Why Italy is doing much better than you think

conte italy

Mr Giuseppe CONTE, Italian Prime Minister. Copyright: European Union Event: European Council – December 2019 (Day 2)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Francesco Daveri, Professor of Macroeconomics and Director of Full-time MBA program, SDA Bocconi School of Management & Gianmario Verona, Rector, Bocconi University


  • Investors can find good opportunities in Italy – despite its economic reputation.
  • Political instability doesn’t translate into economic instability.
  • Italy remains the third-largest exporter in Europe and seventh globally.

When Italy steps into the spotlight, it often does so for the wrong reasons. At the beginning of 2019, The New York Times had this headline about the Italian economy: “Italy slides into recession, stoking global fears.”

Fortunately, in the following quarters, it turned out earlier recession fears were overstated. Now, it appears that in the last two years or so, the Italian economy has merely been stagnating. Yet, in a more recent piece, The Economist ran the title: “Italy is out of recession, but for how long?” – adding “Out of the frying pan” as a header, making their meaning quite clear.

 

A vanished nest egg

The inability of the Italian economy to grow at decent rates is not novel. Since the adoption of the euro and the entry of China in the WTO, Italy’s growth came down to a meagre 0.1% per year, which compares to +1.4% for the euro area (Italy excluded; our calculation from Eurostat data).

The comparison with Spain – an economy similar to Italy – is particularly striking. As shown in the graph below, GDP net of inflation in Spain is now 50% higher than in 2008, while Italy’s GDP is still posting a disappointing -5% compared to pre-crisis levels.

spain gdp inflation finance debt economy
Spain – Quarterly GDP net of inflation since 2008
Image: Trading Economics
italy gdp inflation finance debt economy
Italy – Quarterly GDP net of inflation since 2008
Image: Trading Economics

In turn, the disappearance of growth implies other unpleasant budgetary and social features. As to public finance, data clearly testify the inability of Italy’s governments – there have been 63 of them since 1948, slightly less than one per year – to draw down the country’s huge stock of public debt, running at 135% of GDP, which unavoidably results in high tax rates and reduced public services. Low growth in the economy also leads to unusually high numbers of business bankruptcies, greater shares of non-performing loans and a sluggish housing market whose prices have never recovered since their lows of late 2013. Furthermore, Italy’s economic slowdown is taking place in a country in demographic decline with sinking birth rates and a growing brain drain of young people escaping underemployment. In the meantime, the country continues to be divided between economically desertified southern regions and the productive northern regions (Lombardy, Veneto, Emilia-Romagna, Piedmont) that create jobs and growth but not enough to benefit everybody in the rest of the country.

Italy is actually better than you think

Still, when observed with the attention often used by foreign investors, Italy is not doomed – and it’s actually much better off than one might think.

Yes, Italy’s governments change frequently. But a system of checks and balances gives the President of the Republic powers to guarantee the required stability at the national and international level, even when the Prime Minister is supported by weak governments. And so political instability does not automatically translate into instability of the economic policies actually being put in place. It’s often forgotten that Italy has continued to honor its (high) debt payments, even at times when debt spread was skyrocketing. And more recently, even the ex-ante revolutionary Yellow-Green coalition of the League and the Five Star Movement ended up approving a 2019 budget law, entailing a deficit just over 2% – a number in line with the expectations of the European Commission and markets. The new government that came into power over the summer continued along similar lines.

Seen from outside, it looks like instability, but instead it should be read as “resilience.”

True, industry has stopped growing in the aggregate. And, indeed, the 2008-09 recession hit harder in Italy than in Spain. Spain did less badly during the Great Recession because consumers stopped buying the Italian high-end luxury products during the downturn, while they largely continued buying the much cheaper Camper shoes or Zara clothing from Spain. Yet, while deindustrialization is common in many advanced countries, many segments of the Made in Italy are still vital – from furniture design to micromechanics, not to mention tourism. (Italy is the fifth most visited country, just behind China.) The data indicate Italy’s exports are well above 500 billion euros while its trade surplus will stay close to 3% of its GDP. In fact, Italy remains the third-largest exporter in Europe after Germany and France, and seventh in the world after China, the United States, Germany, Japan, the Republic of Korea and France. In a world increasingly flat, Italian producers appear to be endowed with special features, and so are less pressured to look abroad for cheaper labour costs to withstand competition from East Asia. And those firms that can take advantage of being different may gain easier access to distant markets than in the past.

Finally, Italy’s firms are disproportionately small and small is not beautiful any more – certainly less than it used to be before the Internet revolution. Yet the data from the 2014-18 Italian recovery confirm Italian firms of all sizes managed to grow. This is good for a country whose productive structure is still disproportionately tilted towards SMEs. The small, often family-based firms that adapt to change by replacing old, self-taught managerial methods with more modern ones proved to be more successful than others, showing better results in terms of cash flow and returns on equity. Family managers are pushing Italian small companies to learn the importance of opening up their capital beyond the family, and in some cases going public. While the sinking of Bari’s biggest local bank under a heavy debt burden received a lot of attention, the Intesa San Paolo report on Italy’s districts reported on the enduring success of Bari’s mechatronic industry. Milan-Cortina will host the 2026 Winter Olympics, spurring further investments in an area that remains the most productive in Europe after Baden-Wurttemberg, Rhone-Alpes and Bavaria. With its 100-plus universities and research institutions, some of which are European pieces of excellence, the country is equipping its younger generation with the skills required to face the fourth industrial revolution.

