To Brexit, or not to Brexit…rather not: 10 Downing Street, London

8 June 2018. Prime Minister Theresa May speaks at the G7 summit held in Charlevoix, Quebec, Canada. (UK government photo, some rights reserved).

Almost exactly two years have elapsed after the Brits voted to leave the European Union. Tomorrow, Tuesday 12 June, the elected lower House of the Parliament, the Commons, is expected to open the way for Britain to remain in EU’s customs union and the single market for an extended period of time. Most probably, Prime Minister Theresa May, is to suffer another defeat there. The relevant law is ingloriously named ‘EU Withdrawal Bill’. But the more interesting text isn’t this law, but the UK’s proposal for at least two more years in the EU. This is  the ‘Technical Note’ for Brexit, which 10 Downing St. sent to Brussels last Friday foreseeing a backstop for Ireland.

Actually, it took a memorable and bloody fight at 10 Downing Street for Prime Minister Theresa May to finally be forced to include in her ‘backstop’ proposal an end date for the ‘provisional’ stay in the club until 2021. The initial text didn’t contain a similar reference. It was her Brexit Minister David Davis who forced her to include an ‘expected’ end of the interim period, by brandishing his resignation. If nothing else, Ireland, both Northern and the Eire, the Republic, had a perfect case to get their revenge, turning the Brexit into a nightmare for London. Let’s see why.

The Irish conundrum

The truth is that the insurmountable obstacle for London in finding an honorable way out from the EU, proved to be the Irish border line of 400 km, separating Northern Ireland, still a part of Britain, from the Republic of Ireland, the Eire. From the very first moment, when the negotiations for a Brexit deal between London and Brussels started in September 2016, both sides vowed there won’t be a hard border line enacted in Ireland after the UK leaves the Union. They did that for a very good reason, to avoid a new bloodshed in the North of the island.

Today, there are completely free and unchecked movements and communications between the two parts of Ireland. To safeguard this freedom, the UK and the EU pledged to honor the ‘Good Friday or Belfast Agreement’ between the catholic nationalists and the protestant anglophiles of Northern Ireland. This Agreement ended a decades old bloody and catastrophic civil war in the North.

The signing of the Agreement by the two perennial enemy sides was made possible through securing completely free movements for people, goods and services up and down the border line. This was possible because both parts of the island were members of the European Union, the Northern Ireland as a part of the UK a full member of the EU and the Republic of Ireland on her own account a member state of the club.

Peace through assimilation

So, the border line lost its segregationist role and after a while of free movements the enmity almost vanished, securing a long peace. Actually, the left nationalist Sinn Fein Party of the Catholic side is active in both parts of the island and is represented in both of the two legislatives. To be noted, in the Brexit referendum of June 2016, Northern Ireland voted ‘remain’. However it became clear that the implementation of Brexit and the UK leaving the EU would necessarily entail the enactment of a hard border in Ireland, controlling, monitoring and eventually blocking the movement of people, goods and services.

Soon, this prospect turned the political situation in the North noxious, and a return to the catastrophic past of civil conflict started to look likely. In Eire also there was dismay and unrest with the prospect of a hard border. Dublin has promised to veto any solution containing a hard border. The old enmity with the anglophiles of the North took hold of the population.

EU and UK vow no border in Ireland

The whole affair was too close to a boiling point, obliging the UK and the EU to guarantee there won’t be a hard border in Ireland. Come the Brexit though, Northern Ireland is to leave the EU and the club – comprising the Eire – has to protect  its customs union and the single market from a third country, the UK, with a border.

Brussels made it crystal clear that since a hard border cannot be enacted in Ireland after Brexit, Northern Ireland must stay in EU’s customs union and the single market. But, in such a case, this part of the isle has to be estranged from the UK and border checks and controls to be introduced in the communications between Northern Ireland and the rest of the Kingdom. No government in 10 Downing Street could accept this option, since a part of the Kingdom would be isolated by border checks and controls. The unity and the sovereignty of Great Britain would have been directly diluted.

Squaring the cycle

As a result, a clear impossibility arises. Either cutting the Irish island in two by enacting a hard border, or estranging Northern Ireland from Britain are both two infeasible solutions. Logically, the only solution remains that the entire UK to remain ‘provisionally’ in EU’s customs union and single market, together with both parts of Ireland.

This is exactly what May is now proposing to Brussels. It took two years to her Brexiteer Conservatives to understand this was the only way out or rather in the EU. Actually May didn’t want to include an end date for this ‘temporary’ option, because she knows squaring the cycle is to remain an impossible ad infinitum. Still, the Brexiteers exhausted their ammunition and gained a mention in the backstop document about ending the provisional status at 2021.

Until 2021 or beyond?

It remains to be seen if Brussels will accept this latest London’s proposal as it is. Michel Barnier, the chief EU negotiator for Brexit, tweeted “I welcome publication of #UK proposal on customs aspects of IE/NI backstop. We will examine it with 3 questions: is it a workable solution to avoid a hard border? Does it respect the integrity of the SM/CU? Is it an all-weather backstop?”. In practice, the May document is, in its general provisions, almost identical with what Barnier had proposed to London in December 2017 which was accepted then by 10 Downing Street.

Still, there are a lot of details which have to be clarified and Barnier makes it clear with this three lines tweet. He insists it has to really offer the avoidance of borders in Ireland. He also notes that while the entire Britain remains in the SM/CU (Single Market/Customs Union) it has to respect the full package regulating it, along with the supremacy of the European Court. And, finally, his ‘all weather’ condition for London’s backstop proposal, means there should be no legal end time for the interim period.

