EU Copyright Directive: Will US tech giants comply or ditch the EU market?

EP Press conference on the copyright directive
Date: 26/03/2019 © European Union 2019 – Source : EP
Photo: Mathieu CUGNOT

The Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) approved yesterday the new Copyright Directive by 348 votes in favour, 274 against and 36 abstentions. Should the member states accept this vote, the reforms will be effective immediately and EU countries will have two years to implement them.

The copyright changes will affect mainly big online platforms such as YouTube, Facebook and Google News, which despite their long fight and opposition on this issue, will eventually have to comply or else leave the EU to avoid being fined. However, smaller companies as well could be influenced to a certain extent as the cost of this law’s implementation might be very high and could drive some of them out of business even.

Directive’s analysis

According to the European Parliament (EP), the directive’s goal is to create a framework where large tech firms share their revenue with rights holders such as musicians, performers and script authors who will be able to make a better agreement for the use of their works. However, the way this can be achieved is being left to the online platforms which, even if they aren’t obliged to incorporate filters, they should find the tools to ensure that unremunerated material is not on their site.

Snippets of news articles can continue appearing in Google News as long as they are “very short”. Online platforms such as Wikipedia and GitHub would be excluded from the directive’s spectrum. Furthermore, start-up platforms, which exist less than three years, have a turnover of less than 10 million euros and their audience does not overpass 5 million unique viewers per month, will face a much lighter burden meaning that their only obligation will be to remove the unauthorised works from their website.

Post-vote reactions

The European Commission welcomed the new Copyright Directive and said that it promotes the values and ideals of Europe. More specifically, Vice-President for the Digital Single Market Andrus Ansip and Commissioner for Digital Economy and Society Mariya Gabriel said yesterday: “The Copyright Directive protects freedom of expression, a core value of the European Union. It sets strong safeguards for users, making clear that everywhere in Europe the use of existing works for purposes of quotation, criticism, review, caricature as well as parody are explicitly allowed. At the same time, the Directive will improve the position of creators in their negotiations with big platforms which largely benefit from their content. Writers, journalists, singers, musicians and actors will find it easier to negotiate better deals with their publishers or producers.”

Monique Goyens, Director General of the European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) objected to article 13 (now article 17) of the proposed law which will lead platforms to use upload filters to prevent unlicensed copyrighted content from being published online. In detail, Monique Goyens mentioned:  “We fully support the aim of ensuring fair remuneration for creators, but this should not happen to the detriment of consumers. There is a very high risk that the new law will do more harm than good. This is not the modernised copyright law that creators and consumers need but rather another attempt to protect an industry that has consistently resisted to deal with the impact of technological change on their business model.”

US giants’ response

Google together with Twitter and Facebook would be certainly among the companies to be heavily affected by the new copyright directive. Google’s reaction after EP’s approval was imminent and awaited. A Google spokesperson told the Guardian that: “The EU copyright directive is improved but will still lead to legal uncertainty and will hurt Europe’s creative and digital economies. The details matter, and we look forward to working with policymakers, publishers, creators and rights holders as EU member states move to implement these new rules.” Similarly, YouTube said in a press release that “Article 13 could still have unintended consequences that may harm Europe’s creative and digital economy”.

A spokesperson of Twitter expressed the firm’s worries regarding the future of internet after yesterday’s outcome and stated that “will continue to engage with EU member states and civil society as the implementation process evolves”. Facebook though declined to comment on this topic; at least for the time being.

Thus, the hefty lobbying of the US companies didn’t pay off as the Directive is about to become a law once the EU member states approve it in the coming weeks. The online platforms will then be forced to either leave the EU, as Google had stated in the past for Google News, or adapt to the new digital reforms. Which of the two outcomes will prevail?

Is Google going to remove its infamous News service from the Old Continent entirely as it has done so in the past in Spain due to national copyright law changes? The latter seems quite improbable and is most likely that the tech firm will modify its business model and strategy in order to adjust to the upcoming copyright alterations.

All in all, the Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market, even if it aims at empowering freedom of expression and holders’ rights, is still too ambiguous and might not bring the wished outcome, as the past has shown in similar laws implemented in Germany and Spain. Another point that also needs to be stressed is the fact that online platforms’ filtering could lead to excluding not only unauthorized but also legitimate content; unless more innovative solutions and tools are being incorporated.

