Six steps that can help us to tackle homelessness

Homeless 2019__

Seattle, United States (Steve Knutson, Unsplash)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Alina Turner, School of Public Policy, University of Calgary & Diana Krecsy, Calgary Homeless Foundation


Homelessness remains a critical challenge in both developing and developed countries. According to recent official estimates, about 235,000 people experience homelessness in any given year in Canada, while 553,742 do in the United States. With the exception of Finland and Norway, many countries in Europe have reported increasing numbers of people experiencing homelessness in recent years:

Germany: +150% (2014–16)

Ireland: +145% (2014–17)

Belgium: +96% (2008–16)

Austria +32% (2008–16)

Spain: +20% (2014–16)

England: +15% (2016–17)

These concerning trends have spurred policy-makers and service providers to explore new approaches, including Housing First, systems planning, and investments in supportive and affordable housing. As we learn more about the causes and dynamics of homelessness, we realize that we cannot resolve the issue in the homeless-serving system (the range of local and regional services that serve the homeless).

As a fusion of policy issues, homelessness involves actors, policies and services across government levels and departments, NGOs, the private sector and informal organizations. These form a complex ecosystem that people at risk of experiencing homelessness have to navigate. As a result of this understanding, significant efforts have been introduced to enhance the integration of these services, under the assumption that what we need is better coordination to improve access and efficiencies.

You can picture integration by imagining a network with nodes of activity, interests, people and resources as different parts of the systems that provide services to the homeless. The key then is to focus on which nodes offer clients the best outcomes. These include social services, education, justice, housing, health, children’s services and income support.

Despite work across jurisdictions, efforts to integrate have at times complicated an already uncoordinated service system with additional layers of administration. The unintended consequence has been to make access to support even harder to navigate and negotiate for vulnerable populations.

This brings us to some key questions. What is the role of integration in preventing and ending homelessness? When is it appropriate and desirable? And under what circumstances is it detrimental?

In a research report published through the School of Public Policy at the University of Calgary, we propose six key tenets to consider when introducing new integration measures in efforts to address homelessness (and other complex social issues).

Why should we care about integration?

In 2017, Canadian charities generated $86 billion in revenues primarily through contracts with provincial and federal government, complemented by donations. Of this, our paper estimates that over $27 billion is spent annually on about 170,000 services to deal with mental health, addiction, homelessness, violence and poverty, each with their own target populations, eligibility criteria and funding sources.

In the US, a comparable figure is elusive, as much of the funding for the homelessness “ecosystem” is received piecemeal from federal, state and local governments, private foundations and donors. Direct federal investment totalled $2.5 billion in 2018 for homeless assistance services such as housing, food, education, employment, health and other support services. This is a sizeable amount that unfortunately fails to capture the full scale of resources at play.

 

Despite this dizzying array of support, the most commonly cited concern for those struggling with life’s challenges is that they don’t know where and how to access help. Not surprisingly, decision-makers in funding and government roles also report a lack of understanding around which services are actually operating on the ground, and how they relate to each other. As a result, there’s a strong impetus for improved integration to make sense of the confusing web of support.

When integration goes wrong

However, at times we find that our efforts to make the system more transparent and easier to access have the exact opposite effect. We found evidence from diverse jurisdictions where solutions to integration challenges have actually added more bureaucracy, and therefore even more barriers on the front line.

In Canada, we saw task forces, committees and services being created to deal with complex client needs that had no line of sight to actual client outcomes. In some cases, there were almost as many integration initiatives as clients they sought to help (with tens of government and NGO staff involved in meeting and planning over countless hours).

In other instances, intended improvements for patients and clients were not only never achieved, but in fact worsened because of the additional demands of integration on front line workers. In England, auditors found no compelling evidence to show that integration among social and health services led to sustainable financial savings or reduced health system use. In a US example, integration of service delivery systems for homeless persons with serious mental illness in 15 cities showed limited integration at the system level.

We have to consistently probe the assumption that integration will increase efficiency and reduce costs, which in turn will create better individual and population-level outcomes. Integration efforts will not automatically improve efficiencies; second, more integration does not automatically equal better outcomes for clients or populations; third, system efficiencies are not the same thing as client outcomes (nor does one magically beget the other). The simplest example of the fault in this logic is cutting front line staff to save costs, thereby reducing care for clients.

If integration isn’t a silver bullet, when is it a good idea?

Our research offers a six-part framework to help community leaders and policy-makers involved in such efforts to resist the urge to jump onto another task force, pilot programme or committee.

Articulating how best to move multiple and complex networks involved in homelessness as a coordinated ecosystem is no easy task. It asks for different commitment, thinking, mutual trust, relationships and time. It brings new risks and challenges to individual and organizational stakeholders.

