The New EU-US “Shield” for data privacy is full of holes

Vĕra Jourová, European Commissioner in charge of Justice

Vĕra Jourová, European Commissioner in charge of Justice, Consumers and Gender Equality at the European Parliament Plenary last January in Strasbourg. © European Union , 2016 / Source: EC – Audiovisual Service / Photo: Jean-François Badias.

Last week the “post-Safe Harbour era” was officially launched. On February 2 the European Union and the United States have agreed on a new framework for transatlantic data flows, the so-called Privacy Shield. The two sides have now a brand new data-sharing deal, which will allow websites like Facebook, Apple and Google to transfer EU citizens’ data across the Atlantic and to process them in the US under certain privacy terms.

Background

The announcement by the European Commission came three months after the European Court of Justice struck down the previous data-protection deal, the Safe Harbour, and immediately gave relief to thousands of American companies which used to rely on Safe Harbour to handle data. Indeed, the old agreement have been used for 15 years, since the beginning of the new Millennium, to transfer personal data from the EU to US in compliance with the EU Data Protection Directive and European privacy laws.

Following the cocktail of NSA leaks, Snowden scandal and the Schrems case, which raised concerns that Europeans’ personal data stored by companies in the US might be exposed to American intelligence agencies, the ECJ found that the Safe Harbour was “inadequate” to serve its protection purpose and that was not compliant with the EU Data Protection Directive.

From that moment on a sort of nightmare began for 4,500+ American firms, which started to fear they might have been requested to process data locally in each country they operate. Until a week ago, when things changed again, and “normality” came back.

Satisfaction for a “strong framework”

European Commission’s Vice President for the Digital Single Market Andrus Ansip greeted the news and expressed satisfaction for a “strong framework”. “Our people can be sure that their personal data is fully protected”, he underlined last week. “Our businesses, especially the smallest ones, have the legal certainty they need to develop their activities across the Atlantic”, he added. “We have a duty to check and we will closely monitor the new arrangement to make sure it keeps delivering”, he also declared.

EU Justice Commissioner Věra Jourová also commented the news. “The new EU-US Privacy Shield will protect the fundamental rights of Europeans when their personal data is transferred to US companies”, she said. “For the first time ever, the United States has given the EU binding assurances that the access of public authorities for national security purposes will be subject to clear limitations, safeguards and oversight mechanisms”, she added.

Commissioner Jourová also said that the US government has assured it will not conduct “mass or indiscriminate” surveillance of Europeans. The two sides have indeed established an annual joint review in order to closely monitor the implementation of these commitments, with the first expected sometime next year.

What businesses say

Besides the official plaudit by negotiators and authorities, which have worked to find the perfect balance between the privacy protection needs and the requirements of the businesses, what the real improvements, or the simple consequences, the new data-transfer agreement will bring are still to be defined. From a business perspective, the new deal will have some positive effects.

Many businesses greeted the new deal with a sigh of relief, as many now believe the new deal will bring an end to some big uncertainty the fall of Safe Harbour left behind. Others expressed just a cautious optimism, as they are still keen to see if the new deal will be just a temporary measure or a proper, cost-effective solution. In general, the new pact will effectively allow an easier transfer of data from the EU to the US and grease the “mechanics” of the data flow.

Privacy concerns

However, from a privacy protection perspective, critics are way heavier. European privacy activists were sharply critical of Tuesday’s deal, saying it will not help protect the EU citizens’ privacy, as bigger issues are basically underneath the “tip of the iceberg”.

One of the main critique is indeed that many do not believe that an American government agency which operates in secret can be monitored and checked on a regular base, and so can be trusted. Moreover, activists claim that the new framework is more intended to keep European courts from getting involved into business than to protect citizens from being spied on.

Also Maximilian Schrems, the Austrian law student and Facebook user that triggered the scandal, expressed his own concerns. “A couple of letters by the outgoing Obama administration is by no means a legal basis to guarantee the fundamental rights of 500 million European users in the long run, when there is explicit US law allowing mass surveillance,” he reportedly wrote in a letter. “We don’t know the exact legal structure yet, but this could amount to obviously disregarding the Court’s judgment”, he continued.

A short life for Privacy Shield?

Indeed, and this is what basically everyone thinks, Privacy Shield risks to have a very short life, as it seems it simply doesn’t have what it takes to survive the standards set by the European Court of Justice, but only to “buy some time” instead in the meantime. The Washington, D.C.-based Center for Democracy & Technology published a statement right after the formalization of the new EU-US deal, saying that despite the framework’s improvement for EU citizens’ data privacy it would still probably face trouble in court.

“More aligned” with human rights norm

Jens-Henrik Jeppesen, Director of European Affairs at the CDT, said that the Privacy Shield will be “deemed sufficient by the Court of Justice”. Mr. Jeppesen also declared that he believes the EU Member States should narrow their surveillance laws and practices to be “more aligned” with international human rights norms. “The goal must remain a long-term, sustainable transatlantic consensus on the proper legal framework for law enforcement and national security access to data, as well as strong, transparent commercial privacy practices,” Jeppesen concluded.