The above copyright reforms are of course about to constitute EU law once all key member states approve the text adopted by the EP during the European Council’s vote in April.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Climate change is destroying a barrier that protects the US from hurricanes

Why the fight against nature loss should be a business priority

In an era of global uncertainty, the SDGs can be our guide

Fair completion rules and the law of gravity don’t apply to banks

State aid: Commission approves €380 million German rescue aid to Condor

Future fit: 3 ways fashion can be more sustainable

Data Protection Regulation one year on: 73% of Europeans have heard of at least one of their rights

The British are the most positive in Europe on the benefits of immigration

FROM THE FIELD: ‘A piece of me’ was taken

Ignorance or Refusal: Determinants in the individual’s choice for palliative care

EU Commission – US hasten talks to avoid NGO reactions on free trade agreement

France breaks budget promises once again and the EU’s finance offices are shaking

6 ways social innovators are responding to the COVID-19 pandemic

Hope for ‘long-elusive progress’ in negotiating peace in eastern Ukraine

Australia’s record heatwave: From fainting tennis players to dead fish

Yemen war: UN chief urges good faith as ‘milestone’ talks get underway in Sweden

WHO chief underscores need to address climate change following visit to Bahamas

The impact of COVID-19 on the life of the elderly

5 Ways Companies Can Progress More Women into Leadership Roles

This Latin American country is keeping COVID-19 firmly under control. How?

Shaping Europe’s digital future: op-ed by Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission

Reducing disaster risk is a good investment, and ‘the right thing to do’, says Guterres

Burning Amazon rainforests: Darting towards the doom of Human Race

Young people meet in Malta to shape the future of Europe

The four top Americans who flew to Europe perplexed things about Trump’s intentions

3 actions for business to prepare for a post-pandemic future

Germany and OSCE support an east-west dialogue in Ukraine without exclusions

The global liberal order is in trouble – can it be salvaged, or will it be replaced?

Humanitarian Aid 2016: The needs, the highlights, the crisis and the relief

Thursday’s Daily Brief: Safeguarding civilians, strengthening Ebola response in DR Congo, marking Fistula Day, updates on CAR and Syria

Burundi election countdown amid ‘deteriorating’ human rights situation

This Syrian national has been trapped at Kuala Lumpur airport for 3 months

UN chief urges Hamas and Israel to ‘step back from the brink of another devastating conflict’ in Gaza

EU’s new environmental policy on biofuels impacts both the environment and the European citizen

These 3 countries are global offshore wind powerhouses

We need to talk about mental health at work, say employees

COVID-19, higher education and the impact on society: what we know so far and what could happen

Investing in education and skills can improve the health of both humans and planet. Here’s why

We need better alignment between climate and trade. Here’s a roadmap

The unpleasant truth of plastic straws

Asia and Pacific on course to miss all Sustainable Development Goals, says UN region chief

How global tech companies can champion ethical AI

European Union launches WTO trade dispute against Colombia’s unfair duties on frozen fries

EU Cohesion policy: Commission and EBRD promote innovative use of data in public procurement involving EU funds

FROM THE FIELD: What do you want to be when you grow up? One day I will…

Why the downturn is good news for subscription companies

Aid convoy for north-east Syria postponed over security concerns – UN relief chief

China’s stock markets show recovery signs while EU is closely watching in anticipation of the €10bn investment

Governments should step up their efforts to give people skills to seize opportunities in a digital world

Digital Single Market: Europe announces eight sites to host world-class supercomputers

Technological innovation can bolster trust and security at international borders. Here’s how

Challenges remain in DPRK despite ‘slight’ improvements in health, wellbeing: UNICEF

Gender Hierarchy in Medicine: From University to Specialization

On youth unemployment: unemployment is even bleaker for youth with disabilities

Youth not prioritised in new Commission

Can ECB’s €60 billion a month save Eurozone?

‘Complacency’ a factor in stagnating global vaccination rates, warn UN health chiefs

The EU Commission is lying to the “Right2Water” campaign

‘You can and should do more’ to include people with disabilities, wheelchair-bound Syrian advocate tells Security Council in searing speech

Guterres lauds UN peacekeeping, highlights need to bridge ‘critical’ gaps

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s