Can privatisation be the panacea for the lack of growth in Europe?

From left to right, Wolfgang Schüssel; Fabrizio Saccomanni; Sylvie Goulard; Leonhard Birnbaum; Christian Helmenstein  (United Europe, 13/10/2014)

From left to right, Wolfgang Schüssel; Fabrizio Saccomanni; Sylvie Goulard; Leonhard Birnbaum; Christian Helmenstein (United Europe, 13/10/2014)

An interesting topic was treated last Monday evening in Brussels and the European Sting was present to listen to some ideas on how to boost growth in the European Economy in a pragmatic manner. It would be unfair to say that the idea on the table of the discussion was original or innovative but nevertheless it was worth listening.

“Privatisation Potential in the European Union” was the topic of the event that was co-hosted by United Europe and the Bertelsmann Stiftung earlier this week and lots of people gathered to participate in the debate. The main stimulus was the presentation of the study of Economica Institute in Vienna on how much money would go in the EU’s pockets if the state was ‘convinced’ to withdraw from the public and private sector. Prominent panelists shared with the audience some interesting thoughts, Dr Chrisstian Helmenstein, Board Member of Economica Institute, Dr Wolfgang Schussel, former Chancellor of Austria and President of United Europe, Sylvie Goulard, French MEP, Dr Leonhard Birnbaum, Member of the Board of E.ON and Fabrizio Saccomanni, former Minister of Economy and Finances in Italy.

The evening started with Mr Schussel, President of United Europe and former Prime Minister of Austria, who briefly set the scene of a European Union in economic crisis with its citizens suffering from lack of European identity. Indeed this is roughly the image of Europe currently. Mr Schussel went further on, saying that privatisation is being significantly reduced since 2009. And this is mainly attributed by him to the lack of political will in the Union to endorse systematically privatisation. Moreover, he former Chancellor of Austria linked productivity with privatisation and compared Europe with other parts of the world where productivity is much more impressive than in the Old Continent.

Right after the brief introduction, Mr Helmenstein from Economica Institute, who is the main researcher responsible for this study, came to the podium. While referring to the specifications of the research, the researcher underlined his core finding, that Europe can make up to 500 billion euros if everything became private in one night. Of course, he also presented to us the figures in the case that the state withdraw by 25% or 50% from public and private companies.  Apparently the results of this study are describing an ideal European situation. Truth is, however, that most of EU leaders are familiar with the benefits of privatisation, only that it is easier said than done. Further, privatisation is just one of the means to promote growth. Thus, we anticipated with interest the comments following by the panel.

Mr Saccomanni began his commentary on the results of this study, saying that given the economic state Europe is at the moment, “anything can help” the EU. He praised the macro-economic effect of privatisation and referred to the privatisation of banking sector in Italy as a success story. Further, the former Italian Minister of Economy mentioned how his work with the Letta government had as primordial aim the privatisation of public companies in ‘Belpaese’. He also made the remark that even the Renzi government follows the same path. At least, the “infrastructure of the single market”, he argued, sectors like energy and digital industry, need to be privatised as much as possible for the EU to come back to growth fast.

The turn of Mrs Goulard, French liberal MEP of ALDE, came right after that and she stressed immediately how growth is desperately needed in Europe. Interestingly enough the French MEP discussed about the privatisation potential of France that on its own is not able to eradicate public debt. Mrs Goulard embraced the privatisation idea but at the same time she underlines that Europe lacks a panEuropean strategy and approach on this one. On the country, unilateral approach by member states cannot just do the trick.  The French politician argued that there is a lot of foreign investment to foster growth in the Old Continent, but would not be materialised if Europe is fragmented policy wise.

Last, but not least, Mr Birnbaum from the German energy company, E.ON, argued that the real growth issue should not be privatisation but instead efficiency. He referred to the example of his company that when it takes over a smaller company in the energy industry, then suddenly productivity gets better, as well as safety. He supports that utility industry can bear great advantages from privatisation. As he simply put it, “improvement of industry would not have happened with monopolies”. In a nutshell, for the German business man it is not necessarily privatisation but the mere pressure from the market that can clean an economy and enforce growth. That combined with fair regulation.

All in all, the takeaway from this event was rather positive. Emphasis on the benefits of privatisation is always relevant, especially in these times of economic fragility in Europe. However, it is known that privatisation is not panacea. It is certainly not the synonym of growth but only one means to obtain a growth orbit. Most importantly, most member states have privatisation in their agenda but in general do not see as ambitious results as per the plans preceding. Instead, estimating the impact of privatisation to public debt, as many of the panelists argued about last Monday, is a rather tricky and multifactorial exercise.

