Deep-sea minerals could meet the demands of battery supply chains – but should they?


(Credit: Unplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Winnie Yeh, Lead, Platform Acceleration, World Economic Forum

  • Demand for cobalt, and other metals for batteries used in mobile electronics and electric vehicles, is forecasted to dramatically increase. A potential new source of minerals from the deep-sea could enter battery supply chains in under a decade.
  • Deep-sea mining has attracted controversy due to concerns of potential damage to delicate ecosystems before scientists have had chance to assess what is at stake.
  • Electronics and automotive companies that depend on these minerals to build their products urgently need to learn about and engage on the topic, for the viability and sustainability of their supply chains.

The world is hungry for resources to power the green transition. As we increasingly look to solar, wind, geothermal and move towards decarbonization, consumption of minerals such as cobalt, lithium and copper, which underpin them, is set to grow markedly. One study by the World Bank estimates that to meet this demand, cobalt production will need to grow by 450% from 2018 to 2050, in pursuit of keeping global average temperature rises below 2°C.

The mining of any material can give rise to complex environmental and social impacts. Cobalt, however, has attracted particular attention in recent years over concerns of unsafe working conditions and labour rights abuses associated with its production.

New battery technologies are under development with reduced or zero cobalt content, but it is not yet determined how fast and by how much these technologies and circular economy innovations can decrease overall cobalt demand.

Deep-sea mining has the potential to supply cobalt and other metals free from association with such social strife, and can reduce the raw material cost and carbon footprint of much-needed green technologies.

On the other hand, concerned scientists have highlighted our limited knowledge of the deep-sea and its ecosystems. The potential impact of mining on deep-sea biodiversity, deep-sea habitats and fisheries are still being studied, and some experts have questioned the idea that environmental impacts of mining in the deep-sea can be mitigated in the same way as those on land.

In the face of this uncertainty, the European Parliament, the prime ministers of Fiji, Vanuatu, Papua New Guinea and more than 80 organizations have called for a 10-year moratorium on deep-sea mining, until its potential impacts and their management methods are further investigated.

A stark choice is fast approaching

The world is facing a stark choice, whether to press ahead with mining the ocean’s floors, hoping that the benefits will outweigh the as-yet-unknown environmental costs, or whether to pause for research and better understanding of what’s at stake.

The International Seabed Authority was established to organize, regulate and control mining on the ocean floor beyond national boundaries. Its regulations determine environmental regulations, financial payment regime for benefit sharing and other standards and guidelines. The International Seabed Authority has already drafted exploitation regulations for deep-sea minerals, which will be decided upon at either its October 2020 assembly or its 2021 assembly. Once regulations are finalized and adopted by member states, seabed exploitation contracts could be issued for mining to begin.

In parallel, countries that have mineral deposits in their exclusive economic zones, where the country has the unique right to use the marine resources, are also exploring mining techniques and forming their own regulations. Japan successfully trialled extraction of minerals from the deep-seabed as early as 2017, with the aim to reduce reliance on mineral imports. Cook Islands is also considering granting prospecting licenses in 2021 to diversify its economy from tourism.

Governments and seabed mining companies have been exploring mineral content, measuring deep-sea environmental data and testing seabed extracting technologies for more than 30 years.

Hein et al. (2013)
Image: Map showing deep-sea mineral deposits.
Saving the planet

What is the World Economic Forum doing around the issue of deep-sea mining?

Minerals critical to the clean energy transition have been found in the deep ocean floor. These include cobalt, lithium, copper, nickel, manganese and zinc that are used in batteries for electric vehicle and portable electronics, electronic appliances, energy generation and many other aspects of our daily lives.

Deep-sea mining could offer lower financial cost and a lighter carbon footprint than conventional terrestrial sources of these minerals; it also has the potential to significantly harm one of the last natural wildernesses on our plant. In this relatively young sector, scientific knowledge is still being built on the potential impact of the industry, and the effectiveness of the proposed management methods. As the date for decisions on permitting deep-sea mining contracts gets closer, a fierce debate is emerging on if and how mining should take place. The need for a platform to host a balanced exchange on the issue has become evident.

The World Economic Forum’s Platform for Shaping the Future of Global Public Goods has the Deep-Sea Mining Dialogue, an impartial platform that allows different stakeholders to share their knowledge and perspective on the topic and participate in an evidence-based discourse. The Dialogue invites companies in the metal value chain, manufacturers that use metals, environmental groups, institutes and scientists across different disciplines to come together in a constructive, collaborative and open exchange.

The Dialogue helps inform downstream businesses that use metals in their products about the implications of this potential new source of minerals. The World Economic Forum will be gathering available data and analysis and highlighting critical gaps of existing knowledge to establish a fact-base. Through establishing a framework on responsible metal sourcing, the Dialogue reframes the heated debate on deep-sea mining as a collaborative exploration for a shared vision for the future. The aim is to reach an informed and consensual agreement on the most responsible path forward.

Manufacturing companies cannot afford to wait

Automotive, electronics, battery, aviation and energy development companies have largely been silent in the deep-sea mining debate, up to now. But deep-sea mined cobalt could enter their supply chains within a decade.

As was demonstrated to Apple, Google, Microsoft, Dell and Tesla in 2019, the ethical dimensions of companies’ raw material sourcing choices can have both reputational and legal consequences. That year, a federal class action lawsuit was brought against the five companies, over their alleged use of cobalt produced through child labour in the Democratic Republic of Congo.

The ethical dimensions of deep-sea cobalt mining have the potential to be just as contentious, and could pose no less a legal and reputational risk for manufacturers.

