Marriage equality boosted employment of both partners in US gay and lesbian couples

LGBTIQ

(Tanushree Rao, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Dario Sansone, Lecturer in the department of economics, University of Exeter


Progress towards marriage equality within the U.S. has been extremely rapid in the last twenty years. In 2004, Massachusetts became the first state to legalise same-sex marriage. Following its example, more and more states approved marriage equality until the ruling in 2015 of the US Supreme Court legalised same-sex marriage at the federal level. Were these amendments to marriage law a revolution with a profound impact for gays and lesbians? Or were they just a formal statement recognising that times have changed, but without substantive consequences beyond more marriage (and divorce) licenses?

There are reasons to believe that the economic consequences of same-sex marriage legalisation could be large. Similar past reforms – such as the passage of unilateral divorce laws – have substantially increased female labour force participation (Fernández et al., 2014). On the other hand, the effect could be small. LGBT activists have achieved several successes in the last twenty years, sustaining a steady, gradual improvement in attitudes towards homosexuality, that would now be reflected in the law.

The impact of same-sex marriage legalisation on employment is also unclear ex-ante. Access to marriage may have led to increased commitment among partners (Badgett, 2009) and lower economic uncertainty, as well as shifts in taxation, health insurance benefits, and adoption laws. These changes could have discouraged some individuals in a same-sex relationship from both being employed.

Conversely, homophobic sentiments – although underreported – are still widespread (Coffman et al., 2017). Gays and lesbians commonly experience discrimination from employers, consumers and co-workers (Plug et al., 2004Carpenter, 2007Drydakis, 2009). Researchers have already documented improvements in attitudes and social norms following the recognition of same-sex relationships in the U.S. (Keitzer et al, 2014Tankard et al., 2017) and in Europe (Aksoy et al., 2018). More generally, civil right legislation can affect social customs perceived by employers (Donohue et al., 1991). Therefore, it is possible that same-sex marriage legalisation led to an increase in employment among gays and lesbians since it drove a shift in social norms and a reduction in discrimination against sexual minorities.

Positive impact of same-sex marriage legalisation on employment

In a new paper, I use data between 2008 and 2016 from the largest available survey in the U.S. (the American Community Survey) to compare same-sex couples in states that introduced marriage equality, with same-sex couples in states that had yet to legalise same-sex marriage. Based on these comparisons, I conclude that individuals in gay and lesbian couples were more likely to be both employed following the legalisation of same-sex marriage. This increase (2.4 percentage points) is comparable to the impact of the passage of unilateral divorce laws (Stevenson, 2007) or the introduction of the contraceptive pill (Bailey, 2006).

I find a similar increase in the individual probability of being employed for both the household head and her spouse or unmarried partner. I do not observe any heterogeneity when examining male and female same-sex couples separately. I also obtain similar results when comparing opposite-sex and same-sex couples within the same state over time. Moreover, I find that the positive economic outcomes among same-sex couples were not at the expense of opposite-sex households, with employment levels for opposite-sex couples remaining stable before and after the same-sex marriage legislation.

I further extend the analysis to show that same-sex couples were more likely to work full-time and more hours per week following the introduction of marriage equality. Quite surprisingly, both gay and lesbian couples did not seem to be more prone to have children despite the extension of marriage. I do not find evidence of a surge in migration towards states that legalised SSM. Finally, as shown in Figure 1, the main findings are also supported using different data from the Survey of Income and Program Participation (SIPP). In addition, all estimates preceding the law changes are statistically indistinguishable from zero. These results rule out the hypothesis that improvements in the labour market were actually driven by changes in attitudes among the general population before same-sex marriage legalisation.

Image: SIPP

Discrimination as the underlying mechanism

I provide evidence supporting the hypothesis that same-sex marriage legalisation led to lower discrimination in the labour market, thus increasing employment levels among gay and lesbian workers.

The estimated increase in employment does not seem to be concentrated among married same-sex couples, but it extends to unmarried same-sex couples, singles, and “closeted” cohabitating individuals who hide their sexual preferences.The proportion of gay and lesbian workers in male-dominated occupations, including historically intolerant blue-collar jobs (Plug et al.,2014), increased since same-sex marriage legalisation.There were substantial and long-lasting declines in Google searches for homophobic terms following the legalisation of same-sex marriage.

Policy conclusions

Analogous to the increase in female labour force participation witnessed in the past decades, legalising same-sex marriage led to higher integration of same-sex couples in the workforce. A 2 per cent increase in the probability of being employed for 5 per cent of the U.S. labour force (a rough estimate of the gay and lesbian population) may have resulted in 160,000 additional individuals employed.