Last, if we accept that privatisation can release business in some sectors, create competition and hence growth in the long run, then what are the sectors or type of companies that need to remain public? Are we pro-privatisation for anything? Would we want to pay a price for water we drink or air that we breathe to private companies? And what are the dangers if ownership expands to areas that jeopardise harmony in societies?

All these are questions that we hope the next United Europe conference on privatisation will not neglect to address.







the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

The global liberal order is in trouble – can it be salvaged, or will it be replaced?

Can free trade deliver cheaper renewable energy? Ask Mexico

Human rights: breaches in Iran, Saudi Arabia and Sudan

A third of young people polled by UN, report being a victim of online bullying

The Fourth Industrial Revolution is about to hit the construction industry. Here’s how it can thrive

Main results of European Council of 18/10/2018

Is friendly public transport the answer to the loneliness epidemic?

OECD presents revised Codes on capital flows to G20

The succesful cooperation

Righting a wrong: UN Fund helps thousands of sex abuse survivors rebuild their lives

Here’s what a Korean boy band can teach us about globalization 4.0

Engaging world’s youth vital to preventing violent extremism, building sustainable peace, UN official tells Baku Forum

Commission makes it easier for citizens to access health data securely across borders

First-ever global conference of national counter-terrorism chiefs will strengthen cooperation, build ‘resilient’ States, says top UN official

Protecting farmers and quality products: vote on EU farm policy reform plans

In 2019, ‘reasons for hope’ in a world still on ‘red alert’: UN chief Guterres

Sudan: ‘Exercise utmost restraint’ urges Guterres as thousands march in Khartoum, sparking deadly clashes

Your morning cup of coffee contains 140 litres of water

Wednesday’s Daily Brief: Diplomacy for Peace Day, #VaccinesWork, the cost of war on Afghans, tech and well-being

EU and Amazon cut deal to end antitrust investigation over e-books deals

Refugee crisis update: Commission is struggling alone with little help from EU or G7 leaders

OECD leading multilateral efforts to address tax challenges from digitalisation of the economy

Ukraine turns again to the EU for more money

The London City-EU connection holds despite of Brexit and the ban of LSE-Deutsche Börse merger

What you need to know about 5G

Berlin ‘orders’ the EU Parliament to compromise

Young people are not a nameless, faceless mass. So why do we treat them as such?

Quicker freezing and confiscation of criminal assets to fight organised crime

Stricter rules to stop terrorists from using homemade explosives

‘Catastrophic’ healthcare costs put mothers and newborns at risk

Giving humanitarian help to migrants should not be a crime, say MEPs

Employment: Commission proposes €1.6 million from Globalisation Adjustment Fund to help 400 workers made redundant in Carrefour Belgique

Action needed to end deadly clashes between African herders and farmers: UN chief

Iran cannot be allowed to develop nuclear weapons: Israeli Foreign Minister

Global Cooperation for Local Action: Fighting antimicrobial resistance

UN monitoring team in Yemen verifies pullout of armed forces from crucial port zones

An alternative view of Globalization 4.0, and how to get there

“C’est la vie”? French recession and unemployment to linger in Eurozone

Burnout is a pandemic. Why don’t we talk more about it?

FROM THE FIELD: Hardy seeds bear fruit to protect Colombia’s environment

Africa shouldn’t have to choose between high growth and low emissions

5G networks: to slice or not to slice?

Here are four steps SMEs can take for long-term success

New skills agenda for Europe needs real investment

Italian voters put again the European Peoples in the Brussels picture

External action: more funds for human rights, development and climate change

How close is Eurozone to a new recession which may trigger formidable developments?

Far from a healthy Health Workforce: lack of workforce planning leaves our citizens without access to proper care

Digital Single Market: New EU rules for online subscription services

Brexit negotiations: back to square one, tougher words, no good faith

Why a global recession isn’t inevitable

UN chief highlights action across borders for ‘stable and prosperous Eurasia’

Governments need to honour their climate pledges as risks grow

Sanctions on Russia to be the biggest unity test at this European Council

Why the euro may rise with the dollar even at lower interest rates

More ‘political commitment’ needed urgently for HIV prevention: UNAIDS chief

These chefs are fighting hunger and poverty with gastronomy

We are ‘burning up our future’, UN’s Bachelet tells Human Rights Council

Migrants and refugees face higher risk of developing ill-health, says UN report on displaced people in Europe

‘Digital divide’ will worsen inequalities, without better global cooperation

More Stings?

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s