Poverty data never tells the whole story

poverty

(Unsplash, 2019)

This article is brought to you thanks to the collaboration of The European Sting with the World Economic Forum.

Author: Clayton Christensen, Professor of Business Administration, Harvard Business School & Efosa Ojomo, Senior Research Fellow, Global Prosperity, Clayton Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation & Karen Dillon, Senior Researcher, Global Prosperity, Clayton Christensen Institute for Disruptive Innovation


As global leaders gather at the World Economic Forum to discuss some of the world’s most pressing issues, including inequality and poverty, many will share data to illustrate a phenomenon. However, countries that focus on creating prosperity and not just merely eradicating poverty react differently to data on poverty.

Alleviating poverty is not the same as creating prosperity

Hard as it may be to believe, decades ago Singapore was very impoverished, and one of the main initiatives of the government was to educate its citizens. But when Dr. Goh Keng Swee, one of Singapore’s ministers, would see hundreds of children streaming out of school at the end of the day, instead of being happy, he was heartbroken. He and the Singaporean government understood that simply attending school wasn’t enough. What would the students do after they graduated? How would the economy create and sustain jobs for all these newly educated children? Those were the questions that Dr. Keng Swee was asking.

Focusing on creating prosperity – in contrast to focusing on alleviating poverty – compelled Dr. Keng Swee and the government to ask entirely different questions, pursue different activities and emphasize different metrics. Instead of mostly focusing on the data, they focused on the deeper underlying phenomena. And so, instead of primarily building schools, Singapore prioritized investments and innovation and attracted companies that created jobs. This decision increased the need for education.

As a result, Singapore has become one of the richest nations in the world with a GDP per capita of approximately $57,714. And today, not only do approximately 99% of people attend secondary school, but more than half go on to get a post-secondary school diploma. What would have happened if – as many nations do today – Singapore focused primarily on the data of how many children were educated? It might not be as successful today. The phenomena – the realities on the ground – drive the data.

With trillions of dollars spent in official development assistance over the past several decades, and hundreds of billions spent annually, we believe that if more nations focused on realities underlying the data, we would not only eradicate poverty in the next couple of decades, but we set nations on a path to creating long-term economic prosperity.

What the data hides

Over the past three decades, more than 1 billion people have lifted themselves out of extreme poverty. The rate of global poverty is down from 37% in 1990 to approximately 10% today. But a vast majority of the people who have escaped poverty are from China (approximately 800 million people) and to a lesser extent, India (approximately 200 million).

Poverty in many countries in sub-Saharan Africa is actually on the rise, with no signs of slowing down. In addition, nearly half the world’s population – 3.4 billion people – live on less than $5.50 a day and struggle to meet their basic needs. The problem is that this data can be deceptive. We are awash in data, and we do need this information. But data, metrics and statistics are simply representations of particular phenomena and are not the phenomena themselves.

Consider another example. The data shows that primary and secondary school enrolment rates are now almost on par with rates in high-income countries. That’s a good thing. However, what the data doesn’t illustrate as clearly is that the quality of education couldn’t be more different. In low- and middle-income countries, for instance, more than half the students in school (over 617 million) are not achieving minimum proficiency levels, according to a United Nations study. In sub-Saharan Africa, the number is about 90%. In addition, international assessments of literacy and numeracy show that the average student in a low-income country performs worse than 95% of the students in high-income countries. What this ultimately means is that students are attending school, but are not learning. This is important because programs, laws and investments can cause the statistics to nominally improve, even when reality is going in a different direction.

The importance of understanding the phenomena

In most corporations, a very common measure of success for a firm is the return on net assets (RONA), which is the ratio of income divided by its assets. In essence, RONA tells us how well a company utilizes its assets. If the firm’s RONA goes up, one interpretation might be that customers are willing to pay higher prices for the company’s products.

But RONA can hide the real story. Managers, for instance, can manipulate the ratio by outsourcing as many activities as possible, thereby reducing the assets on their balance sheets. This causes RONA to go up as well. When a company outsources, say, the manufacturing, testing or distribution activity, the company is able to remove assets from its balance sheet, thereby increasing its RONA. There’s nothing inherently wrong with this, but it matters because it could be masking something far more worrying. In essence, what might seem to be, on paper, the story of a company that is thriving, could be more complex. A company might be able to operate with these inflated RONA numbers for years, but eventually the chickens come home to roost. By then, it is usually too late. Fewer corporations illustrate this better than Dell Computer.

