Climate change: won or lost in cities or by cities?

climate change iceland2

(Credit: Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Oliver Harman, Cities Economist, International Growth Centre


Extinction Rebellion disrupted London and brought many transport routes to a standstill on Easter Weekend in 2019. A key demand for the direct action group was for the government to declare a climate emergency.

This demand has since been met – by the UK parliament, as well as the Argentinian senate, the French parliament and the Canadian House of Commons. In fact, a total of 983 jurisdictions stretching from Poland to the Philippines have now declared a climate emergency. However, a major question remains open in all cases: once declared, whose role it is to act?

For many policymakers, the answer is cities. It has been well touted that climate change will be won or lost in cities. Former UN Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon is one proponent of this argument.

The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) went one step further and said it’s down to cities to limit global warming. Such statements need careful examination as they can lead responsible actors to point the finger, rather than make changes themselves.

The role of cities in climate change

Cities are home to 55% of the global population and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) say they consume approximately 70% of energy and 75% of global carbon emissions. This will likely increase as cities, particularly in developing countries, are still growing. By 2050, it is estimated that 66% of the global population will live in urban areas, meaning the use of resources in cities will rise.

Despite their resource demand, cities are also one of the most sustainable inventions humans have created. People living and working in proximity allows efficient public transport, shorter commuting distances and smaller homes with lower electricity use. When delivered correctly, this density leads to much lower carbon footprints than sprawling suburban counterparts.

Therefore, the role cities should play, and more importantly can play in climate change should be a key area of discussion in the upcoming Sustainable Development Impact summit.

Do cities have the power?

It is important to emphasise that even the world’s largest cities with the most devolved decision-making power do not have full autonomy over the key drivers of climate change. Transport policy is just one area in which many cities lack the ability to make and enact policy that would affect climate change.

For example, this sector currently accounts for almost a quarter of global carbon dioxide emissions, and in urban areas 90% of urban transport energy is due to economic activity, transport costs, geography and urban form. Yet globally there is still considerably larger regional, national and supranational government influence driving policy and investments in these areas than there is for city governments.

In Nigeria for instance, design standards and building codes are prescribed at the national level. Similarly, Indian cities have limited say over green infrastructures and density regulation, two key policy levers mitigating climate change. Unable to act against sprawl, cities miss out on the environmental promises of proximity.

Furthermore, even when cities are empowered to enact policy in this area, local political economy issues are as big of a challenges as anywhere.

For example, New York city’s congestion charge has been twelve years in the making and was until very recently still running up against political barriers despite the clear benefits shown in London, Stockholm and Singapore. Therefore, if climate change is down to cities, then it is the role of national governments to enable them to act: they need the policy and investment power.

Which cities can make the biggest impact?

Almost half of urban dwellers live in small cities of less than 500,000 and, when looking at where greenhouse gas reduction can occur, over half of our 2030 reduction potential actually lies in these small and medium urban units. It isn’t, therefore, the large cities that may be able to affect the largest gains when it comes to climate change; it is instead the small human settlements.

Yet, many of these have even less power, capacity and financing to deliver actionable change than in larger cities. It is important not just to enable global cities with the power to change, but global towns, as well.

Image: New Climate Economy

Pointing researchers in the right direction

The policy focus may be towards the wrong actors of change, as much of the research is still being focused in the wrong direction. In particular, while only one-in-eight urban dwellers live in megacities, these areas receive much more academic attention – almost a quarter of all articles and literature since 1990.

The top 10 cities received almost as much focus as the bottom 5,000 in the literature. Yet, if the largest greenhouse gas reductions are available in small and medium cities, then policy research should be focused on options for decision makers in these areas. The spatial focus of research needs to be realigned.

