Parlamentarians to “break up” with reality in the Google antitrust case


How many years can an antitrust case endure in the EU? It certainly depends on many factors but in the case of Google 4 is the minimum. This is because the topic of a ‘digital monopoly’ of a search engine is so refined and sophisticated that for the majority of EU stakeholders it is “terra incognita”. Also because too many interests are at stake, see for example how major European media are campaigning against Google and its power to ‘undermine’ their adverts in the search results.

The Sting has been following the matter very closely and maintains a balanced approach between the ‘search monopoly fighters’ and the right of a company to design its strategy and defence its intellectual property. For 4 years the former EU Commissioner for competition Joaquin Almunia, has been beating around the bush, launching complains, receiving Google’s proposals to alleviate the damage and throwing them back, consulting media and stakeholders. Unfortunately for the department, and fortunately for him, the good Commissioner decided to leave last month and ‘donate’ this hot potato to Margrethe Vestager, the new antitrust chief in Brussels.

As anti-Google campaigns were raging at the end of Mr Almunia’s service, in a clear attempt to push him to make up his mind, finally, it was somehow expected that the matter would escalate in the month of November, the early beginning of Mrs Vestager service. Only that this time it has reached the point where the European Parliament demands the break up of Google. Can this be?

At the end of last week two Parlamentarians, Andreas Schwab, a member of the center-right European People’s Party, and Ramon Tremosa of Spain, a member of the Parliament’s Liberal group, came up with a “potion magique” to resolve the matter. According to that resolution the two good MEPs call the Commission “to consider proposals with the aim of unbundling search engines from other commercial services as one potential long-term solution”.  So basically, what they suggest is to break up Google Search from Google Ads as business units.

“We want fair and neutral search in the interest of consumers. Unbundling is one of the ideas but we proposed several ideas of solutions that are on the table”, they underline. They believe that “the mechanism would hinder Google from applying the ranking algorithms that it currently uses. Thereby, it would be guaranteed that users receive relevant results while benefiting from greater choice”. Also they find it “essential that competition within the EU is not obstructed by multinational Internet companies that possess a dominant position”. But is it valid for two MEPs to suggest the breakup of a company when they are not able to understand or find a better way to solve it constructively both for the consumer and the market?

It seems that not even the two politicians have so much confidence in their resolution. Last Monday they issued a common statement on the matter that goes like this: “Tremosa and Schwab are not ideological against Google! We are against monopolies. Unbundling is one of the ideas but we proposed several”. Moreover, antitrust Commissioner Vestager said through her spokesperson: “We are committed to ensuring fair competition in the markets they are active in. Commissioner Vestager will decide on how to take the ongoing antitrust investigations into Google’s business practices forward, once she has heard what those most directly affected by the practices in question have to say” . Obviously it is in the Commission’s interest to maintain a balanced approach on this one.

Even though Google made no comment or official statement on the proposal issued by the two MEPs, the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA), lobby organisation of which Google is a member, argues: “this motion, especially if passed by Parliament, threatens to undermine the credibility of a long running Commission investigation by blatantly interjecting politics into a legal process”…“Even though this motion is clearly directed at one company, the approach taken in this motion—and the politics surrounding the Google competition case in general—has wider implications and threatens the entire Internet economy”.

Who is right here? Two MEPs that don’t even believe in their drafted proposal or a lobby organisation? The truth as always in Brussels lies somewhere in the middle. While it is always good that the Parliament creates awareness and noise on matters that are of the EU citizen’s interest, it is absolutely the Commission’s job to examine the matter thoroughly and not let it linger like the team of Mr Almunia did.

The MEP’s proposal is expected to be discussed today in Strasbourg and the EU Parliament to vote on it tomorrow. While it will be interesting to see the outcome of this new anti-Google campaign, we would like to hope that this Commission will be able to put a fair closure on the matter soon and not wait again another 4 years for the new new Commissioner to come.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Amid COVID-19 constraints, UN women’s commission meets to push gender equality forward

Mental health problems costing Europe heavily

Family businesses are the lifeblood of the Middle East. How do we ensure they survive?

