Benjamin Franklin was wrong: Amazon can tax evade

Amazon_Logo“In this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes”, Benjamin Franklin said back in the 18th century. Three hundred years later in principle it maintains validity, when it comes to the former. Of course for most developed societies tax is a de facto obligation of the citizen.

Most of us we are not even asked to pay taxes; our employers keep a priori a good part of our salary, we buy anything 20% more expensive and in general we learn to live in a manner that we never think about taxes; we simply and subconsciously pay them by default. Well, this is not the case for companies, especially big ones, that are able to hire teams of experienced people to invent creative ways to pay less taxes.

Governments tolerate corporate tax evasion

Although less taxes paid by big companies mean less school renovations, the governments somehow tolerate to a certain extent this “corporate behaviour”, because with the taxes collected already some schools will be renovated anyway. However, some countries, EU member states, simply overdo it. Recently Apple, Stanbucks and Fiat Finance and Trade have been the aim of Mr Almunia and his team. The reason of this investigation is to confirm whether those multinationals are transferring prices and profits to their subsidiaries in order to benefit from taxation in EU member states that is low and also whether tax authorities are favourable.

Amazon under the magnifying glass

Currently the European Commission is investigating a 2003 deal made between Luxembourg tax authorities and Amazon, the world’s most successful e-shop. Apparently when you buy a pair of shoes online from your home in Europe, you always have a transaction between Amazon Luxembourg and yourself. The paradox is that at the end of the year Amazon Luxembourg is not making any significant profit. Now for a 14 billion euro company this would certainly attract the attention of any tax collector; if not the Luxembourgeois, the EU one for sure.

As Mr Almunia, EU Commissioner responsible for competition issues, puts it: “The Amazon subsidiary in Luxembourg records most of the group’s Europe profit. It pays a royalty to another entity in Luxembourg… “At this stage we consider the amount of this royalty, which lowered the taxable profits of Amazon, was not in line with market conditions. Luxembourg agreed to limit the amount subject to tax.”

It seems that Amazon’s CFO is a cunning one. Amazon Luxembourg is paying heavy invoices for intellectual property, sent by Amazon Europe Holding Technologies SCS (AEHT), the parent company. This of course shows in the P&L (Profit and Loss statement) of the Luxembourgeois company a very small EBITDA (earnings before tax). There you go!

Luxembourg the place to be

In principle the DG Competition is against any special treatment given by some member states to big multinationals. “It is only fair that subsidiaries of multinational companies pay their share of taxes and do not receive preferential treatment which could amount to hidden subsidies,” says Commissioner Almunia. The Commission clearly implies here that Luxembourg state is allowing this phenomenon to occur or is looking to another direction, since its deal with the American online giant.

In response to Almunia’s claim, the Finance Ministry of the small city/state replied with expected reassurance: “Luxembourg is confident that the allegations of state aid in this case are unsubstantiated and that the Commission investigation will conclude that no special tax treatment or advantage has been awarded to Amazon.” Similarly Amazon states officially that: “Amazon has received no special tax treatment from Luxembourg, we are subject to the same tax laws as other companies operating here”.

So, nobody shows any special fiscal treatment and thus nobody receives it. Can we go home now? Not yet. When Almunia and his team open an investigation they are never in a rush to close it. See Google’s case that is lasting now for 4 good years.

It seems that the aim of the Commission is to shoot against the big companies/brands. Is it because these are the only companies with a ‘creative’ CFO? Certainly not! There are two reasons instead; the first reason is that usually these companies make a hell of turnover and thus the fines to be paid are greater. This is highly needed, especially in a European economy that is lately shaky enough. The second reason is that by investigating or even fining the big, the small will hopefully become more prudent.

Millionaires are bound to tax evade

All in all, corporate tax evasion is a big issue, not only in Europe but globally. The source of evil in this case is the mere mentality of the major shareholder of a company; if you ask him, “why do you tax evade?”, the answer would be, “if you could make all this money, would you give half of it back to the state?”

While it is hard to answer the latter, as it is impossible to simulate your behaviour with a few million euros in your current account, it is reassuring to know that there are EU bodies like the Commission that monitor this activity and tries at least to put a break in the predator instincts of shareholders.

At the end of the day Amazon or any Amazon deserves every penny from its slim gross margin but definitely not at the expense of a new bridge, faculty or park that will make the rest of the taxpayers keep paying their taxes and  buying shoes online.

