Does research make sense any more? The dire need for new ways to measure success

This article was exclusively written for the Sting by Ms.  Stijntje Dijk , a medical student at the Erasmus Medical Center in Rotterdam. She is also affiliated to the International Federation of Medical Students Associations (IFMSA). However, the opinions expressed in this piece belong strictly to the writer and do not necessarily reflect IFMSA’s view on the topic, nor The European Sting’s one.

 The question “Medical Research Worldwide – Who is leading and who is lagging behind” – requires us to first identify what it means to be successful. It’s not uncommon to judge individuals based on their numbers of publications, the prestige of journals they published in, their chances of receiving grants. That is after all what we hear we will be judged on in our careers.

What if, instead of chasing prestige, we were judged by the degree to which our research positively impacts our communities? And what if we knew for certain that this was really what our schools cared about when they assessed us? Would our priorities shift?

 A socially accountable medical school takes action through its education, research and service activities to meet the priority health needs of society. It works with governments, health service organizations, and public to positively impact people’s health and demonstrates this through relevance, quality, equitabiliy, cost-effectiveness. [1]  Its aim is to deliver graduates who are change agents with capacity to work on health determinants and contribute to adapting the health system.[2] This was a conclusion also reached by the Global Consensus on Social Accountability for Medical Schools, created in 2010.

Although these principles do look good on paper, they are often poorly reflected in practice, and decisions remain to be taken on external factors such as personal interest. Rudolf Virchow once accurately wrote: “Medical Education does not exist to provide students with a way of making a living, but to ensure the health of the community.”

This april 2017, the World Summit of Social Accountability will reflect on how we can drive the recommendations of the Global Consensus document.

Of course not all science directly shows the value it will have to our societies eventually, and not all other issues should be disregarded. However, we should remain mindful that health professionals have a priviliged position to start with: We had the opportunity to study medicine, whereas many others did not. (In the majority of cases) Our communities have invested in us to receive this education. They often invest in the time we spend on doing our research for our work. Finally, it’s them who often indirectly pay the fees to read the results of that work through journal paywalls.

Several guidelines exist in medical research, however most focus on research involving people, in order to protect them under ethical guidelines. But if even research done without direct population involvement still ultimately effects them, shouldn’t ethical guidelines be then always applied?

Then what is socially accountable research, and how do we assess it? There’s no straightforward answer. I would propose however, the following questions to ask ourselves, when setting our priorities:

  • Would anything change in the world based on the research I’m doing – is it translatable to policy or practice?
  • Am I doing this research because there is a need in the world/in my community, or just because I need to get enough publications on my name to earn a title?
  • Is there an opportunity for participatory action research? Can I collaborate with those affected by the issue studied, and create shared ownership over the research project?
  • Can I effectively argue that this research should be a priority over other potential research areas, considering that time and monetary investments are scarce?
  • Is there any way I can prevent the public from paying double/triple for this research? Can I find any open access opportunities that allow me to still reach my intended audience?

Only then can we live up to our social mandate, and truly lead medical research and education worldwide.

References

[1] Boelen C, Heck J. Defining and Measuring the Social Accountability of Medical Schools. Geneva: World Health Organization; 1995. Available from: http://www.moph.go.th/ops/hrdj/Hrdj_no1/charles.html.

[2] Boelen C, Dharamsi S, Gibbs T. The Social Accountability of Medical Schools and its Indicators. Educ Health [serial online] 2012 [cited 2017 Mar 25];25:180-94. Available from: http://www.educationforhealth.net/text.asp?2012/25/3/180/109785

About the author
Stijntje Dijk is a medical student at the Erasmus Medical Center in Rotterdam. She previously served as the former Liaison Officer for Medical Education issues and Medical Education Director for the International Federation of Medical Students’ Associations.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Refugee crisis update: EU fails to relocate immigrants from Greece and Italy

A 550 km-long mass of rotting seaweed is heading for Mexico’s pristine beaches

MEPs Anti-fraud votes for more votes?

EU ready to relinquish its internal tax havens

FROM THE FIELD: West Africa’s wishful gold diggers

UN experts report: Business ‘dragging its feet’ on human rights worldwide

Without tackling ‘gross inequalities’ major issues will go unsolved, warns UN rights chief Bachelet

Refugees now make up 1% of the world’s population

Technology can help solve the climate crisis – but it will need our help

How can we make entrepreneurship serve the greater good?

Right2Water initiative: Is the Commission ready to listen to citizens?

How farms are getting closer to consumers in the pandemic

What makes a great CEO? The people they surround themselves with

‘Virginity testing’: a human rights violation, with no scientific basis – UN

Monsoon rains turn millions of children’s lives ‘upside down’ across South Asia

Innovation is the key to the pay-TV industry’s long-term growth

Young people are key to defusing unrest and restoring public trust

Review on ethics and technological development

Gender inequality in the medicine field: two commonly issues

JADE Spring Meeting 2015: a step forward for Youth Entrepreneurship

High-technology manufacturing saves the EU industry

Governments and non-state actors need to take urgent action to meet Paris Agreement goals

Schengen: new rules for temporary checks at national borders

Anti-Semitism ‘toxic to democracy’, UN expert warns, calling for better education

European Business Summit 2014: Sting Report, Day I

What makes us happy? AI scanned 700,000 journal entries to find out

Why Italy will not follow the Greek road; Eurozone to change or unravel

UN chief sends condolences to families of Malawi flood victims

These are the world’s safest cities

More than 3,400 classrooms damaged or destroyed by Cyclone Idai in Mozambique, says UN Children’s Fund

Day of the Seafarer: Commissioner Vălean supports the rights of seafarers and their vital role

Eurozone: Economic sentiment-business climate to collapse without support from exports

Failing to agree climate action would ‘not only be immoral’ but ‘suicidal’, UN chief tells COP24

My disability, my identity

European Business Summit 2013: Where Business and Politics shape the future

Three ways the Fourth Industrial Revolution is shaping geopolitics

Can the EU really make Google and Facebook pay publishers and media?

COVID-19: MEPs debate how to best protect cross-border and seasonal workers

The European Union’s Balkan Double Standard

4 things President Trump could learn from Jimmy Carter

Mental Health in the COVID-19 era

Israeli security forces’ response to Gaza protests ‘a recipe for more bloodshed’, says UN expert

7 ways the ‘biological century’ will transform healthcare

How quantum computing could beat climate change

Africa’s Sahel: Act now before the crisis ‘becomes unmanageable’, urges Grandi

Traditional knowledge at ‘core’ of indigenous heritage, and ‘must be protected’, says UN Forum

How the technology behind deepfakes can benefit all of society

This Indian school accepts plastic waste instead of fees

Using ‘leprosy’ metaphors in political rhetoric ‘fuels public stigma’ and discrimination: UN rights expert

The digital building blocks of better communities

Miguel Arias Cañete European Commission

EU should invest more in climate and not sit back on its laurels and watch

Libya ‘in race against time’, but dissolving conflict ‘a realistic prospect’, Security Council hears

India is building a high-tech sustainable city from scratch

Monsanto lawsuit ruling a ‘significant recognition’ of victims’ human rights, say UN rights experts

UN condemns ‘cowardly’ attack on Libya’s national oil corporation headquarters

Russia and the EU ‘trade’ natural gas supplies and commercial concessions in and out of Ukraine

Promoting ‘a healthy sustainable future’, the UN health agency engages young and young at heart to ‘Walk the Talk’

Forget GDP – for the 21st century we need a modern growth measure

UN honours fallen colleagues and friends who ‘risk all to promote peace’

Hostages to a rampant banking system

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s