Why protectionism spells trouble for global economic growth

trump 2019.jpg

UN Photo/Cia Pak President Donald Trump of the United States addresses the seventy-third session of the United Nations General Assembly.

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Jonathan D. Ostry, Deputy Director, International Monetary Fund (IMF)


It is sometimes alleged that for all the microeconomic distortions that protectionist policies inflict, there can be a silver lining in terms of macroeconomic gains: more jobs, more output and a stronger trade balance. Indeed, some economies today are seemingly using commercial policy to pursue macroeconomic objectives. Tariffs can dampen imports, boost net exports (the difference between exports and imports, or the trade balance), and so boost GDP, other things being equal.

Economists, however, have generally been skeptical. Since the time of Adam Smith (or maybe even before), open and competitive markets have been seen as most likely to maximize output by directing resources more productively. Tariffs, on the other hand, encourage both the deflection of trade to inefficient producers and smuggling in order to evade them; such distortions reduce any beneficial effects. Further, consumers lose more from tariffs than producers gain, so there is deadweight loss. And the redistributions associated with tariffs tend to create vested interests, so harm tends to persist. Broad-based protectionism can also provoke retaliation, which adds further costs in other markets.

Moreover, economists believe macroeconomic policies (fiscal and monetary policies such as interest rates or the budget deficit) to be the natural instruments for achieving macroeconomic goals, such as raising growth and jobs. Tariffs are more likely to lead to offsetting changes in exchange rates that frustrate the achievement of macroeconomic objectives; less imports and a stronger trade balance increase demand for the domestic currency, and so its value.

The economic effect of tariffs

These results are for the full country sample as listed in Table 2 of NBER WP 25402/CEPR DP13389.

There is in addition a powerful lesson from history. Protectionist policies helped precipitate the collapse of international trade in the 1930s, and this trade shrinkage was a plausible seed of World War II. So while protectionism has not been much used in practice as a macroeconomic policy, most economists emphatically consider that this is as it should be.

But times change. Some economies today are using commercial policy seemingly for macroeconomic objectives. Can we say something about what the likely practical consequences of such actions are likely to be? In a recent study covering the vast majority of developed and developing countries in the world, and half a century’s-worth of macroeconomic data, we examined the responses of six key macroeconomic variables to changes in the tariff rate: real GDP, productivity, the unemployment rate, the real exchange rate, the trade balance and inequality.

We found that tariff increases have adverse domestic macroeconomic and distributional consequences: these effects are robustly and statistically significant, and are large enough in an economic sense to merit the attention of policymakers.

We also found that output (GDP) falls after tariffs rise because of a significant decrease in labour productivity. When firms in the import-competing sectors receive protection, resources are reallocated within the economy to relatively unproductive uses, and this is harmful to the added value generated by the economy. That is, the wasteful effects of protectionism lead to a meaningful reduction in the efficiency with which labour is used, and thus to a fall in output. Nor did we find an improvement in the trade balance after a rise in tariffs, plausibly reflecting our finding that the real exchange rate tends to appreciate as a result of higher tariffs (a prediction that is in line with theory and much earlier empirical evidence). We also found that protectionism leads to a small increase in unemployment, further bolstering the case against protectionism, and that tariff increases lead to greater inequality after a few years.

 

We found that the hit to economic growth from a tariff increase is more pronounced if the tariff increase is undertaken during an economic expansion. It is also larger for advanced countries than it is for developing countries. This is worrisome, since tariffs are currently being used as a macroeconomic instrument in buoyant economic conditions and in advanced economies.