What’s the World Economic Forum doing about tax?

The World Economic Forum has published its Davos Manifesto 2020, calling on business leaders to sign up to a series of ethical principles, including:

“A company serves society at large through its activities, supports the communities in which it works, and pays its fair share of taxes.”

Additionally, the Forum’s Trade and Global Economic Interdependence Platform provides a vital link between trade and tax communities to enable coherent policymaking which responds to societal needs and reflects business realities.

Taking its lead from OECD-led reforms, the work brings technical issues to a high-level audience and enables honest dialogue among diverse stakeholders on polarizing topics. You can find relevant publications here.

Italy is a buy, not a sell

Italy’s aggregate growth is and will likely remain subdued, reaching 1% per year at most. Yet it’s full of companies with double-digit growth. Growth cuts across industries, localities and firm size. And in reality, its public finances are not fundamentally influenced by political instability. Hence, foreign investors willing to spend some time and money to select carefully are likely to find good investment (and life) opportunities in Italy.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Brexit: political groups discuss options for an orderly withdrawal

A very good morning in European markets

IMF: How To Deal With Failed Banks

Service and Sacrifice: For Ghana, UN peacekeeping is a ‘noble opportunity to serve humanity’

State aid: Commission opens in-depth investigation into compensation for early closure of lignite-fired power plants in Germany

Rohingya cannot become ‘forgotten victims,’ says UN chief urging world to step up support

‘Nothing left to go back for’: UN News hears extraordinary stories of loss, and survival as Mozambique rebuilds from deadly cyclones

Time to be welcome: Youth work and integration of young refugees

MEPs urge the EU to lead the way to net-zero emissions by 2050

Will AI make the gender gap in the workplace harder to close?

The global issue of migration in 2017

How Pakistan is aiming for a green recovery from the pandemic

NextGenerationEU: European Commission endorses Belgium’s €5.9 billion recovery and resilience plan

In Christchurch, UN chief calls for tolerance, solidarity to extinguish ‘wildfire’ of hate speech

Commission to invest €14.7 billion from Horizon Europe for a healthier, greener and more digital Europe

Medical students: catalysts to close the gender gap

Can autonomous cars make traffic jams a thing of the past?

Russia’s permafrost is melting and it could have a devastating global effect

Why cities hold the key to safe, orderly migration

New UN book club helps children deal with global issues

“China will strive to enhance the performance of economic growth”, President Xi highlights from the World Economic Forum 2017 in Davos

Monday’s Daily Brief: US-DPRK relationship reset, ‘Horrific’ Kabul bombing, Anti-conscription plan in Syria, Climate change heat stress, Security Council in Iraq

FROM THE FIELD: Free tutorials in Mali, ‘a life-saver’ for Fatouma

European Commission Joint Research Centre opens world-class laboratories to researchers

The world condemned by neo-liberals to feed trillions to banks: the New Deal exorcised

Mergers: Commission approves the merger of Mylan and Pfizer’s Upjohn division, subject to conditions

What paleoecology can teach us about fires in the Amazon

The link between migration and technology is not what you think

Counterfeiters are taking advantage of the pandemic. Here’s how to stop them

3 reasons why civil society is essential to COVID-19 recovery

Panama’s fight for a delayed right: women’s economic independence

14 innovative projects helping to save the planet and make the world a better place

Italy can stand the US rating agencies’ meaningless degrading

Scale of displacement across Myanmar ‘very difficult to gauge’, says UN refugee agency

FROM THE FIELD: Niger supporting the most vulnerable, as crises mount

6 ways least developed countries can participate in the 4IR

UN chief calls for Security Council to work with Myanmar to end ‘horrendous suffering’ of Rohingya refugees

International partners pledge $1.2 billion to help cyclone-hit Mozambique recover, ‘build back better’

Commission welcomes agreement on the modernisation of EU export controls

One migrant child reported dead or missing every day, UN calls for more protection

Japan’s agro-food sector would benefit greatly from policies to boost innovation, entrepreneurship and sustainable resource use

UN chief ‘following very closely’ reports of chemical weapons use in Syria’s Aleppo

High-technology manufacturing saves the EU industry

5 ways to boost sustainable trade in the world’s poorest countries

The West unites against Mali desert rebels

Sweden gives all employees time off to be entrepreneurs

Happens now in Brussels: Green Week sets the EU and global climate policy agenda

5 surprising ways major cities are going green

“ASEM: Global Partners for Global Challenges”, a Sting Exclusive by China’s Ambassador to the EU

More efforts needed to boost trust in business and finance

The Swiss will pay dearly for voting out fellow Europeans

Recovery effort will fizzle out quickly if there is no long-term perspective

Global hunger is on the rise. These simple steps could help eradicate it

Women that inspire women

Antitrust: Commission opens investigation into Broadcom and sends Statement of Objections seeking to impose interim measures in TV and modem chipsets markets

From low-earth orbit, ‘envoys’ of humanity join UN space forum

This surgeon runs a makeshift hospital for over 200,000 people

European Union launches WTO trade dispute against Colombia’s unfair duties on frozen fries

Inside the battle to counteract the COVID-19 ‘infodemic’

Where are the world’s nuclear weapons?

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s