Lack of info

All in all, the main point here is that a real, effective evaluation of the new deal is really hard to be made at this point, given the tremendous lack of information. The full framework is not yet available, and so the boundaries of the EU citizens’ data are not yet precisely defined. Besides the new clause that foresees an annual EU-US joint review to check the agreement is being applied correctly, we basically only know that the US will provide “written assurances” that they will basically limit surveillance and not a lot further.

The EU declared in last week’s statement that Commissioners Ansip and Jourová receive the mandate to prepare a draft “adequacy decision” in the coming weeks, which could then be presented by the College of Commissioners to the Member States.

In general, with the people’s privacy on the table the ball should be played carefully. No doubt that some steps forward and improvements towards privacy protection were taken, but still it seems hard to believe a final solution has been found.

At the end, if the European Court of Justice sunk an EU-US data privacy deal with such a background like the Safe Harbour one, there’s no real reason why it shouldn’t do the same with this one too.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

How private equity can fund the fight against climate change

Tsipras doesn’t seem to have learned his “almost Grexit” lesson and Greece faces again financial and political dead end

This young scientist is tackling food insecurity for the world’s most vulnerable groups

The global issue of migration in 2017

Visa Facilitation and Readmission: the European Union and Belarus sign agreements

The IMF sees Brexit’s ‘substantial impact’ while the world’s economy holds its breath

Commission launches consultation to seek views on Digital Services Act package

These are the UK’s biggest trading partners

A geared turbofan at Pratt & Whitney's production hub in West Palm Beach (copyright: Pratt & Whitney - a UTC Company- 2018; Source: Pratt & Whitney's website, media center)

The EU Commission approves UTC’s acquisition of Rockwell Collins under conditions

Copyright: MEPs update rules for the digital age

Millions of young lives ‘at risk’ says UN labour chief, calling for an end to child labour

EU-Belarus: MEPs back agreements on readmission and visa facilitation

Migration crisis: how big a security threat it is?

Traditional knowledge at ‘core’ of indigenous heritage, and ‘must be protected’, says UN Forum

UN chief laments ending of Cold War-era disarmament treaty

The US banks drive the developing world to a catastrophe

‘Laser-sharp focus’ needed to achieve Global Goals by 2030, UN political forum told

Colombia’s former president says COVID-19 shows the importance of listening to indigenous peoples on how we treat the planet

This is what happens when a school swaps french fries for quinoa

French election: Will France vote for a reformed or no EU?

North Koreans trapped in ‘vicious cycle of deprivation, corruption, repression’ and endemic bribery: UN human rights office

George Floyd: these are the injustices that led to the protests in the United States

Business should be joyful – just ask the sports world

Parliament backs new CO2 emissions limits for cars and vans

Stricter rules and tougher sanctions for market manipulation and financial fraud

Why Opportunity Zones could be key to transforming our cities

UK: Crawley group wins European Citizens’ Prize

India m2m + iot Forum Hosts Successful 4th Editions of India Smart Cities Forum and India Smart Villages Forum

Let your fingers do the walking

Brexit talks started with a London handicap and Brussels’ sternness

EU summit: Are the London Tories planning an exit from the EU?

If you live in a big city you already smoke every day

5 droughts that changed human history

Trump blocks US warmongers from bombing Iran

How a 3-point plan could help rebuild business for the long-term

Peacekeeping: A ‘great opportunity’ to develop professionally and personally

COVID-19: Save European culture and values, MEPs tell Commission

Israeli security forces’ response to Gaza protests ‘a recipe for more bloodshed’, says UN expert

MWC 2016 Live: Mobile ad industry still waiting for “revolution”

UN relief chief urges Security Council to back aid delivery, more funding for millions of Syrians hit by harsh weather

Africa must use tech to chase corruption out of the shadows

UN receives ‘Humanium’ wristwatch gift, symbolizing peaceful transformation

Your morning cup of coffee contains 140 litres of water

World Health Organization calls crisis meeting over deadly Ebola outbreak in DR Congo

This is our chance to completely redefine the meaning of work

At epicentre of Indonesia disaster, Guterres praises resilience of Sulawesi people

As north-west Syria violence reaches ‘horrifying’ new level, UN relief chief says ceasefire is only option

Mitigating climate change in Asia-Pacific could give region an economic boost

No way out for Eurozone’s stagnating economy

How digital can transform healthcare in Asia for millions of people

Human rights breaches in Hong Kong, Russia and at the US-Mexican border

These are the regions where people have most faith in their schools

MEPs condemn attacks on civilians, including children, in Yemen

Will the Greek economy ever come back to growth?

The European Parliament double-checks the EU 2014-2020 budget

A new generation of women leaders is making waves in the Arab world

UN Human Rights chief urges Venezuela to halt grave rights violations

Afghan refugees: €21 million in humanitarian aid for host communities and vulnerable populations in Pakistan and Iran

The EU threatens to impose extra import duties on Chinese products

We’re all in the same boat on the SDGs. Here’s how we steer a course

More Stings?

Advertising

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s