Does upgrading our minds mean losing the spark of genius?

Brain

(Jesse Orrico, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: George Church, Professor of genetics, Harvard Medical School & Murali Doraiswamy, Professor, Duke University Health System


No two human brains are identical – each one of the 7.5 billion humans on earth has a unique pattern of neural wiring and encoding that provides a personalized view of the world, odd quirks and all. Studies have measured variations in human traits such as IQ scores, attention span and empathy – even variation in how our eyes and brain process the colors we see. This “neurodiversity” is thanks to both genetic diversity – the combination of genes that we’ve inherited from our parents – and what we’ve been exposed to during our lifetimes.

But could science be used to reduce neurodiversity? And should it try? Already, many conventional drugs, such as cognitive enhancers, stimulants and antidepressants, act to reduce certain elements of neurodiversity. Non-invasive prenatal testing and other forms of genetic counseling also achieve that goal, typically to reduce the risk of passing along genetic diseases, while pre-implantation genetic testing selects specific genetic traits in babies.

New human enhancement and genetic technologies – notably CRISPR – are advancing at a rapid rate. Five gene therapies are already approved for clinical use in the US or Europe for some types of cancers and retinal disease, and many hundreds more are being tested. In mice, gene-editing techniques have been used to eliminate traumatic memories and implant new memories. More than a dozen single-gene variants (some not found in nature) have been shown to improve performance on one or more cognitive tasks in animals. Some also delay cognitive decline and are moving into clinical trials.

As research on the genes underlying normal cognitive, personality and social traits progresses, it’s possible that gene-editing will give us the power to select even more such traits. If parents want a designer baby with genes to maximize their intelligence, creativity and even personality, technology could make it possible. But what skills might be unintentionally lost, and what does this mean for humankind?

Neurodiversity underlies the powerful wisdom of crowds. Studies have shown that averaging solutions from a diverse group of people results in more accurate solutions. Diverse thinking leads to diverse capabilities – variations in the art, technology, and consumer products that people imagine and engineer. Quirks allow us to see things in a different light, fueling creativity, innovation and progress.

Certainly, it’s appropriate to argue for the ethical use of genetic advances to alter or eliminate schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, autism, obsessive compulsive disorder, dementia and other mental conditions that cause millions to suffer. But just as certainly, tinkering with the diversity of normal behavioral traits or states in people without illnesses, even making small adjustments, could unleash unintended consequences and ethical dilemmas.

Pursuing this avenue of research might be eased with advances in medical science and gene-editing techniques that could be deployed strategically. For example, rather than using genetics to completely eliminate certain traits or states of mind – those which don’t convey disability but render certain tasks difficult –the approach could instead dial these traits up or down. We might want to instill insensitivity to pain or diminish deafness, or to finely control concentration, creativity, memory, sleep, (day)dreams, or even blood flow and temperature in case of injury.

But the challenge is, as always, where to draw the line between an acceptable and unacceptable characteristic, and who draws that line? For every successful inventor with subclinical, mild ADHD or bipolar traits, there are millions who suffer the disabling consequences of ADHD and bipolar disorder. But where is the border between genius and disorder? Would it be ethical or even appropriate to conduct randomized trials to see what traits should be eliminated and which ones should not be? And what is CRISPR’s role in basic human feelings and beliefs such as love, hate, prejudice and spirituality? These are issues we have to consider carefully.

 

Today in Silicon Valley, it is widely recognized that people who think differently change the world. The bottom line is two-fold. Clearly, new genetic technologies offer people the promise of richer lives with a decreased risk of some serious diseases and disabilities. But if we want our richly creative and innovative world to thrive, we should also seek ways to embrace and preserve our diverse traits. Our future may depend on how well we can balance these needs.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

The EU Commission vies to screen Chinese investment in Europe

Diana in Vietnam

Climate change: Another year of record gas emissions, warns UN meteorological agency

INTERVIEW: UN’s top official in North Korea foresees ‘surge’ in humanitarian aid

Challenges remain in DPRK despite ‘slight’ improvements in health, wellbeing: UNICEF

UN agency ramps up effort to counter growing nuclear threat from cyberspace

As India’s lockdown ends, a mental health crisis is just beginning

First-ever global conference of national counter-terrorism chiefs will strengthen cooperation, build ‘resilient’ States, says top UN official

We should treat data as a natural resource. Here’s why

This Dutch company makes environmentally-friendly paint

Global migration, by the numbers: who migrates, where they go and why

Scientists now think air pollution is fuelling violent crime

UN human rights chief warns of women’s rights complacency

Cyprus banks under scrutiny

Egypt is building one of the world’s largest solar parks

Burkina Faso: Dozens killed in clashes, UN chief condemns attacks

EU Budget 2019: focus on the young, on migration and innovation

Austrian Presidency priorities discussed in committees

Japanese banks to move their European HQ from London to Frankfurt after Brexit

Syrian Constitutional Committee a ‘sign of hope’: UN envoy tells Security Council

India’s economy is an ‘elephant that is starting to run’, according to the IMF

Why is the EU launching a doomed policy in stopping immigrant waves? What are the real targets?

Health Education, is it a necessity?

Internet of Things: a Force for Good or Evil?

Africa’s Sahel must be a top priority for UN peacebuilding efforts, says commission

An all-out fight for the EU budget

From Kenya to China, here’s why countries should start working together on AI

Gender Equality and medicine in the 21st Century: we want the fair share

Top global firms commit to tackling inequality by joining Business for Inclusive Growth coalition

Matthias in Canada

India is now the world’s 5th largest economy

Can Kiev make face to mounting economic problems and social unrest?

The challenge to be a good healthcare professional

What next for Europe? Three (completely) different Davos views

UN Human Rights Council stands firm on LGBTI violence, Syria detainees and Philippines ‘war on drugs’

What’s happening to Greenland will affect the whole world – and our leaders need to understand why

Schengen: new rules for temporary checks at national borders

Employment and Social Developments in Europe: 2019 review highlights that tackling climate change can be a driver for growth and jobs

What happens after you recover from coronavirus? 5 questions answered

Mozambique pledging conference hopes to soften devastating blow of back-to-back cyclones

How the media can be a meaningful stakeholder in the quest to meet the SDGs

Mental Health in times of a pandemic: what can each individual do to lessen the burden?

Migration policy affects attractiveness of OECD countries to international talent

Apparently the EU Digital Single Market passes necessarily from China’s Digital Silk Road

Parliament names radio studio after journalists murdered in December attack

UN relief official in Yemen condemns ‘horrific’ attack on passenger buses

ECB’s Draghi favours a cheaper euro to serve all Eurozone countries

UN highlights need to solve growing burden of forcibly displaced Africans

Lagarde: Keep feeding the banks cut down wages and food subsidies

Central banking in times of complexity

How to unleash the enormous power of global healthcare data

Why Commissioner Rehn wants us all to work more for less

It’s time we took a seat ‘at your table’: Guterres calls on world youth to keep leading climate emergency response

Industry 4.0: Championing Europe’s fourth industrial revolution

Commission moves to ensure supply of personal protective equipment in the European Union

The battle for the 2016 EU Budget to shake the Union; Commission and Parliament vs. Germany

Non-performing loans: banks need to mitigate the risk of potential losses

How secure is blockchain?

Is Universal Health Coverage really available for all in the European Union?

Why Microsoft is a regular to Almunia’s

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s