To summarize: the aversion of the economics profession to the deadweight losses caused by protectionism seems warranted. While the case against protectionism has typically been bolstered by theoretical or microeconomic evidence, the macroeconomic case for liberal trade is also strong. Higher tariffs seem to lower output and productivity, while raising unemployment and inequality, and leaving the trade balance unaffected. These results are wholly consistent with conventional wisdom from standard economics, and bolster the case for free trade. Protectionism just weakens the macroeconomy.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Tax evasion and fraud threaten the European project

Why the ocean holds the key to sustainable development

US and Mexico child deportations drive extreme violence and trauma: UNICEF

Parliament sets up plan to fight the 3,600 criminal rings of EU

Ukraine takes EU money and runs to sign with Russia

UN health agency developing COVID-19 virus treatment master plan

We generate 125,000 jumbo jets worth of e-waste every year. Here’s how we can tackle the problem

Dear Davos: time to declare an emergency opportunity for people and planet

Would a digital border tax slow down adoption of 3D printing?

Why medical students decide to study abroad?

Germany fears that Americans and Russians want to partition Europe again

How microfinance develops decent work

‘Champion for multilateralism’ readies to hand over UN General Assembly gavel

Rohingya crisis: EU strengthens humanitarian support with €10 million

Businesses can lead a revolution in disability inclusion

Eurozone: Economic Sentiment Indicator recovering losses

This underwater restaurant teaches you about the ocean while you eat

‘Counter and reject’ leaders who seek to ‘exploit differences’ between us, urges Guterres at historic mosque in Cairo

Joint advocacy letter template to sign and ratify the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons

Here are 5 new green laws coming into force in 2020

Hatred ‘a threat to everyone’, urges Guterres calling for global effort to end xenophobia and ‘loathsome rhetoric’

Combatting terrorism: Parliament sets out proposals for a new EU strategy

Africans can fight COVID-19 with stakeholder capitalism

Have Europe’s Ukrainian wounds begun to heal?

Africa’s Sahel must be a top priority for UN peacebuilding efforts, says commission

Main results of EU-Japan summit: Tokyo, 17/07/2018

Rising landmine blast toll in Afghanistan highlights long-term care needs of survivors

What the future holds for the EU – China relations?

Gender equality and medicine in the 21st century

Here’s how a circular economy could change the world by 2030

How AI and satellite imaging can stamp out modern slavery

COVID-19: Single market must emerge stronger from the crisis, say MEPs

Parliament supports European Green Deal and pushes for even higher ambitions

This AI outperformed 20 corporate lawyers at legal work

Trump’s Syrian hit the softest option vis-a-vis Russia

Antitrust: Commission opens investigation into possible anti-competitive conduct of Amazon

‘Bleakest period yet’ in Occupied Palestinian Territory: UN human rights expert

OECD presents analysis showing significant impact of proposed international tax reforms

Brexit: UK business fear of a no-deal scenario preparing for the worst

How robotics can help humanitarians bridge the digital divide

These are the 3 key skill sets workers will need to learn by 2030

AI can be a game-changer for the world’s forests. Here’s how

100 years on, UN labour agency mission focussed on growing inequality, says Director-General

Palm Oil: With Malaysia cracking down on production, what’s the alternative?

‘Terminator’ warlord Bosco Ntaganda sentenced to 30 years in prison for DR Congo atrocities

Sudan: UN chief deplores excessive force used against pro-democracy protesters, calls on military and civilian leaders to ‘stay the course’ in negotiations

WEF Davos 2016 LIVE: “CO2 is not the problem, it is the symptom”, the pilots who crossed the world using solar energy cry out from Davos

IMF’s Lagarde indirectly cautioned Eurozone on deflation

The Dead Sea is drying up, and these two countries have a plan to save it

The gateway to carbon pricing? Air pollution policy

Eurozone governed by an obscure body and gray procedures

Afghanistan: Civilian casualties caused by IEDs has reached ‘extreme levels’, UN warns

How migrants who send money home have become a global economic force

Coronavirus emergency: here’s what we know so far

Why Indian students are going abroad to become Doctors?

Development aid drops in 2018, especially to neediest countries

Senior UN adviser sees ‘rare’ victory for humanitarian diplomacy as aid convoy reaches desert camp in Syria

How can we produce enough protein to feed 10 billion people?

The EU launches € 1 billion plan on supercomputers and tries to catch-up with competitors

4 things President Trump could learn from Jimmy Carter

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s