Apple Vs. EU: Will the US tech giant ever pay for taking advantage of Ireland’s taxation?

Press conference by Margrethe Vestager, Member of the EC, on Apple’s antitrust case in Ireland
Date: 30/08/2016. Location: Brussels – EC/Berlaymont.© European Union, 2016 Source: EC – Audiovisual Service. Photographer: Georges Boulougouris

Apple Inc. together with the Irish government showed up yesterday at the EU’s second-highest court to appeal for the 13 billion euros EU tax order. The US corporation has decided to legally challenge the 2016 European Commission’s decision by claiming that its products and services are created in the US and thus the profits were due there.

However, the EC has been insisting that Apple took an unfair advantage towards the rest of the competition channeling most of its EU sale through the subsidiaries in Cork, Ireland. This appeal is likely to change the current status quo of Ireland as a tax heaven for multinationals.

But let’s take it from where all started; back in 2016.

Background

Almost three years ago, in August 2016, the European Commission ordered Ireland to collect €13 billion in back taxes from the US giant technology company Apple Inc., following an investigation into the multinational company’s affairs. The Commission argued that Ireland extended preferential tax treatment to Apple for years which resulted in Apple paying only minimal taxes to the Old Continent. Both Apple and Dublin appealed the ruling, saying that no such “sweetheart deal” has ever been in place and that Apple’s tax treatment was in line with Irish and European Union law.

Apple has already lodged the 13 billion euros into an escrow account during the second trimester of 2018 whereas the appeal is still in progress and is currently heard by the EU’s General Court. A two-day hearing began yesterday at the General Court in Luxembourg with California-based company to be represented by its Chief Financial Offer, Luca Maestri, and a delegation of six people.

Apple and Ireland against European Commission

During the first day of the hearing, Apple’s lawyer Daniel Beard challenged the 13 billion euros EU tax order. Mr Beard stated that:  “The commission contends that essentially all of Apple’s profits from all of its sales outside of the Americas must be attributed to two branches in Ireland. The branches’ activities did not involve creating, developing or managing those rights. Based on the facts of this case, the primary line defies reality and common sense”.

On the same side, the lawyers who represent Ireland in the appeal against the EC’s decision told yesterday that the case is “inconsistent” and “fundamentally flawed” in an attempt to show that this case is untenable. More specifically, former attorney general Paul Gallagher, who leads the team representing Ireland, stated: “Ireland has been the subject of entirely unjustified criticism. It is the commission that should be criticised.” Furthermore, Barrister Maurice Collins, another lawyer representing Ireland, mentioned that the EU executive body “set out during its investigation of Apple’s Irish tax payments to invent a novel and completely profit attribution theory to what was due to the Republic.”

Commission fights back

The European Commission lawyer Richard Lyal said that the aim of this order was to make sure that Apple’s Irish subsidiaries are taxed properly putting the blame to the Irish government as well. In detail, Richard Lyal stated: “To a large extent that (Apple’s argument that all its intellectual property-related activities take place in the United States) is perfectly correct and perfectly irrelevant… They (Ireland) simply accepted an arbitrary method proposed by the Apple Ireland subsidiaries. That in itself gives rise to a presumption of a special deal, exceptionally advantageous treatment. It is clear that the tax authorities made no assessment in 1991.”

General Court judges’ decision

Today is the second and last day of this hearing with the court five judges to be expected to rule in the coming months. Regardless of the outcome, the losing party is likely to appeal to the EU Court of Justice for final judgment which could take many years. This is a very crucial case as it will change or leave intact the Irish regime to protect and be a tax heaven for tech multinationals. That is also why Ireland has already spent 7,1 million euros in mostly legal fees and is expected to pay much more as it may take a decade till the final verdict.