Rather indefinitely

Barnier bases this last request on the fact that the British document refers to the end date as just an ‘expectation’. The text of the document includes, “The UK expects the future arrangement to be in place by the end of December 2021 at the latest. There are a range of options for how a time limit could be delivered, which the UK will propose and discuss with the EU”. This is the 26th and last paragraph of this British Government document, entitled ‘TECHNICAL NOTE: TEMPORARY CUSTOMS ARRANGEMENT’. Obviously, there is no guarantee or legal reassurance that before the end of 2021 Britain would have managed to…square the cycle.

All in all, what Barmier said in his tweet denotes that 10 Downing Street representatives will be badly pressed in Brussels to accept all the initial EU terms as briefly described here above by Barnier. The European Union doesn’t ask for anything, it’s Britain that voted ‘Leave’.

 

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

This is how much people would pay to use some of the world’s most popular apps

Why the UN is investigating poverty in the United Kingdom

THE COMMITTEES: ‘All roads lead to the Fifth’

EU migration deal welcomed by UN agencies

World Maritime Day: Commissioner Vălean calls for support and safe return of seafarers

To solve the climate crisis, we need an investment revolution

Eurozone economy desperately needs internally driven growth

Autonomous vehicles could clog city centres: a lesson from Boston

“Decent working conditions for the young health workforce: what are the challenges and can we find solutions?”

“A global threat lies ahead worsened after the EU’s green light to the Bayer-Monsanto merger”, a Sting Exclusive by the President of Slow Food

Brexit poses ‘particular risk’ to British people in poverty: UN independent expert

A digital tax sounds like a great idea. Here’s why it might not be universally popular

5 ways urban transport could step up a gear for women

Drugs cost too much. There is a better way to fund medical innovation

Boris ‘single-handed’ threatens mainland Europe; can he afford a no-deal Brexit?

Tragedy of Mediterranean deaths continues, as seven drown, 57 rescued: UN migration agency

Act now to end violence, Zeid urges Nicaraguan authorities

A Sting Exclusive: “Cybersecurity: Why consumer products must be looked at urgently”, by BEUC’s Deputy Director General

Banks promise easing of credit conditions in support of the real economy

DR Congo: ‘New waves of violence’ likely, UN warns, unless State acts to prevent intercommunal reprisals

Ebola: EU announces new funds to strengthen preparedness in Burundi

Victims of terrorism remembered

Varna (Bulgaria) awarded European Youth Capital 2017

The European Sting @ Mobile World Congress 2014, Creating What’s Next for the World. Can EU Policy follow?

ECB’s billions fortify south Eurozone except Greece; everybody rushes to invest in euro area bonds zeroing their yields

People, not technology, shape the future of manufacturing

Parliament in favour of lifting visa requirements for Kosovars

Africa Forum aims to boost business, reduce costs, help countries trade out of poverty

EU and Australia launch talks for a broad trade agreement

The horrific trend of the anti-vaccine movement in Turkey

FROM THE FIELD: Going the extra mile with vaccines

Luxembourg has achieved high levels of growth and well-being but must do more to preserve and share prosperity

Reducing deforestation means getting serious about environmental crime

Entrepreneurship and strategic planning: the enabler

4 simple ways to make your holiday season more sustainable

Yanukovych attempts a violent and deadly cleansing of Kiev’s center

‘Revved up climate action’ needed to counter ‘prolonged’ and deadly storms like Cyclone Idai: Guterres

Here are 10 of the most urgent health challenges we’ll face in the 2020s, according to WHO

Women Win in the West

This wall of shoes is for the women killed by domestic violence

School closures triple in Central and Western Africa as education comes under fire

COP25: Global investors urge countries to meet climate action goals

Coronavirus (COVID-19): truth and myth on personal risk perception

Why building consumer trust is the key to unlocking AI’s true potential

UN’s Grandi slams ‘toxic language of politics’ aimed at refugees, migrants

Budget MEPs approve €104.2 m in EU aid to Greece, Spain, France and Portugal

UN experts decry torture of Rakhine men and boys held incommunicado by Myanmar’s military

Can free trade deliver cheaper renewable energy? Ask Mexico

How private investment can boost education access and quality in the digital economy

A top economist shares 3 ways leaders can help economies recover

This AI trash can is designed to stop you wasting food

4 essential qualities for digital leaders

MWC 2016 LIVE: Ford trumpets new in-vehicle system, “fundamentally rethinks” transportation

MEPs question whether the new Migration Pact will bring about real change

Force used against protestors in Gaza ‘wholly disproportionate’ says UN human rights chief

Compensation for damages by the State for infringement of EU law: the European Commission refers Spain to the Court of Justice for its rules on the compensation for damages incurred by private parties

Gender is where the feminist and LGBTI movements meet. Here’s why

UK economy in dire straits: leading banks now officially plan to Brexit too

European Parliament the most trusted EU institution

Refugee crisis update: EU seeks now close cooperation with Africa while Schulz is shocked to witness live one single wreck full of immigrants

More Stings?

Advertising

Comments

  1. Tony Louis says:

    Two world wars won and a maastricht treaty prevented, for what for Theresa May to give this country away, I’m ashamed to be British I dispise everything Europe stands for, an unelected body robbing millions from the working class making the rules by which we have to live.

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s