Same-sex marriage legalisation can thus stimulate economic growth and a more efficient allocation of human capital. Many countries in Latin America have recently legalised same-sex marriage or are considering changing their marriage laws. At the same time, homosexuality is ostracised or barely tolerated in most countries in Africa and South-East Asia. India just abolished its 150-year-old colonial sodomy law. This paper suggests that such laws may affect labour market outcomes in these countries, and it provides an economic rationale to support marriage equality.

This study also suggests that the legal recognition of same-sex couples by U.S. institutions is more than just words, but a powerful act. Each legislative decision has sent a signal to employers, co-workers, consumers, and LGBT members that social norms have changed and that discrimination is no longer tolerated.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

These are the world’s most future-proof cities

Schengen is losing ground fast revealing Europe’s clear inability to deal with migration crisis

4 ways to cyberproof your business during mergers & acquisitions

Eurozone: Black economy loves the South

IMF launches a new offensive against Germany

Is it impossible to place the banks under control?

MEPs strongly welcome the Global Compact on Migration

Connectivity and collaboration in the ICT industry: the key to socio-economic development

Commission deepens criticism on German economic policies

Stricter rules and tougher sanctions for market manipulation and financial fraud

It’s getting harder to move data abroad. Here’s why it matters and what we can do

New UN report shows record number of children killed and maimed in conflict

IPCC reports devastating climate consequences; US in denial while EU does not fully support the 2050 net zero emissions target

Those who produce food are among world’s hungriest – UN rights expert

What happiness can teach us about how we measure human development

Nauru President warns of possible climate change ‘economic Armageddon’

FROM THE FIELD: Weeding out Mexico’s unwanted beach invader

Can We(esterners) ever understand (the) Chinese

Political solutions ‘prerequisite to sustainable peace’, Lacroix tells Security Council

‘Bring to life’ precious moments caught on film or tape, UN agency urges on World Day

Central American migrants must be protected, urge UN experts

These technologies are playing a major role at the Cricket World Cup

What are the real debates surrounding immigration in an increasingly globalized world?

EU and international donors pledge €1.15 billion for reconstruction after the earthquake in Albania

A roadmap for destination management in the digital economy

Britain offers more money for an orderly Brexit but the Irish question resurges

Ebola in DR Congo: New transmission chain risks reversing major gains

Brexit: MEPs concerned about citizens’ rights

Shanghai has tough new recycling rules – and it will stop collecting trash from communities that don’t comply

My unlimited China

UN chief praises Africa for keeping ‘hearts and borders open’ in refugee crisis

5G in Russia: a local and global view on the way forward, in association with The European Sting

UN chief ‘deeply alarmed’ over military offensive in south-west Syria

Globalization 4.0 means harnessing the power of the group

Migration crisis, a human crisis after all

These four countries are the happiest in the European Union

Draghi left alone with no hope of boosting EU growth as Merkel just focuses on next elections

UN condemns ‘heinous’ suicide attack on education centre in Afghanistan

David Attenborough’s worried about this ocean threat – and it’s not plastic

E-commerce is globalization’s shot at equality

Why salaries could finally be on the way up

The Arctic is having holes stabbed through it at an alarming rate

TTIP wins first crucial EU test: MEPs give in to the trade agreement

Employment: Commission proposes €1.6 million from Globalisation Adjustment Fund to help 400 workers made redundant in Carrefour Belgique

“A Junior Enterprise is run only by students.. there are no professors or managers that can help you solve your problems”

ECOFIN: Choosing between the re-unification of Eurozone and a stalemate

This incredibly detailed map of Africa could help aid and development

Financing the 2030 Agenda: What is it and why is it important?

Mental Health Policy, a significant driver for growth

G20 LIVE: Fact Sheet from the G20 Leaders Summit and key outcomes (G20 Antalya 2015 Summary)

A Europe that Protects: Commission calls for decisive action on security priorities

Palestinian children’s education deeply impacted by ‘interference’ around West Bank schools, UN warns

AI will drive the societies of the future. Will the governed consent?

The issue of mental health for modern young doctors

Millennials (and Gen X) – Here are the steps you should take to secure your financial future

EU joint response to disasters: deal reached with Council

The Commission calls for a climate neutral Europe by 2050*

“An open China brings opportunities to Europe”, a Sting Exclusive by China’s Ambassador to EU

Poverty and social exclusion skyrocket with austerity

UN chief extends condolences to families of China landslide casualties

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s