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Estonia is making public transport free

Why Obama asks approval from Congress to bomb Syria?

Measles claims more than twice as many lives than Ebola in DR Congo

UN report sheds light on ‘unimaginable horrors’ faced by migrants and refugees in Libya, and beyond

Worth going ‘extra mile’ for a new Syrian constitution, UN envoy urges

How well you age depends on what you think of old age

Madagascar villagers learn dangers of outdoor defecation

Chart of the Day: These are the world’s most innovative economies

Internet of Things: a Force for Good or Evil?

This Chinese tech giant’s latest gadget is… a bus

Menu for change: why we have to go towards a Common Food Policy

MEPs adopt plan to keep 2020 EU funding for UK in no-deal Brexit scenario

President Sassoli press conference on EU summit, Recovery Fund and Budget

Service and Sacrifice: Malaysian peacekeepers in Lebanon proud to serve their homeland and the United Nations

The company of the future must do well by doing good

We’re fighting the pandemic. Now it’s time to eradicate the infodemic

WHO and UNICEF in campaign to protect 1.6 million in Sudan from cholera

Hundreds of thousands of lives still lost each year to small arms, UN conference hears

Black Lives Matter – for Pakistan’s Sheedi community too

5 ways companies can support their remote workforce

Commission launches initiative for more sustainable cocoa production

Why a global recession isn’t inevitable

5 reasons to protect mangrove forests for the future

Customs Union: New Action Plan to further support EU customs in their vital role of protecting EU revenues, prosperity and security

EU job-search aid worth €2 million for 500 former shipbuilding workers in Spain

Europe is designing satellites that ‘surf’ their way past space debris

What do refugees really need from those who want to help? A refugee explains

Online platforms required by law to be more transparent with EU businesses

Ahead of State of the Union the European Youth Forum highlights lack of action on youth employment

Coronavirus: Eight macro-financial assistance programmes agreed to support enlargement and neighbourhood partners

These scientists are using sound waves to filter plastic fibres from washing machine wastewater

Climate Change : An Already Health Emergency

China hails human rights progress amid calls to close detention camps

A new leadership agenda for private equity

An economist explains what happens if there’s another financial crisis

“There are many converging visions and interests between the One Belt One Road initiative and the Juncker Investment Plan”, Ambassador Yang of the Chinese Mission to EU highlights from Brussels

Parliament sets up plan to fight the 3,600 criminal rings of EU

Eurozone: Statistics don’t tell the whole story

Thinking throughout HIV: changing a perspective

Coronavirus: Commission concludes exploratory talks with Valneva to secure a new potential vaccine

How can impact investors balance the green energy equation?

First EU collective redress mechanism to protect consumers

Mario Draghi quizzed for last time by Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee

Finland has just published everyone’s taxes on ‘National Jealousy Day’

Tuesday’s Daily Brief: Guterres calls for restraint in Venezuela, Jazz Day, the importance of breastfeeding, and updates from Libya, Iran and Mozambique

Survivors of ISIL terror in Iraq want justice, not revenge, says head of UN investigation team

Eliminating waste at scale – eight opportunities for blockchain

UN chief calls for ‘solidarity, compassion and action’ on World Refugee Day

The ocean is teeming with microplastic – a million times more than we thought, suggests new research

‘Ghost fishing’ is threatening our oceans. Here’s how we can tackle it

COVID-19 vaccines: Parliament supports speedy authorisation of safe vaccines

Google’s hot summer never ends: EC to launch ANOTHER antitrust inquiry against the American giant

EU adopts new €100 million assistance package to benefit refugees and local communities in Lebanon, Jordan, and Iraq

UN health agency highlights lifestyle choices that can prevent onset of dementia, as millions more succumb each year

Nearly 900 reportedly killed following ‘shocking’ intercommunal attacks in DR Congo

The end of Spitzenkandidat: EU leaders concluded unexpectedly on EU top jobs

80 million Chinese people no longer pay income tax

The Bavarians threaten Berlin and Brussels with immigration crisis

“Who do I call if I want to call Europe?” Finally a name and a number to answer Henry Kissinger’s question

Commission criticised member states on blocking financial transaction tax

More Stings?



  1. Reblogged this on Ace News Desk 2014 and commented:

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s