School closures triple in Central and Western Africa as education comes under fire

Pedro Sánchez: We must protect Europe, so Europe can protect its citizens

Medical ethics in the age of the social media influencers

EU Commission: The banks are not obliged to finance the real economy

Tackling ‘deeply worrying’ global rise in anti-Semitism is a job for all societies everywhere, says UN chief

Belgium: Youth Forum takes legal step to ban unpaid internships

Opposite cultures: Should it be a problem?

Your morning cup of coffee contains 140 litres of water

“Beating pollution for our planet”, a Sting Exclusive by Mr Erik Solheim, the Executive Director of the United Nations Environment

State aid: Commission approves €30 billion French subordinated loan scheme to support companies affected by the coronavirus outbreak

Everybody against Japan over yen’s devaluation

These are the countries best prepared for the fight against cancer

Earth already has a perfect recycling system. So why not use it?

The movement of anti-vaccers: taking humanity back 200 years

To my Chinese friend

International Criminal Court acquits former president Gbagbo of war crimes in Côte d’Ivoire

The issue of health literacy and how it affects European health policies

Italy and Greece zeroed their fiscal deficits, expect Germany’s response

Global Citizen-Volunteer Internships

Youth Forum welcomes European Commission proposal to speed up financing for youth employment

Reception conditions for asylum-seekers agreed between MEPs and Council

Wednesday’s Daily Brief: Women boost work profits, saving biodiversity, UK loses Chagos Islands vote, Gaza funding, malaria-free in Argentina, Algeria

Draghi strives to control the unruly exploitation of financial markets by banking leviathans

Donald Trump’s victory is a great opening for global EU leadership on the sustainability agenda

Greece at the mercy of ECB while sailing through uncharted waters

Without tackling ‘gross inequalities’ major issues will go unsolved, warns UN rights chief Bachelet

Could robot leaders do better than our current politicians?

What is hydroponics – and is it the future of farming?

Stability in Europe has no chances because of Ukraine

Checks, fines, crisis reserve: MEPs vote on EU farm policy reform

EU to Telcos: Stop Mergers and Acquisitions but please help me urgently with 5G development

COP21 Breaking News_05 December: Carbon Price Needed for Climate Change Success

Progress made in UN talks to end Yemen war, Envoy lauds ‘positive and serious spirit’

The US bugged Europe: Is this news?

IMF: When high yield goes boom

Scotland wants to create an ethical stock exchange (Post Brexit)

The first new university in the UK for 40 years is taking a very different approach to education

EU Trust Fund Bêkou for the Central African Republic extended until 2020

This AI is working with a fleet of drones to help us fight ocean plastic

Time to say goodbye to the plastic straw. But what’s the best alternative?

A Sting Exclusive: “Regulators and the shipping industry collaborating for a sustainable future”, written by the Secretary General of IMO

UN ‘stands in solidarity’ with cyclone-hit India – Secretary-General Guterres

The EU cuts roaming charges further while the UK weighs Brexit impact

Diversity training doesn’t change people’s behaviour. We need to find out what does

This app lets you plant trees to fight deforestation

MEPs condemn criminalisation of sex education in Poland

EU Top Jobs summit ended with no agreement: welcome to Europe’s quicksand!

Forests ‘essential’ for the future, UN agriculture chief spells out in new report

IMF’s Lagarde: Ukraine must fight corruption

Inflammation is the fuel that feeds the cancer flame. So how do we fight back?

‘Proving our worth through action’: 5 things Guterres wants the UN to focus on in 2019

Future fit: 3 ways fashion can be more sustainable

‘Unlock opportunities’ and pave the way for sustainable development, UN chief urges on World Population Day

Yemen: UN envoy asks Security Council for more support ‘to move back’ to the negotiating table

On eve of Gaza border protest anniversary, UN’s top humanitarian official for Palestine calls for calm

UN resolution paves way for mass use of driverless cars

Climate changes and the imminent public health crises

More Stings?


Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s