Currency Union might not let an independent Scotland join the EU as the “Yes” front now leads

José Manuel Barroso, President of the EC, and Alex Salmond, First Minister of the Scottish Government (EC Audivisual Services, 2/12/2009)

José Manuel Barroso, President of the EC, and Alex Salmond, First Minister of the Scottish Government (EC Audiovisual Services, 2/12/2009)

It is almost a week away now. Scotland’s independence referendum is next week, and the situation has never been as delicate and confused as it is now. The news came in last Sunday, and it was a shock: Scottish PM Alex Salmond’s “Yes” campaign is in the lead for the first time. A YouGov poll by The Sunday Times placed the “Yes” to independence campaign at 51 per cent against the “No” campaign with 49 per cent, overturning a 22-point lead for the “Better Together” unionist campaign in just a month.

The two-point advantage is clearly within the margin of error and probably shows a situation which is closer to a draw than to a triumph for one of the two parts, but the news run faster than light. And its echo is still audible. As the Queen is said to be “horrified” at the prospect of a “yes” vote, Chancellor George Osborne promised a “plan of action to give more powers to Scotland” should a “No” vote prevail in the referendum and Prime Minister David Cameron has announced that the Saltire will fly above Downing Street in a show of support for the Union.

But these were not the only reactions to the news. The pound slumped to a 10-month low on Monday as the “Yes” campaign took the lead, losing almost one and a half cents against the US dollar. Sterling reached $1.618, the lowest level since November 2013, and it was not alone while falling. Energy group SSE (Scottish & Southern Electricity), Lloyds Banking Group, Standard Life and Aberdeen Asset Management all fell 1.5% to 2.5% in early trading on Monday, with Royal Bank of Scotland as the biggest ‘faller’ in the FTSE 100 (3% down).

The situation is uncertain for sure, but uncertainty may all come from the same source: the currency that an independent Scotland would use. This is still a big knot and always the biggest question. As largely rumoured, an independent Scotland could not rejoin the European Union if it used the pound informally, as held out by the “Yes” side. This practice is generally known as “sterlingisation”.

Former EU Economics Chief Olli Rehn is one of the most prestigious voices to have confirmed that this theory cannot be taken into consideration. Indeed he declared that it would “simply not be possible” to combine a policy of sterlingisation with EU membership. Mr. Rehn, was quite direct though. In a letter to the British chief secretary to the treasury, Danny Alexander, he said that states applying for membership have to have a central bank. Mr. Rehn officially casted Alex Salmond’s plans of currency union with London, also without an agreement, as he said, into doubt. Therefore the absence of a central bank and not having a formal currency union could prevent an independent Scotland from joining the EU.

So we have the “Yes” front gaining ground on one side, and still no answer to the “what currency is an independent Scotland going to adopt?” question on the other. Not a common view of the thing at least. Mr. Salmond would say there’s no doubt about this, and that an independent Scotland would automatically adopt sterling as its currency.

But I ask: is the currency union option an actual and convenient one for Scotland indeed? And, most of all, is this an option that truly marries the idea of independence from the UK? Basically currency union is when countries with different political systems share a currency. This way there’s always a certain loss of economic – and, someway, political power for the country that adopts the currency in a “second moment”. High interest rates or general limits might be imposed by London, and this would be again some kind of dependency. A much more subtle and silent one, but still dependency. And this is something that should be taken into consideration by the Scots.

The other options seem to be quite hard work anyway. Adopting a new currency would bring total control and general independence from the Bank of England, but also some kind of “start from point zero” for Scotland, with markets to convince and investments potentially falling. The option of Scotland adopting the Euro seems now to be quite unrealistic, as the pro “Yes” campaigners are investing totally on a currency union option, making the Eurozone currency not so popular.

Scotland is running towards a historic moment, which might change its history forever, and the last few days apparently changed the scenario itself like never before. What sounded crazy just a few weeks ago is now shaking the markets, and maybe also the Parliament’s seats. The only risk is that there’s still too much uncertainty, as I said, and that this revolution could take place with unexpected consequences.

Too many question marks and slogans should be replaced by answers, while the referendum is less one week away. On 18 September Scotland votes on whether it is better to end its 307-year union with England and break up the UK. This is something that now has got a completely different sound and outreach.

