agreement shows growth in EU exports

UN chief urges restraint following reported Saudi-led assault in Yemen

5 steps businesses can take to protect air quality after COVID-19

The EU Parliament slams Commission on economic governance

How the tech sector can power the shift to a sustainable economy

Trash bin at the top of the world: can we prevent Arctic plastic pollution?

Eurozone cannot endure any longer youth marginalisation

European Union and African Union sign partnership to scale up preparedness for health emergencies

Turning challenge into opportunity on the course to becoming the first climate-neutral continent

‘Reef cubes’: could these plastic-free blocks help save the ocean?

Eurozone: Negative statistics bring deflation and recession closer

UN food aid to Yemen will fully resume after two-month break, as Houthis ‘guarantee’ delivery

What happens when you toss your water bottle in the trash?

Safe drinking water, sanitation, are ‘basic human rights’: new UN Water Development report

Parliament to ask for the suspension of EU-US deal on bank data

Dutch voters reject EU-Ukraine partnership and open a new pandora’s box for the EU

Progress made in UN talks to end Yemen war, Envoy lauds ‘positive and serious spirit’

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s