Meanwhile, automotive and electronics manufacturers are increasingly acknowledging the strategic importance of their cobalt sourcing decisions. BMW, Tesla, Samsung SDI, SK Innovation have begun bypassing their suppliers of manufactured parts to sign direct sourcing contracts with mining companies that are traditionally many supply chain tiers removed from their procurement departments. For these manufacturers, access to a stable, ethical supply of cobalt is more important than ever. As they increasingly source metals directly, the need to be knowledgeable on environmental and social considerations of their various supply options also grows greater.

Manufacturers who do not engage in the deep-sea mining debate now risk being taken by surprise by its implications in future years.

—Winnie Yeh, World Economic Forum

A rare opportunity to set the framework before an industry begins

Seabed mineral reserves have been estimated to contain 94,000 tons of cobalt across several different regions – about six times current land-based reserves. If responsible exploitation is possible, these new mineral sources have the potential to dramatically catalyse the low-carbon transition. If exploited irresponsibly, we risk incurring adverse and long-lasting impact on the species, habitats and ecosystems gifted to us by the ocean.

A decision on whether and how to forge ahead is upon us. In order to ensure that we rise to the challenge of that decision, and decide wisely, all stakeholders, including the companies that are set to use this ocean-mined material, must be alert to this emerging debate, and engage with it fully.

Those decisions made today on deep-sea mining are likely to have lasting effects on materials supply chains, the global mineral economy, the economies of some countries, the ocean ecosystem and our ability to tackle climate change as we look to the future.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

European Union launches WTO trade dispute against Colombia’s unfair duties on frozen fries

Mexico cannot move forward ‘without addressing the shadows of the past’, says UN rights chief

“If the job market doesn’t exist, then even the most brilliant Youth Guarantee cannot ensure a job to these young people”, European Youth Forum Secretary General Giuseppe Porcaro on another Sting Exclusive

Greece bailout ends but with no substantial effect on citizens’ life

In Pakistan, Guterres urges world to step up climate action, praises support to Afghan refugees

UN spotlights wellbeing of seafarers on International Day

UN rights office calls on Zimbabwe Government to end ‘crackdown’ in response to fuel protests

At UN, Yemen Foreign Minister demands end to ‘Iranian-Houthi coup d’etat’

Half of all violent deaths involve small arms and light weapons

Why businesses are nothing without strong human rights

How Sierra Leone is using 3D printing to become a model state

A new bioeconomy strategy for a sustainable Europe

Happens now in Brussels: Green Week sets the EU and global climate policy agenda

2019 European Elections gets backing from professional footballers

The ECB will do whatever it takes to set the Eurozone economy again in motion

UN launches drive to highlight environmental cost of staying fashionable

UN chief urges top digital tech panel to come up with ‘bold, innovative ideas’ for an ‘inclusive’ future

€200 million to promote European agri-food products in and outside the EU

‘Grave consequences’ await if new deadly escalation of violence in Gaza continues – top UN official

Ambitions are affordable for Asia and the Pacific

The future of science could be in your gut. Here’s why

Venezuela: Parliament recognises Guaidó, urges EU to follow suit

Worth going ‘extra mile’ for a new Syrian constitution, UN envoy urges

More than 3,400 classrooms damaged or destroyed by Cyclone Idai in Mozambique, says UN Children’s Fund

EU-US to miss 2015 deadline and even lose Germany’s support in TTIP’s darkest week yet

This warehouse is one of the world’s greenest industrial buildings

This one small change could transform education for millions

EU Copyright Directive: Will US tech giants comply or ditch the EU market?

Why wearing a mask is the most important thing we can do to stop the spread of COVID-19

How cocoa farming can help stop deforestation

European Commission welcomes the positive assessment about how it has managed the EU budget

My twin from Guangzhou

Ninja innovation and the future of work

Cutting money transfer fees could unlock $15bn for developing countries. Here’s how

The Italian crisis may act as a catalyst for less austerity

Structuring Your Perception: The Key to a Good Mental Health during COVID-19

These are the countries with the highest inflation

Easing fears and promoting gender equality in Chad’s girls-only classrooms

Altruism can be good for business, as these companies show

Recovery effort will fizzle out quickly if there is no long-term perspective

These are the world’s most fragile states in 2019

The Brexit factor in the US-China trade war and other conflicts

Gender Equality as a platform to improve Medicine

EU Strategy on COVID-19 vaccines must guarantee safety and accessibility for all

The ethical dilemmas of medicine

The staggering loss of the Arctic Ocean’s oldest sea ice shown in time-lapse

Civilian death toll continues to mount in Syria, UN relief chief tells Security Council

Coronavirus: the truth against the myths

It’s time for cybersecurity to go pro bono

Working with millennials, leaders say humility works better than bossing around

How businesses can create an ethical culture in the age of tech

World ‘not yet on track’ to ensure children a better future: UN rights chief

Yemen conflict: ‘Fragile’ hopes rise, as violence decreases and life-saving humanitarian funding surges

Antibiotic resistance: challenges and solutions

“Financial crisis will not happen in China!”, the Chinese Premier underlines from Switzerland; the Sting reports live from World Economic Forum 2015 in Davos

Somalia: UN congratulates Puntland region’s newly-elected President

Don’t understand the US-China trade war? This metaphor could help

The big challenge of leadership and entrepreneurship in Europe

Afghans entitled to live ‘free from fear, intimidation’, says UN chief, condemning suicide attacks

250 days until the European Parliament elections

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s