All in all, it doesn’t matter whether Apple is the largest tax payer in the world, what matters is whether the US tech giant and its peers are taking advantage of EU special tax regimes or paying their rightful tax burden.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Digital distrust: We’re losing faith in technology to solve the world’s problems

This Canadian company transforms plastic waste into building materials

UN agency ramps up effort to counter growing nuclear threat from cyberspace

Germany objects to EU Commission’s plan for a Eurozone bank deposits insurance scheme but Berlin could go along

This is what’s happening to the Amazon, according to NASA

These 3 innovative solar farms show why this renewable technology is hot right now

From fire to fake snow – the global consequences of the climate crisis

Blockchain is not a magic bullet for security. Can it be trusted?

Civil society organisations disenchanted with “Youth Guarantee”

Investment Plan for Europe: European Investment Bank to provide BioNTech with up to €100 million in debt financing for COVID-19 vaccine development and manufacturing

Where is heading Putin’s Russia?

Skills, not job titles, are the new metric for the labour market

How we planted more than 5,000 trees during the COVID-19 pandemic

This is how Middle Eastern retailers can keep up with e-commerce

UN chief calls for ‘increased commitment’ to resolution on 10th anniversary of Georgia conflict

In the future, no one should be excluded from healthcare

Eurozone’s credibility rock solid

These are the UK’s biggest trading partners

Draghi drafts a plan to donate more money to bankers, the era of ‘money for nothin’ is flourishing

The “Legend of the Sun” wishes you Happy Chinese New Year 2015 from Brussels

European Agenda on Migration four years on: Marked progress needs consolidating in face of volatile situation

Mental health and suicide prevention-what can be done to increase access to mental health services in my region?

World Economic Forum CEO Climate Leaders call for continued action toward net-zero emissions

What next for Europe? Three (completely) different Davos views

Record numbers of people in the UK have applied to study nursing

5 Black heroes of the environmental movement

New UN-Syrian Action Plan signals an ‘important day’ for child protection, says UN envoy

Why today’s leaders need to know about the power of narratives

The gender gap of medicine in 2018

How COVID-19 is making companies act for the long term

Ecocraft: take gaming to another level by greening Minecraft

Is Eurozone heading for disinflation?

Fisherwomen of Lake Chad show optimism in face of multiple challenges

Myanmar military committed ‘routine, systematic’ sexual violence against ethnic minorities, UN experts find

Britain and Germany change attitude towards the European Union

Global warming: our responsibility

Growth is running out of steam. How do we prepare for the next crisis?

Mali’s ‘self-defence’ groups must face justice, after deadly intercommunal attacks

How innovation from within is transforming International Organizations as well as lives

Joint EU-U.S. statement following the EU-U.S. Justice and Home Affairs Ministerial Meeting

Youth Guarantee putting young people in jobs

COP24 negotiations: Why reaching agreement on climate action is so complex

Commission sets moderate greenhouse gas reduction targets for 2030

10 Downing street: Another desperate attempt to unite Britain on Brexit

We had the hottest June ever this year – this is what happened around the world

Thailand gave healthcare to its entire population and the results were dramatic

What is the biggest benefit technology will have on ageing and longevity?

Turkey’s foreign bribery enforcement framework needs to be urgently strengthened and corporate liability legislation reformed

Youth not prioritised in new Commission

Amazon indigenous groups want to create a nature sanctuary the size of Mexico

Consumer protection: Deal on EU-wide rules for those sold faulty products

From drought to floods in Somalia; displacement and hunger worsen, says UN

Does Draghi have another ace up his sleeve given his Quantitative Easing failure?

Give a chance to the brothers of Ailan: reception of refugees in Greece

State aid: Commission approves €2.5 billion Italian scheme to support self-employed and healthcare professionals in context of coronavirus outbreak

How can you or your organization support the Hour of Pride initiative?

Fossil fuel support is rising again in a threat to climate change efforts

The 2019 European elections: A pro-European – and young – electorate with clear expectations

Revamp collective bargaining to prevent rising labour market inequalities in rapidly changing world of work

The European Sting at the Retail Forum for Sustainability live from Barcelona

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: