Parlamentarians to “break up” with reality in the Google antitrust case

Google_logo_

How many years can an antitrust case endure in the EU? It certainly depends on many factors but in the case of Google 4 is the minimum. This is because the topic of a ‘digital monopoly’ of a search engine is so refined and sophisticated that for the majority of EU stakeholders it is “terra incognita”. Also because too many interests are at stake, see for example how major European media are campaigning against Google and its power to ‘undermine’ their adverts in the search results.

The Sting has been following the matter very closely and maintains a balanced approach between the ‘search monopoly fighters’ and the right of a company to design its strategy and defence its intellectual property. For 4 years the former EU Commissioner for competition Joaquin Almunia, has been beating around the bush, launching complains, receiving Google’s proposals to alleviate the damage and throwing them back, consulting media and stakeholders. Unfortunately for the department, and fortunately for him, the good Commissioner decided to leave last month and ‘donate’ this hot potato to Margrethe Vestager, the new antitrust chief in Brussels.

As anti-Google campaigns were raging at the end of Mr Almunia’s service, in a clear attempt to push him to make up his mind, finally, it was somehow expected that the matter would escalate in the month of November, the early beginning of Mrs Vestager service. Only that this time it has reached the point where the European Parliament demands the break up of Google. Can this be?

At the end of last week two Parlamentarians, Andreas Schwab, a member of the center-right European People’s Party, and Ramon Tremosa of Spain, a member of the Parliament’s Liberal group, came up with a “potion magique” to resolve the matter. According to that resolution the two good MEPs call the Commission “to consider proposals with the aim of unbundling search engines from other commercial services as one potential long-term solution”.  So basically, what they suggest is to break up Google Search from Google Ads as business units.

“We want fair and neutral search in the interest of consumers. Unbundling is one of the ideas but we proposed several ideas of solutions that are on the table”, they underline. They believe that “the mechanism would hinder Google from applying the ranking algorithms that it currently uses. Thereby, it would be guaranteed that users receive relevant results while benefiting from greater choice”. Also they find it “essential that competition within the EU is not obstructed by multinational Internet companies that possess a dominant position”. But is it valid for two MEPs to suggest the breakup of a company when they are not able to understand or find a better way to solve it constructively both for the consumer and the market?

It seems that not even the two politicians have so much confidence in their resolution. Last Monday they issued a common statement on the matter that goes like this: “Tremosa and Schwab are not ideological against Google! We are against monopolies. Unbundling is one of the ideas but we proposed several”. Moreover, antitrust Commissioner Vestager said through her spokesperson: “We are committed to ensuring fair competition in the markets they are active in. Commissioner Vestager will decide on how to take the ongoing antitrust investigations into Google’s business practices forward, once she has heard what those most directly affected by the practices in question have to say” . Obviously it is in the Commission’s interest to maintain a balanced approach on this one.

Even though Google made no comment or official statement on the proposal issued by the two MEPs, the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA), lobby organisation of which Google is a member, argues: “this motion, especially if passed by Parliament, threatens to undermine the credibility of a long running Commission investigation by blatantly interjecting politics into a legal process”…“Even though this motion is clearly directed at one company, the approach taken in this motion—and the politics surrounding the Google competition case in general—has wider implications and threatens the entire Internet economy”.

Who is right here? Two MEPs that don’t even believe in their drafted proposal or a lobby organisation? The truth as always in Brussels lies somewhere in the middle. While it is always good that the Parliament creates awareness and noise on matters that are of the EU citizen’s interest, it is absolutely the Commission’s job to examine the matter thoroughly and not let it linger like the team of Mr Almunia did.

The MEP’s proposal is expected to be discussed today in Strasbourg and the EU Parliament to vote on it tomorrow. While it will be interesting to see the outcome of this new anti-Google campaign, we would like to hope that this Commission will be able to put a fair closure on the matter soon and not wait again another 4 years for the new new Commissioner to come.

Advertising

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Nagasaki is ‘a global inspiration’ for peace, UN chief says marking 73rd anniversary of atomic bombing

Malaysia can show the way towards a holistic model for human rights

Rohingya cannot become ‘forgotten victims,’ says UN chief urging world to step up support

6 facts to know about EU alternative investment funds

What washing your hands can teach you about global change

Here’s why the tech sector could be the next target for Chinese investment in Africa

New UN rights report paints bleak picture in eastern DR Congo

The unpleasant truth of plastic straws

Guterres hails historic Convention banning violence and harassment at work

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: funding for Palestine refugees, families today, tech surveillance

This man is sleeping out in the Davos cold to make a point about homelessness

Future-proofing the European banking market – removing the obstacles to exit

This graphene battery can recharge itself to provide unlimited clean energy

Avocado: the ‘green gold’ causing environment havoc

Around 23 million boys have married before reaching 15; ‘we can end this violation’ says UNICEF chief

How smarter machines can make us smarter humans

EU budget: Regional Development and Cohesion Policy beyond 2020

This NATO experiment used fake Facebook accounts to trick soldiers into sharing sensitive information

The remote doctor, can it ever work?

UN agency warns conditions around Yemen’s key port city of Hudaydah still ‘very bad’, as staff rush to deliver aid

Mediterranean and Black Seas: Commission proposes fishing opportunities for 2020

UN and Red Cross chiefs appeal for end to use of explosive weapons in cities

The Junior Enterprise concept: Business & Education

Close to final agreement on the EU Banking Union

Commission: Raising the social issues that can make or break the monetary union

Impact investment favours expats over African entrepreneurs. Here’s how to fix that

5G networks: to slice or not to slice?

Who should pay for workers to be reskilled?

‘Antagonistic gestures and accusations’ drown out Kosovo dialogue hopes, Security Council hears

Aid stepped up to Syria camp; new arrivals say terrorists blocked their escape

From UN Assembly podium, Central African Republic leader appeals for lifting arms embargo

More women and girls needed in the sciences to solve world’s biggest challenges

A ship with containers at the port of Rotterdam. (Copyright: European Union. Source: EC - Audiovisual Service. Photo: Robert Meerding)

US follows the EU in impeding China market economy status in WTO

Poland: €676 million worth of EU investments in better rails and roads

Blockchain is becoming key for global trade – but is that a gift for hackers?

UN chief pays tribute to ‘enduring contributions’ to regional, international diplomacy of Oman’s late Sultan Qaboos

It’s getting harder to move data abroad. Here’s why it matters and what we can do

European Court rules that ECB’s OMT program of 2012 is OK; not a word from Germany about returning the Greek 2010 courtesy

UN ‘stands in solidarity’ with cyclone-hit India – Secretary-General Guterres

As fighting in Libya escalates, so does number of children ‘at imminent risk of injury or death’

Somalis ‘will not be deterred’ by Friday’s terror attacks – UN chief

Brexit casts a shadow over the LSE – Deutsche Börse merger: a tracer of how or if brexit is to be implemented

The experience economy is booming, but it must benefit everyone

EU Summit consumed by the banks

Yemen: Recent uptick in fighting contradicts desire for peace

100 years after Polish independence, 5 reasons to be cheerful for the future

GSMA head urges regulators to help Europe regain leadership

Taxes on polluting fuels are too low to encourage a shift to low-carbon alternatives

Mergers: Commission approves Assa Abloy’s acquisition of Agta Record, subject to conditions

EU humanitarian budget for 2020 to help people in over 80 countries

Meet the robot fighting back against coral reef destruction

From philanthropy to profit: how clean energy is kickstarting sustainable development in East Africa

EU unfolds strategy on the Egypt question

Chart of the day: These countries have the highest share of electric vehicles

These are the world’s healthiest nations

Global Citizen-Volunteer Internships

Why the answer to a more sustainable future could lie within the platform economy

Youth Entrepreneurship Issue of the month: JEN, organisers of JADE October Meeting, on why JEs should come together

‘No-deal’ Brexit preparedness: European Commission takes stock of preparations and provides practical guidance to ensure coordinated EU approach

Paris, Rome, Brussels and Frankfurt to confront Berlin over growth and the Athens enigma

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s