The South China Sea Arbitration: Illegal, Illegitimate and Invalid

Ambassador Yang Yanyi Chinese Mission to EU.JPGThis article was written for the European Sting by HE Ambassador Yang Yanyi of the Chinese Mission to EU in Brussels. If I have to choose three words to reflect my views of the award of arbitration over the South China Sea disputes unilaterally filed by the Philippines against China, it would be illegal, illegitimate and invalid. And China’s position is firm and clear: non-acceptance. Not surprisingly, some in the West have again pointed their fingers at China and accused China of “thumbing nose at international rules”. I cannot but dismiss these allegations and vilifications as groundless and unjustified. Contrary to what was claimed in the West, it is the Philippines and some other forces that are acting against international law. China is not.
  1. Although the Philippines has struggled to appear that it is asking nothing more than requesting the Arbitral Tribunal to decide that some features in the South China Sea are low-tide elevations incapable of generating any maritime entitlement, it failed to cover up the essence of its submission, which is about territorial sovereignty and maritime delimitation. Nor can it hide its obvious purpose of denying China of its sovereignty over maritime features of the Nansha Islands and emboldening its illegal occupation of maritime features of the Nansha Islands from China.
Many scholars on international law are of the view that the Tribunal that handles the arbitration proceedings has no jurisdiction over the case, as the crux of the case is about territorial sovereignty and maritime delimitation. As Prof. Antonios Tzanakopolos of the University of Oxford pointed out, the dispute between China and the Philippines is “obviously over sovereignty over maritime features in the South China Sea”. It is common knowledge that territorial issues are subject to general international law, rather than the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (the UNCLOS/the Convention), and that disputes concerning maritime delimitation are excluded by China in its 2006 declaration on optional exceptions on Article 298 of UNCLOS. Let me quote 298.1(a) (i) of UNCLOS “… any dispute that necessarily involves the concurrent consideration of any unsettled dispute concerning sovereignty or other rights over continental or insular land territory shall be excluded from (compulsory procedures).” 298.1 of UNCLOS stipulates clearly “… a State may, … declare in writing that it does not accept any one or more of the (compulsory) procedures … with respect to (disputes concerning) … maritime delimitation … historic bays or tiles … military and law enforcement activities…”. Mr. Chris Whomersley, former Deputy Legal Adviser of the UK’s Foreign and Commonwealth Office, made a good point when he said there was “no precedent for an international tribunal deciding upon the status of a maritime feature when the sovereignty… is disputed”. He described the act of the Philippines and the Arbitral Tribunal in a quite metaphorical way: Putting the cart of status before the horse of sovereignty. Simply put, the Philippines’ initiation of the arbitration is in total disregard of international law and the spirit of UNCLOS, and undermines the authority and sanctity of the Convention.
  1. Settlement of territorial sovereignty dispute through bilateral negotiations is an established international practice and in full compliance with the principles and spirit of the UN Charter.
If memory serves me correctly, China and the Philippines were the first countries in the region that agreed to resolve the relevant disputes through negotiations. In June 1986, during his meeting with Jose P. Laurel, Vice-President and Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Philippines, Mr. Deng Xiaoping put forward the principle of shelving disputes and seeking joint development. In April 1988, when Mr. Deng Xiaoping met with Philippine President Corazon Aquino, he spelled out this principle even more clearly. This approach and principle was well received by the Philippine side. China and the Philippines later entered into a number of agreements on bilateral ties and their option of going for bilateral negotiations rather than arbitration to resolve the relevant disputes. These documents include, among other things, the 1995 Joint Statement between China and the Philippines concerning Consultations on the South China Sea and on Other Areas of Cooperation; the 1999 Joint Statement of the China-Philippines Experts Group Meeting on Confidence-Building Measures; the 2000 Joint Statement between the Government of China and the Government of the Philippines on the Framework of Bilateral Cooperation in the 21st Century; the 2004 Joint Press Statement between the Government of China and the Government of the Philippines; and the 2011 Joint Statement between China and the Philippines. The same spirit was enshrined in the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea (DOC), a document of far-reaching historic significance agreed upon by China and the ASEAN, including the Philippines. According to Article 4 of the DOC, “the Parties concerned undertake to resolve their territorial and jurisdictional disputes by peaceful means, without resorting to the threat or use of force, through friendly consultations and negotiations by sovereign states directly concerned, in accordance with universally recognized principles of international law, including the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea.” I had the pride of working on China-Philippines and China-ASEAN relations in the Asian Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, where I was personally involved in the negotiations and drafting of the DOC and a few other agreements. For someone who worked for years on these instruments, the thrust of these agreements cannot be clearer, i.e., disputes shall be settled in a peaceful and friendly manner through consultations on the basis of equity and mutual respect, and third-party dispute settlement, including arbitration, is explicitly excluded. To my shock, far from exhausting diplomatic efforts, the Philippines turned its back on the political commitment it had made and, against the principle of Pacta sunt servanda, unilaterally initiated the so-called arbitration by abusing the UNCLOS dispute settlement procedures. It should not be too difficult to conclude, therefore, who is contemptuous of international law and who is violating the norms governing international relations.
  1. Talking about respecting international law, we need to remind ourselves of the long established principle of “Ex injuria jus non oritur”, i.e., legal right or entitlement cannot arise from an unlawful act, and that the UNCLOS does not allow initiation of Arbitration as in the Philippines’ case.
As I mentioned before, settling relevant dispute through negotiations is the means China and the Philippines have agreed in a series of bilateral documents and the DOC. According to universal principle of international law and order and norms governing international relations, one country is under the obligation to abide by its agreement with other countries. According to 281.1 of UNCLOS, “if the States Parties…have agreed to seek settlement of the dispute by a peaceful means of their own choice, the (compulsory disputes settlement) procedures apply only where no settlement has been reached by recourse to such means and the agreement between the parties does not exclude any further procedure.” In the worst scenario, if a dispute arises between States Parties concerning the interpretation or application of the Convention, according to Section 1, Article 283 of UNCLOS, “the Parties to the dispute shall proceed expeditiously to an exchange of views regarding its settlement by negotiation or other peaceful means.” Yet, despite the fact that the channel for bilateral consultation was wide-open, the Philippines never exchanged views with China concerning its arbitration submission. The so-called “disputes” in the arbitration are sheer fabrication and the whole thing is illegally imposed on China. Again, it is crystal clear that the Philippines and the Arbitral Tribunal are making a mock of international law, including UNCLOS, and their act will not have any lawful and legal effect.
  1. The arbitration does more harm than good to good-neighborliness and peace and stability in the South China Sea.
Putting the South China Sea issue in perspective, one will not fail to see that since the end of the Cold War, the general trend in the region is to seek new concept and approach to promote peace and prosperity. This new concept and approach, characterized by mutual respect, dialogue and cooperation, and strongly championed by China, effectively promoted a peaceful, friendly and harmonious environment in our region, including the South China Sea. It is only in recent years that such positive trend was interrupted if not obstructed. The row over the South China Sea issue is but one phenomenon of such a reversal. People may have different observations of the root cause of the present fluid situation, yet I am afraid that some of them, especially reports from the Western media, are filled with insufficient knowledge of the South China Sea issue and biased views of China and the overall situation in Southeast Asia. One has to admit that the reaction from the other side of the Pacific to the positive development and achievements in Southeast Asia, especially the launching of the so-called “Asia-Pacific rebalancing” in 2010, has had profound impact on the region. Trust and confidence among countries in the region have been eroded, the focus on economic development and the approach of dialogue and cooperation are in danger of being shifted toward and replaced by confrontation. One needs to acknowledge the fact, too, that as a Permanent Member of the UN Security Council, China has contributed to the building of a fair and reasonable international order under the UN Charter and a series of international documents. China has always stood for safeguarding peace and stability and promotion of cooperation and prosperity, and is fully committed to resolving disputes peacefully through consultations and negotiations in accordance with international law and the spirit of the DOC. It is true that China has conducted construction work on some of its islands. But let’s not forget that this is done on China’s own soil, and the purpose of doing so is nothing but improving the living and working conditions of personnel stationed there and better safeguarding China’s territorial sovereignty and maritime rights. This is not targeted at any other country, nor will it impact in any way the freedom of navigation and over-flight in the South China Sea. In this connection, I need to emphasize that as the largest coastal country of the South China Sea and as the world’s biggest trading nation in goods, China has a high stake in peace, stability and freedom of navigation and over-flight in the South China Sea. For its own sake and in the interest of all countries in the region, China is firmly committed to safeguarding freedom of navigation and over-flight in the South China Sea to which all countries are entitled under international law. Coming back to my point, non-acceptance of and non-participation in the arbitration is the move China has taken to safeguard the international rule of law. The so-called arbitration is in itself a breach of international law. It only serves to impair regional efforts to build up confidence and trust and properly settle territorial sovereignty disputes. Many countries and regional organizations as well as officials, experts and scholars have deplored the moves by the Philippines and the tribunal arbitration as an obvious intervention in the sovereignty of countries in the region. They see such moves as most unfortunate that would only exacerbate bad will between countries, and argue that “binary format of a court case” between two parties as such “can never do justice to all”. It is encouraging to see that the mainstream international community is supportive of the “dual-track approach” initiated by China and ASEAN, i.e., disputes related to the South China Sea should be addressed properly through negotiations and consultations among countries directly concerned, while China and the ASEAN countries should work together to safeguard peace and stability in the South China Sea. Let me highlight the Joint Statement on Strengthening Global Stability that China and Russia signed on 25 June 2016, which reaffirmed the principle of peaceful settlement of disputes. As declared by the Joint Statement, it is crucial for the maintenance of international legal order that the means and mechanisms for the settlement of all disputes are based on consent and applied in good faith and in the spirit of cooperation, and their purpose shall not be undermined by abusive practices. The illegal, illegitimate and invalid arbitration initiated by the Philippines and the tribunal may be noisy and high-profile, yet it looks pale against historical facts and international law and order and the trend of the times. It is nothing but a farce in passing. As Mr. Wang Yi, Minister of Foreign Affairs of China, said early this year on the South China Sea issue, “history will eventually prove who is just passing through, and who is the real master.”

Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Interesting reads

© UN News/Laura Quinones Ambition the cat.

COP31: Ambition goes missing as fossil fuel language drops from draft deal

This article is published in association with United Nations. A cat named Ambition went missing again at COP31 on Thursday. While activists delivered the message with humour, it reflected a serious concern: explicit references to moving away from fossil fuels had disappeared from the latest draft climate agreement. On the eve of the summit’s scheduled […]
This article is published in association with European Investment Bank.

‘Losing the battle’: AI hands predators new ways to target children

This article is published in association with United Nations. Artificial intelligence (AI) is handing predators and criminal groups new ways to groom, extort and exploit children, while efforts to protect them are failing to keep pace, senior UN officials warned on Thursday. “We lost the battle on social media because we were lagging behind, and […]
© UN News/Laura Quinones UN Climate Conference in Antalya, Türkiye.

COP31 deadlock persists as countries launch new ‘climate reality check’

This article is published in association with United Nations. With the clock running down at COP31 in Antalya, countries on Wednesday launched a new global check on whether climate promises are being kept, even as ministers remained deadlocked over some of the summit’s toughest questions: who pays, how fast the world moves away from fossil […]
© UNOCHA/Viktoriia Andriievska A man enters a bombed building in Kyiv, Ukraine.

Ukraine: Civilian casualties in 2026 already far exceed previous years’ tolls

This article is published in association with United Nations. This year has seen dramatically higher civilian casualties in Ukraine than any other year since the full-scale invasion of the eastern European country by Russia in February 2022, the UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) said on Tuesday. In October 2026, the number of […]
© UN Climate Change/Kubilay Citfci UN Climate Conference in Antalya, Türkiye.

COP31 enters decisive week as climate talks face political test and AI initiatives gather pace

This article is published in association with United Nations. New international initiatives on artificial intelligence and green industrialization showcased technology’s growing role in climate action, even as negotiators remained deadlocked on finance, fossil fuels and adaptation ahead of the final stretch of the UN talks. Today at COP31 As COP31 entered its second and final […]
UN Social Media/ María Fernández del Moral COP31 press conference to launch the Priorities for Action on AI for Climate Information Integrity.

COP31: New initiative targets AI and reliable climate change information

This article is published in association with United Nations. New guidance has been issued to ensure that people everywhere can obtain credible climate change information from artificial intelligence (AI) and understand how the technology impacts the environment. The Priorities for Action on AI and Climate Information Integrity were launched at the COP31 climate conference in […]
UN News A partially collapsed residential building in the city of Deir al-Balah, Gaza, after residents were evacuated amid heavy rain and strong winds.

Six killed in Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital

This article is published in association with United Nations. An Israeli airstrike on Gaza’s Nasser Hospital on Wednesday night killed six people, injured 27 others and caused extensive damage. Ramiz Alakbarov, the UN Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process ad interim, on Thursday said he was deeply alarmed by the attack.” The strike […]
© UN News/Laura Quinones Sunrise over COP31 as participants arrived as early as 5am to avoid traffic closures.

‘Make or bake time’: Guterres urges climate justice pact as leaders gather at COP31

This article is published in association with United Nations. UN chief António Guterres called for a new global climate justice agreement at COP31 on Wednesday, urging governments to tax fossil fuel companies to help countries bearing the brunt of a crisis they did little to cause. His appeal came as world leaders gathered in Antalya […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Gaza winter aid: ‘No more delay’, Fletcher tells governments stalling on support

© UNRWA Children play outside tents in Gaza. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s Emergency Relief Coordinator, Tom Fletcher, expressed deep concern about the deteriorating humanitarian situation in Gaza, as UN member states and partners have been repeatedly delaying sending their support to the Strip. “Foreign Ministers and partners have […]
This article is published in association with United Nations.l student with a strong interest in research and global health.

