State aid: France to recover €8.5 million of illegal aid to Ryanair at Montpellier airport

ryanair

(Lucas Davies, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.


The European Commission has found that the marketing agreements concluded between the local Association for the Promotion of Touristic and Economic Flows (APFTE) and Ryanair at the airport of Montpellier are illegal under EU State aid rules. Ryanair now has to return €8.5 million of illegal State aid.

Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: “Competition between airports and between airlines is crucial for consumers, growth and jobs. Our investigation showed that certain payments by the French local authorities in favour of Ryanair to promote Montpellier airport gave Ryanair an unfair and selective advantage over its competitors and caused harm to other regions and other regional airports. This is illegal under EU State aid rules. France must now recover the illegal State aid.”

Montpellier airport is a regional airport located in the French region of Occitanie. The airport served nearly 1.9 million passengers in 2018. Ryanair was present at the airport until April 2019.

Following a complaint by a competitor of Ryanair, in July 2018 the Commission opened an in-depth investigation into marketing agreements between the Association for the Promotion of Touristic and Economic Flows (Association de Promotion des Flux Touristiques et Economiques, “APFTE”) and Ryanair and its subsidiary AMS.

Between 2010 and 2017, APFTE concluded various marketing agreements with Ryanair and AMS, under which the airline and its subsidiary received payments worth around €8.5 million in exchange for promoting Montpellier and the surrounding area as a touristic destination on Ryanair’s website.

The Commission’s investigation revealed that:

  • The agreements with Ryanair were financed through State resources and were attributable to the State.APFTE is an association unrelated to the airport operator, funded almost entirely by regional and local French public entities. These public entities closely control the use of the association’s budget.
  • The payments in favour of Ryanair on the basis of the marketing agreements did not correspond to effective marketing needs of APFTE but only served as an incentive for Ryanair to maintain its operations at Montpellier airport.
  • APFTE either concluded the agreements directly with Ryanair and AMS and not with other airlines or organised public tenders that were biased towards Ryanair.

On this basis, the Commission found that the marketing agreements gave an undue and selective advantage to Ryanair over its competitors. The Commission therefore concluded that the agreements amounted to illegal and incompatible aid under EU State aid rules and that the advantage must be recovered.

Recovery

As a matter of principle, EU State aid rules require that incompatible State aid be recovered in order to remove the distortion of competition created by the aid. There are no fines under EU State aid rules and recovery does not penalise the company in question. It simply restores equal treatment with other companies.

France must now recover the illegal State aid amounting to around €8.5 million from Ryanair.

Background

In the aviation sector, the Commission’s guidelines on State aid to airports and airlines (see also MEMO) reflect the fact that public subsidies may under certain circumstance be used by regional airports or regional authorities to attract price-sensitive airlines to a specific airport. Such subsidies can typically take the form of low airport charges, discounts to airport charges, success fees or incentive payments to airlines as remuneration for alleged services – especially marketing.

Public authorities or publicly-owned regional airports may offer attractive conditions to airlines in order to boost their traffic. However, in principle, such conditions must not go beyond what a profit-driven operator would be prepared to offer under the same circumstances (the market economy operator principle). If this principle is not respected, the conditions offered to airlines involve State aid.

In the last few years, the Commission has concluded a number of cases regarding aid to airlines aimed at attracting or maintaining their aircraft capacity at certain airports, finding that they were not in line with State aid rules. For example, regarding the airports of Nîmes (in the catchment area of Montpellier airport), Pau, and Angoulême in France, Zweibrücken and Altenburg-Nobitz in Germany, Klagenfurt in Austria, and the Sardinian airports of Cagliari, Olbia and Alghero in Italy.

Also, the Commission is currently investigating further agreements between public authorities and airlines in certain regional airports, for example concerning the German airport of Frankfurt-Hahn or the Spanish airports of Reus and Girona.

The Commission considers that such measures can be very distortive on the highly-competitive, pan-European air transport market on intra-Union routes. Moreover, such measures can disadvantage regions and airports, which do not use unlawful State aid to attract airlines.

The non-confidential version of the decision will be made available under the case number SA.47867 in the State Aid Register on the Commission’s competition website once any confidentiality issues have been resolved. More information on the Commission’s state aid policy in the air transport sector is available in this policy brief.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

UN working ‘intensively’ to stop Ebola in eastern DR Congo, following second case in major border town

‘Amid stormy global seas, UN charter remains our moral anchor’, says Guterres on United Nations Day

First-ever UN report on disability and development, illustrates inclusion gaps

UN chief highlights action across borders for ‘stable and prosperous Eurasia’

The world condemned by neo-liberals to feed trillions to banks: the New Deal exorcised

The Fourth Industrial Revolution is changing how we grow, buy and choose what we eat

North Macedonia President, credits dialogue and diplomacy for setting a decades-long ‘name dispute’

Indoor air pollution is deadly. Here’s an unconventional solution

Reparations for sexual violence in conflict – ‘what survivors want most, yet receive least’

Why our future relies on more inclusive and transparent innovation

UN chief calls for ‘enlightened self-interest’ from world leaders to save ‘the whole planet’ from climate change

A Europe that Protects: Commission calls for decisive action on security priorities

EU Facility for Refugees in Turkey: €5.6 billion out of €6 billion now allocated in support of refugees

Foreign direct investments the success secrete of Eurozone

10 expert predictions for the next decade in Chinese AI

UN chief condemns air strike that hit school bus in northern Yemen, killing scores of children

The time is up but the game is still not over for Greece: negotiations continue in anticipation of a new deal

Are Halloween pumpkins a problem for the planet?

More billions needed to help Eurozone recover; ECB sidesteps German objections about QE

EU-UK: A deal synonymous to ‘remain’, England pays the Irish price

Dutch voters reject EU-Ukraine partnership and open a new pandora’s box for the EU

Constitutional Committee breakthrough offers ‘sign of hope’ for long-suffering Syrians

UN Mission, community leaders, condemn South Sudan violence which left two dead at camp

A health approach to climate change

3 ways to accelerate the energy transition

Italy can stand the US rating agencies’ meaningless degrading

What empty homes and hipster coffee shops tell us about globalization

What next for Europe? Three (completely) different Davos views

3 reasons why we should vaccinate both boys and girls against HPV

‘Transformational benefits’ of ending outdoor defecation: Why toilets matter

Prospect of negotiated peace in Afghanistan ‘never been more real’ – UN mission chief

Greece to stay in the euro area but the cost to its people remains elusive

Rural women a ‘powerful force’ for global climate action: UN Secretary-General

A UN-backed boost for women-run businesses in the developing world

Here are three technology trends changing the way you travel

Malaysia can show the way towards a holistic model for human rights

Parliament asks for the termination of EU-US bank data deal

Fisheries: Commission proposes measures to conserve stocks of deep-sea species in the North-East Atlantic

Sudan: ‘Violence must stop’, says UNICEF chief, ‘gravely concerned’ over 19 child deaths since military backlash

EU-Ukraine Free Trade Agreement sees the light as Moscow’s reaction once more looms

Nature is our strongest ally in ensuring global water security

In Rwanda, high-speed drones are delivering blood to remote communities

From ‘strength to strength’ UN-African Union security partnership growing, Security Council hears

The 4 types of leader who will thrive in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

‘Complacency’ a factor in stagnating global vaccination rates, warn UN health chiefs

‘Starvation’ now a reality for displaced Syrians stranded in camp near Jordanian border

UNICEF chief hopes 2020 will be ‘a year of peace’ for Syria’s children

Working when sick is rising and harms you and your employer. This is why

Africa cannot afford to lose doctors to COVID-19

EU finally to extend sanctions on Russia despite arguments; Greece again in Europe’s spotlight

Out with the old: Young People transforming Humanitarian Action

A European student just sets the question of the day: What kind of education policies are missing in Europe?

Humanitarian aid: €7 million for disaster preparedness in Southern Africa and Indian Ocean region

Brexit: UK business fear of a no-deal scenario preparing for the worst

How Finland is fighting fake news – in the classroom

As Houthi forces withdraw from key Yemeni ports, UN monitoring chief welcomes ‘first practical step on the ground’

How to create a world where healthcare is a right, not a luxury

Is a full course lunch, a new Commissioner and 2 million anti-TTIP citizens what you would call a “Fresh Start”?

Romania: MEPs are deeply concerned about judicial independence and rule of law

3 steps to strengthen Europe’s competitiveness in the digital age

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s