Follow @carlomotta_ on Twitter

the sting Milestone

Featured Stings

Can we feed everyone without unleashing disaster? Read on

These campaigners want to give a quarter of the UK back to nature

How to build a more resilient and inclusive global system

Stopping antimicrobial resistance would cost just USD 2 per person a year

Brussels to point the finger to Washington for lack of commitment over TTIP

EU Commission: Once in every 20 beef meals you eat…horse probably with drugs in it

Sanity in times of COVID-19

State aid: Commission approves €50 million Italian support scheme for production and supply of medical equipment and masks during Coronavirus outbreak

IMF: When high yield goes boom

Commission presents EU-Vietnam trade and investment agreements for signature and conclusion

The West castigates Turkey’s Erdogan for the ruthless political cleansing

Eurozone: GDP development heads to naught; the expensive euro serves only Germany

Will AI make the gender gap in the workplace harder to close?

Working from home? Here are 5 tips for a more human digital experience

Brexit talks: Today the world to hear of a predictable failure

The COP24 Agreement: Yes, it happened at last

The benefits of exercise in the midst of the Covid-19 pandemic

Mindfulness: a freedom we can still have in the pandemic

EU’s Bank signs € 150 million loan to India as part of record investment in clean energy

European Parliament gives green light to Christine Lagarde

Does it pay for cities to be green?

Night owls, rest easy

This study wants every child in the UK to spend a night under the stars

European Citizens’ Initiative: Commission decides to register an initiative for ‘a ban on biometric mass surveillance practices’

Auditors say EU spending delivers limited value for money but the timing of their report poses questions

The reskilling revolution can transform the future of work for women

DiscoverEU: 20,000 more young people will explore Europe in 2020

A Sting Exclusive: “Asia-Pacific response to COVID-19 and climate emergency must build a resilient and sustainable future”, by the United Nations Under-Secretary-General

To solve the climate crisis, we need an investment revolution

Wages are flatlining around the world – is automation to blame?

ISIL continues to pose a ‘serious challenge’ worldwide – UN counter-terror chief

Humans have caused this environmental crisis. It’s time to change how we think about risk

New labour laws in Qatar benefiting migrant workers a ‘momentous step forward’: ILO

‘Terrorist Iranian regime’ must be checked; Saudi Foreign Minister urges financial pressure

A poor kid died just now. Do you know why?

Venezuela must guarantee judicial impartiality – UN human rights expert

This Japanese company pays its employees to get a good night’s sleep

World Health Day: Statement by Commissioner Stella Kyriakides

State aid: Commission expands Temporary Framework to further support micro, small and start-up companies and incentivise private investments

German stock market is not affected by the Greek debt revolution while Athens is running out of time

It’s time to get serious about the causes of pandemics: UN report

It is now the era to evolve mutually as the bacteria do

Commission announces actions to make Europe’s raw materials supply more secure and sustainable

Greater support needed for refugees and migrants from Venezuela – UN

The Parliament sets the way for the European Banking Union

Security Council imposes arms embargo on South Sudan

The Sting’s Values

Presidents of pan-European youth organisations call upon the European Council to preserve the Schengen principles

How electrification will make the world more inclusive

Fairness should be at the heart of the agricultural goods trade

UN relief chief urges Security Council to back aid delivery, more funding for millions of Syrians hit by harsh weather

COVID-19: More new virus cases outside China than in, ‘no time for complacency’, says UN health agency

Empowering people living with HIV ‘will end the epidemic’, says AIDS agency chief

How poor countries can deal with the economic shock of COVID-19

EU long-term budget: EP still fighting for a good agreement

The digital revolution will transform the steel industry

IMF: World cup and productivity

Things are bad and getting worse for South Africa. Or are they?

Barriers to trade: as protectionism rises, EU continues opening up export markets for European firms

Parliament makes it easier to organise a European Citizens’ Initiative

A neo-liberal toll free Paradise for the super rich and tax hell for wage earners

5 ways social entrepreneurs are helping farmers feed the world

Iraq needs support to ‘leave violent past behind’, says UN envoy as Security Council extends UN mission for one year

TTIP’s 11th round major takeaways and the usual “leaked” document

More Stings?

Advertising

Comments

  1. I was excited to uncover this website. I need to to thank you for
    your time just for this wonderful read!! I definitely savored every little bit of it
    and I have you book marked to check out new things in your
    web site.

  2. Quality content is the secret to invite the users to pay a quick visit
    the site, that’s what this web site is providing.

  3. It’s actually a nice and helpful piece of information. I am happy
    that you simply shared this useful information with us. Please
    keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

Speak your Mind Here

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s