COP31: Energy transition takes centre stage as countries map path beyond fossil fuels

This article is published in association with United Nations. The global energy transition took centre stage on the second day of COP31, as countries explored how to move away from fossil fuels, accelerate clean energy and overcome financial and infrastructure barriers standing in the way. Today at COP31 Energy and Transport Day at COP31 got […]
UN News Two children stand in a rain-soaked tent in Deir al-Balah, Gaza.

Children among the dead as heavy rains flood tents and shelters in Gaza

This article is published in association with United Nations. An infant reportedly drowned and five Gazans were killed – including three children – when a sand dune collapsed on their tents as the first heavy rains swept across the enclave at the weekend, according to the UN aid coordination office (OCHA). Thousands of families lost […]
© EducAid “Before [this], the difference was huge – I used to carry Anas, and he had to crawl on his hands,” said Anas’s mother.

‘For the first time I have my own chair’: Gaza siblings find new freedom

This article is published in association with United Nations. In Gaza, 10-year-old Anas is one of three siblings born without legs and with only two fingers on each of their hands. They struggle to move around and perform daily activities like eating and writing independently. With funding from the UN’s aid coordination office (OCHA), and […]
© UNICEF A child looks out from a makeshift shelter in Rafah, in the south of the Gaza Strip.

Gunfire damages tents at Rafah displacement site in Gaza, as aid teams prepare for winter storms

This article is published in association with United Nations. Gunfire hit and damaged multiple tents at a displacement site in Gaza’s northern Rafah region on Tuesday, reportedly causing injuries and forcing a humanitarian partner to leave the area, the UN aid coordination office (OCHA) has said. The NGO had been working on flood control ahead […]
© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon..

UN peacekeeping chief warns of ‘security vacuum’ as Blue Helmets leave Lebanon and Western Sahara

© UNIFIL UNIFIL remains a critical stabilising factor in south Lebanon.. This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN’s peacekeeping chief warned on Wednesday that the withdrawal of “Blue Helmets” from Lebanon and Western Sahara risks leaving a dangerous security vacuum, while the Security Council remains divided over what, if anything, should […]
© IOM/Haithm Abdulbaqi Young people in Yemen play football on a sandy pitch.

15 years of ‘almost no progress’ in getting young people moving: WHO

This article is published in association with United Nations. One in four adolescents worldwide reported not getting at least 60 minutes of physical activity on any day in the previous week, according to new global estimates released by the World Health Organization (WHO) on Wednesday. That amounts to some 240 million young people aged 11 […]
© UNICEF/Sultan Mahmu A mother and daughter wade through floodwaters in Feni, southeastern Bangladesh.

COP31 explained: What’s at stake at this year’s UN climate summit?

This article is published in association with United Nations. The world has more tools than ever to tackle climate change, yet millions remain unable to benefit from them. As clean energy technologies advance faster than ever, the challenge facing countries at COP31 is no longer just finding solutions – but making sure everyone can afford […]
© UNICEF/Christina Pashkina A school in Chuhuiv, Ukraine, lies in ruins after being hit by a missile.

Air raid alerts and attacks on schools: the devastating face of education in Ukraine

This article is published in association with United Nations. Ukraine has sustained almost 2,000 attacks on education since the full-scale Russian invasion in 2022, with some 270 this year alone, the UN Children’s Fund (UNICEF) said on Tuesday, a day after a strike at a school being used to distribute aid. Tweet URL Since the […]
© UNICEF/Oleksii Filippov People walk past a war-damaged building in Ukraine.

Ukraine: WFP provides hot meals to Oleshky evacuees as UN pushes to restore power before winter

This article is published in association with United Nations. The UN World Food Programme (WFP) is providing emergency food assistance to more than 400 people who were able to leave the Russian-occupied city of Oleshky, in Ukraine’s Kherson region, during a brief local ceasefire. Many arrived in worrying condition at medical facilities in Kyiv on […]

COP17: Nations chart ‘Yerevan Pathway’ to speed up action for nature

This article is published in association with United Nations. At the halfway mark to 2030, countries meeting in Armenia have agreed a roadmap to accelerate action for nature, after a global review found the world off track to meet its biodiversity targets. Agreement was formalised through the Yerevan Pathway as the UN Biodiversity Conference (COP17) […]

Comments

  1. China occupied Tibet is Illegal, Illegitimate and Invalid…

    • CriticalThinking says:

      Alas, another “adult” brainwashed by Western media. If all you can do is plagiarize other’s words, think about moving out of your mom’s basement.

Why don't you drop your comment here?

Go back up

Discover more from The European Sting - Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology - europeansting.com

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

The European Sting – Critical News & Insights on European Politics, Economy, Foreign Affairs, Business & Technology – europeansting.com