Number of urban climate mitigation case studies, grouped according to city size.
Image: Carbon Brief

A regional mismatch is also apparent. African cities’ growth rate is 3.5%, compared to 1.9% globally. Of Africa’s projected 2050 urban population, two-thirds are yet to move in. Energy consumption in this region is increasing at a rate 30% higher than world’s average (2.9% compared to 2.2%). Combining this high city population growth, with increasing levels of energy consumption should give African cities and towns considerable ability to negate greenhouse gas emissions.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

In wake of ‘collapsed’ agreement, new wave of violence threatens millions in Syria’s Idlib

MEPs call for more sanctions against Belarus following ‘Ryanair hijacking’

The British are the most positive in Europe on the benefits of immigration

Refugee crisis update: EU lacks solidarity as migration figures drop

Why is scientific collaboration key? 4 experts explain

Phone lines open between Ethiopia and Eritrea, and people are calling strangers

A skills gap is jeopardizing efforts to end energy poverty

Health & Sustainable Development Goals: it’s about doing what we can

Amid ongoing fighting in northeast Syria, hundreds cross Iraqi border in search of safety

Promoting Equality for Women in the Healthcare Industry : A Physician’s Reflection on His Experiences as a Medical Student

These are the world’s best countries to retire in, as of 2019

A Sting Exclusive: “Entrepreneurship in the Coronavirus (COVID-19) era” written by the Vice-President of Junior Enterprises Europe

From the Field: Women push for peace

Banking on sustainability – what’s next?

Stakeholder Capitalism: over 50 companies adopt ESG reporting metrics

The United Kingdom’s decision to leave the European Union will impact young people’s future the most

Poland: €676 million worth of EU investments in better rails and roads

COVID-19: A time screaming for positivity

German heavy artillery against Brussels and Paris

A busy year in the UN Security Council: more openness, diversity mark 2019

Border management: Commission welcomes political agreement towards making European Travel Information and Authorisation System operational

Mexico must increase foreign bribery enforcement: full implementation of anti-corruption reforms could help

CHALLENGING THE ZEITGEIST OF DIGITAL – Change making projects innovate mobile support for refugees, inclusive environments, early breast cancer detection and more

These are the world’s most fragile states in 2019

How youth and technology can drive Africa’s COVID-19 response

Iraq: UN demining agency rejects desecration accusations, involving historic Mosul churches

Do not jeopardise future-oriented EU programmes, say EP’s budget negotiators

Judges urge Security Council to serve interests of all UN Member States

Strengthening the rule of law through increased awareness, an annual monitoring cycle and more effective enforcement

From farms to supermarkets: MEPs approve new EU rules against unfair trading

Decarbonizing shipping – why now is the time to act

Scale of displacement across Myanmar ‘very difficult to gauge’, says UN refugee agency

EU disburses €460 million in Macro-Financial Assistance to Tunisia, Kosovo, Montenegro and North Macedonia

Recession: the best argument for growth

A new catastrophic phase in the Syrian carnage

The Cold War had an unintended side effect: It created a European wildlife paradise

Aung San Suu Kyi suspended from the Sakharov Prize Community

Libya: ‘Substantial civilian casualties’ in Derna, UN humanitarian chief ‘deeply concerned’

Why Eurozone’s problems may end in a few months

UN envoy ‘encouraged’ by latest talks on avoiding ‘worst-case scenario’ in Syria’s Idlib

Migration: EU helps channel humanitarian support to migrants in Lithuania

Crime and drugs in West and Central Africa: Security Council highlights ‘new alarming trends’

Digital privacy comes at a price. Here’s how to protect it

Connecting Europe Express reaches final destination after 20,000km journey

A Sting Exclusive: “China is Making Good Stories not Bad Ones”, Ambassador Yang highlights from Brussels

The EU Parliament unanimously rejects Commission’s ideas about ‘seeds’

Erasmus+: over €28 billion to support mobility and learning for all, across the European Union and beyond

Where are the charities in the great Artificial Intelligence debate?

This project is using AI and drones to track and protect great white sharks

EU-China relations under investigation?

Why we need to redefine trust for the Fourth Industrial Revolution

The European Parliament hemicycle in Strasbourg (Copyright: European Union, 2017 / Source: EC - Audiovisual Service / Photo: Mauro Bottaro)

EU Parliament sends controversial copyright law reform back to discussion

UNESCO experts ready to assist reconstruction of iconic Notre Dame, following devastating blaze

Backed by UN, Asia-Pacific countries to advance space technology for ‘development transformation’

Is Germany closer to Russia than the West? Nord Stream II and Iran count more

Education should be like everything else. An on-demand service

EU steps up aid for Lebanon – European Commissioner for Crisis Management in Beirut

Commission takes further action to ensure professionals can fully benefit from the Single Market

We must work together to build a new world order. This is how we can do it

Artificial Intelligence: These 3 charts show what people really think

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: