State aid: France to recover €8.5 million of illegal aid to Ryanair at Montpellier airport

ryanair

(Lucas Davies, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you in association with the European Commission.


The European Commission has found that the marketing agreements concluded between the local Association for the Promotion of Touristic and Economic Flows (APFTE) and Ryanair at the airport of Montpellier are illegal under EU State aid rules. Ryanair now has to return €8.5 million of illegal State aid.

Commissioner Margrethe Vestager, in charge of competition policy, said: “Competition between airports and between airlines is crucial for consumers, growth and jobs. Our investigation showed that certain payments by the French local authorities in favour of Ryanair to promote Montpellier airport gave Ryanair an unfair and selective advantage over its competitors and caused harm to other regions and other regional airports. This is illegal under EU State aid rules. France must now recover the illegal State aid.”

Montpellier airport is a regional airport located in the French region of Occitanie. The airport served nearly 1.9 million passengers in 2018. Ryanair was present at the airport until April 2019.

Following a complaint by a competitor of Ryanair, in July 2018 the Commission opened an in-depth investigation into marketing agreements between the Association for the Promotion of Touristic and Economic Flows (Association de Promotion des Flux Touristiques et Economiques, “APFTE”) and Ryanair and its subsidiary AMS.

Between 2010 and 2017, APFTE concluded various marketing agreements with Ryanair and AMS, under which the airline and its subsidiary received payments worth around €8.5 million in exchange for promoting Montpellier and the surrounding area as a touristic destination on Ryanair’s website.

The Commission’s investigation revealed that:

  • The agreements with Ryanair were financed through State resources and were attributable to the State.APFTE is an association unrelated to the airport operator, funded almost entirely by regional and local French public entities. These public entities closely control the use of the association’s budget.
  • The payments in favour of Ryanair on the basis of the marketing agreements did not correspond to effective marketing needs of APFTE but only served as an incentive for Ryanair to maintain its operations at Montpellier airport.
  • APFTE either concluded the agreements directly with Ryanair and AMS and not with other airlines or organised public tenders that were biased towards Ryanair.

On this basis, the Commission found that the marketing agreements gave an undue and selective advantage to Ryanair over its competitors. The Commission therefore concluded that the agreements amounted to illegal and incompatible aid under EU State aid rules and that the advantage must be recovered.

Recovery

As a matter of principle, EU State aid rules require that incompatible State aid be recovered in order to remove the distortion of competition created by the aid. There are no fines under EU State aid rules and recovery does not penalise the company in question. It simply restores equal treatment with other companies.

France must now recover the illegal State aid amounting to around €8.5 million from Ryanair.

Background

In the aviation sector, the Commission’s guidelines on State aid to airports and airlines (see also MEMO) reflect the fact that public subsidies may under certain circumstance be used by regional airports or regional authorities to attract price-sensitive airlines to a specific airport. Such subsidies can typically take the form of low airport charges, discounts to airport charges, success fees or incentive payments to airlines as remuneration for alleged services – especially marketing.

Public authorities or publicly-owned regional airports may offer attractive conditions to airlines in order to boost their traffic. However, in principle, such conditions must not go beyond what a profit-driven operator would be prepared to offer under the same circumstances (the market economy operator principle). If this principle is not respected, the conditions offered to airlines involve State aid.

In the last few years, the Commission has concluded a number of cases regarding aid to airlines aimed at attracting or maintaining their aircraft capacity at certain airports, finding that they were not in line with State aid rules. For example, regarding the airports of Nîmes (in the catchment area of Montpellier airport), Pau, and Angoulême in France, Zweibrücken and Altenburg-Nobitz in Germany, Klagenfurt in Austria, and the Sardinian airports of Cagliari, Olbia and Alghero in Italy.

Also, the Commission is currently investigating further agreements between public authorities and airlines in certain regional airports, for example concerning the German airport of Frankfurt-Hahn or the Spanish airports of Reus and Girona.

The Commission considers that such measures can be very distortive on the highly-competitive, pan-European air transport market on intra-Union routes. Moreover, such measures can disadvantage regions and airports, which do not use unlawful State aid to attract airlines.

The non-confidential version of the decision will be made available under the case number SA.47867 in the State Aid Register on the Commission’s competition website once any confidentiality issues have been resolved. More information on the Commission’s state aid policy in the air transport sector is available in this policy brief.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

MEPs clear another hurdle for the COVID-19 recovery plan

Political consensus critical ahead of Somalia election: UN mission chief

UN chief saddened at news of death of former US President George H.W. Bush

Trump’s blasting win causes uncertainty and turbulence to the global financial markets

Two States ‘side-by-side’ is the ‘peaceful and just solution’ for Israel-Palestine conflict: Guterres

Sustainable development funding is broken. Here’s how to fix it

Why the next 4 months are crucial to the future of the ocean

Hate speech in the digital world a ‘critical obstacle for LGBTI people’: UN’s Bachelet

Europe enters uncharted waters with Kiev-Moscow standoff

The Fight for Women’s Rights

It’s not summer holidays what lead to the bad August of the German economy

EU summit: Are the London Tories planning an exit from the EU?

Track the spread of coronavirus around the world

The Ukrainian crisis to destabilize Europe and the world for a long time

5 world-changing ideas: our top picks for World Creativity and Innovation Day

The psychology of pandemics

Tech can reach the world’s unbanked women – but only if they tell us how it should work

UN health agency team in China to strengthen coronavirus response through partnership

Attempt to defy international law over Golan Heights sovereignty ‘doomed to failure’ Security Council hears

This South Korean city once had the biggest coronavirus outbreak outside of China. Now it’s reported zero new cases

THE COMMITTEES: ‘All roads lead to the Fifth’

Mergers: Commission opens in-depth investigation into proposed merger of Cargotec and Konecranes

World Editors Forum President: Credible media vital in the fight against COVID-19 and fake news epidemic

The Council of Europe adopts Recommendation on young people’s access to rights

The US will impose tariffs on Mexico, says President Trump

How the Irish people were robbed by banks, the Commission and their own government

Reforms in a few countries drive a decline in average OECD labour taxes

Medical students as the critical link to address climate change

Human Rights and Democracy: striving for dignity and equality around the world

Questions directors need to ask in the age of stakeholder capitalism

Human traffickers in Libya are posing as UN staff, says Refugee Agency

Amazon on fire: the interference in global health

A few, or rather two, trade and economic alliances may rule our brave new world

Latin America and Caribbean region deadliest for journalists in 2019

4 myths about manufacturing in the Fourth Industrial Revolution

Youth Guarantee putting young people in jobs

Can cybersecurity offer value for money?

Africa must become more resilient to climate risk. Here’s how

Ireland: prepare now for rising fiscal pressures, external risks

Why our future relies on more inclusive and transparent innovation

Coronavirus global response: EU allocates additional €50 million in humanitarian aid

Mobile health technology: Advances, Facilitations and Promotion of Autonomy

Except Poland, can climate change also wait until 2021 for the EU Market Stability Reserve to be launched?

Fragile countries risk being ‘stuck in a cycle of conflict and climate disaster,’ Security Council told

COVID-19 Wave III: Were the lessons learned from last year any useful?

Commission welcomes the political agreement on the transitional rules for the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP)

Berlin ‘orders’ the EU Parliament to compromise

How music can help children with autism connect

EU to Telcos: Stop Mergers and Acquisitions but please help me urgently with 5G development

US-China trade war at point of no return: Washington’s demands go beyond tariffs

European markets itchy with short-term disturbances

Ten reasons to be optimistic in 2019

From UN Assembly podium, Central African Republic leader appeals for lifting arms embargo

Parliament elects the von der Leyen Commission

4 reasons cities should embrace Universal Basic Income

UN chief condemns terror attack in Kismayo, Somalia

Facts, not fear, will stop COVID-19 – so how should we talk about it?

To realise the full potential of AI, we must regulate it differently

What is the Coral Triangle?

8 steps towards a sustainable economic recovery

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s