Compensation for damages by the State for infringement of EU law: the European Commission refers Spain to the Court of Justice for its rules on the compensation for damages incurred by private parties

madrid

Edificio Metropoli, Gran vía – Madrid, Spain, Madrid, España (Jorge Fernández Salas, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.


Today, the European Commission decided to refer Spain to the Court of Justice of the EU regarding Spanish rules on compensation for damages caused by the State when adopting legislation contrary to Union law.

Following complaints received about certain Spanish provisions regulating the compensation for damages caused by legislative acts that are in breach of Union law, the European Commission initiated an infringement procedure on 14 June 2017, considering that these provisions are in breach of the principles of effectiveness and/or equivalence. These principles limit the procedural and substantive autonomy of the Member States when they set the conditions for liability in case of breaches of Union law.

Firstly, the Spanish legislation makes compensation conditional on a number of cumulative conditions: there has to be a judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union declaring a Spanish legislative act to be in breach of Union law; the injured party needs to have obtained, at any instance, a final judgment dismissing an appeal against the administrative decision which caused the damage; and the injured party needs to have alleged the breach of Union law during that appeal procedure. Following established case-law, these conditions make the award of damages by the State for breaches of Union law excessively difficult and thereby violate the principle of effectiveness.

Secondly, the Spanish rules establish less favourable conditions for the liability of the State resulting from a breach of Union law than for the liability resulting from breaches of the Spanish Constitution. This is a violation of the principle of equivalence.

Background

The Spanish authorities, in their reply to the Commission’s 2017 letter of formal notice, considered that their system of State liability was in conformity with Union law. Given that this reply was not satisfactory, on 26 January 2018, the Commission issued a Reasoned Opinion reiterating its arguments. The Spanish authorities replied on 26 March and sent a complementary reply on 21 December. Further contacts and exchanges between the Spanish authorities and the Commission followed, but to date they have not resulted in any progress. The Commission has therefore decided to refer Spain to the Court of Justice under Article 258 Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

The ‘ASEAN way’: what it is, how it must change for the future

Christmas spending: Who can afford not to cut?

The three sins the EU committed in 2015

Colombia: Santos thanks the EU for its support to the peace process

The smartest cyber investment is collective action. Here’s why

CDNIFY @ TheNextWeb 2014

How responsible businesses can step forward to fight coronavirus

Colourism: How skin-tone bias affects racial equality at work

No tears for Cyprus in Brussels and Moscow

Technology is a means, not an end

Sexual education in a school at the Brazilian Amazon

How do we design an inclusive energy transition?

The EU will always have a stable partner in Montenegro, says President Đukanović

Financial system risk is elevated and global standards are essential in managing cross-border infrastructure investment

The different ways of care: Is there a general rule to follow?

EU mobilises further €15.2 million humanitarian support for food safety, epidemics preparedness and support to people in conflict areas in Latin America and Caribbean

Brussels to tear down the trade wall with Mexico as opposed to Trump’s “walls”

China in my eyes

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “If we do not do properly the Paris agreement, then all 16 remaining goals will be undermined”, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon cautions from Davos

These are the fastest trains in the world

Electronic cigarettes, a better alternative or a well-advertised product

Germany hides its own banks’ problems

EU-UK: A deal synonymous to ‘remain’, England pays the Irish price

New rules on drivers’ working conditions and fair competition in road transport

Dieselgate: Parliament calls for mandatory retrofits of polluting cars

The refugee crisis seen through the eyes of a young doctor from Turkey

€5 billion of EU energy efficiency project money spent on “comfort”

Alcohol abuse kills three million people a year, most of them men – WHO report

European Youth Forum demands immediate action & binding agreement on climate change

Vote at 16 in Malta: next stop Europe

Britain offers more money for an orderly Brexit but the Irish question resurges

What options the new President of Ukraine has?

South Sudan: ‘Outraged’ UN experts say ongoing widespread human rights violations may amount to war crimes

7 amazing ways artificial intelligence is used in healthcare

Learn from the margin, not the center: digital innovation with social impact as transformative force bridging digital divide

Eurozone cannot endure any longer youth marginalisation

‘Young people care about peace’: UN Youth Envoy delivers key message to Security Council

It’s 100 years since US women got the right to vote, but how has gender equality changed?

MEPs agree on new rules to tax digital companies’ revenues

Here are six bold ideas to accelerate sustainable energy innovation

Energy Union: deals on efficiency targets and governance

3 charts to help you understand the American shale boom

EU27 leaders unite on Brexit Guidelines ahead of “tough negotiations” with Theresa May

VW diesel scandal and climate change: can increased independent car checks lead to cleaner mobility?

New Report Offers Global Outlook on Efforts to Beat Plastic Pollution

China revisited by the former Ambassador of Hungary to China

Germany takes cover from Trump in Eurozone and decides to pay for it

Europe provides financial support to African countries while Turkey denies to change terrorism laws jeopardising the EU deal

Environment Committee MEPs vote to upgrade EU civil protection capacity

Trump doesn’t only target Germany, aims to crack the entire EU

Commission unveils its first Strategic Foresight Report: charting the course towards a more resilient Europe

The Council of Europe adopts Recommendation on young people’s access to rights

Peacekeeping chief highlights challenges facing UN Police

Brazil identifies a clear pathway for aligning its transfer pricing framework with the OECD standard

Why education and accountability are important for developing countries?

Syrian Government’s ‘different understanding’ of UN role, a ‘very serious challenge’ – Special Envoy

A 550 km-long mass of rotting seaweed is heading for Mexico’s pristine beaches

War in Syria: ‘Carnage’, flouting of rights and international law, must stop: Guterres

South Africa’s cabinet is now 50% women for the first time ever

Intel, Almunia and 1 billion euros for unfair potatoes

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s