Dell Computer hit its stride in the 1990s and quickly became one of the most successful and profitable computer companies in the world. But over time, in an attempt to continually improve its efficiency metrics and financial ratios such as RONA, the company outsourced many of its operations to a Taiwanese company, Asus. Profitability skyrocketed, and Dell analysts rewarded the company accordingly. The data looked good, but the phenomena behind the data – the innovative prowess of the company – didn’t. In 2005, after Dell had outsourced enough activities to Asus, effectively putting the company into business, Asus announced the creation of its own brand of computers. And the rest, as they say, became history. All along, the numbers had looked good to Dell. But what the numbers had not shown was the impact these decisions would have on Dell’s future.

In a similar way, the metrics of poverty might improve, but that doesn’t mean that the phenomena of poverty are getting better. It might even be getting worse. But it need not be this way. Countries can reliably and sustainably overcome poverty and, indeed many have; however, they did not do it mainly by trying to eradicate poverty. They did it by focusing on creating prosperity. On the surface, the difference between the two strategies may seem like mere semantics, but that couldn’t be farther from the truth.

the sting Milestones

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

5 ways for businesses to walk the talk on gender equality

France is building a village for people with Alzheimer’s

These are the 4 most likely scenarios for the future of energy

Coronavirus spread now a global emergency declares World Health Organization

Mali peace process in a ‘critical phase’, says head of UN Mission

What kind of action on social justice should we expect from companies in the future?

Fit for Future platform selects EU initiatives for simplification and modernisation

Mexico: Helping refugees go into business, a ‘win-win situation’, says UNHCR’s Grandi

ILO’s Bureau for Employers´Activities to publish new study on women in business and management

Finland has just published everyone’s taxes on ‘National Jealousy Day’

Commission presents first reflections on building a strong social Europe for just transitions

A Sting Exclusive: “Paris is the moment for climate justice”, Swedish MEP Linnéa Engström claims from Brussels

How digital can transform healthcare in Asia for millions of people

Recession: the best argument for growth

European Union signs aviation agreement with the Republic of Korea

Is co-living an answer to the affordable housing crisis?

Businesses, governments and consumers to implement a more climate-friendly approach to #BeatPlasticPollution on World Environment Day 2018

Bold, innovative measures for refugees and their hosts sought, at first ever Global Forum

Are we sleepwalking into a new global crisis?

International Women’s Day 2019: more equality, but change is too slow

EU institutions agree on priorities for coming years: A common agenda for our recovery and renewed vitality

Amid ‘volatile’ environment, UN mission chief urges Iraqi leaders to ‘listen to the voice of the people’

India and the US: 5 ways the countries compare

The EU heads of State and Government about the result of the European Elections 2019

Global South cooperation ‘vital’ to climate change fight, development, Guterres tells historic Buenos Aires summit

Suicide in postpartum depression

As Libya talks resume in Geneva, UN negotiator seeks to overcome sticking points

Thursday’s Daily Brief: Climate emergency, call to support breastfeeding, rising political heat and new investigation board for Syria

Humanity ‘at a crossroads’ as damage to planet poses growing risk to health, UN environment agency warns

Australian solar could power Singapore within a decade

Destabilizing Lebanon after burning Syria; plotting putsch at home: King and Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia

From Model T to EV: a short history of motor vehicle manufacturing

EU mobilises €9 million to tackle the food crisis in Haiti

Will Cameron succeed in keeping UK inside the EU and reverse the present economic downturn?

It ain’t over until Google says it’s over

Humanitarian Aid 2016: The needs, the highlights, the crisis and the relief

A money laundering case on Vatican Bank’s road to renovation

We need to talk: UN gears up for 75th anniversary with Global Conversations

NASA is recruiting new astronauts – this is what it takes to apply

3 ways to fight short-termism and relaunch Europe

Humanitarian action: New outlook for EU’s global aid delivery challenged by COVID-19

European Youth, quo vadis?

MEPs urge the EU to lead the way to net-zero emissions by 2050

Coronavirus: Commission issues guidelines on testing

This farmer is saving the jungle by growing food in it

Brussels to tear down the trade wall with Mexico as opposed to Trump’s “walls”

Science leads the response to COVID-19. These 25 scientists are tackling the other global challenges

Half of the world’s population lack access to essential health services – are we doing enough?

Permafrost is thawing so fast it’s gouging holes in the Arctic

Does the EU want GMOs and meat with hormones from the US?

Telemental health care in times of psychological instability: call 188

Climate change and health: a much needed multidisciplinary approach

Commission presents EU-Vietnam trade and investment agreements for signature and conclusion

EU Emissions Trading System does not hurt firms’ profitability

“A divided Europe is not in China’s interests”, Ambassador Zhang of the Chinese Mission to EU welcomes Brussels

EU/Africa, Caribbean and Pacific: towards which partnership?

Commission welcomes political agreement on InvestEU

The ‘ASEAN way’: what it is, how it must change for the future

EU’s judicial cooperation arm, Eurojust, to become more effective with new rules

We can feed the world in a sustainable way, but we need to act now

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s