EU Parliament sends controversial copyright law reform back to discussion

The European Parliament hemicycle in Strasbourg (Copyright: European Union, 2017 / Source: EC - Audiovisual Service / Photo: Mauro Bottaro)

The European Parliament hemicycle in Strasbourg (Copyright: European Union, 2017 / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service / Photo: Mauro Bottaro)


Last Thursday, the European Parliament has voted against a proposed reform of the EU’s copyright law, aimed at forcing tech giants like Google and Facebook to share revenues with publishers, broadcasters and artists. The proposed reform was formally intended to “modernise” the overall European copyright system, and to bring it more “in line” to the digital age. However, the proposal sparked a fierce debate between internet giants and content creators in the past weeks, with internet first-rate names such as Wikipedia’s Jimmy Wales involved on one front and music legends such as Sir Paul McCartney on the other.

Background

The Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market 2016/0280(COD), also known as the EU Copyright Directive, is a proposed EU directive, officially aimed at harmonising the EU’s copyright laws, but also at protecting press publications, reducing the “value gap” between the profits made by internet platforms and content creators. It first saw the light in 2016, when the European Commission released the proposal currently under discussion, after it passed consultations in 2013, 2014 and 2015.

Less than two months ago, on May 25, the EU Council’s COREPER (from French COmité des REprésentants PERmanents) agreed its position on the draft Directive, paving the way to closing negotiations with the European Parliament to reach a final text. On June 20, 2018, the European Parliament Committee on Legal Affairs finalised their amendments to the directive as well and greenlighted the proposal. However, last week, MEPs voted not to proceed to the negotiation stage, but instead to reopen the directive for debate.

The vote

So last week, on 5 July 2018, Parliament’s plenary voted by 318 votes to 278, with 31 abstentions, to reject the negotiating mandate proposed by the Legal Affairs Committee last month. After the vote, the rapporteur, Axel Voss (EPP,DE) said: “I regret that a majority of MEPs did not support the position which I and the Legal Affairs Committee have been advocating. But this is part of the democratic process”.

European Parliament’s rules of procedure provide that if at least 10% of MEPs (76) object to opening negotiations with the Council based on the text voted in committee, a plenary vote will be held. This was also explained by the European Parliament on an official note, which was released last week. By the deadline of midnight on Tuesday, the requisite number of MEPs had lodged their objection.

Controversial proposal

The proposed EU Copyright Directive was an attempt by the EU to officially “modernise its copyright laws”, and move towards the Digital Single Market. However, it didn’t make everyone happy, particularly because it contained two very controversial and highly-contested parts. The first one was Article 11, which was designed to protect newspapers and other news outlets from internet giants like Google and Facebook, requiring them to pay publishers when users share links.

The second one was Article 13. Article 13 was indeed designed to make online platforms such as YouTube seek direct licences for content such as music videos, images or text. Article 13 would indeed require the upload of a sort of “filter” to have all content uploaded online checked for copyright infringement.

Reactions

Opponents of the Copyright Directive clearly celebrated the rejection of the proposal. Julia Reda, a Pirate Party MEP who had campaigned against the changes, was among the first ones to tweet her satisfaction. “Great success: Your protests have worked! The European Parliament has sent the copyright law back to the drawing board”, Reda said.

Among the backers of the proposal, BPI Music, which represents the UK’s music industry, said: “We respect the decision by MEPs to have a plenary discussion on the draft Copyright Directive. We will work with MEPs over the next weeks to explain how the proposed Directive will benefit not just European creativity, but also internet users and the technology sector”.

Fierce debate

Internet’s most influential names and music industry all start massively collided on the proposal in the past weeks, with the first group claiming the reform could have a massive impact on how people use the internet, limiting freedom, and the latter in support of the law, which would have helped protecting intellectual property. Among the campaigners against the proposals there are high-profile names such as Wikipedia founder, Jimmy Wales, the world wide web inventor, Sir Tim Berners-Lee, the net neutrality expert Tim Wu and the internet pioneer Vint Cerf, which sent a letter to EU Parliament’s President Antonio Tajani, saying the law was an “imminent threat to the future” of the internet.

“We support the consideration of measures that would improve the ability for creators to receive fair remuneration for the use of their works online […] But we cannot support Article 13, which would mandate Internet platforms to embed an automated infrastructure for monitoring and censorship deep into their networks”, the signatories said. “For the sake of the Internet’s future, we urge you to vote for the deletion of this proposal”, the letter also said.

Music industry’s plea

On the other hand, there were about 1,300 musicians who urged politicians to approve the Directive. Music legends such as former Beatles member Paul McCartney, Annie Lennox, Placido Domingo and David Guetta tried to persuade MEPs to make sweeping changes to copyright law, but those names were not enough. In a letter published on IFPI, Sir McCartney urged MEPs to support the proposal. “The proposed Copyright Directive and its Article 13 would address the value gap and help assure a sustainable future for the music ecosystem and its creators, fans and digital music services alike”, he said.

Next steps

With last week’s vote, the proposal has been pushed back to the European Parliament for further debate and will be revisited in September, allowing sections of the proposal to be rewritten. “We will now return to the matter in September for further consideration and attempt to address peoples’ concerns whilst bringing our copyright rules up to date with the modern digital environment”, said rapporteur Axel Voss in the official EU document. September 10 will be the date.

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising

the European Sting Milestones

Featured Stings

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Adjust UN force in Abyei to current realities, peacekeeping chief urges Security Council

Commission launches debate on a gradual transition to more efficient and democratic decision-making in EU tax policy

YO!Fest back in Strasbourg for the 2nd edition of the European Youth Event – 20-21 May 2016

UN chief praises Malaysia’s death penalty repeal as ‘major step forward’

Deutsche Bank slammed by the US-based trio of IMF, Fed and Moody’s

‘Score a goal’ for humanity, says Mohammed, celebrating winning link between sport and development

PM May fosters chauvinism, declares trade war on Europe

European Globalisation Adjustment Fund, who gets it and who pays the bill?

‘Path to peace’ on Korean Peninsula only possible through diplomacy and full denuclearization: US tells Security Council

Independent UN rights expert calls for compassion, not sanctions on Venezuela

G20 LIVE: G20 Leaders’ Communiqué Antalya Summit, 15-16 November 2015

German stock market is not affected by the Greek debt revolution while Athens is running out of time

Alarm over violent attacks on lawmakers, opposition in Malawi, ahead of elections

FROM THE FIELD: Persons with disabilities bike towards sustainability

‘Everyone must be on board’ for peace in Central African Republic: UN’s Lacroix

‘Health is a right, not a privilege’ says WHO chief on World Health Day

In Marrakech, UN chief urges world leaders to ‘breathe life’ into historic global migration pact

Is your business model fit for the Fourth Industrial Revolution?

Biggest London City Banks ready to move core European operations to Frankfurt or Dublin?

5 leadership lessons I learned from doing my own ‘undercover boss’

European Business Summit 2014: The role of youth entrepreneurship education in EU’s Strategy for Competitiveness

Russia and the West to partition Ukraine?

On Youth Education: “Just a normal day in the life of a medical student”

EU Parliament: A catastrophic crisis management by European leaders

The deforestation risks lurking in the banking sector

EU and India re-open talks over strategic partnership while prepare for a Free Trade Agreement

EU Visa Policy: Commission welcomes agreement to strengthen EU visa rules

The race for Driverless vehicles: where is the industry heading?

Trump’s trade wars: Aiming at long term gains for America

EU Emissions Trading System does not hurt firms’ profitability

What happens when the Eurogroup decides to help Greece

UN affirms ‘historic’ global compact to support world’s refugees

‘No steps taken’ so far to end Israel’s illegal settlement activity on Palestinian land – UN envoy

Can the US-Iran rapprochement change the world?

Office workers in these economies clock up the most extra hours

Towards a seamless internal EU market for industrial goods

Global Compact on Refugees: How is this different from the migrants’ pact and how will it help?

Medical Doctors in Industry 4.0: pure science fiction

3 lessons from India in creating equal access to vaccines

3 reasons why AI won’t replace human translators… yet

IMF: Sorry Greece, Ireland, Portugal we were wrong!

The DNA of the future retail CEO

General Assembly officially adopts roadmap for migrants to improve safety, ease suffering

EU members commit to build an integrated gas market and finally cut dependency on Russia

5 charts that explain big challenges facing Italy’s new government

Spending on health increase faster than rest of global economy, UN health agency says

Greece: The new government of Alexis Tsipras shows its colors

MEPs to vote on overhaul of road transport rules in July

The European Parliament hemicycle in Strasbourg (Copyright: European Union, 2017 / Source: EC - Audiovisual Service / Photo: Mauro Bottaro)

EU Parliament sends controversial copyright law reform back to discussion

Commission and ECB prepare new financial mega-tool in support of SMEs

Mali facing ‘alarming’ rise in rights violations, warns UN expert

Britain heading to national schism on exit from EU

A Sting Exclusive: “Sustainable development goals: what role for business?” Commissioner Mimica asks live from European Business Summit 2015

MWC 2016 LIVE: BlackBerry acquires Encription, talks Microsoft and health

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: UNESCO ready to help after Notre Dame fire, and updates on Libya, Nicaragua, and the Cyclone Idai response

Congolese expelled from Angola returning to ‘desperate situation’: UN refugee agency

Better housing means better health and well-being, stress new WHO guidelines

Planet’s Health is Our Health and the Reverse is True

More hiring freedom can reduce teacher shortages in disadvantaged areas

EU sets ambitious targets for the Warsaw climate conference

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s