There is no doubt that more effective delivery is needed, in addition to improved integration across agencies, systems and policies, to address complex social challenges like homelessness. However, such efforts must be done with intention so as not simply to add more layers of bureaucracy to an already confusing service network. The focus must remain on the clients, and not on the systems involved.

Integration should not be considered a cure-all for what ails the system. Rather, it would be more realistic to take a transformative and deliberate approach to collaboration and change.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

EU job-search aid worth €9.9 million for 1,858 former Air France workers

Children are so hungry in one British town they are eating from bins

EU tourism industry expects a new record year in 2014

UN chief extends condolences to families of China landslide casualties

Will Cameron succeed in keeping UK inside the EU and reverse the present economic downturn?

99 per cent of intravenous drug users lack access to health, ‘social services with dignity’ says UNAIDS chief

3 ways firms can master the digital challenges of the 4IR

Hunger, displacement and disease: 4.3 million people remain in dire need of aid in Chad

Ensure that widows are ‘not left out or left behind’, UN chief urges on International Day

Myanmar: Conflict resolution at ‘total standstill’, military commanders must answer for crimes against humanity

European Commissioner for Youth wants young people to be at heart of policy making

How to outsmart bias when you’re recruiting

Five ways to increase trust in e-commerce

Reforms in the Western Balkans and Turkey: annual assessments and recommendations

Electronic or conventional cigarettes – which is safer?

Online radio and news broadcasts: Parliament and Council reach deal

New Syria fighting represents ‘giant powder keg’, warns aid veteran, as he leaves UN stage

A bad marriage can be as unhealthy as smoking and drinking

Tsipras doesn’t seem to have learned his “almost Grexit” lesson and Greece faces again financial and political dead end

Posting of workers: final vote on equal pay and working conditions

Why do overwhelming proportions of EU’s youth feel excluded?

Violence against women a ‘mark of shame’ on our societies, says UN chief on World Day

Commission calls on Leaders to pave the way for an agreement on a modern, balanced and fair EU budget for the future

Cyprus banks under scrutiny

Russia and the EU ‘trade’ natural gas supplies and commercial concessions in and out of Ukraine

A Sting Exclusive: “The competitiveness of Europe depends on a digital single market”, EPP President Joseph Daul highlights live from European Business Summit 2015

EU and African leaders to jointly tackle the migration crisis across the Mediterranean

Investors have a role in securing our shared digital future

Why do US presidential elections last so long? And 4 other things you need to know

‘We will not give up on looking for peace for South Sudan’: UN deputy chief

Around 260,000 children in DR Congo’s Kasai region suffering severe acute malnutrition

Parliament wants to suspend EU accession negotiations with Turkey

18th EU Eco-Innovation Forum in Barcelona shows the way for Europe’s new Environmental policy

Are the G20 leaders ready to curb corporate tax-avoidance?

Eurozone: Even good statistics mean deeper recession

Civil protection: Parliament strengthens EU disaster response capability

‘Critical moment’ for sustainable development, UN chief tells major financing forum

Is the English language too powerful?

Viktor Orbán, Hungarian Prime Minister, at a 2015 event in Brussels, Berlaymont. (Copyright: European Union , 2015; Source: EC - Audiovisual Service; Photo: Lieven Creemers)

Hungary and Ireland build front to say no to EU tax harmonisation plan

SoftLayer, an IBM company, @ TheNextWeb 2014: Masters of Failure and Change

Does Draghi have another ace up his sleeve given his Quantitative Easing failure?

Soil pollution ‘jeopardizing’ life on Earth, UN agency warns on World Day

North-east Nigeria displacement crisis continues amid ‘increased sophistication’ of attackers, warns UN

3 ways to fight stress at work

Most people on the internet live in this country

‘Climate change is the battle of my life’, UN chief tells students living on the frontline in Fiji

Humanitarian aid: €7 million for disaster preparedness in Southern Africa and Indian Ocean region

As many as 330,000 displaced by heavy fighting in south-west Syria – UN agency

Is Haiti better prepared for disasters, nine years on from the 2010 earthquake?

Climate change and health: an everyday solution

This is our chance to completely redefine the meaning of work

Visiting North Korea, UN relief chief spotlights funding shortfall to meet humanitarian needs

The United Kingdom’s decision to leave the European Union will impact young people’s future the most

JADE Testimonial #2: Jacques @ Process mapping

The Czech economy is thriving but boosting skills and productivity and transitioning to a low-carbon productive model is vital to sustainable and inclusive growth

African cities will double in population by 2050. Here are 4 ways to make sure they thrive

Peacekeeping chief highlights challenges facing UN Police

We are on the edge of a new ‘cyber’ space age. This is how we make it a success

How will the NATO-EU competition evolve in the post Brexit era?

IMF: Sorry Greece, Ireland, Portugal we were wrong!

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s